Shanti Devi And Others v. Financial Commissioner Haryana And Others
!"#$$% # &
$ '$'$'( & '$ '
)
(
!
"#$
% & ' ((((( $'$'*" +*,*- *.$ /*- 00
!)* !+ , !
"!! !)* !+
0
*- . - ! + /
" ! !
+ +
, 0
*'1'212* + " + + & 2 ! 3"
+
"!! !"++
+ !
" !! , + + & 2 !
2- + 3
, " " " #
!
+
4 +
+ 5 + 261)2122, ( !$1!21 ! " +,7+ , 8 " ! + , ,
!*2# ! ,, " 2 8 + 5 +
"
$ .11.21*2 9 0 -.: , , ! "
1;*221*2 9 0 -;:
,
1<1)21*. 9 0 -': " 8
**1621*=9 0 -<:,, " + " !
+ 5 + . + 0 " )1 "8 *66)9!
>*66) ?: !
"
, "
" , ; 8 + 5 + + " " !
!
" ,
!
, ! !+
, , " #
, ,
3-
, ,, +
" # ' , ! ! !
"
! +
= @ 0
! *66) , =. =<,
" ,
!
+
)1 );8
=. =<
- A=. 3- !2!
45*"
63 "*"33!7*8 75/!9 "3:- + + #
=; 3- !23 "*"3:"!3+*9 ";/ ;+3!2!
45*"
63!7*8 75/!9 "3:- 9*: + + #
, !
92: 3! B ,
#+ !
" + + " !
='75/!9 "3:7* < 2!/ !77 "
"3!23+ : 3- 3
" " !
" "
, ! + +
,
, ! , + " ,
== 75/!9 "3: < ;4" " *"3 5*3 !" !2 =
"3- 0 !
! ! ! " !
" + " ! !
! ,
4- =) "
/!2- *:
2!/3, "366 */:3!3 "*"33!< *<*/3! / ;+3 3! !75 ":*3 !" 3!
! !
! ,
!
"
" +
! " " "
!
=6 *< - 36 3! 5*6 !75 ":*3 !" 2!/ 75/!9 "3: 3! "*"3: !" =
"3 !/ !" "+*"
"3 !2 + : / "3 " !
+ +
! ,
, " " " "
=<!75 ":*3 !"2!/ :34/<*"
!2 - */ ";3 "*"3:> 9*: ,
"
+
, - , + !
"
!
"
" "
!!
, ! " 0 + ! ?
, , ! , "
" !
92: 3! " !
"
!
" !0 , !
+
,
!
-
! + "
"
" !
" ! -
! ,
!, " !
! , - ! "
*<2< " !!
! ,
!DE
5- ) 3
, " ! ! , "
" , , ! , "
, !
!" +" ,
+ #+ !
" + 8 ! " # ,
, , ! " " ! !
+!
,
! , " !
)1 ! *66) 6 ! -"
# , + ,
! ! " !
*$ , , + B + !
!
! ,!!
+ , ,#
! !
#+!
! # " !
* $
- A= 8 , + B 9$ : + !
! 8 ," ,!!
+ , , # !
! !
,
# # !
!!
E < B , +!
21
=)
"
"
+ !
!
!21 8
6- + , , "
" !
, " !
" , ,
! " !
+ ! " ,
*1 )1
- A)1 /7 "*3 !" !2 !75 ":*3 !" <6
"4 !4/3:- 9*:3
" "
"
! ! !
"
! +
92: 3! !
! ! 0
! " !
E ** 8 ! ! ! !
!
, " ! , " !
+ ! 8
, !
! 3 " , , ! " !
=< )1 !*66)
" + ,! ! , ,
" !
" + " !
+ *2 !
=)
"
!, !
7- , !
! +
! !
" , - !
0
" ! + ! *. " !
+ 5 +
! '+/ )*/3*/' ";+?:$'3*3 !2*/6*"**" *"!3+ /. 011 1$ 8 , ,
" ++
, " " 8 , " + ," !
! !
21 + ! + , " !
, " !! " ! ,
! *; @ !+ , "
, ,
! # !!
"
! , " +
! *' 3 ,
! !
! + 5 + + ! , " " !! +!
" +
,, + " " !
!
+ ,
!
8- 4 "
$'$'(
)
( $$% @ #+% F @
" F