Pran Nath Khanna And ORS v. Union Of India And ORS

 



  
   



 !"!#$%& 

'

#

()( ## #* ('"



!#'" +'","

#!#
#*!

#* ('"

 "-#*# "
 

 

  

 



.$ /')0 1)'!"( #2*3

' /' '45!

) 1!

2*3

' !#'"  

!   ! 4 !#  #  (  "6!#7    (  ,'

2  /'  .,#!1  ),4 '  .( '4 # '

13'#4# .

#*!#7,#"1 - "# ! #8( 1 #!#  
#*!

9'"-#*#  2  /'  !"(!  ) ,"( 12  *3

  '


9'"-#*#  #*/"/,#!"(  #*(!2**!

1*3

#'

12 ,#5 8''"-#*# % % :

'#* ,#"1' !#'"( "( #**3' 0 -!"    !#  (    (  1 '#*  ,#"1"  '  '"-#*# " &
#3!0 (#

,''*'0(! (0-'-" - ""2# '-1;< !* 3!

!"'=,!'* 8!1*8; ('"-#*# "

 (1 #* !#'" 0 " =,!'*8;'"-#*#

">,#*' (

;" 2?

@'-,81! -,'-""'

  0!*#!#79,'1 #!#794 !# # # -'

!# '

 # ("

'

(1 #*'4?)/ @)/ @ ( '*"0'- ""*!# (;

'" #*8; :

#* =,!"!

!#11 '94- # , ;  (- !#'"A4 !#7'!3 # !"

0(!1 """"!#7 4-#"

!#2 (8#!

"  .

!#" %2  #* %&  ( :

#*  =,!"!

!# 2?&2# 41;2"1

!,4 #*!# 0'# 7'

# * 

(4*"-!

(

(!",'

!# "#$%&'( )(*(& +''% ,)-.(-#/')#0#(.( (&.**(&+1')#!

234
2
./.%45 !

"

7'!

11;(1*

3#!# ( " =,!"!

!#,#*' 

1  !7(0 ;"   2  ?

@2  (  83  4# !#*  0  "

, ';

8#!

"  '  =, 11;  *4!""!81  (   *  1 #*<0#'"  ( - !#'"  1"  '1;  ,-#  0  * !"!#"    (!"  ,'

2  8 (  *

* ?- ""*!#
 3

21*- .(-1*(&*(+1') /')#0# 
66.##.(')! *%*(&1*) 7./.#.(  *(&  +1')#4  #* 
  383 

2)'6 *0)/')#0#(.( (&.**(&+1')#4 0('8; (8#!

""1

!,4 #*!# !# '4" ( 83< !

* * !"!# (!",'

2( 38#B #**  ("!4!1 '1;"!

,

*1 #*< 0#'" 1!

# 0 "-1 *,-# ('*'"2##B,'" <% #* <&2 - ""*8; (!",'

!#"!4!1 ' !' ,4"

# "  # ('  7'!3 #     !#'"  !" 

 8"!*"

",84!""!#

!#" 2 (; '',##!#7'4 -!11 ' -"

8' (! '"'"-#*# <

;", ;'

('1 " 834# !#*8#!

"8, ("

4 '0!

((1*#1;

# (-1

#*!'

!#"( 38#7!3#8; (!",'

!# (!'

"C"D( 77'!3*- !#'"( 3#0 --' (* (!"
,'

 ? ( 3( '*1 '#* ,#"1' '

!"

"4

5 1#7 ( #*7# (',7( (' '*  (-'!# !-1"1 !**0#8; (!",'

!#1*#
'# #* .

1 '7!#7"A" "C",-'

D2 '# !#*!"-,  ,'

('2 (

(8#!

""1

!,4 #*!# ( 38#B #**8; (!",'



("!4!1 '1;"!

,

*1 #*<0#'"3!*'*'*

*?!#( .!#7(A"  "  C",-'

D2  #  1"  8  ( '*1;  *!"-, * 
#  ("

!' ,4"

# "20 ' (3!0

!

!"!4-'

!3,-#'"-#*#

">  #"!*' !#'"A 1 !4' (7'

# "1

!,4 #* !# !# '* # 0!

( (* !"!# (!",'

!#1*#
'# #* .

1 '7!#7"A" "C",-'

D  (0'!

- !#!" '*!#71;*!"-"*!# (110!#7

'4"$< C!D (- !#'""( 1143

!#C"D8' # !!*  4- #  , ;< ,4<:

#*   =,!"!

11 '0!

(!# -'!*#4# (' (7'

# 

'"

!*8#!

"E C!!D ("

!*4- # , ;0!11!"",# !  #*

11' (' '*"9'-1;'4 (

, ;
#*!

E C!!!D (4- # , ;"( 11 ('

 '* '4!# 0( ('  '  # !#'"  '  # 1* 

'"

!*8#!

"2"- !

11;!#3!0 (* !"!#"

 (!",'

#* (#F81.,-'4,'

'1!* ,-#8; ( 1 !4 # "E C!3D
 !#'" ',#*# 1* 2 "1"- 6!#7 ",--14#

';0 '*  (!" "( 118- ""* 0!

(!# -'!*,'4# ("'4 (*

!1!#7

3

(

!#C"DE C3D (

;", ;
#*!

"( 11*-"!

( 4,# 2! #;2- 81!# '4"",--14#

';

'*2!#!# <8 '!#7!B**-"!

,# C"D!#

#;#

1!G*8 #6 #**!"8,'"4# ('"( 8  ",85 (  !# 1  * !"!#    (  #F81 .,-'4,'

!#.- !

1 :

3 -- 1C!3!1D  &    &  1*$  '5  !'

'2  

!7(0 ;2
+3"

5"(0 '.!#7( #* '"  '!

- !#"

#*"*!"-"* '*!#71; 2 

4 7$ 9).%5 !

 2 

4 78"

7$