High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1417/2013dismissed

Vikram Singh Karta Virender & Vikram Huf v. Collector Urban Estate Karnal & ORS

2015-03-31Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

"'( #()* +$$, -./01"2- 3.45"1'"/(1 #(1" #/01"2 66(77" ' /(1*8* .( 77()'14-()'14 19" *'"'(45"1 "7" #'.(1* (*6 #( '*

+ :; - 5 ;- 1(*( '+

66(77" ' 6(1* 1 "81"< (74***'" ' "1=" " >.('.(1'.((61'(1* 7)"7 (?*6"6(12"=9("77?(#'*(( '.(@8#32( 'A 9(1( (11(#''.((61'(11 ' $ >.('.(1'.(@8#32( '*.87#9(1(61'(# '.(#3(*'A

;- 4% ;&

1"=(1 '.* "667)"' * 1 67") 3 1()1# (B81(* ' $ (B81(* ' $"1('"0( 1()1# 667)"' *"))1# 37=#*6*(# " "*( 66(77" '."* 7(#'.*"66("7"3" *''.(1#(1#"'(# $46"**(#9='.(7("1 (###' "7*'1)'8#3(45"1 "74 <#(?.)..*) '(26'6('' 8 #(1-()' $87(%&

?"*#*2**(#

.( ")'* '.()"*("1('."'67" '

%"66(77" '.(1( &

7(#"*8'9( 1('.(7("1 (###' "7 <78#3(4-( 1<* 4 5"1 "74 1#()7"1"' '1()'

='.(7" #1()1#"*6(1'.(61<* * #8 -8))(** )'4 ,C 81'.(1 61"=(1 ?"* 2"#( ' )161"'('.( "27="31((2( '*#"'(#," # D8"" )(*'1"7616(1'= 1(<( 8(1()1# 1(7( 6(12" ( '

@8 )' ?"* *83.' 1(3"1# 3 1(*'1" 3 '.( #( ( #" '* 12 2"0 3" =)." 3(* '.(1()1# 13.'*D8"'.(*8'616(1'='77 '.(#()* '.()"*( .( 77()'145"1 "74(.*7#"145"1 "7 " #*21"'"(?" 4**'(1 '.(67" '

!"66(77" '4?(1(2"#( '.(#( ( #" '*7 3?'.'.(*8'4" "667)"' 8 #(1 1#(1$ 87(*" # 1("#?'.-()' , ?"*"7* 7(#4?.).

?"*#*2**(#9='.(7("1 (# <78#3(48 1<* 45"1 "74 <#( 1#(1 #"'(# , .( 67" '

!"66(77" ' 61( (11(# "

"66("79( 1('.(7("1 (###' "7*'1)'8#3(45"1 "74?.<#( 1#(1#"'(#CC4#1()'(#'.(#( ( #" '*'2" '" *'"'8*D8 "98')1("' 3" =)." 3( '.(7" #1(3*'(1?'.1(*6()'''.( *8'616(1'='77'.(#()* '.(*8' '*)7"2(# '.("667)"' 7(#8 #(1 1#(1$87( %& '."'#(*6'('.(*"#*'"'8*D81#(14-'"'( <(1 2( '4 "1=" "4 *'"1'(# '.( 61)(** ' ")D81( '.( 7" # " # 7"'(1 '1" * (11(# '.( 7" # ' "1=" " -'"'( #8*'1"7 (<(762( '

161"' % *.1':- :&"

'(1**8 3 ')(8 #(1-()'

'.(;" #)D8*' )' .*?"*# (#(*6'('.(*'"'8*D8 1#(1))1# 3''.(67" '

!"66(77" '4'.(*"#*'"'8*D81#(1 ."*9(( <7"'(# .( 7("1 (###' "7 *'1)' 8#3(4 5"1 "74 ## ' "31(( ?'. '.( 67(" '.( 67" '

!"66(77" ' " # 1()1#(# '.(

77? 3 # 3*+

E '(1 .("1 3 '.( *892** * 2"#( 9= '.( "667)" '" #7("1 (#)8 *(7 1'.(1(*6 #( '*" # 6(18*"7 '.(1#(16"**(#9='.()26('( ')81'4 '.* 81'* '.(6 '."' 1#(16"**(#9='.( )26('( ')81' CC."*9(( <7"'(#9='.( 1(*6 #( '* .("667)" '## ' '(161(''.()81' 1#(1 '.(13.'6(1*6()'<(9()"8*('.(*"#*'"'8* D81#(1?"*6"**(#D8"'.(*."1( '.(*8'616(1'= '(1 *( 9('?(( '.( '.1(( 7(3"7 .(1* ( '.( "27= 2(29(1* '.("667)" '*8).)." 3(."*9(( 2"#(9='.(1(<( 8("8'.1'(*?'.1(3"1#'*."1( '(1 *("2 3'.( "27=2(29(1* .(1(*6 #( '* ."<( ')1("'(#" =)." 3( '.(7" #1(3*'(1 '(1 *( "2 3'.( "27=2(29(1*.(61)(**'")D81('.( 7" #9='.(-'"'( <(1 2( '*"#

(1( ')"8*(

")' .(1( 1(4'.(61(*( '"667)"' 7(#9='.( "667)" '* '2" '" "97("3" *''.(1(*6 #( '* )"*( '.( "667)" ' ."* " = 31(<" )( D8" '.( 7" # ")D8*' 61)((# 3*4.(."**6() )1(2(#=' 7( 9@()' 9( 1('.(;" #)D8*'

)(198')(1'" 7= .()" '3('" =1(7( 12'.*)81'D8"'.(1#(1*4

" =46"**(#9='.(7" #)D8*'

)(1 ?.).'.( 61)(**'")D81('.(7" # '.(67" '

" #'.(1)

? (1*."<(9(( '"'(#9='.(-'"'( <(1 2( ' ( )(4 <(? '.*)81'4 #*9(#( )(1<7"' " =1#(1."*9(( 2"#(9='.(1(*6 #( '*( )(4 '.("667)"' 7(#9='.("667)" '

67" '

."* 2(1'

" #'.(*"2(*#*2**(#F .(67" '

!"66(77" '."*)."77( 3(#'.(*"# # 3* ."<(.("1#'.("66(77" ' 6(1* 47("1 (#***'" ' #<)"'( ( (1"7 1'.(-'"'(" #."<("7*)"1( 877=3 ('.183.

'.(1()1# .(67" '

!"66(77" '.2*(7 ."*6 '(#8''."'.* *8' 1#()7"1"' " # @8 )' ."*9(( #*2**(#9='.(7("1 (# ##' "7 <78#3(4-( 1<* 45"1 "74<#(@8#32( '#"'(# 4 '.( 318 # '."' '.( 7" # ."* 9(( ")D81(# ?(<(14 ' * "7* ' #*68'(# '."' '.( 67" '

!"66(77" ' ."* 61( (11(#" "66("7"3" *''.(*"#@8#32( ' 6(18*"7 '.( ")'* '.()"*(*.?*'."' '.*)"*( 612"17= '.( #*68'( ?"* 1(3"1# 3 '.( .(1'" )( " # '.( 67" '

!"66(77" ' ?" '(# '."' '.( #*68'(# 616(1'= *.87# 9( 1()1#(# .(1'(# "6"1')87"1?"="*6(1'.( "27=*(''7(2( '

" #'.(*"2(*.87#9(1( 7()'(# '.(1(<( 8(1()1# "31((?'.'.( # 3* '.(7("1 (###' "7*'1)'

8#3(45"1 "74'."''.(61)((# 3*8 #(1'.(7" #")D8*' "1( ( '1(7=#

(1( '.(*'"'8*D8?"*1(3"1# 3'.() '1<(1*=D8" )." 3( 7" #1()1#1(3"1# 3 .(1'" )(" # ?"=)" 9( (B'( #(#'"**82('."'(<( '.(7" #")D8*' 61)((# 3*

)87# '9( '"'(#9='.(-'"'( <(1 2( '.(7" #")D8*' *" #(6( #( '61)(**.(1(?(1( "<(12( '* '.(67" ' '."''.(-'"'(*3 3'*'"1'7" #")D8*' 61)((# 3*" #'.( *"2(*.87#"7*9(*'66(#'9( 3*4# ' #" = "87'?'.

'.( 2683 (# 1#(1 #"'(# $4 6"**(# 9= '.( 7("1 (# ##' "7*'1)'8#3(45"1 "7

*(D8( '7=4'.("66("7*#*2**(# %5 ;- &

$$, *@0*