High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-CARB/28/2022dismissed

Parsvnath Developers Ltd v. Brig. Devendra Singh Yadav And Others

2025-01-20Mr. Justice Arun Palli,Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal17 pages

!"#$%&'& & & () &*"+&*!, ! $

#&-+& .& ! !*/!&+ &- - 0 10- 2 3!&- -4 !$$## +&! !,-+& .& ! 00- - 5- 4 !$ 66666 2! $$## ) ! "#$ %&'& &# ! 7

$ 8/ ! 4 # "& & 1 * .&-&.!& ! !$$#& &$48/ !$ (99 # .& !+ &4 !4&&# -:

4 ! ! ; < .& ! + & & 4 ! 8& & &#& & - ::7 4 ! ! ;::7 < =&* 4 ! 80 &$ & &$48/ !$ $$## + &>4 ! ::7 . ##. ! $ & & $4 + & > . 8 48&*$ & ! '$ 2! $$# & & &*- 4 8 8 ! ?

&- 4 .!& ! @ '#/ #* !/ * ' . 8/ 8 ! &2!?

& 8 && .! ! !$ & &$48/ !$$## + &>4 !::7 !##*&* !.

$8/ !8& #2&8 #. #8'& &8# .& ! ' . # ! 8 4&# "#!&- .! ! 8& & $ &*.

2!& 4; <; <! *& 8 & 8/ ! $ & .!& ! !& !## $ &

. > ##8 & *' @ . @

8 . !$ -.!..&$&4# ' &* $$@&' #/ - & & (&##* "! !- "& & .& ! $$## ) ! "#$ %&'& 8&* #$9 .* ! !#&?

&. #8#$8/ ! #$& & &# #/'

##/* '(& ' & &.* $8 . !$ & 9 $$ ! & ! & '/

! ! &'&# *' - & & $$ $ 8 . ! $ & #&* ! 4&#&*4$ & & + &:4 !::7 @ >8/ ! $ 2! & $ & & . $$ 8/ ./ 4 $#/ @ B# &' #/- ! $ & & . ##. &

@ !#&* ;

!"#

$ %

& '

!"#

( !

)

> '

(

," - 9 . #8&*&4& ' &! ! &## !& *- & 40 && &4 ! ! $$ $8 . !$ & 9 &$$ ! !$0 & *!. !#&* !4&#&*4$ & & + & 74 !::7 @ 7 8/ ! $ 84 !& - $ .!& ! &

7 @ A- 1 & %!- 4' !&4 1 & 4 9&.$$& #8& 7 2!8& &$ &* '' "#!& &* ! $ / 4 ! '- $$#& & 4 @ & 4 &' '= ! ..'8/ !$ 84 !& -.!& !.##. & : : A @ ! &' '= ! . . @ $ > &'&# $$#& & . *& 4&#8 !'..& !. 7 .& !#&8 / =

! $$$& '/ '/ 8 &#8# & #. @ : 2! $ ! $4 $$#& & & ! C&*! 4 "#!& 4 @ & 4 &' .!& ! . ##. &

@ A D ##/- ! . . :

@ $ & & + &>4 !::7 @ . $4 8/ ! $$## !& & ! .& $$#& & (99 # @ > . 4&# 8/ !

$ .!& ! . $$ 8/ ./ 4 $#/ @ 2! * & & ! $$#& & . ! & ## $ &* ! 8

"#!&- !0 && & & &$ & & + &>4 !::7 . #8.& ! ! "#!& .& ! ! .& 2!& .

$ 8/ ! 4 # "& & 1 *-.& !&'$ *.$-#&* ! 4&#&*4 !& $$#

%+& #$ &* !$ &.! ! 8 & & ! $&* $ 4 ! 0 *' - @ '#/ #* !/ * ' .8/8 !& :

#&- # +& # $ &* ! $$## !' #/ 8'& ! !&'$ *& &8#- 4-& !'&& $ !0 *' 4 !+ $' & ! 4 ./* */* * 01 1& (234 5

! "! 2! * ' . ! &&. 4 ! 0 && & # & # 4 ! ##8 &*' - !; <4 !8& . #8 .& - !4- !$ & & + &>4 !::7 . #! 84&# .&9 . 8'& ! "#!&.'#/ !; <4 8& &&&.4 !@ # &0 && & # - !; <4 8& &. # 8 = 8 !; <48& & &# 4 .' ! ##8 &*' -$ &

##/# > !4#*.& ! !$&&4+ & &- -> 4 !::7 4&* !0 *' & ! 4#$% $-& . 8'& ! !E /&& &F4 & ! & 0 *' & ! 0 && & # & # 5 & ! ##8 &*' - !4- !; <48& &.&## 8 = 8 ! ; < 4 8& & % +& # #

4 !&

' -& # &* !$8/ !& 4' &' &'- !$8/ !"#!&C&*! - ! . !

' '= * !& * ' 4 . # ' '8 4 0 *' ! # $ & 4 #' *' . 8/ # +& # ! &' 4 * ' 2!&0 *' ./**/** 01 1&(2345

"!&

% 6 7 3 5 1& 7 %

3 5

'( ()(*& "

78 9 : 3 5 1& 4 ;

3 5

" +,-+.%,'!/& ! <'.1&75:3

9* 5

+,-+..,""0& / 6 3

9 2 3 5 1&*%

' +,-+..,'/")& ) 7 .

;

%5 1&7 % 5

' +,-+.%, '"& ( = *= %

554 1& 0 >

* 3 5

' +,-+.#$0'0 * ; ;' 7

3 5 1& = < 4 '

+,-+./)*& 0 * / 3 5 1& % ? 5

'" 0"

& ' 2 4 3 5 1& : %3 5

+,-+..,")' %+1 '' 3'1&03= 5

' 9 . 8'& ! .! 8 ! ! ; < ! && &# ; < ' & $ #/- ; < & #/ 4

& 9 . 8'& ! &4 ! * ' 4 ! $ &

$ $# >-; <& = 8 !; <-+ &> . #8 '& ##&.!& !. !& &4 ! $ & 9 . 8'& 8/

#& ! ! & & . # & 9 ! 4& & &- .! & ! ; < ; < . # 8 ' &- !$# .!8& &. # =$# . #8 = 8 !; <40 && &&; <. #8 = 8 !; <4 && &2! & &. #8.!#/ !; <&4&@ ! ; < & 4&@ 9

! - ; < ; < 8 & !*- !4- !; <48& &. ##8 ' !; <48& &2! !& . #8.! !; < && &$ #/$&-& ! & !$ ' 9 . 8'& !

! &

' - ; < . # #/ 8 4

& 9 .# 8'& ! !$ . #8 $$ 4'&&* !& 4; <; < !/! !'#4&# !$ & & + &4 !::7 !&*! !$ & &

+ &:4 !::7 .&9 .# 8'& ! &4 ! !&*! ! 0 && & 4 !& C&*! ! !0 && & #.& !$ & & + &>4 !::7 - ! !$$& ' 48& . #8&##*# !. . #! * - +&! ! ,- # +& # $ &* !$ 8'& .& !?

#!' ! !& &##*#& /& !&'$ *4- ! &8& &$ &* . & "#!&- !$ & & + &>4 !::7 . # ! 84&# "#!&# ! ! .&. # ! /0 && & #.& ! !&$ & &%+& ##

A 4 !

' -& # &* ! ##8 &*' .& !$ &4& 4 # > !4- !$8/ !& ! "#!& C&*! $ &##/ ! @ $8/ !"#!&C&*! -&.!& ! !$$#& &4@ &4 &'.##.9 . 8'& ! ! &$$#& &!8'8/ !$ !& !"#!& C&*! #/ & ! & ! ! 0 && & # .& ! ! $$#& & 9 . 8'& ! ! . E@ # &F ! 8 ' & & # > 9 . 4 ! 8'& ! !

##8 & *' . 4 ! /

! ! 8

!*& !::7 4 !'' & !/ 9 .4 ! 8'& ! ! $&/0 && &. #84 ! "#!&- 4 !$ &*!8 & "#!&- !4- !$ & &

+ & > 4 ! ::7 . # 8 '& &8# "#!& # $ 4' !@.& ! !$$#-4 .#'

&@.& ! !$$#& &4&#4 ##&*4 ! > > > @ $8/ !& -.!& !&/ . $- 4 * ' & ! '& $$# . 8&* ! C.- 4&* ! & > > > >

@ >$ &#/$8/ !C&*! 4"#!&-& . 8'& ! 80 &.&84 !C&*! 4"#!& ! * & ! .*#/ 8 & ! * 4 $$# ! 80 &!8& 9 .4 ! 8'& ! !&*4 !8& # &8 # .!# "#!&9 .4 ! 8'& ! ! &

' - !; <48& &. #$ !0 && & # 9 . 8'& ! @'$#- &4 ! . . $ & 4' 9&

G'/ !; <48& &. %$$& ' 4 8& &. !&*!-& #8* ! ! $&/ . #8!&*! %9 .4 ! 8'& ! ! 0 *' #& $ 8/ # +& # $ &* ! $$## .$& ! '' '4 !'$ & + & 4 ! ::7 - !4- . # $$#/ 9 . 8'& ! 4 !@ &!&*8* 8/ !"#!&C&*! -#/ ! "#!& . #! ! 0 && & & $ & & + &>4 !::7 %+& ##- $ 4' 4&* ! 0 *' #& $ 8/ !&'- @ &#/ 4 !0 *' #& $8/

#& 8'& ! !&'$ * 8 $!#9 $$ 4!& &- #+& #$# #& $ !4##.&*0 *' ' *

6 1& = 5

'! '' )'0&

@ 3

4 * 5 1& <= = 4 "" / %2 .3#456!((& " A

% 1& = 4

'/7

"& !

51&* .4 3 5

! +,-+..,"(*& / > 3 5 1& ? ,B 4 5 #((#8

& ) *.3 9 4 1& 3 >

/ *)'*& ( * 4 5 1& 4 3

+,-+..4 '!!"& * . = 4 1& < = * %

0// &

: 0 A .

% 1& 2 >) 3 %

'0 '"!( & ' %6 6934% & '' ./** 01 6934% & '

6% )3 5 1&= 5

/"00& '" % ) ;

5 1& 0 > 5

' +,-+.!!*& '! C A ='

7 1& A

+,-+.,,/0!& '/ ='*1&<= 3 5

'( +,-+..,*0"!& ') 1 6 51&< D* 3 5

' +,-+.#$(/& '( * > 3

4 4 1&

6 3 '

+,-+.'

!" %+1 '* 24 4 5 1&A

'("

! 2! & 4 '& &8&#& / 4 ! & $$# . # & 8/ # +& # $ &* ! $ 9 . 8'& ! &&.4 !$&&4+ &>A4 !::7 - ! & $$#. # 8'& &8##& & !&*.$#

$ !0 *' 4 !+ $' 49&& ! 4./**/* * 01 $ 8 &* ! * ' - # +& # $ &* ! $$## & ! 0 && & # . ! & !

##8 &*' - !'. #8$$#& 8#&44&#&*4 !$ & & + &>4 !::7&

&*#/- ! E F-4&@8/ !$ &-. #8 = 8.& !

08 C/ C&*! - !&*! ! "#!& * ! '& &8&#& /-& . 8'& ! $ !$&&4> #

- !$$#. #8'& &8# > H! & ! 8'&&'8/# # 4 !$ &-!* ! *! !# /$&& ! #. ! 80 2! *!- !& 4'& &8&#& /.&4 * ' !8'& -.' & $$$& = $ !& & 4& 84

!&* $ !'& 4 ! + &>A 4 !::7 4##. EFB= ! =

* G$

* ,$

* FH- 7.

Section 13 of the 2015 Act reads as follows:

"!F =

4 4 7 ! =

4 4

7 0 4 = 4

)

' !

= =

70 ) ' 4 7 .

2 4 4 = 7

)

7 4 4

? HF

4 3 !,"G

!,"G = * FB

= = !,,++

!,,+ (

5 3

4 7 4

=I 17.

The issue of maintainability of an appeal under Section 37 of the 1996 Act read with Section 13(1) of the 2015 Act against an order passed under Order 7 Rule 10 CPC directing the return of the petition under Section 34 of the 1996 Act was first raised before this Court in the case of ./**/** 01 $(&0 *' : - & !!# ! !$$#.'& &8#H! !' ! ! + $' 4 9&- $ 4' '& 4 ! - ! & 4 '& &8&#& / . # & 2! + $' 4 9& #8 #/ &

! & 4 '& &8&#& / 4 4&* ! / $&& ! & #. ! 80 - ' ! # & ! *& $ $$#& & A # &* ! 4$ & &4&# + &>4 !::7 4 $ & ! $$$& - $$# + & >A 4 ! ::7 .& !+ &> 4 ! -. #8'& &8#I EH ? !

! "!B * 4 4 /

* FH

' (

?! "!G * FB

= = !,,+ * !F!

4 = "!

2 4

3' 2 4?! , "!G '

3'224

* FB

= = !,,+ 7

: =

* 4 4 / 7 = 6 * * =

*534 ( +!G

"!G 24 ' =

* !F

4 4 = "!* FB

= = !,,+ * !F

4 4 = "!

* FB

= = !,,+

)

* !F!

4 = "!

2 *

= = !,,+ '

* FB

= = !,,+ 2 2 4

* FB!

= = !,,+

* FH

= = !,,+= 7*

* !! ? B; !"434

* FH

= = !,,+ ))) ))) ))) !

* FB

= = !,,+ * !F

4 4 = "!

' < >) 4 J < >) 4 * "

= = !,,+ * !F!

4 = "!% )

4 4 = "! = = !,,+ 4 *44BB B, BF!

FH !F ! "

9 B I!F * !F!

4 4 =

4 7

)

I !H

4 7

2 ? HF

4 3 4 !,"G * FB

= =% ? HF 434

* FB

= = = 7

24 !

* G * FB!

* !F!

4 = * '

* !+

= =

J * FB

* !F!

4 4 = K K K " /

4 : 7 5 3

= = = "!

* "

= = 4 =

* "

)

: 7 5 * !F!

4 4 =

* "

= = !2

J * FB

= = )

* !F!

4 4 = J

* !F!

4 = ?

) =

* FB = = = "!

4 4 = 3

* FB

* !F!

4 = %

= = * G

* G

* FB!

* !F!

4 4 = @

* FB

= =

* !F!

' : 7 5

* "

= =

* "

* " %

* "

I 4 I* "

* !F!

4 =

K K K B

% J %

4 =

* "

= = 4 4 = =

;! * 0

; !

* !F!

4 ==

4 4 = D

* !F!

4 = '

* !F

4 4 =

)

= = L

4 =

I !F /

* !F!

4 4 = "!

* FB

= = !,,+

* FB!

2 '

= 2 4

* FH

* FHI !H %

* !F!

4 = "! ? HF434 ? HF; !

I!= =

* !"H ; !"

? B ) ; !"

? B

* FB

= = !,,+

* FH= '

I * FHI

* FH * FH

' * FH

= = !,,+ * 4 4

7 /

* !! ? B; !"434 * 4 4 / '

* FH

(

7 ))) ))) ))) !, %

7 .

* ,

= = !,,+

4 =)

' J

* ,

= = !,,+

. 4

* FB:

' <

B "!G

7 .

=)4 5G 7 .

' + ! "!B!,

' F"

"!GG ' * 7 64 !

<O * FB

= = !,,+ "%

* FB

= = !,,+ - 9&.4 ! #

4&&*& 8/ !+ $' 49& !& 4'& &8&#& /-.4& ! !$ $$#& '& &8#

&*#/- ! ' & &'& ! * 4 '& &8&#& / - ! $$# & 8&* &'& ! * 4 '& &8&#& /- . & * & ! '& 4 ! + &##

A !- ! $ & & . # 8 #&8 / &# / ! '/- '&&8#&#.-&4&

** H! !$=&*) ,)5 H! !$ 8# ,)5