High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/3356/2010disposed of

State Of Haryana & ORS v. Santokh Singh Etc

2016-05-0524 pages

! ! "

#$%

& ''(

+( ,$- +# ! + !.!+-/

"( !

#" ! $ "#" ! % !" %& '(

)*+,-

+,-++,.+,,"+/,-0+/,. ,, ! !

!" %& '( )*1.+1.+2"-.2-".,,".1-"..-1"..--"..-." /,3"/+32"/+33"/32/"/-."/-12

/./,2 ! " %& '( )*-2+-21,,"+/+/3,," 2,-2,,"3,.-"3,..,,"2," -,,"----2,+"332,2"..3/,2" +,3+,-,3"-,-,3"+3"+3 ,3

* )*/-,,",,"

,"//,,"

*2 ) *13/,,"

*+3 )*/. ,,

*+ )*,,2 ! " %& '( )*-2+,,"21121."3/+"3+,"3.,"3.2" 3.-"3.."3."3.1"3.+,"3.+-"3.+/"3.2,"1/3+ 1/33"-12."-/+.

-/+/,2 !

4 " %& '( )*1/2.1/3,,2 ! 4% 5" %& '( )*.13".-,.-+,2

! 6 " %& '( )*+2,

'( )*+1,, ! 7 " %& '( )*3..,,

1-3,

'( )*+/

++,,, !

5" %& ! 8" %& '(

)*-2+,,03,13,1.,, ! 6 " %& '(

)*3+/1,, ! 47 5" %& '( )*.13".-,.-+,2

'( )*2+-+

2+-.,2 ! 6 6

" %& '( )*.1++,2 ! ! 6 " %& '(

)*1-,+"-/3"-/1

,,3/,2 !

" %& '(

)*+33,

+33,,

)*/,+, ! 8 # " %& '(

)*-1/--1,

--/,

'( )*1 ,,

1-,, ! 4 " %& '( )*32/32/+,, ! $

9 " %& )*3,23,,"32.,"-3"-3+".3 .31,2

2122

2123,2

'( )*++3"++-"++-3,,"1,3- ,+

-,2 !

" %& ! %

7 " %&

)*1,22

1,3,+ + !.!+-/0 # 1 23 & -1 ) " 5 &

)*/-,"3"321332"1-"13/" +2++,"++2.++."2,+2,/

"1,2+1,3/

""2+-+2+.,"3.,.3.2,"-12."-/+."-/+/

,,-3

+1,++1,.

)*-2+-21"+,-"+,-++,.+"

+-3+--"+/+/3"+33,"+33"+/,-"+/,."2,-2,-2"3,23" 3,13,1."3,.-"3,.."3.."3+/1

32/32/+

"32."1-3"

2"+2

-1/--1

--/

"/,+

"11, 11"-,,"----2

"332,2"-3"-3+".3 .31"21121."2122"2123"3/+"3+,"1-,+"1.+1.+2"1/2. 1/3,"1/3+1/33"-/3"-/1"-.2-".,,".13".1-".1++".-, .-+"..3/"..-1..-."/,3"/+32"/+33"/32/"/-."/-12"/./

,,3/

4"+,3+,-"-,-"+3

9 :; & *++:9<,,

2-:9<,1 & % & " &=

&= 5

&5% "

5 & &

& &"& & )*++31,,1!

567!86!'9663 7 " & & &=

" & > & ?

:*% 9 " 5 ) && "

& ,/,,2&

& 2 @

&= &" ./2 'A &B (" 5 & 5 5

& 2,,2

& 1 & @

&= && 'A@9B ("%

5 " % % ;

& @95 *- -,,,3@9

% &= 3& & 9

& &

5 %: 5 @9"

5 &

& . &9 = "

&5 5 && @ && 5

% &=

.& & 9

2& &

! %

%5 5;

5 && -+,," 5 %

& 5 &

7 % %: 5 &&

5 "

& &=

5" & % &

& " & & &

% & %& " 9 &

%5 &

& & & &" %

5% "

5 % && "

& &=

" "

& & 7 & " 3,1 9 9!:--+:9<:,3 ) *++31,,'

("%

;

2 - 5 & 3 9 9%8 &

% & & % & % 3.,3

5 5 " & 55 9 % 3,1< % & &

> :< 5

5 &

7 % *"$

*% < &

> :<<

:*% < &

> :+<

> 679 &"$

> :2& &&

& "

&= 9& "8 < 7 & &0 $

&5 &

& .9 &

& . &%

5 & 5

> :2

> :3 " 5 && -"."8& "7

!9$

":1 &

> :3<

% & & 5 %: & & " &

& 9

% % 8 & +3,,1"

& &

& "5

& &&

% D % 5 &

:*% & 5 & % & "

% " %"5 & & &

5 %

& &

5% " &

% & 7 "

& &=

& & %:

% & > &

5 & &=

&= 8&@ "C

& 9 "%

2,, :

1!;!'967! 53"5 & B 9 5"

2,, %5 < "

2+& " %

% 7

6 5 &= %

& .2///

& 2 &" 8&@

= &C

! %

&= & "&

9 31,E: = % 2,, !;!'96,&' (< 9 !;!'96,&' (

B 9 < &= "

23-& &= " %

%6 "

%" % & ,/,,2

5 7 && %:

5 " &

5 8& % & %: "

% " & &5

&= !;!'96,& ' (

&= 5 &= " &

5 &

9 !; !'96,&' ( % &

% &=

& & & @ &

5 &

& 5 & &

" :

& F>8

F>8.

' *31-2 .,,2( &5 :

5 &

& 2 &" 5 % & & &

& > %5 % & " :

= % &=

" & & !;!'96,&' ( #% > & %: " 9 & &

" &

< & &

% & && " 5 % &

5 &

& % &

& 5 & " &

" & ) " &

% &:

2.,,2F>83 & & % &=

&= 8&@ !;!'96,& ' (

" & & " & !> &"

5335 &

+ "

8 5 & & " &

+1"+.

2, :

F>83 %7 "

3 5 2.,,2 2.

& & " && " 5

& %7

%6 5

5 & "

& % & & & & & & & "5 %

6 5

5 & "5 & 5& &

& +. 5

@ && &

&5 %

"& 5 % 5 "

6 &

5 & &

& & & *5 >= & 9 "5

& & %

2,, 9 !;!'96, &' (" % &%

% %:

5 % & & & " % &" 5 % "

& " &

%"& ">& %: "

% B 9 & &

&+6;2/6;>'*19'30'867 ! "*>?601

3 !

4 0

5 &% & &=

" % B 9 -

6&7! 50

1 3!

"5 & & 5 &"

# $

% & $

% & (

% )

* ++,% )

* ++,

"% - ,, ,,,./ % ) "

0 -,,

"% -1

2$2 "% 1,

"% 3 ,1 ,,,./ "% 4 -3 ,,,./

% )

// $ 5 % ) # $

-7

-,,4

"% 3, (

"% 3 18 7,,./ "% 4 47 7,,./%

- * ++8% )

# $

(

% $

(

% ) -;

(

, - 1;

,,;

% <

# $

% )

(

% &

# $ "

$% &

(

% )

$ 5

% &

=> < " % 5@

&= & 5 B ) 9

& @

&= "

,+ ' B *5 &B(

&= &"./2' A ; &B( 5"

& 5 & 5 5& *5& &

*5&

& %

5 &"5 &

#9'#?9'#) @6 )#2 "9'#) )@ 69"

$@*A2)9@ B )"A"2$C 9 ?B $DE99)9@ "2#<99))9@ B "22))?2*2) $) -, 8 F8, @6 -, 8G / A

(

% / )

% /

% / $

A /A A

AAA

(

% / ) 6

% /

? < (% /

? % / &

F G

% / ) 9

%> 7 % *5&5

5 % % & &%

5 %5

&"5 & 5

; & &5

&= !; !'96, &' (

& & "

B 9 !6 ' 67! 560

1 3!

<" /6' !'96 )! 50

4 1 3!

68'?6'

&7>'?6'67 @*'7 9'0*>60

4& & :

5 % % B 9

68'?6'&7>'?6'A&' ("5 & & &"

# $

% )

(% &

% ?

% 2

% 3

% #

% &

(

% )

# $

"% ,./ % %

%> & 9 !;!'96, &' (

> % %5 % %& %

&= %6 " 9 & &

& & %% &%

% &

& &

5 &

& 5 %& "

& " & 5 5 B 9 " % &

.,1"

'7'2 CC2 <4B <

168/*67! 53 < &

& 9

& &=

& 3 &" B 9

+!7

-1 /

-1% "

F G &

F-G &

(

0 (

$ %

F8G &

0 (

$ %>

)

-1 I

-1%

$ / )

)

-7%,+% +!7%

) /

% )

+!7

$ % )

(

* +!!

< % *

? A J K /

4% 9

"% 7 -, ,,,./

% '

F-,,8G - $$ -47

)

@ %

) $ J-K $

< % ) $ L

8% M 9

% #

(

$ 0

(

% )

( % )

!+7

(

= ( % M>

% N ?J8K $

-1 $

8, +!- -7

+!7

% % "

FB G ?"%

% FG

% #

# $

< % ?

@ J7K

# $ (

" 33 11,./

"%1! 1,,./

) $

# $

(

% % "% 33 11,./

@ &

!;!'96,&' (5 & 5% " & 5 & !;!'96, &' (" 9

& ) "

9 !;!'96, &' (

B 9 < & " & 5 @ &

& &

.,,. 9 )*1,,.' %

("5 & B 9 "% ,,2 !-"1 4=

:1! 5768*;*>;2 635% " 9 !',&

" &< & 5 & && & > "&

& "

5 " &% & & &

&& 5 &" B 9

"*1&3)! '2*60

13!

) "5 !',&' (5 & 9 "

!;!'96,&' (5 % % 5

5 &= &

% &" &

& & "5 & 5 %

5 &= "

" & % 5 &

5 % E "5 "&

E " & & % 6 %5 &

& & & & & %

& &" &

& &% & " 5 %5 &

& 5 " 9 & %5

2,, 9 !;!'96,&' ( & %"

!;!'96, &' (5 &= % & .2///"5 &" 5&= % & ,/,,2"

" 5 3H " &3

3 5

5 B 9 6 2+90 '2 *2 C' - 7 6?6' #'7?6' "2 60

=143!

!6 ' 67!

560

1 3!

<05 68/* 67! 50

13!2 0

5 5 I

& " &

%" 3

3 # I

%"5 & 5 " %: 3

3 " % 9

!;!'96,&' ("

&..1-, =

..-E: = && "

5 &% &

" ..-E: =

& 2 & 9 "55 @9

&& <

5&=

& F% &&=

& &

:*%9 < & ">& &

& = &" & 5 &=

5 &

% &$

9 @

% 6 5 * 5

*-+%

5 & &

%6 5 5 % "

5 & "

< % & 5

& 5 5

% &= & & ) < %5 "& & &

5 5

& && "&

%: %5 9 " "

" B

9 5 9 G:

' ')'"2!'9660

1 3!

6&)! 50

1 3!

D 6 '6)! 560

1 3!

# $#""%#&' ()$$ * ")

+ ,

# #-.

/0"

$ $ * "+

( 1 ' # 2 &%3 #

$#""%# #44$$ * "

#- #44$$ * "

'7 /* # #- 8 #44$$ * "

4 9":

#- 8 44+ ) $ $ * "(

# 2 &%3 #

; "2 .'!#*' ;# #44+2&+

# .'!#*' ;; "<" # 44($$ * "

) 0 ' # #- 8

#44)$$ * "(

= = 5 & 9 5

5 % && < % "& & & 5

5 <& & &

:*%9 " " &" &

5 <5 5 && <

" % & %

5 &

& "

5 5 %&% & &

& % 9% &

5 5

> & % " &

5 "5 & 5

& & &< & "

5 5

& &&

% && &

5 5 %& & "

& %"5 & %

&"5

+,I %: % "& " &&

% &&

5 5 & &&

% &&

" &" & & &= ;

&& @&& & % &

& & 5 %&

5 9 & &

& & & &

%"& 5 " 9 & %5 5

& &% "

5 %

5 >

& % && "

5 &% &

..-E: = "

& 2 &

5 &%+,I %: % " & " &&

% && 7 "

5 %

% % & "5 % %" 5 & : &

" : "

5% "5 &

1+ !.!+-/3 8 # &