High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/880/2012allowed

Pardeep And ORS v. Anand Singh Kadian And ORS

2015-09-09Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri9 pages

!"#

$%$& '

$ ""#

! """

( )*( + ++

,% -./ # $%&'( #')&'( # &'( # *+ &'( , 000 +

+ 1

-. +/ . 0 1

+/#((23-+$&)**4 &5+$67#2-(00

5 ' !63 (3

(/& (

& 8 !$3 ... 3)**' 2+/ 3 3(/(9

:8 ;;004 &53(/(;;0067 )+ 3(/( 9

:8 01,1 4 & 53(/( 01,167 . 3 ' %. . ($$ 9.

3.' 3(/(

((+3(/((.( ' 3(/(8!$3)+ $ *$$+/3 3&#*) $

*$$ (( 3/& 3$(($3+ *$ , (3 (3$ 0( (($ 3$ ((&. +/3 ( ('< ' ( ;, #((& 14 &( 167 - 3(/( ;;00..+/ !4 7. $.=$(23/>34 7- 3(/( 01,1 . $ .=2-< % =$( 23/>34,7-( +/ .3= .3& &. 3(/(;;00&3(($(

(( +$ . + /3 / <

(39$+33(/(.$/$. $( (3/ + $3+ +*( .(($+. . 3(/(;;00 '(+ /''('(.(( +(3 ,&$ 3(/(01,1& '$ ($+*(+// (3

, : & . $. ?(((($$$ '( :2 ;;009

:8 01,1@ ?('/ (3 3@= . A@ 4,7 ? 3+@ 4:7

B 3A3 .3/& *?

(3'(($3A A

& / ('($3 ; 2 ($($3/'('+ ($+33+ ($ & +$(3(($(33+/

'( 3$ (( $

$ 3(/( ;;00 3(/( 01,1 (( /& +/(3 .3 0 ' +/ . 0 1

+/ +$& - $+3 3 +/ # $ %& ($ & # ' )& ($ & # & ($

: # *+ & ($ ,'+ 1 =&$+/($ & A3//. ((8$ ( A3& ?

*& / . A3 +/ 3& 3..((<( 93.+/.3(/( C$(.(+$ ( ((.(9.'&

'A?

D& + . )+ . ' 3(/( 01,1 3.' 3 .((3(/((.3(/(;;009 3' +3(/()+ 8!$3 3&.$

'$*$&.

3%9&)**'#> 2D ,B

& 3.. %=# & <$ 3$(($3+*$ ; ,

9 33A3+/ 3.($(' # :::D %=# < ; ,

3 $!$3 *& ' 2&88

. ( )**(

((

$ ( A3 ?

. (A3?

/ (

B /( A3 .($

(+//3$3 (+/ /

-88 1

A (+/ =

+ &$ 3 (( ' %.&($ (3 ( $

( 0:22( + 8 * )+ # 3+$ .33 $ !$3 *& 2&+ (8 !$3=3& $!$33(/(+ '+/+8!$3..3#*). ' &(($(<3(/( )+ . ..

3. + E3

$3+ +3(/(''((. 3+/3 ( ($(+/3& = +

388 ( 3+$ ((& .

((3(. + 8!$3)+ ./ ( 3 $!$3 *..9 3 3C$/(( <(+/(($(+.+3(/(

=88 A &3( AB

3 3'

& ((&. 3 . *$ A;

; 33(( .($*$$

+/$ (((( $((/A1 ( ( 3(/(01,1.(A+ A1&)+ & (3. . 3(/( (( $( (/ A

& 4 7.. $ 3(/(;;00- 3(/(.+ '+/(8!$3=3/& .3& /3 (($( (( +/(3&+$ 3 / 3(/(''((

$ 3(/( ;;00 , $

3(/(01,1$(/'(('D $3 ($3 ((+/$+&

.+A&+$3 $ '((.''3 3(/(;;00 .+/33(/(01,1.+/()+ (((/.+'+'& , $( +$3

, -(3 (3(($

3 3$ '($((. +/$ ' ( ;, ( 1 ( ;, (' /3 (3$($ 3$+ =$. / (( 1

0 /. 3+ ($3' ( .&. 3'( $$+ +/( 3+3$(( $ $ 3'(&(3(

( ($& '(3&(3/+

: (3 (3 $ +' '& C$3 .'(($( (( $ $ 3'( $+( ( ;, '/(3

(3$$+ (4 7&(3+C$ +3+3(

.((3+3.$/. $( ( $ . '('((( / # +/ (3 (3$ ( ;, 4 7 ( 1&(3C$' ((.$ /. $( ' ' '($/ $ . '(-/C$3'(($( (( $ $ 3'(

' (&++'+'

3 ?

&3 ((+/ & .. 3(/('' ((($388 A &#> 2D ,B

A:# :::D %=# <

; ,

AB&+(($ .( 3

*$ <( $ $ 3(/(;;003(/(01,1-88 3/' +'$( .+$+ '( ('33 (+( 88 &./ ($3$+(('($ (( /& +$$ ,' ((.( 3 3< ( $ $ 3(/(;;003(/(01,1

; 8( 3.$.

(- '( +/ $.

. '$+ / (($-(3 , 3 -(((($

=/'/. .+ , D 3-'$ '( (. 3/(+(( /&(3 ( , D 3 ,;& D $3

( $ ( ;, ( 1& (3+.(/(( '

( ($ ( 1- (.:

/ 3 ( ($&(3 $ 3$ B(3 B& :& D -+3 ( ($ 3$ (3'( (((3 +$(+/ D,( A.('(3

1 .$'($.3 +' &$( D,( A (3$(3 ,&,;& D =+'& (3.

. $A& B D (($ (( /3$ ,&: &B D .(3 (3-3$ (3(/ 0BF $3 3 (3 G- 3(33$ .+C$.+33+ ( (3 A.G+<.++$ ( 3 D 3*/

0 23 +/ & . 3(/( ;;00& $

3(/( ;;00 , $ 3(/( 01,1-(.3(/(01,1. / ,((-(( $ $ +3(/((( /&. */ '/ + /3 B F

(33$&3 B F++/, -(( /. 2+

+ ""#