Ashok Kumar v. State Of Haryana And Others

  


   

 
   

 !"#

$%& '&()*)+,-






 



 

   


 ", .

/"0
 0 

/ .

/"0
1 0// 2&*&+%, "203$24$25$+$60&+)2 '7($%&5)%8 "2$7&&+9:%$6 '7($%& 2%8&:&%)%)+&2 "2 +;92")%%$<6 '')%)+$< '7($%&&+&2$<6$2=$+$5)%8 "2"$+> 8$+;8$26 **)*%$+% '7($%&&+&2$<6$2=$+$  $>&*8 )+'$< 8&  :&%)%)+&2  8$*  $::2$(8&'  %8)*  (92%  (<$)?)+4  %8$% $(@9)*)%)+ <$+'5+&'A=%8&:&%)%)+&28$*<$:*&')+7)&5 :27)*)+*    0&(%)+ 

#    %8&  )48%  %  $)2 
?:&+*$%)+  $+' 2$+*:$2&+(=)+/$+' (@9)*)%)+&8$A)<)%$%)+$+'&*&%%<&?&+%  (%6

2*82%6.%8&

(%.# /&$2+&'*&+)2(9+*&<$::&$2)+4 2%8&:&%)%)+&2*9A?)%%&'

%8$%+%) )($%)+9+'&20&(%)+ %8&/$+' (@9)*)%)+ (%6C- 2 *82%6.%8&C- (%.#5$*)**9&'+  --8&:&%)%)+&2 )<&'A>&(%)+* 9+'&2  0&(%)+     %8&  C- (%  (<$)?)+4  %8$%  %8& 89*&  8$'  A&&+ (+*%29(%&'+%8&$(@9)2&'<$+'6)+58)(8%8&:&%)%)+&2)*2&*)')+47&+)+

 %8&  2&:2%  *9A?)%%&'  A=  /$+'  (@9)*)%)+ 
<<&(%2  2  *82%6  .%8&
<<&(%2.#6$ %&28&$2)+4%8&A>&(%)+*9+'&20&(%)+ (%6)% 5$*?&+%)+&'%8$%%8&2&5$*.

.(<$**(+*%29(%)++%8&:$2% $(@9)2&'  <$+'6  58)(8  5$*  2&(??&+'&'  %  A&  <& %  9%    $(@9)*)%)+ )%89%(+*)'&2)+4%8&A>&(%)+*6%8&<$+'5$*$(@9)2&'$*+%) )($%)+ 9+'&20&(%)+ (%5$*)**9&'+  --C 5$2'5$* $++9+(&'A=%8&
<<&(%2+B 

685&7&26+ 92%8&2$(%)+5$* %$;&+ 29%)<)*$%)+ <$+'$+'%8&:&%)%)+&2)**%)<<)+:8=*)($<:**&**)+ %%8&2& &')'+%')*:9%&%8& $(%%8$%(?:&+*$%)+ 2%8&$(@9)2&'<$+'

%%8&&D%&+% 8)**8$2&8$*A&&+%$;&+A=%8&:&%)%)+&2&<)$+(&8$*A&&+ :<$(&' +  %8&  2'&2*  :$**&'  A= %8)* 
92%  )+ 
  -  

E 05$%$+%&2  0)+48  $'$7  7  0%$%&    $2=$+$  $+'  %8&2*6  '&()'&'  + 

F
B

E08)2)$?$+'%8&2*70%$%&

$2=$+$$+'%8&2*6'&()'&'+B 

$+'


-C

E 3)*8$+  0$8$)  $+'  %8&2*  7  0%$%&    $2=$+$  $+'  %8&2*6  '&()'&'  +   

 +%8&%8&28$+'6<&$2+&'(9+*&< 2%8&0%$%&*9A?)%%&'%8$% %8&<$+')+>)+%;8&5$%)*5+&'A=&)48%(G*8$2&2*69% 58)(8*&7&+ )+(<9')+4%8&:&%)%)+&28$7&2&(&)7&'%8&(?:&+*$%)+8&:&%)%)+&26 58)*$
9+()<<2 %8&$2&$6)*%2=)+4%?)*<&$'%8)*(92%A=(+(&$<)+4 ?$%&2)$< $(%*+:$2$42$:8  %8&:&%)%)+6)%8$*A&&+:<&$'&'%8$% 5)%89%(+*)'&2)+4%8&A>&(%)+* )<&'A=%8&:&%)%)+&26+%) )($%)+9+'&2 0&(%)+ (%5$*)**9&'658&2&$*9% %8&%%$<$2&$)+%8& ;8&5$%?&$*92)+4 )48$*$+' )*5$*6 )*5$*$+' )*5$+*)*5$* 2&<&$*&'658&2&%8&(+*%29(%)+5$*&D)*%)+4%5$*+<=%8&A$<$+(&<$+'6 58)(85$*+%) )&'9+'&20&(%)+ (%

%&2%8&$5$2'5$*

B $++9+(&'6:**&**)+ %8&<$+'5$*%$;&+6%8948)%?$=+%8$7&A&&+ 9%)<)*&'  $*  *9(8  8&  :&%)%)+&2  %$;)+4  A&+& )%  %8&2&  8$'  2$)*&'

(+*%29(%)+A=&+(2$(8)+4:$2%%8&2& +($*&$+=(+*%29(%)+&D)*%&'$% %8&%)?& $(@9)*)%)+ <$+'658&+:$2% %8$%5$*2&<&$*&'6%8&:&%)%)+&2 59<'  8$7&  (&2%$)+<=  2$)*&'  %8&  )**9&  )??&')$%&<=  %8&2&$ %&26  $*  %8& +%) )($%)+9+'&20&(%)+ (%5$*)**9&'+  --C &$2'<&$2+&'(9+*&< 2%8&:$2%)&*$+':&29*&'%8&:$:&2 A; 8&:&%)%)+&2)+%8&:2&*&+%($*&)*(G*8$2&2)+$>)+%;8&5$% 8$7)+4%%$<$2&$  )48$*$+' )*5$*%) )($%)+9+'&20&(%)+

%8&C- (%5$*)**9&'+  --8&:&%)%)+&2)+(<9')+4%8&2(G *8$2&2* )<&'A>&(%)+*(<$)?)+4%8$%%8&2&)*(+*%29(%)++:$2% $(@9)2&'  <$+'6  58&2&  %5  2?*6  ;)%(8&+  $+'  7&2$+'$8$  8$7&  A&&+ (+*%29(%&'8&A>&(%)+*5&2&(+*)'&2&'8&
<<&(%22&(??&+'&'

2  2&<&$*&    %8$%  :2%)+    <$+'  8&  *$?&  5&2&  $((&:%&'  A=  %8& 7&2+?&+% 2&$ )*5$*$+' )*5$+*)*5$*+%+%) )&'9+'&2 0&(%)+ (%658)<&%8&2:$2% %8&;8&5$%5$*$(@9)2&'9%   &)48%  (G*8$2&2*6  *&7&+  )+(<9')+4  %8&  :&%)%)+&2  $((&:%&'  %8& (?:&+*$%)+)??&')$%&<=%8&2&$ %&28&:**&**)+ %8&<$+'5$*%$;&+ 8&$5$2'5$*$++9+(&'+B 

8948$:<&$)**948%%A&2$)*&'

)+%8&:2&*&+%:&%)%)+%8$%%8&2&&D)*%&'?2&(+*%29(%)+685&7&26+ *9(8)**9&5$*2$)*&'58&++%) )($%)+9+'&20&(%)+ (%5$* )**9&'$A9%+)+&=&$2*A$(;8&)**9&5$**948%%A&2$)*&'+<=$ %&2 %8&&+$(%?&+% %8&

(%A=(<$)?)+4%8$%%8&2&&D)*%&'(+*%29(%)++ %8&$(@9)2&'<$+'68&+(&6%8&$(@9)*)%)+<$:*&'&7&+%8948%8&:&%)%)+&2 8$'  %$;&+  %8&  (?:&+*$%)+  8&  $(%  %8$%  :$2%    %8&  <$+'6  58&2&

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

:**&**)+%$;&+A=%8&$9%82)%)&*65&'+% )+'%8$%$+=($*&)*?$'&9% )+%8&:2&*&+%:&%)%)+ 2)+7;)+4%8&:27)*)+* 0&(%)+

#

(% 2<$:*)+4 $(@9)*)%)+ 8&52)%:&%)%)+)*6$((2')+4<=6')*?)**&' $>&*8 )+'$<# 9'4&  927)+'&20)+48)<<# 9'4& -

 ?;

8&%8&2*:&$;)+4H2&$*+&', &*H 8&%8&22&:2%$A<&, &*H