Chhatter And ORS v. Haryana State And ORS .( Supersteructure/Trees/ Tube Wells/Apporationment Nature ( In Rfa 1235/11)
!"# $#%&'&()#%#*+#, -
) ./ 00/ ,#'#(") ,01!&2#($,!!&(-0#(&,$3%!"#4&"1 ,1!5#($#,- ,0!($##601!,*!- ,12!4!" , ,%1&("- , !$!3- ,*&"!&(- ,$!,'1!&(- ,!*78*!,0!&(& , '01##(808,!-$3%!"#'
,"1#2!($4(#,' ,01&3#($,!04!,6-''&'"!("$3%!"##(#,!2-!,9!(! !:#'1&($!2
! "
"
#$ "! ! $ " %!&
!"!' ( ! '( !"! "')* "! ,&# 29- "1# !%"' !,# "1!" "1# 2!($- '&"8!"#$ &( 3&22!5#' ;!<&,!+!$!($!&$#,68,=&,!(-#1'&2!($&'",&%"8,5!(4!''851"" +#!%>8&,#$+9"1#0"!"# !,9!(!3&$#("& &%!"&($!"#$ ?
&''8#$8($#,0#%"&(@ "1#/!($%>8&'&"&(%"-AB@
,'1,"-C"1# %". ,$#3#26*#("!($8"&2&'!"&("1#,# !',#'&$#("&!2-%**#,%&!2- &('"&"8"&(!2!($6#('6!%# ,0#%",' -
!($ @-8,5!("4!'
224#$+9("& &%!"&(8($#,0#%"&(? "1#%"$!"#$B?
?1# /!($%>8&'&"&(22#%",
,'1,"-"1#22#%",. -3&$#!4!,$@
$!"#$
D-$#"#,*&(#$"1#*!,E#"3!28# "1#!%>8&,#$2!($F
GH6#,!%,# ,!22"96#' 2!($6#,"!&(&(5"3&22!5#;!<&,!+!$ 55,#$ !5!&('" "1# !4!,$ "1# 22#%",- "1# 2!($ 4(#,' &2#$ +:#%"&('(,# #,#(%#8($#,0#%"&(A "1#%"-"1#2#!,(#$%8,"
+#24-3&$#$&
#,#("!4!,$'!''#''#$"1#*!,E#"3!28# "1#!%>8&,#$ 2!($F- GH6#,'>8!,#9!,$ ( '*# %!'#'- 3&$# !4!,$ $!"#$ @ - "1# 2#!,(#$ # #,#(%#8,"$#"#,*&(#$"1#*!,E#"3!28# "1#!%>8&,#$2!($F -@ GH6#,'>8!,#9!,$ ('*#%!'#'-3&$#$&
#,#("!4!,$'-"1#2#!,(#$# #,#(%# 8,"$#"#,*&(#$"1#*!,E#"3!28# "1#!%>8&,#$2!($F -D @GH6#, '>8!,#9!,$ ,"1#'!E# %(3#(&#(%#-$!"# ("& &%!"&(8($#,0#%"&( @ "1#%"-"1#!*8("!4!,$#$+9"1#22#%",!($"1## #,#(%#8,"
!($"1#$!"# !4!,$ "1## #,#(%#8,"&("1#6,#'#("'#" !66#!2'&'
#I",!%"#$+#24&("!+82!"#$ ,*) !"# *8("!4!,$#$+9 *8("!4!,$#$ !"# !4!,$ ("& &%!"&( "1#22#%",6#,!%,# +9"1## #,#(%# "1# 8($#,0#%"&( &( 8,"6#,'>8!,# # #,#(%# @ "1#%" 9!,$&( 8,"
?
- -@ GH @ -D @GH D
/#!,(#$%8('#2 ,"1#2!($4(#,''8+*&""#$"1!""1#!,#!!22 !,8($"1#!%>8&,#$2!($1!$!2,#!$9+##($#3#26#$!," "1#2!($&( '8,,8($&(54!'68,%1!'#$+9"1#+8&2$#,'!($$#3#26#$-41#,#!'6!,"4!' !%>8&,#$ 1#,# !,# (8*+#, '!2# $##$' 6,$8%#$ ( ,#%,$ +9 "1# 2!($4(#,' '14&(5 "1# 3!28# "1# !%>8&,#$ 2!($ 0*# "1# '!2# ",!('!%"&(' 6#,"!&( " "1# 2!($- !$:&(&(5 " 41&%1 4!' !%>8&,#$ 06#%& &%!229'!2#$##$ I
-3&$#41&%1 &'4!'!($ &'4!('&'2!($ 4!''2$!"!(!3#,!5#6,&%# @-D @6#,'>8!,#9!,$$#'#,3#'"+# ,#2&#$86( ,"1#68,6'# !''#''*#(" %*6#('!"&(-!'"1#1&51#'"
'!2##I#*62!,&'"+#%('&$#,#$-!'"1#,'!2#",!('!%"&('*!91!3#+##( 8($#,3!28#$1#2#!,(#$# #,#(%#8,"1!$5(#4,(5&(!6629&(5!
%8"
J-41&%1&'(":8'"1#'!2#",!('!%"&('6#,"!&("2!,5#%18(E' 2!($1#'#4#,#("&'2!"#$'!2#",!('!%"&('-1#(%#-$#'#,3#"+#,#2&#$ 86(4&"18"#3#(!662&%!"&( !(9%8"# 8,"1#,'8+*&""#$"1!" ,"1# #!,2&#,!%>8&'&"&(%2'#""1#!%>8&,#$2!($-"1&'%8,"&(A @
?K08$!*! !($ "1#,' 3 1# 0"!"# !,9!(! !($ "1#,'- 41#,# ("& &%!"&(8($#,0#%"&(@ "1#%"4!'&''8#$(ABBBD-1!$!''#''#$ "1#%*6#('!"&(F -
GH6#,'>8!,#9!,$ &(%,#!'#F J6#, !((8*4&"1%8*82!"&3##
#%", J6#,!((8* 2!"-&'%!2%82!"#$-'&*&2!,
&58,# 4&22 +# !,,&3#$ !" !($ "1# '!*# '182$ +# "1# !*8("
%*6#('!"&(-41&%1"1#2!($4(#,'$#'#,3#"+#5,!("#$("1#!,#!&( >8#'"&(-"1#+8&2$#,'1!$68,%1!'#$*'"6!," "1#2!($1#,#4#,# %#,"!&(2# "8"6%E#"'-41&%1"1#2!($4(#,'$&$("!5,##"'#22""1# +8&2$#,'-41&%14#,#!%>8&,#$1#2!($4(#,''182$("+#*!$#"'8
#, ("1!"!%%8("('866," "1#62#!"1!""1#!,#!!22!,8($1!$+##( $#3#26#$ +9 6,&3!"# +8&2$#,'- ,# #,#(%# 4!' *!$# " 3!,&8' 2&%#(%#' 5,!("#$8,"1#,,# #,#(%#4!'*!$#""1#,!"#'!"41&%1"1#62"'4#,# '2$+9*8%16,&,""1#!%>8&'&"&(&(>8#'"&( &("1#'!*#, (#!,+9!,#!1#+,%18,#%2#!,29'855#'"#$"1!""1#!,#!&'"1#+#'"62!%#" 2&3#&(4&"1!224,2$%2!'' !%&2&"&#'!3!&2!+2#1!"'14'"1#6,#'#("!($
8"8,#6"#("&!2&"9 "1#2!($ /#!,(#$%8('#2 8,"1#,,# #,,#$"2#""#, !22"*#(" ID 3&$#41&%12!,5#%18(E
D !%,#' 2!($4!'!22""#$+90"
@ G'//&*&"#$(B F -
GH6#,'>8!,#*#"#,1&''14'
6"#("&!2&"9 "1#2!($1#!
,#'!&$2!($&'2%!"#$:8'"%2'#""1# !%>8&,#$2!($4#3#,-2#!,(#$%8('#2%82$("$&'68"#"1# !%""1!""1# !
,#'!&$!22"*#("4!''#"!'&$#+9"1&'%8," 8,"1#, ,#2&!(%# 4!' 62!%#$ 86( !( ,$#, $!"#$ D - 6!''#$&(@B K6&!*3!,9!(!0"!"#!($"1#,'- 3&$#41&%1"1&'%8,"1!$!4!,$#$%*6#('!"&(F -
GH6#,'>8!,# 9!,$ ,"1#!%>8&'&"&(&("1#'!*#!,#!-41#,#("& &%!"&(8($#,0#%"&(@ "1#%"4!'&''8#$(BBBD,"1&'68,6'#-,#2&!(%#4!'62!%#$ 86(!:8$5*#(" "1&'%8,"&(08$!*!.'%!'# '86,! ("1#"1#,1!($-2#!,(#$%8('#2 ,"1#0"!"#'8+*&""#$"1!"
"1#2#!,(#$# #,#(%#8,"1!$,#2&#$86('!2#$##$ I
-41&%14!'
6#,"!&(&(5"!'*!2262" &'4!'!($ &'4!('&'"4!',#5&'"#,#$( @
1#!662&%!"&( %8"
J"1#,#(%!(("+#'!&$"+# 8(:8'"& &#$-%('&$#,&(5"1#'*!22(#'' "1#!,#!$#!2"4&"1"1#,#&(1# 0"!"#&'("&(!66#!2# 8,"1#,'8+*&""#$"1!""1#,#!,#(8*+#, '!2# $##$'6,$8%#$(,#%,$+9"1#2!($4(#,''"!,"&(5 ,*"1#9#!,BBA 22"1#'!2#$##$'& %('&$#,#$9#!,H4&'#$(",# 2#%""1!""1#,#4!'
%('&'"#("&(%,#!'#&("1#6,&%#' "1#2!($&("1#!,#!-,!"1#,-2!"#,&("&*# "1#6,&%#',#$8%#$('*#%!'#'-#3#(!""1#'!*#"&*# ,"1#2!($ 6#,"!&(&(5""1#'!*#,#3#(8##'"!"#-"1#,#4!'2" $&
#,#(%#&("1# 6,&%#'"*!9+# ,"1#,#!'( '6#%& &%2%!"&(,"1#'*!2262"+#&(5 %2'#""1#2!($!2,#!$968,%1!'#$+9"1#+8&2$#,' ,41&%1"1#+8&2$#,'
*!9+#4&22&(5"6!9!(96,&%#(%#"1#,#&'("1&(5(,#%,$"'14 "1!""1#,#4!'&(%,#!'#&("1#6,&%#' "1#2!($&("1#!,#!$8,&(5"1# &("#,,#5(8*-&"482$+#""!2298(:8'"& &#$"%2!&*&(%,#!'#-41&2#,# #,,&(5 ""1#:8$5*#(" "1&'%8,"&(08$!*!.'%!'# '86,! # 8,"1#,'8+*&""#$ "1!"3#($##'&(*'" "1#'!2#$##$'!,#+8&2$#,'-1#(%#-"1#,#!,#%1!(%#' 3#,'"!"#*#(" '!2#%('&$#,!"&(,6!9*#(" 1&51#,6,&%#' , %**#,%&!2!(52#%!(("+#,82#$8"# 8,"1#,'8+*&""#$"1!""1#,!"#'!"
41&%1"1#62"'1!$+##(!22""#$&("1#!,#!$#3#26#$*8%1! "#,"1# !%>8&'&"&(,&("1#!,#!'41&%1*!91!3#+##($#3#26#$! "#,"1##!,2&#, !%>8&'&"&(%!(("+#*!$#"1#+!'&' ,!''#''*#(" %*6#('!"&(-!'&"
%!((" +# %*6!,#$ 4&"1 8($#3#26#$ 2!($- 41&%1 4!' +#&(5 68" " !5,&%82"8,#8'#+# ,#&"'!%>8&'&"&( #!,$2#!,(#$%8('#2 ,"1#6!,"&#'!($6#,8'#$"1#,#2#3!("
,# #,,#$,#%,$ =&$# ("& &%!"&( $!"#$ ?
- "1# 2!($ 6#,"!&(&(5 " ,#3#(8##'"!"#' ;!<&,!+!$!($!&$#,68,=&,!(4!'!%>8&,#$ 1# '%!((#$%69 "1#!%>8&,#$2!($&'!66#($#$+#24) 1#,#&'('&"#62!(6,$8%#$(,#%,$+9"1#2!($4(#,'!' '8%1'14&(5"1#!%>8&'&"&( 2!($1#0"!"#4!'$&,#%"#$"6,$8%#!
'&"#62!(&(%8,"$#6&%"&(5"1#2%!"&( "1#2!($-41&%14!'6,$8%#$ 1#2!($4(#,'1!3#6,$8%#$3!,&8''!2#$##$'(,#%,$-41&%16#,"!&( ""1#,#3#(8##'"!"# 3&22!5#$!*68,-41&%1!,#!'8($#,) I !"# ,#!02$ "!20!2# 3#,!5# =&22!5# #5&'",!"&(
HH ('&$#,!"&( 6#,'>8!,# (9!,$
@
H@H
@-D-
-D ;!<&,!+!$
H@HB D-?
BBGH !&$!,68,
?
B
@
H H@ AA-
;!<&,!+!$ @ B
@ H
H
@A-
!&$!,68,
D
@
H HD -
;!<&,!+!$ ?
@
@
D
-BA ;!<&,!+!$ ?
D
H A-@
-D !&$!,68, D D
- -
-BBBGH ;!<&,!+!$ A
A A
D-B @GH ;!<&,!+!$ B
-??GH ;!<&,!+!$
H
-@
-
!&$!,68,
DH @-
- !&$!,68,
H
-A
B@GH !&$!,68,
@
H
H?
B
-A?GH ;!<&,!+!$ @
@
H H -?A-
@- @ GH H$H
D
@
H@ -B-
GH -D GH!&$!,68, ?
?
@
@-
GH -@ GH H$H D @ D
@
GH - D H$H A
D
@
@- ?- AAGH @-?
;!<&,!+!$ B B
@
H -
-B?DGH H$H
? B
@
HAHB DD-A
GH -D@GH H$H A B
@
HAHA A
-B GH H$H
@
H -
-?@ !&$!,68,
@
@-D ;!<&,!+!$ @ B D
H@H
-AA-
!&$!,68,
B D
@H
?-
@- BAGH H$H ?
A
H H ?
- -B
@-@ ;!<&,!+!$
B
H@H
@-B BGH H$H @?
D @BBA
?
A- ?-
-DBGH H$H @D
D @BBA
?
A- ?-
-DBGH H$H @A
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H @B
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H
D @BBA
?
A- ?-
-DBGH H$H
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H @
D @BBA
?
A- ?-
-DBGH H$H
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H ?
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H
D
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H ?
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H ?
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H ?
D @BBA
?
A- ?-
-DBGH H$H ?
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H ?
D @BBA
?
A- ?-
-DBGH H$H ? D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H ?
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H ?
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H ?@ D @BBA
?
A- ?-
-DBGH H$H ?
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H ??
D @BBA
?
A- ?-
-DBGH H$H ?D D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H ?A D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H ?B D @BBA
?
A- ?-
-DBGH H$H D
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H D D @BBA
?
A- ?-
-DBGH H$H D D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H D
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H D@ D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H D
D @BBA
?
A- ?-
-DBGH H$H D?
D @BBA
A- A-
-DBGH H$H ("1&'6!," "1#!,#!-"1#2!($1!$#!,2&#,+##(!%>8&,#$#,"!&( 2&%#(%#'1!$!2'+##(5,!("#$""1#6,&3!"#+8&2$#,'1#,#4!'#!,2&#, !%>8&'&"&( 2!($&("1#!,#!-"1#2!"#'"+#&(53&$#("& &%!"&($!"#$
?
-%2'#""1#!%>8&,#$2!($- ,41&%1"1&'%8,"&(B K1!($#,3!,9!(!0"!"#!($"1#,'-$#%&$#$'#6!,!"#29"$!9- !''#''#$"1#%*6#('!"&(F -@ GH6#,'>8!,#9!,$1#,#+#&(5"&*# 5!6 "49#!,'-&(*96&(&(-&(%,#!'# ,"1#"&*#5!6%!(+#5,!("#$" "1#2!($4(#,'$$&(5"1#'!&$!*8("-"1#%*6#('!"&(482$%*#8" " @GH6#,'>8!,#9!,$-41&%1"1#2!($4(#,'$#'#,3#"+#5,!("#$ 3#(& "1#'!*#&'%('&$#,#$4&"1,#5!,$""1#'!2#$##$'6,$8%#$( ,#%,$+9"1#2!($4(#,'6#,"!&(&(5""1#2!($ "1#!,#!-&(*96&(&(-
A "1#!
,#'!&$%*6#('!"&(4&22+#:8'"& &#$%('&$#,&(5"1#'*!22(#'' "1# 62"'$#!2"4&"1"1#,#&(!($"1#2!,5#!,#!!%>8&,#$ %%,$&(529-"1#2!($4(#,'!,#1#2$#("&"2#$"%*6#('!"&(F
@GH6#,'>8!,#9!,$ ,"1#!%>8&,#$2!($1#9'1!22!2'+##("&"2#$" !22'"!"8",9+#(# &"'!3!&2!+2#""1#*8($#,"1#%" 1#!66#!2'!,#$&'6'#$ !%%,$&(529
!:#'1&($!2 8$5# #%#*+#, -
*E
# #,"#6,"#,