← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/3496/2010disposed of

Punjab Small Ind. And Export Corp. Ltd v. Kartar Singh And ORS

2016-03-04Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi14 pages

 





!

"#$

%" 

"&

& '

(()**

 

      



 

 +,         -)  ".$/ -* #



- 0 " -/1 ! "#   $ % &   

 ' $ !) 

() *

+,#

  - . /012/013#%0!0    *

+,456*

+,#

  - . 2/17280%#%0!0 + *

+,#   

  

    - . /01//013#%0!0 - 0 " -/12

#*

45 " ,#!%  -  

*#4,3

  - . 2/17280%#%0!0# 9#,9  *        : ;#

  8

 - . /012/013#%0!0# 9

 4 *  , +  ,  * 

 

 # 

 





     



   

           - .2/17# %0!0 3 

     +  

   

 

 

  

!" #$%$







& '

( 

( #%$)*+ ( ,  - 

.

 

#&&#$%$





 



  

 

 

&%#$$/       

 0$1234  

  

 

  2  

#&&#$%$  

.

 







& (  5

 

0%#0#$$)



) ( 

             

 

         

 

 

 





& (

  5

 

#0#$$6   



)

(   

  

 

 

 (  

 

#$#0#$$&    



) (     

 

 

#%#00//8



) (     

 0$1234 9  ! 5 8/3:6 ;

   

 

$#0//)



& ( '

 



    #300//6  

 963$)%/:2'



   



 "





     







#% ( "



 %

 

   9 "

  

  

0000/#/ 

  

90  

                   

 

!"

    



  





    

   



  

  

<     #0 

       

      

   



 

     





    



 

   

    

  



 



 

 

        



   

 

   

    

&%#$$/



    

        

     

   

#&##0//0!= >##:(06(      #&##0//0

            

 

     

9)$////:2    

 

  

    )##$$)    

  <    

 

               

, "

 "  (5 3#6% 0//6  

!"

    0080/#8< 

  6

& 8/30//)   



  



!!" #$   



  ?2      

       

    



     

  



                

   

    



!    "#  





#

 

 

  $% & ''%()*

+,-.                

  %

#    /

      *

  

            /

      0      #   

    #     

 

        

 

 





 

       

         

   1  2  

3  (.

   1    

"    

  

      

 43  (.   53 

"  /

 

   5 "      6 78 # "

+ "

# 

   

           

 

 "

   

   

   

     0      #   

    #   

  $% & ''%()* +,-.                          

 %   #   

    

 

$% & ''%         # 

     

 

       

 

 

  "    

   9   

#   

 %  

    ''%

  

  

 

  

 

                  # 

    

 #       2



    # "     

         



    $% & ''%  ()*  +,-.

 5

#  

/

 0         

        

  #        

0         !    

   "  

 

  : /

  # 

   !    

      "    

 ; !  #     

  

     8 #$<#%%%-!

 = <   %   *-           

    9)$////:2 

9803///:2

 

, "



      



         

,

"

8

% 0080/#8 

?2  







 

  



 

 

 

    



   

 

  

 





  

  



  







    

  





  

            

    

      

    



 



    

 

   

   





   

!   





     

        

    





"               





  



 



#

  



     

      $

   

   

 



  

 



 

       

 !

   



 

   

   

 

    

              !

      

     



  

  

     





     



% 

 

           



 

  

  

    

 

    

 

     



 

   









    

      

      



 

&

   

   '   

  

&

  

   

    

    

 



()* 

   

 "



 





 

   

 

     !

  

   ! 

   

%  



 

  

 

  

  

+  

 



 "        

   

     

  

 -*   

                   

  

  

   



       



 

( 33 =



  

  



 <

    

        != @:$ 

   *+'"9,  -'

 8)3%$## #0#8



     



 

   



&1234 82) 

 

   

2    





      



   

 

     

   

  



 

   





  != >##:(:)$  #/86 '"9  "



  ;

     =            

  7 

;

A9006///:2  0//8   

 

 

  

 )     (    

 

 

#%#00//8   != >##:(:6#  #/8$ '"9 "



;

 =    



  7 

;

A906////:2 0//)   

   

   



   

   

 

  

 

  

   

;

(  != >6:(:8  638 '"9  2@  

  B   *"  -        

   #80#$$&

 @ "

 

;

 

  

7 

;

  08#$$8

08#$$6  96////:2 (  != >6:(:6  633 '"9  

     

  



  7 

;

 

#$)#$$&A9&0///:2 <

 

     2

 = 



 

    



     

 <





    

.

 

 

  



 

 

   

   

              ;

"



   

  7 

;

 

 < 

 

    

   != >$:(:# 3&3 '"9     

 

!"   &C 

0)80//& 98/#6///:2   96<   



   



   

  

, "

9 & :*  '

;2

   

 <

, "

&'%*-    

   #//D7   



E "



&'% *- 

         

        



      

    

 

&%#$$/  

  

   

   06

 







, "

&'%*- 

 

 

   



 

        

        

                

   

   .

 

  != >6:(:6     9&0///:2

#$)#$$&  





E "

  



 94 -<2

(4

",4  =( /* :* 9>9( #(:>9( !4

92

5  76  9?

1,  9 :*  '

;2

35 4   

  



#6D

 

  

 2   9&0///:2     #$)#$$& #%#00//8

 





) ( 

  



 

   

.

  #6D

 

  

         3    

 %  

        

9#%#)#8#/          

 

 9#%#)#):2     7 

         

   



, "

+(4,> #94@  3&5 >;

/ :*  '

,@

35  782 

           90        

   

   

 



  

 

    "



;

  =

   9006///:2 0//8      



(  "



                   0//)        906////:2      

   

  

    #%#00//8    

  

90 

#%#00//8    

    

=   

  

  

=

              

  

 B  

 < =  

   



  "

 

 

  



  

      

 

  &%#$$/ 

     

 

 

  

 )     (    #%#00//8        2        

   

 





) (

 



     

  

        

       

          

              

        

    

 

 

  

 

  

 

 

   

 







   

  





  

  

 

E "

       

   

  (

   

E  "



8/30//)  97(5 )6)6 0//8   

 9)$////:2

9803///:2



0080/#8

   

 

   <   

E

"

      (

 

      



      

    

9803///:2

 &%#$$/

#3#00//8  

       

 .

 

     

 

 



     

 9803///:2

 

        

 



  



 

 <  

 

     

 

   



   

      



      

  



   

 #,, >



   

          2 8/30/#)  

"

97(5 )6)6 0//8  0080/#8  

E "

 

     

 

 

!"



     

 

   

 

  #,,

  

   

    .

 

   

  

     

   

       



    

 2 0080/#8     

E "

   

  

 

     



  "

 8/30//)

 

E "

 0080/#8

    

        

          

    

                      "

    

       

   

 

   2  

E  "



 2 



  ,#,

9, + ,  , ,  4

 +,9 4   ###   , #,  ,, , #,  +*, 4  #  *  # ,  +4 # 

# 9 ,, *

  +# 4

9  ,,+ *##  4 9  ,* *   #    9

" 

# 9  4 < #,    # (+ #,<   * 

9 

#,,*   #   4 

9

 #,, 

 =4+* +>    %%2%0!2

9=?  *  4 

 ,+  # 2*%3*000@> 4#7A!110!3!%%002*     9,+ 9 # #9  6  *  4  



 

 9 # +  *  ++  # ,  9*  4     +     +*  

  #  

    #*+  *4+* 4  ,  **

3- 0 " -/15 ? # &