Virendra Kumar Bhatnagar v. Municipal Corporation, Gurugram And Others

  
 
 
 
  
   
   
   
 











 !"

 !"

 !"

 !"

#$% %&'(')*

#$% %&'(')*

#$% %&'(')*

#$% %&'(')*           







+',%)-,#./0#,1#$)#2#, %$'$')%, +( !/)'&'3#4
,3,#$') /,/2,#0#)-$1%,( %(3)-%)$(

!*
!*
!*
!*56!
..! 56!
..! 56!
..! 56!
..!

,%(%)$* !,(1'(1
13,#7-8&#$%7

,$1%3%$'$')%, !,69%(1')1#47-8&#$%7

,$1%,%(3)-%)$:&#8%#$,

..!7 ..!7 ..!7 ..!7 1%3%$'$')%,'(#22,'%8%-#2#')($$1%,-%,-#$%-

;

3#((%- <= $1% ')$
00'((')%,7 !/)'&'3#4
,3,#$')7 /,/2,#0 #)- ,-%, -#$%- >



 3#((%- <= $1%
00'((')%,7 !/)'&'3#4
,3,#$')7/,/2,#0<=?1'&11'(#33%#4 '4%-/)-%,%&$')@  $1% #,=#)# !/)'&'3#4
,3,#$') &$7 ;;@ A , (1,$ B$1% &$5C 1#( <%%) -'(0'((%- )<,'% 7$1%3%$'$')%,?#((%,8%-?'$1#)$'&%/)-%,%&$') @  "<"   $1% &$ )  

 #44%2')2 $1#$ 1% '( ') /)#/$1,'D%- 3((%((')   4#)- 0%#(/,')2

 #&,%(7 ,0')2 3#,$   .1#(,# @E 7 ('$/#$%- ') $1% ,%8%)/% %($#$%   '9#)-%,3/, 1('7 /,/2,#0  1% 3%$'$')%, (/<0'$$%- 1'( ,%34= #44%2')2 1'( 3((%((') $ <% 4%2#4 #)- #/$1,'D%- ) $1% 2,/)- $1#$ $1% 4#)- ?#( 2'8%) $ 1'0 ) 4%#(% <= $1% ,#0#)&1#=#$7'9#)-%,3/,1('7/,/2,#0')

> ,#3%,'- E

 =%#,(#)-$1%,%# $%, ,0$1%=%#,

$ >?1'&1&#0%$#)%)-) F> >1%8'44#2%'9#)-%,3/,1('?#(')&4/-%-?'$1')$1%4'0'$( !/)'&'3#4
,3,#$')7/,/2,#08'-%)$'

'&#$')-#$%-F

#)-# $%, $1% $%,0')#$')   4%#(% ) F> > ) %G$%)(') ?#( 2,#)$%- <= $1% !/)'&'3#4
,3,#$')7/,/2,#01%3%$'$')%,1#- '4%-#&'8'4(/'$ , (%%9')23%,0#)%)$')H/)&$')?1'&1?#(-%&,%%-);  @,%($,#')')2 $1% !/)'&'3#4
,3,#$')7 /,/2,#0 , $#9')2 3((%((') ?'$1/$ #-3$')2-/%&/,(% 4#?#)-$1%(#'-,-%,?#(/31%4-')#33%#4-%&'-%- )E 

1%,%# $%,)$'&%?#('((/%-/)-%,%&$')@  "<" $1% &$ )  

 ') ?1'&1 $1% '03/2)%- ,-%, ?#( 3#((%- )

;

#2#')($ ?1'&1 $1% 3%$'$')%, '4%- $1% ($#$/$,= #33%#4 <% ,% $1%
00'((')%,7!/)'&'3#4
,3,#$')7/,/2,#0 6%#,)%-&/)(%4 ,$1%3%$'$')%,1#((/<0'$$%-$1#$# $%,$1% 4%#(%?#($%,0')#$%-7#&$')&/4-1#8%<%%)$#9%))4=/)-%,$1%#,=#)# /<4'&,%0'(%(#)-6#)-8'&$')#)-%)$%&8%,="&$7 ;

A ,(1,$ B$1% &$  ;

5C #)- )$ /)-%, $1% 3,8'(')(   $1% &$  4$1/217 4%#,)%- &/)(%4 ,$1%3%$'$')%,1#(8%1%0%)$4= #,2/%-1'( &#(%</$1#(

#'4%-$0#9%#(/<($#)$'#4(/<0'((') ,3%,(/#-')2$1'(
/,$$$#9%# 8'%? -'

%,%)$ ,0 $1% 8'%? $#9%) <= $1%
00'((')%,7 !/)'&'3#4
,3,#$')7/,/2,#0')1'('03/2)%-,-%,1%3,8'(')( $1%&$

;

 #,% )$ #$ #44 #334'&#<4% #( $1% 3,3%,$= 8%($( ?'$1') $1% 4'0'$(  !/)'&'3#4
,3,#$')7 /,/2,#0 , ?1'&1 $1%= 1#8% ,'21$4= ')'$'#$%- 3,&%%-')2(')$%,0( %&$')@ $1%&$$,%&8%,3((%((') ,0 $1%3%$'$')%,7?1'(')/)#/$1,'D%-3((%((') ,0$1%4#($ /,=%#,(

>
)(%I/%)$4=7 ')-')2)0%,'$')$1%3,%(%)$3%$'$')7$1%(#0%'(1%,%<= -'(0'((%-$1/21?'$1/$#)=,-%,#($&($( ..!"

..!"

..!"

..!"            







              
 1%$1%,(3%#9')2:,%#()%- 

%(: 1%$1%,,%3,$#<4%

%(: