Aseem Takyar v. Union Of India And ORS

 


   ! " #   
 " 

"$%&"&'()(*+  

 )&&,$-.$/ &%(%(*&/ 0&/)1)

*(**2($$*2$*%3&/ &)4*2&*%)
 +5!

6
7 6 

8
 6
 5!

6


 8 "


   



    

 "    #$   %&

6 

8
 6
 '()      
&+ ,$

$- .))1$*'&9/(%'&/%(/$/(8,$*2$,1)/$*. %3&/  )1(%$:;&  9/(%8  /2&/8  /  2(/&'%(*  $)  %3()  *5:;&
1/%,$.2&&,(%(*%3&$'%)$*2'(/'1,)%$*'&)%3& '$)&&)4&'($;;.(*%3&*$%1/&,$*2$,1)2(/&'%(*<%3& /&)4*2&*%)%/&,=&%3&;;;$>$$%7  

%7   !3$<$*;;;$>$$%1/%3$;"()%/('%6*(4$%,$(*%$(*&2 :./&)4*2&*%):&(*<(;;&<$;8=(2$*2$<$(*)%*%(('$%(* 2$%&2@ 

  **&A1/& 8(*%3&(*%&/&)%B1)%('&C   ,$ ,$             /  

  ,    ,#          0

      



 

   "

 $ 

,  12 3 %&13002 , 

/ 

#    , 40 

 * 
/5  6 7
 40  $ & $ ,$,    

      ,  ,   ,          2

 " %& , 12  89$

# ,  
/,#   0    

  %



   $

 9       0         &   , /5 5#   12     12

 &#,

 12 1 3002

- '$%(*%;;4;$>$ '3& &A&'1%(*< $1%3/(%.

/  %3& '*'&))(*$(/&8$)%3&'$)&,$.:&8)3$;;&)%$:;()3$%;; 4;$>$:&.*2$2()%$*'&%&*-(;,&%&/)/,$,1*('(4$; /;'$;%9*$/&$;(,(%)+ /=(2&2%3$%%3&&A&'1%(*<$1%3/(%.,$.8/ /&$)*)  %  :&  /&'/2&2  (*  9/(%(*<8  ;'$%&  /  $;;9  %3& '*'&))(*$(/&%;'$%&$%;;4;$>$9(%3(*$2()%$*'&%&*

  -(;,&%&/))1'3,1*('(4$;/;'$;%9*$/&$;(,(%)8:1% (**'$)&9(%3(*(=&-(;,&%&/))1'3,1*('(4$;/;'$; %9*$/&$;(,(%)+ /=(2&21/%3&/%3$%93&/&$)&'%(*%3& *$%(*$;3(<39$.84&/,$*&*%:/(2<&8:.4$))/%1**&;8$) %3&'$)&,$.:&8()'*)%/1'%&29(%3(*%3&,1*('(4$;/ %9*$/&$;(,(%)/9(%3(*(=&-(;,&%&/)/,)1'3;(,(%)8 4/(,$/(;./1)&%3&/&)(2&*%))1'3,1*('(4$;/%9* $/&$8%3&%;;4;$>$,$.:&&)%$:;()3&29(%3(*%3&,1*('(4$; /%9*$/&$;(,(%)/9(%3(*$2()%$*'&(=&-(;,&%&/) /,)1'3;(,(%)C     $  

   9  9$   ,

    

,,# 12

+"  -%&  , / #, ,#   0:

30 ;      9

,5#30 <  &, 

       ,      ,    /  $,# # 9    

/

 ,$ & 

3 $ , 

/  

#   ,$  40 #,   12 3,$

, , 

/ 

E      40 

12'3)- '$%(*%;;4;$>$+ 

 *.%3&/%;;4;$>$*%3&)$,&)&'%(* *$%(*$;3(<39$.$*2(*%3&)$,&2(/&'%(*)3$;;*%:& &)%$:;()3&29(%3(*$2()%$*'&)(A%.-(;,&%&/)+ /=(2&2  %3$%  93&/&  %3&  &A&'1%(*<  $1%3/(%. 2&&,)  *&'&))$/.8  (%  ,$.  / /&$)*)  %  :&  /&'/2&2  (* 9/(%(*<8&)%$:;()3/$;;9%3&'*'&))(*$(/&%&)%$:;()3 $*%3&/%;;4;$>$9(%3(*$2()%$*'&)(A%.-(;,&%&/)+ /=(2&2  1/%3&/  %3$%  $  %;;  4;$>$  ,$.  :& &)%$:;()3&2  9(%3(*  $  2()%$*'&    )(A%.  -(;,&%&/)  /, $*%3&/%;;4;$>$()1'3%;;4;$>$()/';;&'%(*&&/ $4&/,$*&*%:/(2<&8:.4$))/%1**&;C  $ , 5 $  



 ,         ,    

    /  ,$  ,     40      %$

# %

 "  %$

#    

   

 3= :00 24         

# ,

 $     12

                      7 

$ , %$ 
3&%*$6'(&%. &<2 $*2 */

0) 
3(&&*&/$;$*$<&/&'3*('$;$*2 %3&/) @6

*;(*& ;;?



 ,    

# ,

 $     2 3#,

@  9 

$   $ &)3$;;*&A%2&$;9(%3%3&'3$;;&*<&*%3& </1*2%3$%1*2&/ 1;&  8%3&2()%$*'&:&%9&&*%9%;;

4;$>$))31;2*%:&;&))%3$*)(A%.-(;,&%&/)*%3&)$,& )&'%(*$*$%(*$;3(<39$.$*2(*%3&)$,&2(/&'%(* 3& '/1'($;9/2) 1;&  $/&D$*.%3&/%;;4;$>$*%3& )$,&  )&'%(*    *$%(*$;  3(<39$.  $*2  (*  %3&  )$,& 2(/&'%(*C   *  %3&/  9/2)8  93&/&  *&  )&'%(*    %3& *$%(*$;3(<39$.():&(*<2&=&;4&21*2&/$'*'&))(* $</&&,&*%8%3&2()%$*'&$*%3&/%;;4;$>$*%3$%)&'%(* )31;2  *%  :&  9(%3(*  )(A%.  -(;,&%&/)   =(2&*%;.8  %3() /&F1(/&,&*% 1;&  ()*%:/&$'3&2(*%3&4/&)&*%'$)& 3&&///*%3&4$/%%3&4&%(%(*&/);(&)(*'**&'%(*< %9)&4$/$%&)&'%(*)%3&*$%(*$;3(<39$.$*2%/&$%(*< %3&,  $)  (  %3&.  $/&  *&  9  )&4$/$%&  '*'&))(* $</&&,&*%)3$=&:&&*&*%&/&2(*%:. 8*&/%3& /$2$:$2!$/&(;;.  )&'%(*  /,  -(;,&%&/  E   %

93('39$)$9$/2&2* &:/1$/.   3& )&'*2$*22()%(*'%)&'%(*()/%3&)%/&%'3/,!$/&(;;.% 6(%$41/$;;(*</,-(;,&%&/ %E

 /93('3$'*'&))(*$</&&,&*%9$)&A&'1%&2*

1*&

 3&/&$/&%9)&4$/$%&'*'&))(*$</&&,&*%)/%3& 2&=&;4,&*%%9)&4$/$%&)&'%(*) E &*'&8%3& /&F1(/&,&*% 1;&  ()*%:/&$'3&2  3&%;;4;$>$ 93('3():&(*<&)%$:;()3&2$%-(;,&%&/ ? ()*%3& !$/&(;;.6(%$41/  )&'%(*  $*2  3&*'&8  /  %3&  41/4)&   ',41%(*<%3&2()%$*'&9(%3(*%3&,&$*(*< 1;&  8%3& %;;4;$>$*%3&/$2$:$2!$/&(;;.)&'%(*91;2:&* /&;&=$*'& 3&4/=()(*) 1;&  3$=&8%3&/&/&8*% :&&*:/&$'3&2C   
&+  $ 1:'3)

?      ;<#     

#

                ,$       ,        + "     %&,     ,  $ 

  4 

,$ ,#$2 

  4

 300  #   ,$   #9         /9$  # 

 $ &                       $  
&+ $$ , $ / ,,   #,   $# 7 6 

 
 6
 

   " 3> 30 = 
 

 $@  A@

  , A@