Subhash Chander v. Anil Kumar & ORS


  


 

 !" #"$%&%'( 

 )*+, &,, '#"- .."// '! 0"-&*& '%/1*2 - '#!,"-& "&.'#"'!&



)*+, &,, '#"- '# '!,"- .."// '!& 0"-&*& '%/1*2 - '#!,"-& "&.'#"'!&  3456 )1 7,"!,"-".-!"-& 6$ /"8&. ."-&2 9+" //8"#!  &""!,":*#;2"'!< "&

+"-"

"--"#!!,"".-!"-&-'!<"& 7,"!,"-!,":*#;2"'!&,*/#+"-".-!"#%'!,"%;"&!<"& -"&"'!3),-%))),"=, 8 !#0$ !" -!," .."// '!&>%'+!,  .." /& ),-%)%'; />#0$ !" --"&.'#"'!?4 '&*- '$"2. '9>%'+!, .." /&  9!,%&$22':*#;2"'!%'!"'#!#%&.&" 


!%!/"# &)*+, &,, '#"-0"-&*&'%/1*2 - '#!,"-& '#




!%!/"# &)*+, &,, '#"- '#!,"-&0"-&*& '%/1*2 - '#!,"-& &+!,!,"&" .." /&, 0" -%&"'*! !,"'"

%'$%#"'! '# 8 -#
-$'0"'%"'$"> $!& -"+"%';! ="' -2




.."// '!&  , 0"  #%-"$!"#  !,"  -"& %#  .." /&  ; %'&!  !,"

8 -## !"#

. &&"#+9 ),-%1 2 /1 '!> !-$$%#"'!

/ %2&  -%+*' />  ,! =  0%#"  8,%$,  $/ %2  ."!%!%'  .-" "--"#  +9  !,"

$/ %2 '!&  8"-"  //8"#  8%!,  $&!&  '#  !,"  $/ %2 '!&  8"-"  8 -#"# $2."'& !%' &@>

A4 '#& >?

A4-"&."$!%0"/9,".- 9"-

-"', '$"2"'! $2."'& !%', &+""'2 #"%'!,"&"!8 .." /&  / %2 '!&, 0".-"

"--"#."!%!%'&*'#"-)"$!%'   !- B",%$/"&$! %'&,-!4!,"$! & -"& %# ? -%"

/9!,"$ &" !,"$/ %2 '!&%&!, !'?

%! ': /%C ': /% /';8%!,,"-2!,"- %!,%/"&,8"-"$2%'; -2,! =$%!9! ,"-,2"8,%/"&%!!%'; &.%//%'-%#"-'&$!94 4?D 8,%/"

%!,%/"&, 8 & #-%0%'; !,"& %#  &$!9 !  +*!   .2>8,"' !,"9 -" $,"#  '" -  ,"'#-  #"/  )$,/>  )'". !   #>  ,! =>  %'  !," 2" '!%2"> !-*$=+" -%';-";%&!- !%'4

4(@ $ 2" -2,! = $%!9&%#"+"%';#-%0"'+9%!&#-%0"-- &,/9>'";/%;"'!/9 '# ! ,%;,&.""# 8%!,*! //8%';!,"!-

%$-*/"& '#!= &*##"'!*-'!8 -#&)*'$%!9 9"4. &&8%!,*!;%0%'; '9%'#%$ !- '#&!-*$=!,"&%#" !,"

"'#%';

0",%$/"%'!!,"&$!9 %!,%/"&, '#$ *&"#!," $$%#"'!*"!!," %2. $! %!,%/"&, '#%! ': /% "//#8''!,"- # /';8%!,&$!9 '# &*&! %'"#&"-%*& '#;-%"0*&2*/!%./"%':*-%"&'!,"%-."-&'& %!,%/"&, '#%! ': /%8"-"! ="'! )>,! = !"- -- ';%';&2".-%0 !"

0",%$/"+*! %!,%/"&,#%"#%'!,"8 9!,&.%! / '#%! ': /%#%"##*-%';

 !,"!-" !2"'! ! )>,! =%'2-'%';,*-&

,"#-%0"-  !,"

"'#%';0",%$/" /"# 8 9 -2!,"&.! !"-/" 0%';!,"

"'#%';

0",%$/"  !  !,"&.!," $$%#"'! 8 &  8%!'"&&"# +9)*+, &,  !,"- 

%! ': /% '#*'$/")*-"'#"-)%';,>8,8"-"&! '#%';'!,"&%#"%' 8 %!%'; - *!-%$=&, 8 -)*-"'#"-)%';,  %!,%/"&, #"$" &"#8 & ;"# +*!@9" -& '#8 &-*''%'; +" *!9. -/*- '#8 &" -'%'; &

A4."-2'!,),"8 &, 0%';&*'#," /!, '#.,9&%E*"),"8 & $'!-%+*!%';  //  ,"-  " -'%';  -  !,"  2%/9  7,/"    !,"  2%/9  8 & #"."'#"#*.',"- -"0"-9 &."$! /% "%! ': /%#"$" &"#8 & ;"#

9" -& '#8 & &!*#"'! !,$/ && '#*&"#!$'!-%+*!","-2!,"-%' ,*&",/#  8-=  '#  &,"  8 &  " -'%';  &

A4  ."-  2'!,  !8 -#& ,*&",/#

%-&

''!%$">-"&.'#"'!& .." -"# '#-"&.'#"'!& '#

 %/"#!,"%-:%'!8-%!!"'&! !"2"'!&!%&./" #"#!, !  /&"
, & +""';!-";%&!"-"#+9!,"."!%!%'"-&%'$//*&%'8%!,!,"/$ /./%$"," %'0/0"2"'! !,"

"'#%';0",%$/"%'!," $$%#"'!8 &#"'%"# !%&

*-!,"-#"'%"#!, ! $$%#"'!!=./ $"#*"!- &, '#'";/%;"'!#-%0%';

-"&.'#"'!"'9%';!,"- 0"-2"'!&> '&8"-%';-"&.'#"'!&.- 9"#

-#%&2%&& / !,"$/ %2."!%!%'& "&.'#"'!    %'  ,%&  8-%!!"'  &! !"2"'! !=  .-"/%2%' -9 +:"$!%'&-"; -#%';2 %'! %' +%/%!9>$ *&"  $!%'"!$ '2"-%!&>%!%& ./" #"#!, !!," '&8"-%';-"&.'#"'!, &&/#!,"

"'#%';0",%$/"! 1 &,2%-%  6 /  &'   !,*-   &&  -"&%#"'!    1 -! -.*- >  ,! =  '

DD

8,"-" &!," $$%#"'!, &$$*--"#'?

//!,"#$*2"'!&

?

."-! %'%';!!,"0",%$/"%'$/*#%';%'&*- '$", &+""'!- '& "--"#%'!,"

' 2" 1 &,2-%6 /+"

-"!," $$%#"'! '#& %#1 &,2-%6 /, &! ="' !,"

"'#%';0",%$/"'&*."-# -% -2!,"$*-! ( "&.'#"'!4'&*- '$"2. '9%'%!&8-%!!"'&! !"2"'! !=&"0"- /.-"/%2%' -9+:"$!%'&!%& //";"#!, !-"&.'#"'!8 & '!,/#%'; 0 /%# '#"

"$!%0"#-%0%';/%$"'$"!#-%0"!,"

"'#%';

0",%$/" !!,"!%2"  $$%#"'! '#!, !-"&.'#"'!48'"- !,"

"'#%';

0",%$/", &0%/ !"#!,"!"-2& '#$'#%!%'& !,"%'&*- '$"./%$"'

2"-%!&>%!%&./" #"#!, !  /&"
, &+""'/#;"#%'$//*&%'8%!,!," /$ /./%$"+9!,"."!%!%'"-&,"$'!"'!& 
8"-"8-';/ %2 '!& , 0"  $'$$!"#  /&"  &!-9  %'  !,"  ."!%!%'  "'9%';  !,"-  0"-2"'!&> '&8"-%';-"&.'#"'!.- 9"# -#%&2%&& / !,"$/ %2."!%!%'& @ -"./%$ !%'8 & %/"#
-2!,"./" #%';& !,". -!%"&>

//8%';%&&*"&8"-" - 2"#34

7,"!,"-.-"&"'! $$%#"'!%&!,"*!$2"- &, '# '";/%;"'!#-%0%'; 0",%$/"+" -%';4

A(@  +"%';#-%0"'+9-"&.'#"'!'%/1*2 -'?

 -"&*/!%';%'!#" !, %!,%/"&, '#%! ': /%> & //";"#<

 %&&*"%&.-0"#%'

%-2 !%0">!8, ! 2*'! '#

-28,2>!,"."!%!%'"& -""'!%!/"#!-"$0"-<

 "/%"

D ,"-%+*' /> !"- &&"&&%';!,"!"&!%2'9 !,"8%!'"&&"& $$".!"#!,"$/ %2."!%!%'&> & -"& %#
""/%';#%&& !%& %"#8%!,!," +0"& %#8 -#>!," .."// '!& , 0"#%-"$!"#!,".-"&"'! .." /&> & -"& %#

 , 0"," -#/" -'"#$*'&"/ -!,". -!%"& '#, 0";'"

!,-*;,!,"-"$-#& !,"$ &" 6" -'"#$*'&"/ -!," .."// '!&, &&*+2%!!"#!, !%'$2"

%!,%/"&,, &+""'$2.*!"#'/8"-&%#" '$2"! F-"!*-'& -!,"

9" -

D4

8 & %/"#%'8,%$,%'$2" !,"#"$" &"#, &+""'&,8'

&&>

A4.   ,"%'$2"! F-"!*-'  %!,%/"&, -!,"9" -

, & .-0"#,"-%'$2" &&>?

A4."- ''*2,"/" -'"#-%+*' /, & %;'-"#!,"-"*!-'&," *!*-".-&."$!*&-"; -#%';%'$2" #"$" &"#

%!,%/"&,  '#  ""! ':%  , &  '!  +""'  ! ="'  %'!  $$*'!   &*2  

&

A4%'-"&."$! / &!-%!"& 8 -#"#+9!,"-%+*' /%&'/8"-&%#" ," 2*'!;- '!"#%'-"&."$! $'&-!%*2%& /&"F!-"2"/9'/8"- &%#"%'-"&."$! +!,!,"#"$" &"# ? 6" -'"# $*'&"/  - !,"  .."// '!& , & -"/%"# *.'

*!,-%!9 

  !"#"

$

 %  "

&'(#%$ ) '  -"./9  !  !,"  +0"  '!"#  &*+2%&&%'&>  $*'&"/  -  !,"

-"&.'#"'!& , &&*+2%!!"#!, ! #"$" &"#4 %!,%/"&,8 &'!#%'; '9 +*&%'"&& '#%'$2"! F-"!*-', &+""'&*+2%!!"#'/9!$-" !""0%#"'$" -"; -#%';%'$2"!%&&*+2%!!"#!, !$/ %2 '!&, #'!"F 2%'"# '9 8%!'"&&>8,8 & $*&!2"- " *!9 -/*- //";"#/9-*'+9 %!,%/"&, ,"%'$2" &@

A4."- ''*2 &&"&&"#+9!,"-%+*' /%&',%;,"- &%#"   !%& *-!,"-&*+2%!!"#!, !%' *!,-%!9*+*"

  ,  , 

  %  "

& (-&#( %$

.>'5+/"!,"."F*-!, &+&"-0"#!, ! 2*'!%'-"&."$!

*!*-"  .-&."$!*&  $ '  '/9  +"  ;- '!"#>   %'  $ &"  !,"  #"$" &"#  %&  0"-'2"'!"2./9"" '# , &."-2 '"'!%'$2" ," 2*'! /-" #9 ;- '!"#%&',%;,"-&%#" '# &&*$,'$ &"%&2 #"*! -"', '$"2"'! !%&&*+2%!!"#!, ! %' *!,-%!9  " / + 012-  3# +%

 "

)."$% /6" 0"!.." /  &@ @

?#"$%#"#'

(

?>!,"%0%&%'"'$, '5+/"."F*-!

, &  -"

"--"#  !,"  2 !!"-  !  / -;"-  "'$,  !  #"!"-2%'"  8,"!,"-  *!*-"

.-&."$!*&  %'  -"&."$!    !,"-  !, '  0"-'2"'!  "2./9""  $ '  +" $'&%#"-"#< ( '-"./9!!," +0"'!"#&*+2%&&%'>/" -'"#$*'&"/ -!,"

.."// '!&, & *-!,"-&*+2%!!"#!, !!,%&*-!%' *!,-%!94/!"+ 

   #    56  

  
 D   

#"$%#"#' '* -9 >

?,"/#!, !!," *!,-%!9 

 7 0&+%( $ ' +"-"/%"#  & !,"2 !!"-, & +""' #%&$*&&"# %'  #"! %/ -"; -#%'; *!*-".-&."$!*&!%&&*+2%!!"# /!,*;,!,".-'*'$"2"'! 2 #"+9'5+/"!,"."F*-!%' *+*"

 70 &+%( %& "E* /"'$,+*!!,"  *!,-%!9 

 70 &+%( %&-"E*%-"#!+" //8"#>%'0%"8 !,"+&"-0 !%'&2 #"+9 !,%&*-!%'4/!"+

 70&+%( #"$%#"#' '* -9 >

? @ ," %-&!E*"&!%'8,%$, -%&"& -#"!"-2%' !%'%&!, !8,%$,

!," *!,-%!%"&%"> *!,-%!9*+*"

 70&+%(-

( !, !  *!,-%!9

 70&+%(&,*/#+" //8"# %'-"&."$! ;- '! *!*-".-&."$!*& #"$" &"# !,  !,"&"

*!,-%!%"&, 0"+""'.-'*'$"#+9!,-""*#;"&"'$, '5+/"."F *-!,%&*-!%' *!,-%!94/!"+

  +#  

56 

 
'



#"$%#"#' '* -9

?-"/9%';*.'
*//"'$, *!,-%!9 !,%&*-! 

#8" "*

3+*

 %  //

"% '9 + !

56  &( ,"/#!, !8,"'!,"-"%& #%-"$!$' /%$!

+"!8""'  !8  #"$%&%'&    !,"  )*.-"2"  *-!  -"'#"-"#  +9  $4"E* / "'$,"&>%'!, !$ &">!,"0%"8! ="'+9!,""'$,8,%$,%&2-" -" &' +/" &,*/# +"  //8"#  )> %' *!,-%!9 4/!"+

 70&+%(>!,%&*-!$2"&!!,"$'$/*&%'!, !&%'$"- !%

/ 8/ %##8'+9'5+/"."F*-!%' *!,-%!9

 7 0&+%( , &'!+""'#%&.-0"#+9'5+/"!,"."F*-! '# "/ +- !"-" &'%';&, 0"+""';%0"'+9!,"."F*-!%'!,"& %#$ &"

-;- '!%'; *!*-".-&."$!*& '# &&*$,!,"0%"8! ="'+9'5+/"!," ."F*-!%'!, !$ &">$ '+"& "/9 //8"# D  )>-"/9%';*.' *!,-%!9 4/!"+

 70 &+%(  2 !,"0%"8!, !0%"8! ="'%' 

 70 &+%(-"; -#%'; *!*-".-&"$!*&%'-"&."$! &"/ 4"2./9"#."-&'$ '

+" //8"#

,"&"$'#E*"&!%' -%&"& -$'&%#"- !%'%&8,"!,"-!,"

%'$2" &&"&&"#+9!,"-%+*' /%'-"&."$!  %!,%/"&,&,*/#+"

@ $ /$*/ !"#'!,"+ &%& %'$2"! F-"!*-'&-'!<

 ,"-%+*' />  !"- ..-"$% !%';!,""0%#"'$"-" $,"#!!,"

$'$/*&%'!, !!,"&"-"!*-'&, 0"+""' %/"#8%!,%' &. ' 4?2'!,& '# &&*$,!,"&"-"!*-'&$ ''!+" $$".!"#!,"-8%&" /&>!,"$/ %2 '!& , 0" '!.-#*$"# '9"0%#"'$"'!," %/"!, ! %!,%/"&,8 & $!* //9 #%';!,"+*&%'"&& " *!9 -/-0"'!,"$/ %2 '!&, 0"'!&! !"#!," ./ $" 8-=  %!,%/"&,%'-"&."$! +*&%'"&& " *!9 -/-'"

!,"$/ %2 '!%&) '#&2"!%2"&-"!*-'& ''4" -'%';8% "%& %/"#:*&!

!&,8 '9&". - !"%'$2" #"$" &"#'!,".-"&"'!$ &">!,"%'$2"

! F-"!*-'&,8&!, !'! F, &+""'. %#)>!,"-"8 &' %' '$% / /% +%/%!9%'&*+2%!!%';!,"&"-"!*-'&!,"-8%&"> &#%&$*&&"# +0">%'!," +&"'$"  '9"0%#"'$"!, !!,"#"$" &"#8 & $!* //9#%';!,"+*&%'"&&  " *!9 -/->!,"& %#-"!*-'& -"2" '%';/"&&

,"/" -'"#-%+*' / , & ! ="'!,"%'$2" #"$" &"#  & &@

A4."- ''*2,"E*"&!%' -%&"&8,"!,"-!," 2*'!%&-"E*%-"# !+""', '$"#%'-"&."$! *!*-".-&."$!*&<'290%"8!," 2*'!

&@

A4."- ''*2&, // /&%'$/*#"!," *!*-".-&."$!*& #"$" &"# &'"0%#"'$", &+""'.-#*$"#'!," %/"!, !!,"#"$" &"#8 & $!* //9 -*''%';!,"+*&%'"&& " *! -/*-)>!,"%'$2" !,"#"$" &"#%& ! ="' &&@

A4."- ''*2%'$/*#%'; *!*-".-&."$!&!,"-8%&" /&> !,"$/ %2 '!%&8-=%'; &) '# &&*$,!," $!* /#"."'#"'$9

& >A4, &+""'$--"$!/9 &&"&&"#%'$/*#%'; *!*-".-&."$!*&+9!,"

-%+*' /,"2*/!%./%"-%'-"&."$! %!,%/"&,, &+""'-%;,!/9 ../%"# 8"0"->!," 2*'! &

A4%'-"&."$! / &!-%!"& %!,%/"&, '#

"! ':/%%&'/8"-&%#","-"

-"> &*2 &

A4%'-"&."$! " $, #"$" &"#&! '#& //8"#%'0%"8  *!,-%!9  

 70 &+%(%'-"&."$! / &!-%!"& '#!- '&.-! !%'"!$

 ,"/" -'"#-%+*' /, & //8"# &*2 &

A4%'-"&."$!

  $'&-!%*2!)*+, &,, '#"-> !, ! 2*'! %&'/8"-&%#")> ="".%';%'0%"8!," *!,-%!9

 70&+%( &*2

&>

A4&! '#& //8"#%'-"&."$! /0" '#

"$!%'!+!,!,"

$/ %2 '!&%'-"&."$! #" !,  %!,%/"&,

? )  -  &  #" !,    ""! ':/%  %&  $'$"-'"#>   &*2  

&>

A4&! '#& //8"#%'-"&."$! /0" '#

"$!%'!+!,!,"

$/ %2 '!&

,"-%+*' /, & //8"# &*2 & >?

A4%'-"&."$!

#" !,  ""! ':%>8,, .."'"#!+" ;"# +*! 9" -&>!,"& %# 2*'!%& /&'/8"-&%#")> &*2 &

A4&! '#& //8"#%'

-"&&."$! #" !,  ""! ':/%8,%$,%'$/*#"& &*2 &

A4'

$$*'! ,"- *'"- /"F."'&"& ""! ':/% '#&>

A4%'-"&."$!

/0" '#

"$!%' )>%'!,%&2 ''"-> &*2 &

A4&! '#& "', '$"#%'-"&."$! #" !, ""! ':/%,"& %# 2*'!&, //$ --9 %'!"-"&!C(GH."- ''*2 -2!,"# !" $/ %2."!%!%'!%//-" /%I !%'

)>%'!,%&2 ''"-> &*2 &>

A4&! '#&"', '$"#%'

-"&."$! #" !,  %!,%/"&,,"& %# 2*'!&, // /&$ --9%'!"-"&!C (GH."- ''*2 -2!,"# !" $/ %2."!%!%'!%//%!&-" /%I !%'

( !,!," .." /&&! '##%&.&"#  $$-#%';/9

@ $.9 !,%&:*#;2"'!+"&"'!!!,"!-% /*-! -&!-%$!

$2./% '$" &(  -:; ,0.