High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8537/2015dismissed

Aman Rohella & ORS v. Guru Nanak Dev University & ORS

2015-05-06Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath12 pages

! " #

" # $%&

!"

# $%#&' () '

#

( &) # )

! ## " ## *

! + ,

-. ##

/ $ '

# " #/ # "

&

( # 0 # )

(

# 1

)

2

" )

( "

"

# &3$&4$, "

"

!

(5 "

# $

4" #

! 0 #)

/ 6

" /

"

## "

' ( ##"

# "

# " 77*7* 7 " ' " (

"

! 0

'

! "

! + , -. /" ##

8#

9 :; /" " ( ! (

# "

$<)<8#

9 "

:;

!

/

/

( # /"

( (

(

( " # "6

" / # &3$&4$,

( ( ( " # 9 :# 9* !0

: ' " #

#

" (

# 1

)

# ! " #

(

"

" # / " =1&3$1# 11&3$1 6 5

" / 5 # # ! > " # (

* 6

" #

? "

# ##

"

! ?

"

" ?

" / #

/

$

&),&3$& ' / # 4 #

#

0 "

# " "## #

( # " *"

" #

!/ !

" # ' # " " ## /

&)=&3$&( " *"

@ # " ( #

" "##

4

!

!!

"

# $

%

&

%

'( %

)*

+

,

&

-

!

)*

%!!

*$

.

&

&

!

/

0 &!

1

* !!

*

.

&&$ & &&$!

3 &!

+ , %

1

* !!

+ /

'

4("

56'

7

+(9

* ' ( " " ## /

(

&1)&3$& / /

! =)' (

4 ' &&$!

'

:

,

!$

)

1

* !! &

&

&&$!

$

%**

*

$ &&$!

&

&& -

!

!!

"

# $

&&$

.

$

&

&

'(9

' #

*

" #

? "

# ##

"

! ?

"

" ?

" /

" ( 0 ! 6

"

6

"

"

4 #-

*!!

;;;

*$

-

.

&

:

)*

*!!

.

& $

&

.

%**

*

&

. <% $

<% $

%*

*!!

.

!

&

*

%

*

.=

!

*

&

*!!

.

>

!

&&

*$

!

%

*!!

)*

*!!

.

*

&

3

*

- &!

!

<% $

(

*!!

.

&

!

*!!

.

*

$

*

&

>

*

&&

)*

*!!

&

*!!

.

&

-

!

!

*

*

%

&

!!

&&

&!

.=

&

-

*

=.

8

*!!

.

$ &

3!

%

$

*!!

&&

&

-

!

-

-

&&

-

*!!

.

! %

-

$

! %

-

$

*!!

.

& !

&&!

-

> " # (

6

" / ( " *"

#

&)=&3$& # ( &1)&3$&/

#A ?! &3$& (

<=&3$1 $ 3C /

*

! "

"

! #

#

"

/ "

$

0 ! )

(

( "

! )

!( # )

" ' / # # " (

( "

! # " ( ""

# ( #

( "

!

( " " "

? $

0 ? /

! )

0 0 " " ( "

" #

#0

( !

# / " " ""

!

" # B

" #

6

"

!

" # " *"

/

"

## "

#

7 " A ! # *

( ** *

+ ,-. /, - 0, 1/,/ 2 3 !3,4 -0,5 "

&<&3$=/" *

" *"

/

"

$3+1. $3+C. # "

( ! /

# " /

# "

*

" /

" (

&1)&3$&B (

" ( " *"

"

' (

! " #

#

"#

*

" # +/67 !3,4 1 /70 0-, - 0,5 7658 ( &

'( +/67 !3,4%

0-8,0 1 36 02,7, - 0,5 7658 (

&

'

B * #/700-,-0,&/.,)

$ /

77 " "

! 5($<)1 ! &1# 5( / # " 2

#13D# " (5 "

-$

77

" # !

?(5 "

? !!

! ( ! !

"

$D # !!

! # ! 0 $

# # 77 0 <

$<-= / $<-3 / (

# #E0"

&$/""

-$ +/"/# " $<)1.

!

"

( !

$D# # "(5 "

$D#

!!

! #

(5 "

/( # 6 ## (5 "

0 "

"

#

!

"

E0"

&$

$<-3 ! /

( "

(

!

"

-$' @

7 "# *

"! ! (/#

# E0"

&$/

"

" #

"

"

/! ( ! &1 / -$ /# " / 5 " $<)1""

!

*

"

"

:

# #

##

!( # #!

"

9 -$ ' /

!

"

-$ ' /

"

,$+&.+.# 5( "

/

!

"

"

! 0 ## "

"! !

B ( " #

! # # ! "

##" " # "! ( ! ( $<-3 /

5 "

( "! " ( "

( ' /

"

"! ( ! (

# E0"

&$ # * # $<-3 9

"

:

" 9

/

!

:' "! ## "

(

/ ## "

# B

"

" ( (

"

( " !

"

$<-3 /

/

# # 0 $<-=#

5 " $<)1

/ "

( ( # $<)1 /

(

# ! !

" ! #

2

# ! 0 /

#!

"

/"/ # " # /

" (

# / " / /!

*

5 ! B " " # 3602,7,-0,&/.,) /" (

/ "#

"

/

( "

"

( " ! /

5 " /

"

5( "

$<=- B

" #"

!

## ( "

! , " A ?! &3$&/

"6

" #

" " ( ! / # &1)&3$& #

> " # ( !

" # *

(

#

( " /5 $

/

(

&

! $

( /

,

2

13D " ?

# # /

/

= # ,

( /

1

!

13D" ?

# # #

B# )

""

" /

/ ( ! "

! " # ,

#)

/

/

"

/ (

)

# $

6

# / (

&

# " "

"

( #" /" ( # # /(5 "

&

/

( "

#

$

# @ 0

#

# " =

? (

(" ,

B / #

B # * ! )

( &1)&3$& #

' " (# ! " #

"

! " # )

"

! # ?

#

# !

( #

# ! )

0 "

/ " # ( /

# " " "" B !

#

"

&$# "

/"

4

78

*!!

.

& !

.

$

*

*!!

.

:

+

78

!

&

.

-

.

$!

$

- ?

7.8

&&

-

-

!

*

*

.

&&

.

!

78

)*

*!!

*$

&%

&&

.

!

.

!

%*!

&

%

%**

=

*

.

.

9

B !

" # (

" """ /!

" " / " /# / # / ! "

! ##

/ B / # # B #

(

!