High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8547/2015allowed

Hitender Pal v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-04-17Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath6 pages

!!!!!

"#$ $%&'&() "#$ $%&'&() "#$ $%&'&() "#$ $%&'&()

!!!!! &#$(*$+", $#&#&($+ -' #"#$ "+."(""(*#/$+' $'0(*$(#' !!!!! 1)2 31 4 1)2 31 4 1)2 31 4 1)2 31 441

!!!!! +$'$(#) 1+"(5".-"'/&'#/6 *7%"#$6

+#/$0$#&#&($+ 1+-&'/","+86 **, 6"+."(" 1+ "9"6 *7%"#$6

++$'0(*$(#' # !!!!! 441

6 441

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

,,$8$6"+&*"="*#&'"7$++$*&(#/$0$#&#&(#/"##/$##",&(%:$ #/$

":&,.&'(9

6>0$+"((;:/$0$#&#&($+2' "#/$+/"'%('#+;%#$* #/$/;'$9&#/&(#/$,&:&#' 1;(&%&0",+0+"#&(6"+&*"="*&(#/$.$"+

#&' ;+#/$+"7$++$*#/"#4-B

-,#,&($&'0"''&(87$+#/$ /;'$ #/$0$#&#&($+( "#"=;# ) 16#/$0$#&#&($+9"' "%%&*$(#",,. $,$%#+%;#$* 9/$( /$ 9$(# # #/$ + /&' /;'$ $ 9"' &(&#&",,.#"<$(# 4'0&#","(*#/$+$"

#$+#"

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

+:#/$+ /&'/;'$ /"7$ %('&*$+$* #/$

"%#' "(* %&+%;:'#"(%$' #/&' %"'$ "(* ": #/$ 0&(&( #/"# 0+&:" "%&$ &# &' "00"+$(# #/"#

#/$+$ &' "( =,&8"#&( ( #/$ 0"+# +$'0(*$(#' # # $(';+$ #/"# #/$ '"

$#. :$"';+$' "+$ "*0#$* # 0+$7$(# $,$%#+%;#&( "(. 0$+'( =. %:&(8 &( %(#"%# 9&#/ #/$ ,&7$ 9&+$' /$ 0$#&#&($+ /"7&(8 +$%$&7$* &(5;+&$' ( "%%;(# $,$%#+%;#&( &' (# *$="#"=,$ $#&#&($+ /"7&(8,'#/&'=#//"(*'6($,$8"(*,$ #

$$# &' "00"+$(# +: #/$ 0/#8+"0/' "(($F;+$ # &' "00"+$(#,. " %"'$ '#+&%#,&"=&,&#. /$0$#&#&(9"' &,$*&(#/$.$"+ #&' ",+$"*. 0:/$:"##$+%"((#=$#"<$( ;0 + &(", *$%&'&( ( #/$ &(#$+$'# 5;'#&%$6"(&(#$+&:%:0$('"#&( ' ,"%' &'+*$+$*#=$0"&*##/$0$#&#&($+9&#/&( " 0$+&* #9 :(#/' +: #*". =. +$'0(*$(#' # 65&(#,.+'$7$+",,. + "+8;:$(#'6 (9 # %:$ ;0 ( ;8;'#

6 ( 0;+';"(%$ # #/$ "

+$'"&* +*$+6 #/$ +$'0(*$(#' /"7$ ",,$8$*,.0"&*#/$&(#$+&:%:0$('"#&( ,"%'##/$0$#&#&($+ 3$"+($*%;('$, +#/$0$#&#&($+/"'';=:&##$*#/"##/$%"'$ #/$ 0$#&#&($+ &' $F"%#,. '&:&,"+ # #/$ %"'$ +$0+#$* "' ":"( -' ##"+ ":"( -' ##"+ ":"( -' ##"+ ":"( -' ##"+ "+."(" &5,&-&#+"(&8":3#*"(*#/$+'

"+."(" &5,&-&#+"(&8":3#*"(*#/$+'

"+."(" &5,&-&#+"(&8":3#*"(*#/$+'6666 HIH&7&,I@ @&(

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

$+$(%$=$#9$$(#/$%"'$ #/$0$#&#&($+ "(*":"(H;0+"I ":"(H;0+"I ":"(H;0+"I ":"(H;0+"I"'#/$&(5;+&$'';

$+$*=.=#/ #/$:"+$$F"%#,.#/$ '":$ /$ 0/#8+"0/' ":"( "+$ "00$(*$* 9&#/ #/$ *$%&'&( #/$ ,$"+($*&(8,$ $(%/ #/&';+#"' 00$(*&FD2"(*#/$0/#8+"0/' #/$0$#&#&($+"+$"00$(*$*9&#/#/$0$#&#&("' (($F;+$ H,,.I /$+$&'(*;=#&(:.:&(*#/"##/$%"'$ #/$0$#&#&($+&'

;,,.%7$+$*=.#/$*$%&'&(+$(*$+$*&(#/$%"'$ ":"(H;0+"I ":"(H;0+"I ":"(H;0+"I ":"(H;0+"I &+'#,. =.#/$,$"+($*&(8,$ $(%/ #/&';+#"(*#/$(=.#/$(2=,$;0+$:$ ;+#

A /;'6 &( 7&$9 #/$ "

+$'"&* "%#' "(* %&+%;:'#"(%$'6 #/$ 0+$'$(#0$#&#&(&'/$+$=.",,9$*&(#$+:' #/$*$%&'&(+$(*$+$*=.#/$ ,$"+($* &(8,$ $(%/ #/&' ;+# "(*#/$ ;0+$:$ ;+#&(#/$ %"'$ ":"(H;0+"I ":"(H;0+"I ":"(H;0+"I ":"(H;0+"I"(*"(":;(# ,"%60"&*=.#/$+$'0(*$(#'"'&(#$+&: %:0$('"#&(&'+*$+$*#=$"*5;'#$*9/&,$:"<&(8#/$+$:"&(&(80".:$(# #/$%:0$('"#&(&(#$+:' #/$*$%&'&(+$(*$+$*=.#/$,$"+($*&(8,$

$(%/ #/&';+#"(*#/$;0+$:$;+#&(#/$%"'$ ":"(H;0+"I ":"(H;0+"I ":"(H;0+"I ":"(H;0+"I H 441

I H 441

/$#/$+'0$"<&(8>+$"'($* ) $'> /$#/$+$0+#"=,$ ) $'>