New India Assurance Company Limited v. Deepak Chibber And ANR




    
  

 

  
  ! !"#$%  & '(!!) ##*+"!  , 

--!.. /!+#*# !!-0 (11!+ (!+

2!#-! #      
 
 3+!#! $ + 24!#(5 6(+789" !

+ (!--!.. + .5 6-!(89" !

++!#-!   +## 14!" +

+ 73.6(+789" !

++!#-!  

::::




#1. ;"!+  " ! !

  .! *+  ;8# 0!+!"+ '(#+!+)..#-#! 

   +##

14!" #

 # (!#!(9!!7!+<!*   (!#7!)+  !  

   -##!  1;  (!   +  ""! #  .7#  '+1*.8 (<+(  )(!+!1;  "7-!#   (#  1!!  )+!    ""*  

4*+!##*# !1;!!-0 (11!+7 +9!("*.+""!  ( 0-."!

= &

'(!'+1*.(#)+!"7-!#  2# =8%8= ! .!(!+!*!+$

!"."(+<!# 2# 8

 '+#-+  "(+<!# 2# 

6!+9"!#  ! 2# 

= 6-!".!

2# 

 3#*

!+<# 2# 8

,## !4;7! 2# 8

% 3!+7! #1. ;

2# 8&8=

& ,## # *!# +!;!+ 2# 8

  

      (#  1!!  .!  1;  (!  #*+"!

"7-;)(!+!#"+## 14!" #(9!1!!-+!

!++!1; (!".7 #!!0<!("!7!  "7-!#  *#!. + (!#*+"!"7-;(# +.; +7! (  (!

--!.(#1!!-+!

!++! "(..!<! <#  (!'+1*. ) "* # '(! +# #*17##7!1;"*#!.# ( # +9!+  (!

!<9!(".!)#(.<."!"! +9!.<( 7 +9!(".!1* (! )#  +9<  (+!!  )(!!.!+  1!+<   > 

8  (!  )#   "7-! !  +9! (!9!(".!?*!#  (!1## ."!"!-##!##! 1;(7 '##.?* *7 "7-!# 8 #+<*! (   (! 7!

""*++!"! (!4*+!)#<-.7!"(".@<!!+< @'86!" + 8 (<+( # +<*! ( "7!  (! 9" 7 ##!##!1; (!'+1*.A2# 8 -!+7 (#(<(!+#! .1.! 1!+!*"!  8 #+<*! (  (!'+1*.(###!##!



.## "7!#1. ; B (*<( (!##1. ;#?* -+ "*.+.71   (!)(.!1;

*#!.+!-+!#! < (!".7 (##*--+ !##!##7! 

"7-!#  +#1. ;) ( (!#*17## (  (!#7!#.1.! 1! !("! (!1## . !# ##!##7!  #1. ;1;7!".1+ 3C 8 (<+()(!+!1;#1. ;  (!!D !  =B(#1!! ##!##!8  +!

.!" !    (!  "!+  " !   !  

   >!  (#  *+ (!+ +<*!  (  "7-!#   )+!  *!+ 9+*#   (!+  (!#  #*"(  # +#-+  "(+<!#8 ! "(+<!#8#-!".! 8-#*

!+<# .## !4;7! ! "

#.1.! 1!!("!  8".7 # !  .! "7-!#  +.## 7 +7.-+#-!" #

*#!.+!-+!#! < (!+9!+ "*7 )!+  (!9!(".! ?*!# (##*--+ ! <#  (!'+1*.) (+!<+ .1. ;

(!#*+"!"7-; -;"7-!#   (!".7 1* ) (* ;+<(  +!"9!+;

#+<*! ( #<+##9!(".!)!<( #.!## ( %0<#  (!9!(".! ..#) ( (!!

  ,<(  +/!(".!

*!+6!" 
  (! +/!(".!#" 8 &&
#(+ E (!" E8 +9!+)#"7-! !  +9! (!9!(".!?*!# !9!  (!+!)# !+#!7!   +#-+ (#+9<."!"!

 (#" !D 8+!

!+!"!

(#1!!7! . !# 4*<7!  >E1.! (!6*-+!7! *+  ! "# $% "& "'( )$"*


"(

"+$,-.

"/)-)*$#01233+

$342

(9!(!+"*#!. + (!-+ !#8-!+*#! (!--!+10  (!+!"+#



!

+!9!+ <  (!#*17###) (+!<+ ?* *7

"7-!# -;1.!  (!4*+!9" 78 )*..0! !.) ( (!

##*! "7-! !";  (!+9!+ +9! (!9!(".!?*!#  (! 1## ."!"!-##!##!1;(7 #-* 1.;8<+##9!(".!)!<( 

(+!!)(!!.!++9!1;5*.!!-6#.!## (%0<# 8 (!+!

+!8

..#) ( (!-*+9!) ,<(  +/!(".!!

! (!"

F(! (! " #"+"*7# "!#  (!-+!#! "#!+!!D7! (!.<( 

. !# 4*<7!  >E1.! (!6*-+!7! *+  ! "#$% "& "(+ ($
#*-+8  " !   +#!  1;  (!  #*+"!  "7-;  ) (  +!<+   "7-! !";  (!+9!+ +9! (!9!(".!?*!# # 7!+ +*# +!+! 1!+!4!" ! '(#1+<# (! *+  ##!##7!  "7-!# 7!1;

(!'+1*.

'(!'+1*.(#+!71*+#!7!"."(+<!# 2# 8

 (!#7!#

+7! '(!4*+!9" 7+!7!(#- .#!3C (<+(  +7  

= &      &   !

+  !  7 (  '(!

".7 (#-."!+!"+"*7! #) (+!<+ (# +! 7!  3C 8  (<+(  1*  (!  (#    !D7!  (!  +! <  " +  '(!

"*7! #-."!+!"+ <9!".!+-" *+!) (+!<+  (! *71!+     *+!    4*+!#  #*# !  1;  (7  >)!9!+8  +7  (!

#  !7!  +  ;<<+).8!D7! -+9!#1. ;8 "1! 7!*  (  (!*+!#*

!+! +" *+! 1) (!*+9#"*.+4*+;

( +!!+!(7#1.!  (!!D !  B##!##!1; (!!+.!+ #1. ;1+=B#-!+ (!##!##7! 7!

  '(!

4*+!#*

!+!!#*+<!+;*+<(# +! 7! 3C 8 (<+( '(!

'+1*.  (# )+! 2# 8 +-  #*

!+<#  9!)

 *+! 4*+!##*# !"*-.!) (-!+  +! 7! #+ - !  (! " *7 (  (!4*+!#*

!+! +" *+!)#-!+ ! *-8".7 #(..1!!  .! 7*  2# 8 +- #*

!+<#
 .7* 2# 8   7-!# )+!1; (!

'+1*. + +#-+  "(+<!#8#!+9"!#  ! 8#-!".!   (! *! 2# 8 #!("! 2# 8 
 .7* 2# 8  '(!'+1*.(#..)!7*  2# 8&8= +.## * *+!"7!?*#1. ;#*

!+!1; (!9" 7 +  ;<<+).8  .3+ !##+8!-+ 7!  + (-!"#83C 8 (<+()# !D7!    -+9!  #1. ;   (!  !D !   B    (!  #1. ;

"!+  " !@D  (#"+## !D7 8(!(#!-#! (  # -##1.! "77!  (!#1. ;+!.  )(.!1;) (* "#*. < (!#1. ;7*.

)..1!.!## ( (!-!+"! !

 +!#-#!    *+  ?*!# #8  (!  ) !##  (#  !-#!8  +!-+*"! (!+!1!.) ++!;+!

!+!"!$
   

    

 

 

  

 



 

 !       





                   

      "# $%

  &

 

 '

 

 



&

 

  '      

     '



 ( 

 !

  '      

 !

  )#) 

 *+       '

$) 

    '

  ' 

 

   



   '

       





 

  

 

 

  

      

,         '

    

  

          

 '  '

- 

 

   

   



 



.       

    

/            0     

   

 

   

     

        

   0  . 

      

'0

 / 

   

  

 

 

        0     , ' , 

  

     

   

  

      1 '(!  4*+!  9" 7   ..;    -.7    !"(". @<!!+<   . !+  (!   '!"(    !"(".  @<!!+<  +7 5*+*0#(! +G9!+# ;

+  ;<<+).#)!+ .# ?*!# 1; (! *+ (!-#! (   (!- ! #9.9!<!#041# )("(+!?*+!.;# < (!+!7;1! *" .#1. ;1*  (!

)..419.9< +9!..<8).0<8-(;#"..1*+ (! (!#1. ; )..1!!+7*# !

7+! ( B###!##!1; (!#1. ;1+  (!1##  +!#-  (!" +8 !+!#  4*# "!)*.1!

#!+9! =B#1. ;# 0! ""*  +##!##<.## "7!

'(!  4*+!  )#    # *!    -.7    !"(".

@<!!+<  (! 7! ""*++!"! (!;!+& >#"7!# ##!##! 2# 8 -!+7 ( >!#..)!1!!

  * *+!-+#-!" # A=B  !+--.;<7*. -.!+ & *" .#1. ;A=B8

* *+!.## "7!"7!# 2# 8  
2# 8DD&H
=B * *+!-+#-!" #D
*" .#1. ;A=B

'(!'+1*.(#..)!7*  2# 8 +.##

!4;7!  . !

'(!4*+!--!+!1!

+! (! *+ (!!# --!+ 1!!-!! (#).0< >!#)+!7* 

2# 8 +.## 7! !# . !

 (!+#*7 2# 8 # )+! +.## 7 +7.-+#-!" #  7-!#  2# 8

)+!1; (!'+1*. +.## # *!# +!;!+#

+7!  (# 7!+8  ."7-!# #2#

 "7-!# )+! 1; (!'+1*.#+!*"!  (!!D !   2# %8& 
=8%8=I



'(!  --!.    "+## 14!" #  +!  #-#!      (!

 +!# !+7#






   !"#"$ %" &$" "'

("

 F(! (!++!-+ 1.!$ J!#