Kiran Devi And ORS v. Union Of India

  

           

  !"#"$%&%'()

 *%+ '",% '#!-"+& .."// '! & 0"+&1&

'%''#%  "&.'#"'! &

 (  23

 4 * 34  +"&"'!(5

+416- &-4 $-#", 7#,$ !"7+7

+4* ' 7#,$ !"7+!-" .."// '!&

+* +8%'#"+4%'9-7#,$ !"7++"&.'#"'!  :-"!-"+!-" ".+!"+&/$ /'";&. ."+8 <6" //;"#! &""!-"=1#98"'!>
 6"+""++"#!!-" ".+!"++'!  :-"!-"+!-"=1#98"'!&-1/#6"+".+!"#%'!-"#%9"&!> 55 55 * 34 

3 -%&%&%+&! .." /%/"# 9 %'&!!-"=1#98"'!# !"#


7 . &&"#6<!-" %/; < / %8&+%61' /7 - '#%9 +-"'$-7 - '#%9 +-7 %'

&-+!2!-"+%61' /27,%#";-%$-!-"$/ %8 ../%$ !%'%/"#6<!-".+"&"'! .."// '!&7; &#%&8%&&"# 1+8%!4%'9-7 9"# 61!
<" +&7-1&6 '# .."// '!7  !-"+ .."// '!&
!? '#&' .."// '!)7; & / 61+"+6< .+"&&%' '?@
7!-"#"$" &"#!/#-%&;%"!- !-"%&9%'9!-%& &%&!"+2&-1&" !,%// 9" 1'#"+.1+7"-&%/ '#%&!+%$! 81'  9 + '# !-"+" !"+%'!-"","'%'97-";1/#9!!-"+&%&!"+2&-1&" !86 /  '# ;%//&! <!-"+" !'%9-!!%&&! !"#!- !%'!-"","'%'97-" $$8. '%"#6<  88% /% & ,%'#"+*18 +;"'!!+ %/; <&! !%' 9 #- +%:+A&-.7 ;-"+"-".1+$- &"#&"$'#$/ &&+#%' +<. &&"'9"+!+ %'!%$A"!+86 /

'!!"6 +#"#!+ %'):-"'!-"!+ %'+" $-"#6"!;""',%// 9"

5
5 1A-"+% '#86 /  '!! !'%9-!7#1"!-" ,<="+A 1+8%!4%'9-"// #;'+8!-"!+ %' '#&1&! %'"#9+",%1&%'=1+%"&'!-",%! /. +!&!-" 6#<  '#  &1$$186"#  !-"+"!  '  !-"  &.!   '  !-"  '"B!  8+'%'9  %" )@
7 ! 61!@(? ' $$1'!%'+8 !%'&1../%"#6<4-%,

8 '# 8*%&- '7 '98"'7+"9 +#%'9!-"#"!"$!%''"#" #6#< /<%'91! !!+ $A !*  
) )56"!;""'1A-"+% '#86 /

'!!7 !-"%'!%8 !%'; &&"'!!!-"4 7 86 /  '!! -"

%'C1"&!  ; &  $ ++%"#  1!   -"  ."+&' /   &" +$-    !-"  #"$" &"#  ; & $'#1$!"#7+8;-%$-'!-%'9; &+"$,"+"#-".&!8+!"8; & /& 9!$'#1$!"# '!-"+"./<7!-" %/; <&!A!-"./" !- !%!%&'! $ &" 1'!; +#%'$%#"'!;%!-%'!-"8" '%'94"$!%'
 $!-" %/; <& $!7@D@!; &&! !"#!- !!-"#" !-- #$$1++"# & +"&1/!6"%'9+1' ,"+6<!+ %' &!-"& %#."+&'9!"'! '9/"#;%!-!-"8,%'9!+ %';-%/" $+&&%'9!-"!+ $A-"#"$" &"#; &'! . &&"'9"+!-"!+ %'81$- /"&&6' %#". &&"'9"+ +8!-"./" #%'9&7//;%'9%&&1"&;"+"+ 8"#(5  :-"!-"+!-"#"$" &"#; & 6' %#". &&"'9"+ !!-"!%8" %'$%#"'!>
 :-"!-"+!-"%'$%#"'!%&$,"+"#;%!-%' 86%!4"$!%'
 $

+" #;%!-4"$!%'
?5 $!>  :-"!-"+!-"   ../%$ '! &%& +"!-"&/"#"."'#"'!&!-"

#"$" &"#%'!-%&$ &"> ?

"/%" !"+9%'9!-+19-!-"",%#"'$"7!-"+%61' /$ 8"!!-" $'$/1&%'!- !!-"#"$" &"#; &'! 6' %#". &&"'9"+ '#

55 $'&"C1"'!/<7!-"$/ %8 ../%$ !%'; &#%&8%&&"# - ,"-" +#!-"/" +'"#$1'&"/&+!-". +!%"& '#- ," /& $ +"1//<9'"!-+19-!-"%/" %+&! //7!-%& 1+!.+$""#!#"!"+8%'";-"!-"+%!%& $ &"  //+8!-"!+ %'+!-"#"$" &"#; &+1',"+6<!-"+1''%'9!+ %'7 & &19-!!6"8 #"1!+8

+".+! '#!-"$ &"+"&.'#"'! -"%'C1"&!+".+!; &$ ++%"#1!'"B!8+'%'9%")@
 ;-"'!-"#" #6#<; &+"$,"+"# -"&%!"./ '%& /&#+ ;''!-" %'C1"&!+".+!7;-%$-&-;&!- !!-"#" #6#<; &/<%'9=1&! #=%'%'9!-" 1./%'"1!&%#"!-"!+ $A&."+!-"%'=1+<#"&$+%6"#%'!-"%'C1"&!+".+!7 6 $A&%#"!-"-" #; &6 #/<# 8 9"# '#!-"6+ %'8 !!"+; &$8%'9 1! -". +!6!-!-"""!;"+". +!/<$+1&-"# !-!-"/"9&;"+" 6+A"'+8!-"A'""=%'!-"+ %/; <./%$"$ 8"!!-"$'$/1&%'!- ! %!%& $ &" //+8!-"!+ %'-"%'!"+%8+".+!# !"#

!-" 4 &-;&!- !!-"./%$" /&$'$/1#"#!- !%!%& $ &" //+8!-" !+ %'-"%'=1+%"& +" /&#"&$+%6"#%'!-".&!8+!"8+".+!+8!-" %'=1+%"&  $1./"#  ;%!-  !-" $'$/1&%'  #+ ;'  6< !-" 7 %!  - &  !  6"

$'$/1#"#!- !%!%& $ &" //+8!-"!+ %'-"%'=1+%"&8"'!%'"#%' !-"%'C1"&!+".+! &;"// &.&!8+!"8+".+! +"1'/%A"/<;-"''"%&+1' ,"+6< !+ %';-%/"$+&&%'9!-"+ %/; </%'"-"+"+"7!-"$ &".1!+!- 6<+"&.'#"'!!- !%!%& $ &"+1',"+6< !+ %'- &!6"+1/"#1! '#%! - &!6"-"/#!- ! 1+8%!4%'9-#%"# & +"&1/! //+8!-"!+ %' -"'"B!C1"&!%' +%&%'9 +$'&%#"+ !%'%& &!;-"!-"+ !-"#"$" &"#; & 6' %#". &&"'9"+ !$8"&1!!- !!-"#"$" &"#"//+8!-"!+ %''!-"'%9-! %'!"+,"'%'9?@
 )@
%&#" #6#<; &+"$,"+"#%'!-"

5?5 8+'%'9')@
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

 !-"+ '#;%"!-"#"$" &"#- ,"&! !"#%'!-"%+&! !"8"'!+"$+#"#1'#"+ 4"$!%') + !- !!-"#"$" &"#; &8"'! //<1.&"! '#; &8%&&%'9 +!-"/ &!
# <&4 +# + 4%'9-7 !-"+!-"#"$" &"#7; &"B 8%'"#' !- !.%'!'$+&&"B 8%' !%'7-" &&"+!"#!- !#"&'!A';;-"!-"+-%& &! !"8"'!; &+"$+#"#6<./%$"+'!761!-%&!-186%8.+"&&%'&; & 6! %'"# '#-"#"&'!A';;- !; &;+%!!"'!-"+"%'-";%"!-" #"$" &"#; &'!"B 8%'"#-"+"+"76 +"&! !"8"'!1'#"+4"$!%')

+ 6"+"!-" $ ''!6"! A"' & 9&."/!+1!-' $!7!-" $!& '#  $%+$18&! '$"&  &-;  !- !  ;-"'  !-"  #" #  6#<  ; &  +"$,"+"#  ' )@
7!-" 8%/<!-"#"$" &"#; &%'+8"#6<!-"./%$" &!-" ' 8" !-"#"$" &"#  ;-%$- ; & !-"+;%&" '! A';'  !  7 %'#& 8"'!%'%'!-"%'C1"&!+".+!.+". +"#')@
%!&"/-"+"+"7!-" %'#%'9&+%61' /%'!-%&+"9 +# +"/% 6/"!6"+","+&"# ',%";!-"+"9%'9#%&$1&&%'7!-"%'#%'9&+"$+#"#6< !-"  +%61' /  '  //  !-"  %&&1"&  +"  +","+&"#  -"  .." /  %&  //;"#

"&.'#"'!5+ %/; <&%&+#"+"#!. < &?77 5 &$8."'& !%'!

5)5 !-" ../%$ '!;%!-%'!"+"&! !!-"+ !"@E."+ ''18+8!-"# !" %/%'9!-"$/ %8 ../% $!%'%"D
!%//!-"# !". <8"'!  

* 34     )

 &=A& :-"!-"+&." A%'9 +" &'"# ( "& :-"!-"+ ".+! 6/"

( "&