High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19854/2024dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. No1566779a Ex Naik Gurbachan Singh And Another

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$%% "#"&#'

!"#$(%% ) * *

!" " " +$ ,-+ % **

* .

,-+ *% ** * + #$%&'()* +#,-#.-/&01#-0&2%03&2 4#5,&6&51510&#37 +#(,1.-0)%,-#.-/'89-5&4# #&360'&05 ::::

* .

/% ,#%$,5,&1035-05;#156&51510/5,&6&51510&#3,&#&10 01040'1-/6#-)34#5,&3&5510$-31'&45,&#'&#'-5&' <

=00&>%#& ?/ -3 6-33&' () 5,& 2&-#0&' #.&' #9&3 #1(%0-2 909&#0&'/;,&#&()35,&92-1.4#&360'&054#5,&$#-054 3&#819&&2&.&0545,&'13-(1215)6&03104#5,&3&#819&#&0'&#&'() ,1.10&4&09&&9%#15)#63=?,-3(&&0-22;&'/()90'010$ 5,&3,#54-224 .05,3-0''-)34#.5,&#&@%1315&)&-#34 @%-214)10$3&#819&4#&-#010$3&#819&6&0310105,&

0'1&020'34"&#!

&360'&05 ;-3 &0#22&' 10 5,& 0'1-0 #.) 0

-0';-3'139,-#$&'5,&#&4#.0< <&360'&05 ;-3$#-05&'#&51#10$6&0310/-3-'.1331(2&5,1.-36&#5,& &0310&$%2-5103,&#&-45&#/#&360'&05;-3#&&0#22&'105 &4&09&&9%#15)#63=3&#819&?0

<99#'10$55,&

6#&8-2&056219)/%60-55-1010$5,&-$&43%6&#-00%-510/#&360'&05 ;-3'139,-#$&'4#.3&#819&105,&0<

-45&# #&0'&#10$-3&#819&4 )&-#3/

.05,3-0''-)3/;,19,;-3 3,#5() .05,3-0''-)3/3-35.-A&5,&32'1&#&0-(2&'5 9.62&5&5,&@%-214)10$5&#.4)&-#3/4#5,&6%#63&4$#-054 3&#819&6&0310/5,%34#5,&3&90'3&#819&#&0'&#&'(),1.105,& < &360'&05 ;-3 '&01&' 3&#819& 6&0310 () 5,& 9.6&5&05-%5,#15)4#,13059.62&510$5,&#&@%1315&@%-214)10$ 6&#1'4#&-#010$3&#819&6&0310105,& &&210$-$$#1&8&'/#&360'&05412&'/(&4#&5,& 2&-#0&' #.&' #9&3 #1(%0-2 909&#0&'/ ;,&#&()3 ,& 9-35 - 9,-22&0$&55,&-4#&3-1'#&B&9510#'&#,&3-1'/(&9-.& -22;&'81'&#'&#'-5&' <

,&6&#-518&6-#545,&3-1'

#'&#13&>5#-95&',&#&10-45&#* >>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

"# $ % "

&'()

'*& + + , - .

*&&*'*&0 /

(**'*&1

2 34 &&210$-$$#1&8&'4#.5,&-4#&3-1'#'&#-36-33&'%60 5,&=3%6#-?/()5,&2&-#0&'#.&'#9&3#1(%0-2909&#0&'/5,&

< 6&51510&#01040'1-,-3412&'5,&#&-$-10355,&1035-05;#156&51510 (&4#&5,13%#5 *&567

7"# "819 2 0# !'"&#

28"19 :

1717"#

,&2&-#0&'9%03&24#5,&6&51510&#33%(.153/5,-55,& 2&-#0&'#1(%0-2,-34-12&'59031'&#5,-5105&#.34&$%2-510 45,&&0310&$%2-51034#5,&#.)/ -0'&$%2-510 45,&&0310&$%2-51034#5,&#.)/

/5,%302)5,& .6&5&05%5,#15);-3&.6;&#&'590'0&5,&'&4191&09)105,& #&0'15104@%-214)10$3&#819&/5,%3()5,&32'1&#4#,13(&9.10$ &05152&'53&&A5,&&0';.&0546&03105,1.,&3-1'&$%2-5103 -#&&>5#-95&',&#&10-45&# = C+D/ ?

&'5 67

23 #

8 &9

# &5

4 = C+D/

;< 23 #

# = 23 #

# &5

23 #

8 4

1 +#&8&#/5,&+10135#)4&4&09&81'&219)2&55&# =

77=&072? '-5&'

/ 103&#5&'92-%3&=18? 10 5,& &$%2-510 45,&&0310&$%2-5104#5,&#.)/

,& #&2&8-056-#5;,&#&4/13&>5#-95&',&#&10-45&#

6&#%3-245,&-4#&-.&0'.&05;%2'.-A&1592&-#5,-5 #&21&4 @%- 90'0-510 4 '&4191&09) 10 #&0'1510 4 5,& -66315& @%-214)10$3&#819&/135(&-99#'&'0.&#15/3-35&03%#&5,-5-0 -#.)6&#300&213&21$1(2&4#-52&-350&3&#819&6&0310

,&2&-#0&'9%03&24#5,&6&51510&#34%#5,&#3%(.153/5,-5 5,&B%'$.&0545,&2&-#0&'#.&'#9&3#1(%0-2/#10916-2!&09,/ &;&2,1/#&0'&#&'109-3&5152&'-3 ! "# $% ;-3059##&95#-5,&#;-3905#-#)52-;-0'4-953/ 5,&#&4#&/0#&21-09&%$,55,-8&(&&062-9&'05,&3-1'B%'$.&05 ,&#&2&8-056-#-$#-6,3/-399%#105,&8&#'195=3%6#-?-#&&>5#-95&' ,&#&10-45&# '

'9*9'*&)

;

$+?

@ 8

/ $ &9*)'**& !

! 8

/ $ '**'*&1C

3 +

# #

$ - .%/

D %

'*&( *1&&'*&(

3 ?

# / 2B $3

7777 7777 9)

# #

;

23 /

2# 3

$ +

# ?

? ! G + ?

# 8

$ +

G F ?

$ !

F B + B 8

$ 2 3

& ‟ '

( )

* ) )

23 ?

23 # #

# #

+ '2'3

'**1

&9*)'**& ! &'

+ + !2 3 #

,-.-/ 0 /1-/-/2 23 /

2 3 # ?

# 23 "

23 # !

"8197 "&1% 109&5,&&>635%2-5103.-'&106-#-$#-6, 45,& B%'$.&05#&0'&#&'()5,&"0E(2&6&>%#5109-3&5152&'-3 #7"#"8 #!700#!#"19 ) %*& #!

*7#49 060/#&6#5&'10-/32 ,-,/ 6-#-$#-6, ;,&#&4 (&9.&3 &>5#-95&' ,&#&10-45&#/8&#9.&35,&'13-(210$&44&953/14-0)/43%6#-&>9&6510 =18?/-3(&9-.&103&#5&'81'&6219)72&55&#'-5&'

/5,%3/ 105&0'&'5;#A-3-0(35-92&#-5,&#-$-10355,&32'1&#92-1.10$#&21&4 490'0-510105,&#&@%1315&3,#54-2243&#819& &' / #

/ # 7

# #

F ?

# # # #

'9 I &0)5 #

'**& # 7 #

,&#&4#&/5,&B%'191-28&#'195=3%6#-?/'&3#&0'&#0&$-5&' 5,&3%6#--#$%.&05#-13&'()5,&9%03&24#5,&6&51510&#3/5,-55,& &.6;&#.&05590'0&5,&#&@%1315&3,#54-22/(&9.&33215-#12) 8&35&'105,&.6&5&05%5,#15)/&36&91-22);,&05,&,&#&10-(8& %0'&#210&'6-#-$#-6,3/-399%#105,&8&#'195.-'&10*& #!

*7#49

060, '0

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

#&@%1#&'/;%2'(&#&35#195&'4#.

/-3&0813-$&'()5,& +10135#)4&4&09&C&55&#'-5&'

7#02 !

"8197 "&1% 0-45&#.-5,/5,13%#5410'30.&#15105,&;#156&51510 -0';15,(3&#8-5103-(8&/5,&3-.&13'13.133&' ,&1.6%$0&'#'&#/-36-33&'()5,&2&-#0&'#1(%0-2 909&#0&'/13.-105-10&'-0'-441#.&' 1363&'4-20$;15,-226&0'10$-66219-510=3?/14-0) ;*

* .

< ;* * +< (%% 0B-2 9 :

037#4= "# !

9 :"1052