High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9874/2014allowed

Jaswinderpal Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2016-10-17Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

! "#$ %$&'(')* + "(,')%$-."/0')12")%#2$-( $#'#')$- (!

3$-(4( 0#"#$ 4)5"6")%#2$-( $(.)%$)# (!

* 78 0 9 80 -$($)#*:

-92"##';%<&"#$; -#2$.$#'#')$- - "5"#")("/;(('(#")# 4)5"6

2$#2$-#2$ $.-#$-( /&"/)$,(.".$-=">6$"//,$%# ($$#2$54%1=$)#?

6$-$ $--$%##2$ $.-#$--)# @ 2$#2$-#2$54%1=$)#(24/%6$-$.-#$%')#2$%'1$(#? ::

2$ .$#'#')$-(; ,2 ,$-$ ,-A')1 "( $"% )(#"6/$( ') 4)5"6/'&$;,$-$6A$%%4-')1#2$'-($-<'&$') +;%"#$% @; -$1'(#$-$% 4)%$- #2$ <"-'4( .-<'(')( -$<$)#')

--4.#') &#; ; "# /'&$ 0#"#') '<'(') +; 84%2'")"

) -#4)"#$/>; #2$ #-'"/ '( (#'// &)#')4')1 ) #2$ =$"),2'/$; "// #2$ .$#'#')$-(2"<$-$#'-$% -=($-<'&$2$1-4($ #2$.$#'#')$-('(#2"# #2412 B.-<'(')"/.$)(')2"(6$$) -$/$"($%##2$=;64##2$- -$#'-"/6$)$ '#(2"<$)#6$$)-$/$"($%##2$= 2$-$(.)%$)#(;')#2$-$./>;2"<$#"A$)#2$(#")%#2"# B .-<'(')"/.$)(')2"(6$$)-$/$"($%##2$.$#'#')$-(2$.">=$)#

/$"<$$)&"(2=$)##"//#2$#2-$$.$#'#')$-(2"("/(6$$)-$/$"($%#'( (#"#$%#2"#')"%%'#')##2$&-'=')"/&"($;"%$."-#=$)#"/')C4'->,"("/( ')'#'"#$%;'),2'&2#2$.$#'#')$-(2"<$6$$) 4)%14'/#> &2"-1$( -"=$% "1"')(##2$=

,$<$-; #2$ ="##$- '( (#'// .$)%')1 ') #2$

'&$ #2$ 0$)'- 04.$-')#$)%$)# /'&$;84%2'")";%4$##2$.$)%$)&> #2$&-'=')"/ &"($2$-$ -$;#2$-$(.)%$)#(54(#'

'$%#2$%$#$)#') 1-"#4'#>; ")% #2$--$#'-"/6$)$ '#( 2"<$2$"-%#2$/$"-)$%&4)($/( -#2$."-#'$(")%2"<$"/( &"-$ 4//>1)$#2-412#2$ '/$ #'(.-<'%$%4)%$- 4/$ #2$4)5"6 '<'/0$-<'&$(

4/$(#2"#')&"($ .$)%')1%$."-#=$)#"/.-&$$%')1(;#2$1-"#4'#> #2$ <$-)=$)# $=./>$$ &") 6$ ,'#22$/%; 4)#'/ #2$ &)&/4(') #2$ %$."-#=$)#"/-54%'&'"/.-&$$%')1(-'((4$ ')"/-%$-#2$-$)2$);

#2$-$"-$ 4/$( "!; 6!")% &! #2$4)5"6 '<'/0$-<'&$( 4/$(;,2'&2 .-<'%$#2"#"&#')&")6$#"A$)"1"')(##2$-$#'-$%$=./>$$(')&"($

($-'4(&-'=$-1-"<$='(&)%4&# %='##$%/>;')#2$.-$($)#&"($;#2$ &-'=')"/&"($'(.$)%')1 -"64#/"(# @>$"-(."-"//$/%$."-#=$)#"/ ')C4'->,"("/(')'#'"#$%;,2'&22"(6$$)&)&/4%$%;64#)-%$-'(6$')1 ."(($%%4$#.$)%$)&> #2$&-'=')"/#-'"/ "= #2$<'$,#2"##2$%$."-#=$)#"/.-&$$%')1(")%#2$ &-'=')"/#-'"/&")1('%$6>('%$ 2$-$'()6"-)#2$."-# #2$ %$."-#=$)##."((" ')"/-%$-)#2$%$."-#=$)#"/.-&$$%')1($<$)' #2$ &-'=')"/#-'"/'(.$)%')1#6$')1(;#2$-$(.)%$)#("-$%'-$&#$%#."(("

')"/-%$-')%$."-#=$)#"/')C4'->,'#2')#,=)#2( -=#2$%"#$

-$&$'.# &.> #2'(-%$-2$.$#'#')$-(2"<$)#6$$)2$/%14'/#>') #2$&-'=')"/#-'"/ 2$-$ -$;#2$-$'()1-4)%#,'#22/%#2$-$#'-"/ 6$)$ '#($D&$.#1-"#4'#>#6$')1(;#2$-$(.)%$)#("-$%'-$&#$%#-$/$"($ "//#2$--$#'-"/6$)$ '#(##2$.$#'#')$-(;'

")>;$D&$.#1-"#4'#>#(2"// "/,">(6$.$)##2$.$#'#')$-(#.-&$$%4)%$- 4/$ "!; 6!")% &!

:@:

#2$4)5"6 '<'/0$-<'&$( 4/$(;'

#2$>(%$('-$ 2$.-$($)#,-'#.$#'#')'("&&-%')1/>"//,$%

80 !

+ (5A( 2$#2$-(.$"A')1-$"()$% * $( 2$#2$- $.-#"6/$ *