High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/27256/2018dismissed

Raminder Singh And ANR v. Divisional Commissioner Karnal And ORS

2018-10-25The Taxing Officer,Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa11 pages

!"#"$% &"$' ()"$*+ $+ ( ""$ (# , (#-# + "."#"$ /&&"##"$ (01 ($ / $'+ (# #2$' $#

( # $% 3()& +) "$"0'.!

(+ 2 ""$ (# ( # $4("2 ""$-$' (("!/ # 5 + $#"-"$ + #6 $ "/ ' ("##- $! 4(""$+ $ -( ! ("( (" (7- #+"$* "&2-*$ '(' ('

'8 9 :;8<2 ## '6=( #2$' $;

&&"##"$ (0 1 ($ / "."#"$0 1 ($ /0 4+ ( 6= $ / + 2 ""$ (# "/ '-$' () !"$>; + -$?

6,"// * &&$@ $'# : *-/ "$<!08 :

(#+(A+ !A<+ #6 $'"#&"## ' $'(' (

+ // !(;!-&;

2-= &&"##"$ (0 1 ($ /;( #2$' $ '

:; <+ #6 $

"(& ' ("

!# + !

# ( + + ( & $!+ = ;( #2$' $ 9 "/ ' 2 ""$-$' () !"$ + !$

:;<6 ( + ##"# $// !(0#( ' 01 ($ /;( #2$' $>:

(#+(A+ 0 # ( ' A< ( ? !& $ + 2 ""$ (# 6 "$* "$ -$ -+("B '

!!-2 "$ :( B"$*<@ $'& #-("$*

1 $ /# 3 (/ # #"- '"$+ ( . $- # ."// * +-$*( :-&<!&2("# '"$

1+ #( # 5050508C 05>090 050 C5 6 "$*

4"+"$+ '

"$""$ ) !"$:*<:< + ! #2 ( (+ = (88;8 2$$"! 02 ""$ (#22# '+ # & 6= "/"$*( 2/= $'

6+#"' #/ '+ "( ."' $! ( D"$*"$!$#"' ( "$+ $"( & ("

/ .

"/ 6/ $( !(' $'+ ("$*+ 2 (" #00#( ' (' ( '

( ? !& $ + 2 ""$ (# /#"&2# ' "$ #

5;2 ( + !

( (+ "("// * /!!-2 "$."' (' ('

:; < **(" . ' * "$#+ 6. (' (0+ 2 ""$ (#2( (( ' $

/ $'+ # & 4 # //4 '6=+ // !(;( #2$' $."'

(' ('

' 8 :;< $'# #"' + (' (2 ## '6=+ 0# ( ' **(" . ' * "$#+ (' ( // !(0+ ( & $!+ =

!+ // $* ' + # & 6 ( + + $ &&"##"$ (0 + D "."#"$0 + D $' 4+"!+ 4 # //4 ' ."' (' ( '

' :;< $# 7- $/=0+ (' ( // !(4 ## #"' $'& (4 #( & $' '

!D4"+ '"( !"$+ // !(#+-/' "(#' !"' + 7- #"$ "/ $!&2/"

$! + (' ( &&"##"$ (0+ // !(

( + ("$*6+#"' #02 ## ' ( #+(' ('

' :; <+ ( 6= '"#&"##"$*+ / + 2 ""$ (# $'-2+ /'+ (' ( ? !& $ ## '6=0#( ' $

8:; <)"// **(" . ' * "$#+ (' ( '

' :; <0 + 2 ""$ (# 2( (( ' $ / $ :;<6 ( + &&"##"$ ( $'4+"!++ #6 $'"#&"## '

4+"/ 2 ##"$*+ "&2-*$ '(' ('

'8 9 :;8< $'+ "#+ #-6? !& ( !+ // $* "$+ 2( # $4("2 ""$ "# (*- '6=/ ($ '!-$# / (+ 2 ""$ (#+ // !(

> + #!&&" ' *( . ((( / 44+"/ ' !"'"$*+ 7- #"$ "/ $'

(' ("$*+ "( ? !& $ (&+ / $'"$'"#2- + # -(+ ( (*- '+

/ ($ '&&"##"$ (+ # /#( 2 '+ # & "// * /"=4+"/ ( ? !"$* + "( / #6++ (' (# ( $/ * //=#-# "$ 6/ "$ #&-!+ #+ 2 ""$ (# ( 2-(!+ # (# + / $'"$'"#2- (' / ($ ' !-$# / ( + 2 ""$ (# $' 2 (-# ' + 2 (;6D ( 2(! '"$*4"++ & (0""#$ ! ## (= E( !

) !"$#:*<:<0 $'>; + ! $'4+"!+ ( #-$' (%;

# $ "

% &

% ! % # $ " % !

$ '

(

" " ! "( ( "

(

" " "

) !**+, " '

(

- )

! (

! ' " " "

! " "" ( ( ( " !

" "" " !

( ""

. "

" (

" !

/ ) " '

" 0

(

!12*

3 . "

(

" 0

(

! "

" "

4 "( ( "

" (

(

+" ""

! " !

"" ! !

, ""

! ! "0

+! "

(

- ) ! ""

" " 0

" " !" !

"" " "

" ""

(-# / # !"$ + !( .

/#+ 0#( '

+ ."$*?-("#'"!"$"$+ ."// * & = "+ ( ( $ 22/"!

"$ & ' +"&6=( & $!+ = ( $"$+ 6"

$ + ."// * ( $= +

"! (& $"$ '+ ( "$

(& D"$*#-!+#-&& (= $7-"(=0(' ( ( ? !& $ + 2 (#$04+"#"$4($* -/(-$ -+("# '2## ##"$

+ / $'(+ ("&&.

6/ 2(2 (="$+

+ ."// * 4+"!+"#. # '"$+ ( & $!+ = -$' (+ ! $'2-+ $!+ =

"$2## ##"$+ ( $'+ (' ("#6 E !- ' # ' !( ( 2## ##"$ ##"2-/ '-$' (+ -$?

6 $ $!=!0 :

(#+(A+ ! A<"# -(+ (2(."' '+ "

'-("$*+ 2(! '"$*#-$' ( ) !"$ 0 7- #"$ "/ "#( "# ' $'" 2(. #+ 7- #"$ "/ "#( //="$./. '00#( ' #+ //( !('+ "$'"$*+

! "(#' !"' + 7- #"$ "/ "$+ & $$ (/ "''4$-$' ( ) !"$ :>< + !)-6;# !"$:< /##"2-/ #+ 0#( '

#+ //6= $(' ("$4(""$*( 7-"( + 2 (#$2 = 2 $ /="$( #2 !

+ / $'(+ ("&&.

6/ 2(2 (=4+"!+4 #"$+"#4($* -/(+ #6 $ -$ -+("B '2## ##"$ ( $/ ##+ $ ". +-# $'(-2 # $'$ &( + $ $+-# $'(-2 #2 (+ !

( 2 ( $$-& + 2 $ /="#$ "'4"+"$+ 2 ("' +"(='

=# (&+ '

(' (0+ # & "#6 ( !. ( 6/ # (( (# / $'( . $- )-6;# !"$:9< -(+ ( $."# * # + "

+ 2 (#$( -# #(

"/#!&2/=4"++ (' ( ."!"$2 ## '

-$' (#-6;# !"$:<4"+"$ $'

=# + (' (00#( ' & =-# #-!+ (! "$!/-'"$*2/"! (! 0 #& =6 $ ! ## (= (2-"$*+ $!+ = "$2## ##"$)"// -(+ (#-6;# !"$:

</ =#'4$+ "

2 (#$"# -$'"$4($* -/(-$ -+("B '2## ##"$ + / $'(+ ( "&&.

6/ 2(2 (= #+ &"/ ' + $'"#(' ( '6 ? ! '-$' (#-6;

# !"$:<0#+ //6 2-$"#+ 6/ 4"+"&2("#$& $ ( (&4+"!+& = E $'4= (#"#( / .

$& $"$+ ( + 2(! '-( ( D"$* !*$"B $!

$! (2(# !-"$"#2( #!("6 '-$' () !"$ ;

$' ; + ! ) !"$>;:< + ! /D# 6-+ ( & '= /

* "$#+ (' (2 ## '6=0#( ' -$' () !"$ :<( :<

-(+ (2(."' #+ $#-!+ /#+ ///" -$/ ##+ &-$ 2 $ /=0"

$=0"&2# '-$' (#-6;# !"$:<"#' 2#" '4"++ // !() !"$ >;:< "# ( * ('"$* + ( & '= ( ."#"$ 6 ( + &&"##"$ (

* "$#+ (' (2 ## '6=+ ##"# $// !( "+ (-$' (2(."# #-6;# !"$:< # !"$ ((' (:#<2 ## '6= $= -+("=#-6('"$

+"& $+ 2( # $!

# 0 '&" '/=0 2 ""$-$' () !"$ :<

+ !4 # "/ ' * "$#+ 2 ""$ (#6=( & $!+ = $'+ # & # //4 '6=0#( ' ."' (' ('

8:; <4+"/ 6# (."$*+ + ( #2$' $#+ . $("*+!-/".

/ $'

6 !

-# +"#/ $'"#!$"$-"$* #6:*( B"$* (!4#< (&+ . (=6 *"$$"$* $'$!&2 $!-( ?-("#'"!"$+ # E!/-' '+ / $'

"$7- #"$ (&+ '

"$""$

0#( ' /#"&2# '

"$ #

5;2 (+ !

( 2 (= ( ("// * //=!!-2="$*+ / $'

$'+ "#("! . /2& $ $' $!+ =

"! (4 #'"( ! '' /". ( + 2## ##"$+ ( & $!+ = -& -(+ ('"( ! '+ +

&-$ "$ 6 *' 2#" '"$+ $!+ = -$' + 2 ""$ (#!+ // $* '+ 6. (' (6=4 = $ /

( + // !(04+"!+4 # //4 '$ 8 :;< "## "# " '

4"++ (' (2 ## '6=+ // !(0+ ( & $!+ = !+ // $* '+ # & 6 ( + + $&&"##"$ (0+ D "."#"$0+ D:

/+-*+ + $& $!/ -( + # & "#' #!("6 ' # /6-"#+-/'6 ( ."#"$ "$." 4 ) !"$>;:< + !< $'4+"!+4 # //4 ' $'+ & (4 #( & $' '6 !D+ // !(."' (' ('

' :;

< $2-(#- $! + 6. ( & $'(' (0+ // !(' !"' '

+ & (

( #+ -$'+ (' ( ##"# $// !( ( ? !& $ + 2 ""$ (# '

8 "# 2 ( !/= / * / $' .

/"' $'

!$# 7- $/=0'"#&"## '+ "( / $'!$!/-#"$'( 4$6=+ // !( "$+"#(' ('

' :; <"# #-$' (%;

) " " 6 !(

(

! 6

" "" (

(

!. 6!

8 - - -221 $"

9" (

" 6

:; 2!22290" " "

)""

9" "

" 6

5 * "$ **(" . ' * "$#+ (' (2 ## '6=+ // !(0+ 2 ""$ (#2( (( ' $ /6 ( + &&"##"$ (-$' () !"$>;

+ !0( + ("#+-/'+ . 6 $( ."#"$-$' () !"$>;:< + ! $' 4+"!+ 4 # '"#&"## ' 6=+ &&"##"$ ( 4+"/ 2 ##"$* + "&2-*$ '(' ('

'8 9 :;8< *( "$*4"++ "$'"$*# ( !(' '6=// !("$+ //4"$* (&#%;

7 " "

6 6

! ) ""

$ 1+4 1*4

< ! ""

" " (

" = (

# > !?- ( (

! (

) " "

( " ""

6 @ #

< # 8 ) (

4 -2+ "

" (

(

$ " 75 @ ! "

""(

)

"" " "" )""

( "

) "

$'"#2- '/=0+ 2 ""$ (#+ . $2 "' . $ #"$*/ 2 $$=

"$!&2/"

$! + (' ('

8:; <2 ## '6=0#( '

4+"!+"#2( ;( 7-"#" ( "/"$* $ /-$' (2(."#) !"$>;:< + ! $'""#$!$! ".

6/ #+4 $'-$' (4+ !"(!-&# $! # + /$6 + / + 2 ""$ (#4 # $ ( "$ '6 ( + // !( 4"+- 2 =& $ -# ( !+ (* # ( + ( " #+-/' + . 6 $ ( ? ! '

-("*+/= /#6 $"! '+ "$." 4 . (& $#& ' "$2 ( *( 2+ > + 4(" 2 ""$0+ 2 ""$ (# + . .

"/ ' + ( & '=

( ."#"$6 ( + "$ $!"

/&&"##"$ (0 (= $ * "$#+ "&2-*$ '

(' (# '

' $' 8 9 2 ## ' 6= + // !( $'

&&"##"$ (0 ( #2 !". /=0 $' 4+"!+ "# # ' 6 2 $'"$* ( + ( ( 0$$ + $'0+ 2 ""$ (# ( ( "#"$*+ 2/

( +"#-(+ "&2-*$ '(' (# ( $#-# "$ 6/ 6-$+ + ( + $' + = + . ( #( ' + ( & '= ( ."#"$ 6 ( + "$ $!"

/ &&"##"$ (+-#0"$+ # & 6( +0+ 2 ""$ (# ( 6/4"$*+

$'!/' $'+ =#+-/'+ . !+# $ #4+ #+-/'6 + 22(2("

( & '= * "$#+ "&2-*$ '(' (# $! + 2 ""$ (#+ . /( '= !+# $+ ( & '= ( ."#"$6 ( + "$ $!"

/&&"##"$ (0+ $ + ( "#$!!

#"$ . $ "/ + 2( # $4("2 ""$ (# D"$*+ ?-'"!"

/ ( ." 4 +# . (= (' (# 4+"!+ ( + #-6? ! & (

!+ // $* -$' (+ (2(! '"$*# )"$! + 2 ""$ (#+ . $2 "' . $ #"$*/ 2 $$=-

+ &-$ 2 $ /="$ (&# ) !"$ :< + ! $'+-#+ = ( $ $"/ ' ("$.D"$*+ E( ('"$ (=?-("#'"!"$ +"#-(6 "$*

/- (# / 4 $'+ ' /"6 ( /=4+"/ -$ -+("# ' $'"// * //=

!!-2="$*+ !&&$/ $' + ."// * # &#+ 2 ""$ (#4 $2(/$*+ /""* "$$$ 2( E( $+ (?-#( & "$"$2## ##"$ + / $'"$'"#2- 4"+- =& $ $=-# (!+ (* # $." 4 + 6. 0+"#-(' #$ "$' $=& (""$+ 2( # $4("2 ""$ $'/ 4"+$2"$0 E! 2'"#&"##+ # &

"#&"## ' :) @< :3)) <

+ + (#2 D"$*5( #$ '%

#5 + + (( 2( 6/ %