High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19847/2024dismissed

Union Of India Ministry Of Defence Through Its Secretary To Government Of India And Others v. No 3386176n Ex Nk Sher Singh And Another

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$%&& "#"'#( !"#$&& ) * * +$ ,-+ & **

* .

,-+ *& ** * + !"#$%&'( )! *+!,+-$./0!+.$10#.2$1 30!4*$5$4/4/0.$!26 *

* .

/& *!0#"*4*$/.24+.48!/45$4/4/0.-4*$5$4/4/0.$!2*$!$/. ./0.03.%/+-5!+'230!4*$2$44/."+2/%$034*$0!%$!%+4$%

9..$:#!$ ;- +2 5+22$% &' 4*$ 1$+!.$% !,$% 0!<$2 !/&#.+1 <0.<$!.$%-8*$!$&'24*$<1+/,03!$250.%$.4030!4*$"!+.403 2$!=/<$$1$,$.4034*$%/2+&/1/4'5$.2/0.30!4*$2$!=/<$!$.%$!$%&' */,/.$3$.<$$<#!/4'0!529;*+2&$$.+1108$%-&'<0.%0./." 4*$2*0!43+1103%+'23!0,4*$!$>#/2/4$?'$+!203>#+1/3'/." 2$!=/<$30!$+!./."2$!=/<$5$.2/0./.4*$

0(1'020(34"'#!

$250.%$.4 0 8+2 $.!011$% /. 4*$ .%/+. !,' 0. ? +.%8+2%/2<*+!"$%4*$!$3!0,0.

$250.%$.4 08+2"!+.4$%!$4/!/."5$.2/0.-+2+%,/22/&1$40*/,+25$!4*$ $.2/0.$"#1+4/0.2*$!$+34$!-!$250.%$.408+2!$$.!011$%/.40 $3$.<$$<#!/4'0!5292$!=/<$;0.

<<0!%/."404*$ 5!$=+1$.4501/<'-#50.+44+/./."4*$+"$032#5$!+..#+4/0.-!$250.%$.4

08+2%/2<*+!"$%3!0,2$!=/<$/.4*$0.

+34$!

!$.%$!/."+2$!=/<$03'$+!2+.% %+'2-8*/<*8+22*0!4&' %+'2-20+240,+@$4*$201%/$!$.+&1$%40<0,51$4$4*$>#+1/3'/."4$!, 03?'$+!2-30!4*$5#!502$03"!+.4032$!=/<$5$.2/0.-4*#230!4*$ 2$<0.%2$!=/<$!$.%$!$%&'*/,/.4*$ $250.%$.4 0 8+2 %$./$% 2$!=/<$ 5$.2/0. &' 4*$ <0,5$4$.4+#4*0!/4'30!*/2.04<0,51$4/."4*$!$>#/2/4$>#+1/3'/." 5$!/0%30!$+!./."2$!=/<$5$.2/0./.4*$ $$1/."+""!/$=$%-!$250.%$.403/1$%-&$30!$4*$ 1$+!.$% !,$% 0!<$2 !/&#.+1 <0.<$!.$%- 8*$!$&'2 *$ <+24 + <*+11$."$404*$+30!$2+/%!$A$<4/0.0!%$!*$2+/%-&$<+,$ +1108$%=/%$0!%$!%+4$%

*$05$!+4/=$5+!4034*$2+/% 0!%$!/2$:4!+<4$%*$!$/.+34$!( :::: ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

"#$ % $

& '()

*****+ ? $$1/."+""!/$=$%3!0,4*$+30!$2+/%0!%$!+25+22$%#50. 4*$92#5!+;-&'4*$1$+!.$%!,$%0!<$2!/&#.+1<0.<$!.$%-4*$ 5$4/4/0.$!./0.03.%/+*+23/1$%4*$!$+"+/.244*$/.24+.48!/45$4/4/0. &$30!$4*/20#!4

*'567

7"# "819 2 0# !("'#

28"19 :

1717"#

*$1$+!.$%<0#.2$130!4*$5$4/4/0.$!22#&,/42-4*+44*$ 1$+!.$%!/&#.+1*+23+/1$%40<0.2/%$!4*+4/.4$!,203$"#1+4/0. 0 ?034*$$.2/0.$"#1+4/0.230!4*$!,'- +.%$"#1+4/0.

0034*$$.2/0.$"#1+4/0.230!4*$!,'-

-4*#20.1'4*$ 0,5$4$.4#4*0!/4'8+2$,508$!$%40<0.%0.$4*$%$3/</$.<'/.4*$ !$.%/4/0.03>#+1/3'/."2$!=/<$-4*#2&'4*$201%/$!30!*/2&$<0,/." $.4/41$%402$$@4*$$.%08,$.4035$.2/0.40*/,*$2+/%$"#1+4/0.2 +!$$:4!+<4$%*$!$/.+34$! 9 B)C- ;

,-.* /0 & 1 2

& !

3 ,4 2 & &

&2 & ! &

! 0 *+ 9 B)C-

;

* 5 & !

" ! ,- !

0 67 & 1 8 & &

&* !

*+ 9* )0!$0=$!-4*$)/./24!'03$3$.<$=/%$01/<'1$44$!0

669$.601; %+4$%

- /.2$!4$%<1+#2$9/=; /. 4*$

$"#1+4/0.0034*$$.2/0.$"#1+4/0.30!4*$!,'-

*$ !$1$=+.45+!48*$!$03-/2$:4!+<4$%*$!$/.+34$!

5$!#2+1034*$+30!$+,$.%,$.480#1%,+@$/4<1$+!4*+4 !$1/$3 >#+ <0.%0.+4/0. 03 %$3/</$.<' /. !$.%/4/0. 03 4*$ +5502/4$ >#+1/3'/."2$!=/<$-/240&$+<<0!%$%0.,$!/4-20+240$.2#!$4*+4+. +!,'5$!20..$1/2$1/"/&1$30!+41$+240.$2$!=/<$5$.2/0.

*$1$+!.$%<0#.2$130!4*$5$4/4/0.$!23#!4*$!2#&,/42-4*+4 4*$A#%",$.4034*$1$+!.$%!,$%0!<$2!/&#.+1-!/.</5+1D$.<*- $8$1*/-!$.%$!$%/.<+2$4/41$%+2 ! "# $% 8+2.04<0!!$<4!+4*$!8+2<0.4!+!'401+8+.%3+<424*$!$30!$-.0!$1/+.<$0#"*440*+=$&$$.51+<$%0.4*$2+/%A#%",$.4 *$!$1$=+.45+!+"!+5*2-+20<<#!/.4*$=$!%/<492#5!+;+!$$:4!+<4$% *$!$/.+34$! -*5 1

;

2 - *< *-<,(2 6 !

=$ & 3

?2@= , *<(*-<<, A > A

! ?@=

-<*<4*-<,9B !

& !!

2 2 !B

$ ! 2 2 ! B

= ; =&C 2#

D#*>E*4<-<,F<9*,,*-<,F! >:5

$ >:5

? @= & & B 0000 0000 (* >

!& ! 2

% ; 2 2 & 2

6 G E* 2

= $

! 2

$ A !

H !

$ 3 & & !

= $ 2!

H !

H $ = A !IH

@ 3 &

! ; =& @ *5 *

& ‟ '

( )

* ) )

$ !! !

& 5 !

& + > &!

-- > : 5 ! >2-<<9*5 !

2 & &! , *<(*-<<,

A ,- A

! *+

,-.-/ 0 /1-/-/2 A 2 !

2 !

$ 2

! ; =& *

*& G E*

A 9 !&* #8

"8197 "'1& /.<$4*$$:5024#1+4/0.2,+%$/.5+!+"!+5*0 034*$ A#%",$.4!$.%$!$%&'4*$0.E&1$5$:0#!4/.<+2$4/41$%+2 #7"#"8 #!700#!#"19 ) &*'

*7#49 060-!$50!4$%/.-/32 ,-,- 5+!+"!+5* 8*$!$03 &$<0,$2 $:4!+<4$% *$!$/.+34$!-0=$!<0,$24*$%/2+&1/."$33$<42-/3+.'-032#5!+$:<$54/0. 09/=;-+2&$<+,$/.2$!4$%=/%$501/<'61$44$!%+4$%

-4*#2- /.4$.%$%4080!@+2+.0&24+<1$!+4*$!+"+/.244*$201%/$!<1+/,/."!$1/$3 03<0.%0.+4/0./.4*$!$>#/2/4$2*0!43+11032$!=/<$ ,-* & & 2

1 &

! 0

,- * !

0 H $ 5 !

2 ! !

& 5 ! *H&

& - J 2,K(.

, > 2-<<, 0 2 !

*5 5 ! !

* *$!$30!$-4*$A#%/</+1=$!%/<492#5!+;-%0$2!$.%$!.$"+4$% 4*$2#5!++!"#,$.4!+/2$%&'4*$<0#.2$130!4*$5$4/4/0.$!2-4*+44*$ $,508$!,$.440<0.%0.$4*$!$>#/2/4$2*0!43+11-&$<0,$2201/4+!/1' =$24$%/.4*$0,5$4$.4#4*0!/4'-$25$</+11'8*$.4*$*$!$/.+&0=$ #.%$!1/.$%5+!+"!+5*2-+20<<#!/.4*$=$!%/<4,+%$/.*' #!

*7#49

060, (0

-+11#%$%40/.4*$=$!%/<4,+%$/.*+,+ +#!E2<+2$-%0 /.=$24A#!/2%/<4/0./.4*$!/40#!4-404*!0#"*A#%/</+1/.4$!=$.4/0.- 4*#2,+@$4*$$250#2$%<0.%0.+4/0. 0.2$>#$.41'-4*$<#,#1+4/=$$33$<4034*$+#4*0!/4+4/=$ A#%/</+15!0.0#.<$,$.4+2<+!!/$%/.4*$+&0=$$:4!+<4$%5+!+"!+5*- ,+%$ /. ( ) 4*#2 <0,51$4$1'

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

-+2$.=/2+"$%&'4*$ )/./24!'03$3$.<$B$44$!%+4$%

7#02 !

"8197 "'1& .+34$!,+4*-4*/20#!43/.%2.0,$!/4/.4*$8!/45$4/4/0. +.%8/4*0&2$!=+4/0.2+&0=$-4*$2+,$/2%/2,/22$% ? *$/,5#".$%0!%$!-+25+22$%&'4*$1$+!.$%!/&#.+1 <0.<$!.$%-/2,+/.4+/.$%+.%+33/!,$% /2502$%03+10."8/4*+115$.%/."+551/<+4/0.92;-/3+.' ;*

* .

< ;* * +< && .A+1 9 :

037#4= "# !

9 :"1052