High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18307/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. Ex Sep Macp Hav Ishwar Dass And Another

2024-11-18Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

!"#$%#&'('$)*

"#"$%& '& $ ( )*' +

+* ,-+ ..

. /

,-+ . ..

. + -!,./0 %

121 314

1 5 5

$'7 % 481 2*!31 21 314,9 :1

;;;;

. /

0 <2

!-22 1 = +

42+

$'7

,14 + 1/ 6

2 - 1, 6 2

,1, ( $

'4 1 +1, ./ 2 51

, 3,

: < .!

,4=2 ./2:513

2- ,1.5/+

=1155 =,

!&"1!2!&345$1)6

, 3/

@ 161

62152!

-2:

62 9:42 :!

,2,1.5/ 7+

..8 . 91 ,=1 ,:21 -,6

3 9:

23 6,:21 -42 ,1.5/=11,A B6

56./2%,:15C , <2,1.5/53 :513 62

=1 ?:, ./ 2 3+ !2

/4 2!

2 -

, 21 2 !+ ,1.5 = 2 1 .!1.5

. - 1-- 191, ./

6351 9:

5 -1-- 9,4

65,4.6

2 51

, 3,

: < .!

15 :

,4 =2 ./ 2 :1 1 :2155 - 216

1, ?:

$'<21,4.:13 =,9,

,1,( <2 + 19+1 621,

> 1:,2 16

$% $& '$'$ (

" # ) @ 5 -1-- 9,6

3216

1+1,!+

2$!+ 1'4./251

, 3,

:< .!

15:

,42 +

6 ,12165,2 1-1 2 1 = +

2 )%#5#)&#($%":'($15" ( C6

:, - 31D1 66:91,?!,:1

2+ = +

4 1!6!511 :6

, -=22

2.61553 61 /,19E91 /33. 62,6 +

54.!+ 2. -

55, 21 3/4,+12 15

1-4!+

2.:

- 5,41133. 62:

3.11 ,6 :1.523 4 213 31 -!

,:,4/2 1++ !+

42!+ 53 2 :. -:

!1.5 . 2 :

- 15

. -:

!1.5 31-- 191,

. 1 351 9:42!1:F! ,46

342+ :+5

2 2?!,-3 ,./2&

G.5+> 4 :15, 1 $% & % " !

4 +

, ' () * & ( + <2 591 +1 11+2 6 2 1, 9 ,: 1 > 1:, 2 16 '* (

! !

+ , -. /

! !

! 0

'$1 !

2 3 ( %*&'5 ( #066 -3

%78.

-.(

93 : ;3 %<-.= -. >

(

-3 *.

-!.6 !

93 %<-.= -!.6 ! ?

! ! ?

9%<-.= -!.6

! @ A

9%<-.=B -!.6 @ A

066

5C @ -@ 4 .'$$'D52 ,C

4 5

7& *

) :9 1, -$' 621.

9> 1:,+ :+54 2 !-2+ ,5/,:51 421=2 1,1.5/.:

3 15,!+

/33. 62:

3.11 ,6 :1.523 41 ,=2:2

2 > B

4 2 !+

4 2 !-2 1 / !:2 ,1.5, 33. . 915,, 6

32 3/4.!/ 2

.1- ,2. 6 6,1.5/+

25421- 3 6,1.5/+

1 / 33. 62:

3.11 ,6 :1.523 4=2 3 15,

@ =2 1 ,1.5/ 1 F!1 !3 6 B

4 .! 3+ 195/

1 ,:51 1

3 2 %,:15 C ,4 :1 ,,5/ +

: -2121,11 ,,1.5/. -1

-1-- 191,./351 9:<21,,:51 1

3 ?

,./22 3 4 ( %*&'5 ( #066-3

%78.

) !

42 !-22 1+ !3+

1- , !0F0!2 ,+2/:151 ,3 152152 61 /33. 62 ,6 :1.523 :

,4+:155/=2 121- 62 .:

55,42

,1.

!2.:

-. =21 /,1%

42 !-22 2 15 16!

+ !3+

4 21 =2 1 / ,

2 4 2! ::!

!.F! 5/4 2 ./ 2 1, 21++ - 6 ,

- 61 /,14 .+ !3, .1F!5 62

- 9: 1 1 33. 6 2 ,6 : 1.523 3+ 195/42

9 -2

, =3 F!1. 6 $!+ 1'!0F0!2:

,4.! ,

23+5 / 41 ,

:1421,

! 31 !

,:21 -,42 !+

42:5131 .:

3 5, :9,1.5/+

4155261: , : :!31 : 1 ,1 2

6 9: ./ 2 :

,41 .:5 5/:

! H,42!6

,:51 -=22 2

61 /,19E92:

,41F!5F!1

6 351 / 9: 1 ,7

2 13 . - 1-- 191, ./

. 1 351 9:

( C21131/42 315 6

216!

+ :+5$'21/2 :1 ., 15 6,1.5/+

2 :

,4.!

5/!+

0 1'23 61::+1 : 62:

, 351 / 9:4 3

-.:

- :

,,./2%,:15 , 919 2 . - . =2 1 ,1 =2:2 =9 4.:

:5!,, ./

-23 6 3 5, .' / 6!

2 64 31/ 15

!.F! 5/.:

:5!,,./2%,:15C ,4

1 6

6 351 / 9:

. 1 351 9:4 213. -1 :

- 15,1 !

4623,:15 +

2 5,212,1:

!5,

219. ,:,

3,:15>13 1

62:

,. 31,42!+

2.:

- 5, 9:42 !+

42 13=55

.,3, 2191 ,!

- 9:4/ 2 !1

$!+ 1'42%,:15C , 12 1

:5!, - %

415 ,:51 , !+ 142131 ,1

2%,:15C , 6 =2-!,5 51,, = 21+

62I8!, %,:15$%51 /

'4 JI"

53 0 8 15 :+5I <2 6

421 .

=, ,=22 3 21.

9+ :+54=22 123 6 53 62+

2 3/42!16 1+ 53 /3,:15>13 1

. -31, !00!215242!1

.:13 :

,,1.

3,1. -231 ,7

=22 3

.:131++ ,, 2121,,1=1 1,

1-%

415

., ,46

3261:121 ,4=22 2 1 :1!15 >! 2 !+

62,141 ,7

42!+ 2

553 62+

1D - +51:4 !00! 2 1:9

./ 23 351 9:4=2 ./42 31/:

:5!,212

2,1.! =11F!5 62 - 9: 2 3/ ,1!:2=11 .!1.5

.:131-- 191,./2 351 9: 1,,

415 .-12 ,6

,4=22 2%,:15C ,4,, 155/+

:, 31D1 ,15, :91 :, 15:2:D4+1 :!51 5/1++ 1 - 2 1,9 62,142

!-23+5 /3 61 6 3,:15 :2 F!4 2! !

95 - 2 .5 :D :21 - : :

=2 6

34 2,1.:13 :,%

4621, 3+5 /3 615!51 5/42 ./31/.:

:5!,,F!1 !+

2 642!!.F! 21++ 53 1D +51:4 =1

- 15.! =,

351 9:.,. -1

-1-- 191, ./+

: 6351 9:

5/462!+ 13+5 /, :2 F!121- 61++ 53 1D -+51:42!./2 %,:15C ,:

,451, 1:

:5!

4212 1

:, : 61 /,14.!/21,,

2. -2 53 61 /+

5 21 3/4 19/

:!51 5/2!.F! 1:9,:

7 !+

2 64 ,!

-2:

6351 9:4.!= !5, 1!

155/ 51, 1=55:

:5!

./2%,:15C ,4211:9 !+

.! .:13 :, 6

3 1 66:9 :1!15 - : :

=2 ./2 = !5,., 15 6,1.5/+

@ & =9 4

= 21, ,19 42 , .> 1: -2:

62 +

41.:13 :

,,./2 51%,:15C , ,-!!, ,. /01 21$!3 4,#$ 51 ,

,17,1.5 :2

-:15

::!

: $ 5 6

6 '7 ) $ 856 '7 ) 1 .!1.5

1-- 191, ./351 9:,!

+1: 1 1 $6 1 1 @ 2+ 48% ' ( 1, - 62 :

, 91521123 62 $1'

%"<"

"" "

1++ 53 1D -+51:

.:1331,

62+ :+5$!+ 1',:51 ,./2&

G.5+> :1 5,1$% & % " !

'5)./2%,:15 ,421 3,1=2:22 =9 4,,

.,2+

4 3 5, 2 3/4,,31D+ 53 /

- 6 4 2 ,:51 1

6 51= ?!,-3 $!+ 1' 21 ./2 1+ !3+

212 :!

- 621,,1 =11F!5

6 9:4 .619 1.5/ , =,9192

<2 !-2 2 1, + !3+

.!1.5.!2

! 51,9, : .!21,+ !3+

.:13 :1 !+

2 +

& =9 4 2 1, :1 9, 1,,!: -,:21 - -

!9192

4 6

- 5/

.! -21,+ !3+

4.! 1!

155/15 ,,:11

,!/15 !+

2%,:15C ,4 -1-56 2 ,19 1 2 -4 2

!-2 3+5 /3 6 2 1 6 .5 :D :21

) - : :1!15 :

:2 F!$'4 =2 ./ 31/ .:13

195,212

- 62,1

21 3/+

54 .:13 :,6

31 :, 15- :6135/2

./=115 .1, 23,:15 +

421 2,1.!6

1=556

3, 1

=11:

- 15,1 ,.:13 2 1-- 191,./

.:131 351 / 9: & =9 41 1, - +

$!+ 1'4,:5 2121 . :

,, 1 /+,6

31 ,

219. :

,, 2 > $!+ 1' 1,5/4 :

9, : .! 2 + !3+

$!+ 1'21. 5,./2+

42 ./42 :

1 -9

=-21- 2 +

623,:15.

,4 1 > 1:, $!+ 1'

+:!

!5/4 2 ./

, : :1 . 1- 2!+ 155

3, 1

4.,2 ./2

62,1:1

.1, .1F!5 61 :, 15- :

6135/2

5/4 .,:51 1 6

6351 9: 1,,

4 .,:51

.1 .!1.5

-1-- 191,./

6351 9: ./2+

42 !-21,2 212,1$'

::!

,=25 9:.:13+

3,./2,6 :+

1+1:1 14.! :2

>+ 31 ,1 2

591 -!51

4=2:231D2

- 62,1$' 1 +1:1 14

.-16!

F!5211!:24G

-,,

1 6

6351 9:

.:131-- 191, ./

62351 9: :

F! :4251:D 621,

>+ 31 ,1 2 -!51

4 , :

1 2

:5!,4219 62

- 621,,1$'!+

2 +

2! ::!

, 1+1:1 142 ./421,

- 1 . ,:51 , .:

3 1-- 191, ./

. 1

6351 9: ) !

4 : 3 62?!,-3 ,./2 +> 4 :15,19 !

" # ?

& ,

*+ : =2 41,:51 1

31, 2 > 4212. 6

, - 664 21 3 , =, 2:

,!51 5/15 2 !

1 ,61.5 -2 .:13 9, 2 +

2 D - F!1 2 1++

, - 66. -31, 2619

"9 = : 2 ,:51 1

6 51= 31,

,:$!+ 1'31D21,,:51 1

.1 >+ !51

651= 342 ./42>+ !51

651= 34131, 9 ,: $!+ 1'15 31D22 !

,. 6919 2 ,6 : +

5 :

,4 4 4 15 5 2 :

,42! 11 /3D2- - 62 , =3 1 31,2 !

41 ,21

4 26!55:

3+53 41+5 !

4.,

+:9 62.1 461 /4 6,51/1 ,51:2

<2 6

4 2 - - 6 2 . 6 6 2 1++

, - 664 3 629 ,:$!+ 1' ,./2< .!

,415 ,

!66 6

31 /55-15/1 , . !+25,

')!2 56#5$%":'($15"

16 31242 6 ,

3 2= +

,=2 . 91

94213,3,

<23+!- ,

41+1,./251

,< .!

,431 1 ,1 ,166 3,

+ , 615

-=2155+ , -1++5:1

$'461 / .

. /

. + KL 22 +1D -7 1

, 0 M7

22 +

1.5 M7