High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29035/2017disposed of

Jaswinder Singh v. The Financial Commissioner Revenue, Punjab And ORS

2017-12-19Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath6 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!&)%'*#+%',- #"%"%'#+ .& -#%'!'$%!/00%&&%'#+1#2#'3#13'4!5!'*"-#+& #&6'*#'"& 7( 7( 7( 7(8 97 ::7 8 97 ::7 8 97 ::7 8 97 ::7 +#&#'"( 7+!+433+%1*2$!"#1

+"-#6#"%"%'#+ 7+ !/+!0%',-1*2$!"#1

+"-#$!2#!"+ ::7 1 ;9< ::7 1 ;9< ::7 1 ;9< ::7 1 ;9< -# 6#"%"%'#+ -!& $-!//#',#* "-# 2!/%*%"= "-# +*#+ *!"#* 6!&&#*5="-#%'!'$%!/00%&&%'#+13'4!55=)-%$-&-#-!& +#0!'*#*"-#$!&#5!$>""-# %&"+%$"//#$"+1 !,!+"*#$%*#"-# %&&3# +#,!+*%', "-# !66%'"0#'" 9!05!+*!+ .%//!,# 7#-/%1 #-&%/ !)!'&-!-!+ ' 5+%# 1 "-# 6&" 9!05!+*!+ )!& !*2#+"%&#*1 63+&3!'" " )-%$- "-+## !66/%$!"%'& )#+# +#$#%2#*1 '# %/#* 5= "-# 6#"%"%'#+ ;

!&)%'*#+ %',-<1 '* 5= !+5-!4!' %',- ;&%'$# *#$#!&#*< !'* +* 5= 7!4+ %',- ;+#&6'*#'" < -# %&"+%$" //#$"+ !66%'"#* "-# 6#"%"%'#+!&9!05!+*!+' -#&!%*+*#+)!&$-!//#',#*5"- 5=7!4+%',-!'*!+5-!4!'%',-5# +#"-#00%&&%'#+1 !/!'*-!+

%2%&%'1 !/!'*-!+5=)!= ")!66#!/&-#!66#!/ 7!4+%',-)!& *%&0%&&#* 53" !+5-!4!' %',-8& !66#!/ )!& !//)#* 2%*# +*#+ *!"#* -#6#"%"%'#+"-#'$-!//#',#*"-#+*#+ "-#00%&&%'#+%'

+#&6#$" "-#!66%'"0#'" !+5-!4!'%',-!&9!05!+*!+5=)!= !' !66#!/5# +#"-#%'!'$%!/00%&&%'#+-#&!%*!66#!/)!&!//)#*' ? 7!4+%',-$-!//#',#*"-#+*#+ "-#00%&&%'#+5=)!= !)+%"6#"%"%')-%$-)!&)%"-*+!)'5=-%0' ? %'$#"-#+# )#+# ' +#2%&%'!/ 6)#+ )%"- "-# %'!'$%!/ 00%&&%'#+ !'* '/= !66#//!"#6)#+&)#+#$'

#++#*36'-%01"-#+# +#1!+5-!4!'%',-*%* '" %/#+#2%&%'6#"%"%'!'*6+# #++#*!)+%"6#"%"%'!,!%'&""-#+*#+ %'!'$%!/ 00%&&%'#+ *!"#* ? 53" &%'$# "-# %'!'$%!/ 00%&&%'#+ )!& $'

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

5# %' "-# %"'#&& "-%',& % "-# %063,'#* +*#+ "-#)+%"3+"!&!/&"-#%'!'$%!/ 00%&&%'#+*!"#*? !+#&#"!&%*# !'* "-# 0!""#+ +#0%""#* " "-# %'!'$%!/ 00%&&%'#+ " *#$%*# "-# %&&3# 9!05!+*!+% !

+#&- 5= -#!+%', !// "-# "-+## $'"#&"!'"&1 '!0#/=1 7!4+ %',-!66#//!'"1 !+5-!4!' %',-+#&6'*#'" !'*

!&)%'*#+%',-+#&6'*#'"? ""-%&&"!,#1%"%&6%'"#*3""-!"!+5-!4!' %',--!&&%'$##C6%+#* '&#D3#'"/=1 )# *%+#$" "-!" "-# 0!""#+ 5# *#$%*#*!

+#&-5=-#!+%',"-#!66#//!'"!'*

!&)%'*#+%',-+#&6'*#'"?%'$#"-# %&&3#%&6#'*%', +"-#/!&"=#!+&1%")3/* 5# 43&" !'* !66+6+%!"# " ,%2# 3+"-#+ *%+#$"%' "-!" %'!'$%!/ 00%&&%'#+ $'$/3*#& "-# 6+$#&& )%"-%' ! 6#+%* 0'"-&!

"#+!66#!+!'$# !+"%#& &-!// 63" %' !66#!+!'$# 5# +# "-# %'!'$%!/00%&&%'#+' E -#+#!

"#+1 0!""#+ )!& -#!+* 5= %'!'$%!/ 00%&&%'#+1)-2%*#-#++*#+*!"#* 1-!&+#0!'*#*"-#$!&# 5!$>""-#//#$"+)%"-"-# //)%',5&#+2!"%'&(

? B -!2# $'&%*#+#* "-# !+,30#'"& !*2!'$#* ' 5#-!/ 5"- "-# 6!+"%#& !'* #C!0%'#* "-# #2%*#'$#' +#$+* -# &#""/#* /!) %' "-#0!""#+ 9!05!+*!+%%&"-!""-#+*#+

%&"" //#$"+1 5#%', !66%'"%', !3"-+%"= 9!05!+*!+1 %& " 5# +#&6#$"#* 3'/#&&%//#,!/%"=+6#+2#+&%"=%&#&"!5/%&-#* " %& '" !66+6+%!"# + "-#+ +#2#'3# !3"-+%"%#&1%'$/3*%',"-%&3+"1"&35&"%"3"# "-#%+)'6%'%' +"-!" "-#!66%'"%', !3"-+%"= ' "-%& $!&# "-# '85/# %,- 3+" -!& &6#$% %$!//= -#/* "-!" - 7!4+ %',- $!'*%*!"# -!& 5##' *#6+%2#* "-# 66+"3'%"= 6+#&#'"%',-%&$/!%0!'*-!& +#0%""#* "-# 0!""#+ " *#$%*# "-# %&&3# /!05!+*!+% !

+#&- 5= -#!+%', 5"- "-# $!'*%*!"#& -# $!'*%*!"#& -!2# +!%&#* $#+"!%' %&&3#& !'* 6+6#+ *#"#+0%'!"%' "-#0#+%"& "-#$!'*%*!"#&&-3/*5#*'# 5="-# %&""//#$"+ '2%#) "-#!52#1"-%&0!""#+%&+#0!'*#* " %&"" //#$"+1 !,!+ " -#!+ "-# 6!+"%#&!'*6!&&+*#+&>##6%',%'2%#)"-# *%+#$"%'& "-#'85/#%,-3+"

'2%#) !$""-!""-%&0!""#+%&-%,-/= *#/!=#*1 !& 5&#+2#* 5= "-# '85/# %,- 3+"1 "-# 6!+"%#& !+# *%+#$"#* " !66#!+ 5# +# "-# %&"" //#$"+ !,!+ '

@ )%"-3" )!%"%', + !'= 3+"-#+ '"%$# + %'"%0!"%' -# %&"" //#$"+ &-3/**#$%*#"-#0!""#+)%"-%'

*!=&E 9#!+'#* $3'&#/ + "-# 6#"%"%'#+ -!& &350%""#* "-!" "-# %'!'$%!/ 00%&&%'#+ -!& $00%""#* ! 6!"#'" #+++ !& "-#+# )!& ' *%+#$"%'"-#+"+#0!'*"-#$!&#5!$>""-#//#$"+"*#"#+0%'#"-# &3%"!5%/%"= "-# $!'*%*!"# + "-# 63+6&# !66%'"0#'" !& 9!05!+*!+ +!"-#+*%+#$"%')!&%&&3#*5="-#3+"""-#%'!'$%!/00%&&%'#+" *#$%*#"-#%&&3# 9!05!+*!+!

+#&-5=-#!+%',!//"-#"-+##$'"#&"!'"&" %& 3+"-#+ &350%""#* "-!" *3+%', "-# 6#'*#'$= &%'$# !+5-!4!' %',- -!* #C6%+#*1"-#+# +#1"-#+#!+#")$!'*%*!"#&%' +!=1'!0#/=1"-#6#"%"%'#+ !'* +#&6'*#'" !'* %" )!& + "-# %'!'$%!/ 00%&&%'#+ -!2# " *#$%*#!&")-%$-$!'*%*!"#%&&3%"!5/# +"-#6&" 9!05!+*!+ 9#!+'#*$3'&#/ +"-#$!2#!"+F+#&6'*#'" &350%"&"-!" "-#+#%&'#+++%'"-#+*#+ "-#%'!'$%!/00%&&%'#+5#$!3&#&-#-!& +#0!'*#*"-#$!&#5!$>""-#//#$"+"*#$%*#"-#&!0#)%"-%'

*!=& !'*!/&,!2#!//66+"3'%"%#&""-#6#"%"%'#+!'*+#&6'*#'" !&)#// "+!%&#!//%&&3#& -!2#-#!+*/#!+'#*$3'&#/ +"-#6!+"%#&!'*!

"#+#C!0%'%', "-#+#$+*1!0 "-#$'&%*#+#*6%'%'"-!""-#%063,'#*+*#+%&6!"#'"/= #++'#3&5#$!3&#+#&6'*#'"-!*" //)"-#*%+#$"%'&%&&3#*5=

A "-%& 3+" )-%/# *%&6&%', 9 A %' )-%$- -#F&-# )!& *%+#$"#* " *#$%*# "-# %&&3# 9!05!+*!+% !

+#&- 5= -#!+%', !// "-# $'"#&"!'"&!'*)!& 3+"-#+*%+#$"#*"$'$/3*#"-#6+$#&&)%"-%'!6#+%* 0'"-&!

"#+ !66#!+!'$# "-#6!+"%#& '$#1 "-#+# )!&' *%+#$"%' %&&3#*5="-# %2%&%' #'$- "-%&3+"""-#%'!'$%!/00%&&%'#+"

3+"-#+ +#0!'* "-# $!&#1 %" &-3/* '" -!2# 5##' +#0!'*#* 5= -#+ " "-# //#$"+ +"!>%',*#$%&%'+!"-#+&-#-#+&#/ )!&&366&#*"*#$%*#"-# 0!""#+"!*43*,#"-#&3%"!5%/%"= "-#$!'*%*!"#& '2%#)"-#+# 1"-#%063,'#*+*#+*!"#* %&-#+#5= &#"!&%*#!'*"-#0!""#+%&+#0!'*#*5!$>""-#%'!'$%!/00%&&%'#+" "!>#!*#$%&%'%'+#&6#$" "-#!66%'"0#'" 9!05!+*!+%'"#+0& +*#+6!&&#*5="-# %2%&%' #'$- "-%&3+"%'9 A *#$%*#*' @ -# 6!+"%#& !+# *%+#$"#* " !66#!+ 5# +# "-# %'!'$%!/ 00%&&%'#+#2#'3#13'4!5' @ @ ;::7 < ;::7 < ;::7 < ;::7 <

-#"-#+&6#!>%',F+#!&'#* #&F -#"-#++#6+"!5/# #&F