Jagdish Singh v. State Of Punjab
! "#$# %& '
('
&)*+'+ , + !"#$% & %#'("'$% & '(#$)%* %+', $% & # " + -'./ 01 - "" , . ./012/.34 , . .0142.
34 - + #, . ./012/.34 + &' %
5
632 13/$ 431$3.! , " 5"$)"
,## 7 $ 4/2,, '" / "& " & "
# 5
8 " *'"
# "' $
""8 ""
.
!
" #
$ $
%!
#
! & &' (
) &*
&+%
- , $ . $ , ! /& *
0
#& !
, & 0
!
&+%
&1
,$ + "% ,
- $ , $ $
$ , ! 2
, 3
& +%
, , 4% # ( 5 %,
6
6 7 7 0 &+%
$%(0
8- ( $ , $. ,93 8! /& *
0
#&0
!
&!
, &+%
81
" $ , "
,93 8! % 7( $ & 0
!
& 3
& !
, & +%
:8 - $ , $
,93 / ::/8! 2
,
'& +%
, % 6
6 (##%% !&:&
;
,
, %/ <:10= $ !, $ & 4%
!
" #
$ $
%!
#
! & &' (
) &*
&+%
%( %
>
7
6 % 6
#
,
, % ,
%
% 6 :
% , * : % ,/$4?
. & :& &. :: -
#
:% 2
,3
&
#@ %
0
;&+%
6 %
% % % 6 %
%
% :6
#
6
, 6
+& %
%
6 $
A ( @
/
*
- (
6 6 % 6 6
( 5
& % :
%
( 5
# (
%
% 1
6 % 6 @ 6
# 7 % =:
, ,6
%
% , %
6 ( 5
5
#
6 5 , %
, $
( 5
6 %,$
#
#!
7 @B $7
@!
"7 @7
%@ !&:& 9!76 #$5 + @7 #$;
7 %
8
% 1 ;%
, ,
( 5
5 %
5 2 @
/
% =: % 6 & #
6 :7 % , ( 5
( %
#6
% ( %!&/& (% 3 & % @
( %
#6
65 %
6
%
0072 , 4% #& 6
16 0
# :5 0
:/ 0
% , 4% #
# %
.
6
93 //8
6 % 6 ( 5
% ( 5
,( @
6 !
7 @B 7
@!
"7 @
6
6
5 % %
6
( %
#6
5
% 4% # 91C8, 5
6 % (# %
#
, 7
@ 6 %
%
#
6 %
%
% !&:& 5
6 % (%
@
# , 6
; & 65 %
6@6
% % % % ,6 4% 6 %
#, % # ,
6 @ %
,%, % 1 # % %
#6 % 6
6 (##
, , (! &:& + @
6 # # %
, % , 5
% 6 , % ,
6 % % =
%
% %/ <:10=$ !,
, 5 4% # 4% (
% % 6 % 1 &
# %
( 5
#@
#( , %
# 6 %
5
"%(
$ !
" #
!
" #
$ $ $
%!
#
&! & &' (
) &*
&+%
3 / : ) 4% #
6
% (# $1 !
@ .% $*
+%
6 6 4% #
!
" #
(% ;
,$ %
,! )0
#&-
% & +%
6 @ ,62 < *: 1
% # *
&+%
7
6
# ,
(%# ,+'A1
6
,$ %
,6
@ 1
,$ "% ,! % 7( $ &0
!
&
&+%
6 @
#
5
% 7( $ 3
& +%
7
1
, %
@ ,
,6
5
* : % ,/$4?
0
;&3
&+%
1
, 6
1
,$ "% ,- $ ,$ $
,
,$ . ,
& -. 1
%
0
;& *
+%
7 1
,
6 B @ /
*
-
,
, * : % ,/$4?
% 0
;&3
&+%
, 6 6
6 - ,$ $ . ,! /& *
0
#& !
, & 0
!
& +%
& 5 # ,
%@
( 5
!/&:& 6- ,$ . ,
,$ "% ,&- $ ,$ $
,
!&/& 6
,5
# - ( $ ,C 5 ,
#
, #
6 ,
5 %
5 @ %( /
A% , , #
( 5
1
,$ "% ,&- $ ,$ $
$ , , # 6 (%# ,
( 5
( %
#6
(%
& % @ ( %
#6
7
@ 6 , # ( 5
$ !
$ ,$< $ ,! % !
@ & .
&
6 , # (
.
, 6
6
#6 (
6 ,
6 %
- ,
# ,
, # 5 % !
" #
9,
8
% <# ,- ,
% 6
1
,$ "% ,&- $ ,$ $
$ ,(# , , #
9,
8 % 5 % !
" #
, 5
.
$ , 6
% , # (
(% , 5
%% (# B
!
" #
, 5
@ - , , 0!3 :
( D( % "
(= #
,0 % 0
,
,C 6 D( 3 -% @3
%"
5
:
: 6 (# ,
(
,5 %
0 01 6 #- , 6 %
( , @ &6 %
(#
5
4% (
9,
8 6 , # (
(# - ,
7 (
,
6 ( ,
(# 5 , ,
< %
6 96
#8
&
# %
(" 4% #7 5,
4%
- ,$ . ,&1
" $ , $ "% $ ,
- $ , $ $
$ , (# , %& < 10A% , 5,
# , % , # 6
(
7 & # (
, %& < 10 - ,$. ,&1
" $ ,$ "% ,
$ ,$ $
,0 $1 !
@.% $*
&+%
7$C $*
&+%
% 6 $1!
@.% $ *
&+%
6
D( 01
%
&+%
&6 % 6
D(
A %#0 &E +%
&6 % 6
D( A %# 0 !%
0+%
&6 6 * 6
4% # 6 D( 0 &+%
6 6 4% # A09!8* $A 0 &+%
C 6A %# 0 !%
06 $C*
, 4% #
5, $A A %# 0 !%
0+%
5 ,
,6 4% #
( , ( 5
- ,$ . ,! /&*
#&!
, &0
!
&+%
&1
,$ + "% ,
$ ,$ $
,! 2
,
&+%
&C ,
,6 4% #
%
# *1! $C $ % 5, 0 ! (
%,6 <
! 7> />3F 4 7 "
# 8+ ' " & " - ' 8 ' #8 # "' && "
33% 9 . - #8" & #6/2 # & # ":# % 9 ./ , ; "'$ "
' # " & "
33<3 % 9 .4 - ' 8
& " " '8""& '= # "" & + " "
8 ' & "
8" #& & $
"
& ""
"" =8 & $ $ 3 '8 #" '# +8 5
% 9 . 8 ""
# "
' "
# #=#" $#8# ( " * 8"
'- " '
" $& 8
" ' # "- "
'$333; ' ' # 41; ' 7 " # # '
# $ "
&""
> #-+?@ # ,6103 ' # # 8 # "'
& % 9 .1 - 8 # 8 "
'
& 8 # "
' / " . # " '# 41;
' ' % 9 .0 & $ & 3133/
" @ /< " ?,,"
' "'""8 % 9 .< - ( "
* 8" *%"
7 "
&". 7 "
+8 (?@ # ,20<3/ ' # " # ;
' # &" " *'" '
' "8 # "' & '
' & $ " " ; ' '
' ( " * 8"
% 9 .3 -
""
' " @ /< " ? ,, # & 3/3434 & ""
" & ' % 9 . "
& ' "
8 & "
& *'"& ""
"" '' = #
" '" " ",8 & $ # 8 # & 13034% 9 .1 ""
" # "# - +"" + " ' "' ' 8 "
# " -
' # ' "- ;' ' " ' " & & & = # .
# "' #"',, . .0142>34& 2334 $" "8" "' "' # "$ ;'
"8 '
% + (#$" 5"7 $88 ;' .
F
!
" #
(% ;
- ( $ , $ %
$ , ! ) 0
#& -
% & +%
6 @ ,62 < *: 1
% # *
&+%
7
6
# ,
(%# ,
6
,$ %
,6
@ 1
,$ "% ,! % 7( $ &0
!
&3
&+%
6 @
#
5 ,
% 7( $ 3
&+%
7
1
, % ,
@ ,
,6
5
* : % ,/$4?
0
;&3
& +%
1
, 6
1
, "% ,&- $ ,$ $
,
,$ . ,
& -.1
%
0
;&*
+%
7 1
,
6 5 @ /
*
,
, * : % /$4?
% 0
;&3
&+%
, 6 6
6 - ,$ $ . ,! /&*
0
#&!
, &0
!
&+%
& 5 # ,
%@
( 5
!/&:& 6- ,$ .
$ , 1
,$ "% ,&- $ , $ $
,
!&/& 6
,5
# - ,C 5 ,
#
, #
6 ,
5 %
5 ,B @ %( /
A% , , # ( 5
1
" $ , $ "% $ ,& - $ ,$$
, , # 6 (%# , ( 5
( %
#6
(% 3 & % @ ( %
#6
7
@ 6 , #
( 5
$ !
$ ,$ < $ , ! % !
@ &.
&
6 , # (
.
, 6
6
#6 (
6 , 6 %
- ( $ ,
# ,
, # 5 % !
" #
9,
8 % <# , - ,
% 6 1
,$ "%
$ ,&- $ ,$ $
,(# , , #
9,
8 % 5 % !
" #
5
.
, 6
% , # ( (% , 5
%%
(#B
!
" #
, 5
@ - , ,
0!3 : ( D( % "
( = #
, 0 % 0
,
,C 6 D( 3 -% @3
%"
5
:
:
6 (# ,
(
,5 %
$
0 01 6 #- ( $ , 6 % ( , @ & 6 %
(# 5
4% (
9,
8 6 , # (
(#- ( $ ,
7 (
,
6 ( ,
(# 5 , , < %
6 96
#8
&
# %
( " 4% #7 5, 4%
- ( $ ,$. ,&1
,$ "% ,
$ , $ $
$ , (# , , % & < 10A% , 5,
# , % ,
# 6
(
7 & # (
, %& < 10 - ( $ ,$. ,&1
,$ "% ,
$ ,$ $
,0 $1!
@.% $*
& +%
F 1 7 "# & $ # "8& "' "8
# "8 .
8 ' " . "" " " "65./0# 43;'
@ # ' # "$ . "8
# '"
3138 . 8 "= # 8 "" . # # " # $.
""# 8 " " & "' " " 8& "" " # "" " ' 3$ 9 "
# " 8 "8 % '
#-+) & " " 8+ $/1$333>. # " & # 0$3$333>. # '. " $ . & " " $ 9 " ) 6422 33<3& # " 8 ""
8 # 9 "
= # & " 9 "
$ # " '8"" "$ 3$# +8 # #" '8"" "@;' # "# +8 "
" # # 8 # ( " * 8"= # # " # " """ & "# =";8 # " & $ . 9 "
" 8 " > 8'$" . & 8. " $## 8 "
& "( " * 8"
## # "& 0 = &"## '" " 2 % " "' 3234 " # "8 . $ 8& 8 # " "'"
" 88$ " $# >" 8" 8 "
33<3 " 888 # """'
"
# "' ( " * 8" " . " #
# "& 2
& 8 ""
" & "
# ""
# $, #
# '
" < ! # 3
" $'$ ., + 1 '
('
B @ , G? B G?