High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22557/2019dismissed

Maninder And Others v. Punjab And Haryana High Court At Chandigarh And Another

2019-08-26Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina8 pages

# !" $$%& '( & )#*+,)-%. /,,+)-%"

0.11"

%2231.%-1- . "4#%-%+%%2 #2

0" 1 , "1.# 120.%1%,5 " "2 , ,%1 , " , ,%1 , ""2"6 225 %25. 73 8 )""2 "2 " 6 2 - !19:9 : ; 12 9)""2,-%:!1+

89<

!1=:.%"-11.&5

< 9: )""2 " 6 2 11 2211. %&5 :4"%"6 211 11 .%2"->22 "2#+

%11. %&5 9:"11 1 1%%2 -%?1 2 8

.-+"" 12.11 1>" %.1.# /-2 "2?,2 /-2 "2?"?* 9:0 % 1 1 / 3-1% @- 9:0 % 1 - "%% "2"9% ," ,: 9-:0 % 11 - " ; 1," %" A011 1 2 % 11 % - 31 + ? %222 72#0131 %112-1" 2 >2 11 1"

:4"%"11 "2 22 ,,%1, "+- .#%222"

+ 25%2,+

%11. %&5 9:,1%%1 1/ 3-1% @- 9: 0 % 1 - "%% "2"9% ," ,:=

A $% ""2 %2"- >22"2!19:"% .1 1 :

8!1"- 711 "2 22 ,,%1, "- "222 ". 02"225 %25 # "% - ;- "2 1+ . <1% %= 2"1 %2-"%%"%2"B ""21" 1C 1 ""%%1"23.11 11 1%?2 .2 2"1 !19:9 :0 D 1$"212!%2 22 9 : %2" D 1 6 2-12 ' %

" ( 2 ,1/.+, ,%1, " 11.,,%1, " % 2"2"6 22 0. 2 , ,%1 , " . %22"2%2"1.-% ,,%1, "022"-%% 2%22B21%1- "2 ".%22%%"

0 D 1 22 2 A % 11 " -% " 6 2 2 2 1 1,,%1, ".%.# % %22 5?" "%%1 "2%B+"2.1 1

%21.1%% "2022 2 %22 "11881 1% %% .222" "1"% !1 + A8 2 ' ) - %22 22+ " ?' . 2

8,,%1, ". "3 "2 "6 2"%"131+" % .112""%022% ".211- %2" 11. %&5 <B -. "% "%"1 25%25 + % 22 # "-1 %% " 2 """ 2 1%#" -. D 32 )%% 1+ 3 "%% " %=

0 22 ""- %22

2"""22 1 % #" -. 32 0 ".%1 ( ) 21"+" - ""% . . " B % 1,1"!1 %1."% 7"6 211

%%2 %% ; 1

," %" A . 7"11 "222 ,,%1, "+- .#%222 " + 25%2 ,*%,01."2 3%B""%1 +"2 .2 -%%.%" %2%21 0%% + + -1 31 "% %1 )%1A31"""%"1)%1' BB%"1"+ .11 " %%1% 1"%!19:9 :0- #

"20)!""-% .#1. %. -2#%.#%%B ".%%,0"2!1 5) !1

8.%"% %.(." 2 " ; 1 , . " 2 %"20-%2"1222>"% .1 1"22" "2 11. % %-% 1.%

)#*+1,1!1 A

8!1 2%-!1 A 11.&5

< A2 ; 122 > 11>%"% .%2"->2"% +

1% 11 - %12 "2 ,-%%C%?C%1"%

11 #%>%" ".%"%%%"2 1. 0 C%?C%1 1 - 1 E/E " )! 1 .E 1 E" "% 2% "2= B-.!1+"2 2

51%%2"->2 "% "2342+11"% -% % #%>%"".% "%%%"21.+%1 -% 0 )! " "- 2 "2%",,%1, "0 ."-%11 11 12 "2"6 2 B-% 2-% 1 ,1"""5 #1-1- 0.+1 2"2 1B

% % 12,1 2-%%1 + .1%%" 1""121!12""1

0 % %22 ,?" "2""121102" % >%-%22111 "1"132 B - % .#1 " + "1% , " -1 >% 2- %1.#0 1

2 % 25%25 5%252 0 "%"1 5%252 --% "%.11#."2 B.+E25%25E1 2" 2 1 "1 1 %1 0..%2 2 !19:9 :.""1"2" 11 " 2" % D 1 220%""2 1%2%% . 1 " " 11 1 .

51"1%B %22"2 1 21 "212%% 1 -.2% 0 #%% 1.11 102%2." "-2 .

( %20B 1-"1"%# 8 B-++ 22 . "2%%-- >% . %)%1 'B0 + %1+ %2 11 12" % D 1221

%""%- "2-1 "2" %-#. % 1 "2%%

% 10 "2> " 22"-1" 1% .121 - A 4 +B2 . "22

!"#!$%& '