High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/38763/2023allowed

Manjeet v. State Of Haryana

2023-11-29Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri7 pages

"%&'&#( )** (+""!

***** "!&!&#(", -",'.'

/! !"

,0 (

*****

"'1#(2"(!

34 * / / / ,"'"(! ,* -&5 '67 28#% !"7

1"!&!&#(",* ,* -&'6 9 : '60 17

7 ,0 ( * / /

; 4< * 1,"'"(!

!6&,2 1"!&!&#( $&9"2 =) #2"

,&>&( 9 ,#%"2.,"

@" ,&(?

#* 2 !"2 **7 ; 22"2 9 !", #(<7 ,"?&'!","2 #9&%"

/! !&#( / 2 , ,( .(27

&'!,&%!

('&* * !

'.@>&!!"2 9" ,("2 %#.('"9 '&(%"

** A6&%6 !6 ( >#(!6'* "

$.,!6", '.@>&!!"2 %9" ( &(8#98"2 1,"'"(!

A '

19 (!"2 .1#( 6&> 1#9&%"

2."

1#9&!&% 9 "(>&!0* "

'.@>&!!"2 1", 99"? !&#('7 %# %%.'"27 ( >"907 !&'6 '6&'6 A '

11,"6"(2"2 99"?"2 ,"%#8",0 5?'*

1&.> 1"!&!&#(",7 A6&%6 > ,?&( 990 6&?6", !6 (

1,"'%,&@"2 %#>>",%& 9 C. (!&!0 /# $ , 99"?"2 ,"%#8",0 %# %%.'"27 ( >"907 !&'6 '6&'6 %#(%",("27 '.@>&!!"2 6&> 99"?"2 ,"%#8",0 @#.!

* 5?'* 1&.>* "

'.@>&!!"2 "8"( #!6",A&'"

%# %%.'"27 ( >"907 !&'6 '6&'67 "D!"(2"2 @"("$&!

##,2&( !"

"(%6 )) ** 9>#'!

0" , >#(!6'

"9 1'"2 $!", %# %%.'"2 ?, (!"2 @ &97 '!&99 $ %&(?

&(% ,%", !&#( (#A 6&'

!#! 9 %#>"'

#.!

>#(!6'* "

$.,!6", '.@>&!!"2

#.!

A&!("''"'

"D >&("2 !&99 2 !"

% .'"2 2."

(#( 11" , (%"

1,#'"%.!&#( A&!("''"'* "

'.@>&!!"2 %#('&2",&(?

$ %!

'&>&9 ,90 '&!. !"2 %# %%.'"27 ( >"907 !&'6 '6&'6 "D!"(2"2 @"("$&!

@ &97 !6","$#,"7 %#('&2","2 ?,#.(2 1 ,&!0* * 4" ,("2 %#.('"9 $.,!6", ,"$",,"2 +.2?>"(!'

1 ''"2 F/ !"(2", (!&9 -'* "(!, 9 .," .

(8"'!&? !&#( (#!6",G7 ;< / 7 F#62* .'9&> .'' &( -'* /! !"

;

"96&<G7

;/< =7 /1"%& 9 4" 8"

11" 9 ;,&>&( 9< #*

) !&!9"2 6"", + /6.59 -'* /! !"

!! , , 2"'6G /1"%& 9 4" 8"

11" 9 ;,&>&( 9< #*= ) !&!9"2 @& , 5 '6 -'* /! !"

2&'6 G %#(!"(2"2 8&"A $ %!. 9 1#'&!&#( A"99 +.2?>"(!'

1 ''"2

"'1"%& 990 &!

$ .9!

%%.'"2 '&!. !&#( "8"( "$$"%!

A&99 2&9.!"2 ?&8"( $ %!'

%&,%.>'! (%"'

" %6 "8",0 % '"*

=* ( 6 (27 ,* -&'6 9 : '60 17 9" ,("2

7 ,0 ( 7 '.@>&!!"2 '# $ , %#(%",("27 ' >"

%#,,"%!

%# %%.'"27 ( >"907 !&'6 '6&'6 "D!"(2"2 @"("$&!

##,2&( !"

"(%6 *** /# $ , %#(%",("27 '.@>&!!"2 &!

%#,,"%!

&(8#98"2 @.!

#11#'"2 ?,#.(2 ,"%#8","2 C. (!&!0 5?'*

?, >'

1&.> A6&%6 $ 99'

% !"?#,0 %#>>",%& 9 C. (!&!0 !6","$#,"7 1, 0", 6&!

@ ,

* 6" ,2 9" ,("2 %#.('"9'

1 ,!&"'*

* $ %"2 &(% ,%", !&#( !6 ( >#(!6'

'! !"2 6 8&(?

%9" ( &(8#98"2 !&99 2 !"7

#.!

A&!("''"'

"D >&("2* ##,2&( !"

"(%6 ?, (!"2 %# %%.'"27 ( >"907 !&'6 '6&'67 A6# A '

% .?6!

'1#!

A '

?, (!"2 )) **7 A6&%6 0" , >#(!6'

?#* 99"?"2 ,"%#8",0 5?'*

?, >'

1&.>7 A6&%6 $ 99'

% !"?#,0 %#>>",%& 9 C. (!&!0 !6","$#,"7 1, 0", A#.92 %#('&2","2 9&?6!

* #(3@9"

/ !"(2", (!&93'

;'.1, < 2&'%.''"2 &''."

,"? ,2 &!'

"$$"%!

,&?6!

9&$"

,!&%9"

#('!&!.!&#( (2& * , #*=) +.2?>"(!

,"1,#2.%"2 .(2", F=)* /.@'"%!&#( ;< > (2 !"'

%#.,!'

%#(!&(."

1,#%""2&(?'

2 0!#2 0 @ '&'

!&99 %#>19"!&#( "8&2"(%"* 6","$#,"7 #(%"

'! ,!'7 &!

'6#.92 ," %6 9#?&% 9 "(2* - ,&#.'

2&,"%!&#('

&''."2 ?&8"

.(("%"'' ,0 2+#.,(>"(!'

,"'.9!&(?

A&!("''"'

@"&(?

A#( #8",* #A"8",7 (#(%#>19& (%"

) %#(!&(."'

? 0 @ (2#(* ",6 1'

%#.,!'

9#("

% ((#!

$ .9!"2 >.9!&19"

," '#('

9" 2 '.%6 2+#.,(>"(!'* 6#.?6 '"%!&#( > 5"'

2+#.,(>"(!'

!##

9#(?", !&>"

1",&#2 "D%"1!&#(7 !6"0 @"%#>"

(#,>* H"

!#.%6&(?

.1#( 1,#8&'&#( '6#A 1 ,!

%#.,!

#, 1,#'"%.!&#( A#.92 %",! &(90 8&#9 !"

,!&%9"

* 6&'

'# %%.'"2 1",'#( &(% ,%", !&#(* 6&'

1,#8&'&#( >.'!

119&"2 &(.,&(?

@"("$&!

%%.'"2 A6&9"

%#('&2",&(?

119&% !&#( @ &9* H6 !"8", ( !.,"

#$$"(%"7

1,#9#(?"2 !,& 97 11" 9 #,

,"8&'&#( ? &('!

%%.'"2 #,

%#(8&%!

#, &(% ,%", !&#(7 A#.92 8&#9 !&8"

,!&%9"

* H6&9"

%#.,!'

A&99 "(2" 8#., %#>19"!"

9" '!

,"%#,2&(?

"8&2"(%"

1,&8 !"

A&!("''"'7 &(2&% !"2 C.&!"

$"A #%% '&#('7 !6"0 '6 99 > 5"

'.,"

%%.'"2 2#"'

'.$$", #%% '&#("2 2."

(# $ .9!

6&'

#A(*G * #62* .'9&> .'' &(3'

;'.1, < 2&'%.''"2 &''."

,"? ,2 %%.'"2 1",'#( 8&' 8&'

@ ,

,"9"8 (!

, '

+.2?>"(!

,"1,#2.%"2 .(2", F)* 19 &( 9&!", 9 &(!",1,"! !&#( %#(2&!&#('

;&*"*7 '6#.92 ' !&'$&"2 %%.'"2 ?.&9!0 A#.92 %#>>&!

#$$"(%"< A#.92 "$$"%!&8"90 "D%9.2"

9!#?"!6",7 ,"'.9!&(?

1.(&!&8"

2"!"(!&#( .(' (%!&#("2 1,"8"(!&8"

2"!"(!&#( A"99* 6","$#,"7 > ((", A6&%6 '.%6 '1"%& 9 %#(2&!&#('

"( %!"2

% ( %#('&2","2 A&!6&( %#('!&!.!&#( 9 1 , >"!",'

A6","

%#.,!

," '#( @90 ' !&'$&"2

1,&> $ %&"

9##5 > !",& 9 ,"%#,2 ;A6"("8", 119&% !&#( > 2"< %%.'"2 ?.&9!0* (0 &(!",1,"! !&#(7 A#.92 ,"'.9!

%#>19"!"

2"(& 9

1",'#( %%.'"2 #$$"(%"'

'.%6 !6#'"

"( %!"2

* '! (2 ,2 %#('&2","2 !6","$#,"7 #("7 A6","

%#.,!

A#.92 9##5 > !",& 9

@,# 2 > ((",7 ," '#( @90 '""

A6"!6", %%.'"2E'

?.&9!

1,#8"2* +.2?>"(!'

%#.,!

6 8"7 !6","$#,"7 ">16 '&I"2 ' !&'$ %!&#( A6&%6 %#.,!'

"D1"%!"2 ,"%#,27 &*"*7 %%.'"2 ?.&9!07 1,&> $ %&"7 @ '"2

," '#( @9"

," 2&(?7 A6&%6 2#"'

% 99 >"!&%.9#.'

"D >&( !&#( > !",& 9'

%#99"%!"2 2.,&(?

&(8"'!&? !&#( ; '

6"92 (&#( (2& 8*

!! ( 9&5<* , (!

?,#.(2 .(2."

!,& 97 % ((#!

' &2 $"!!","2

%!7 ?&8"( &>1", !&8"

= A6&%6 119&% @9"

#$$"(%"'

!## ;,"$* / !"(2", (!&9 '.1, <* 8&(?

,"? ,2

!6"'"

$ %!#,'

%#.,!

#1&(&#( $ %!'

% '"7 11"99 (!

2"'",8"'

"(9 ,?"2 @ &9*G )* /&>&9 ,907

6"", + /6.59 E'

;'.1, < #1&("2 .(2", F* !

11" ,'

'#>"

#%%.1 (!'

J#(2 &!0E , &(%9.2&(?

, 8""( .,0 .(""!

.,0 '&(%"

,"9" '"2 @ &9* !

!,."

C. (!&!0 ,"%#8","2 %#>>",%& 9 ( !.,"

1,#8&'&#('

#,2&( ,&90 !!, %!"2* #A"8",7 @'"(%"

%,&>&( 9 $ %!

9 '!

!A#

6 9$ 0" ,'7 A"

' !&'$&"2 %#(2&!&#('

% ( 2&'1"('"2 '! ?"7 '# 0"!

%#>>"(%"

!6#.?6 %6 ,?"'

$, >"2*G * .,!6", ,"%"(!907

@& , 5 '6E'

;/.1, < 2" 9!

&''."

1,#9#(?"2 &(% ,%", !&#(* ,"9"8 (!

1#,!&#( +.2?>"(!

,"1,#2.%"2 @"9#A F=*

,"? ,2 !A&( %#(2&!&#('

%!7 9" ,("2 %#.('"9 ,"'1#(2"(! /! !"

2.90 6" ,2* 6.'7 '!

%#(2&!&#( '! (2'

%#>19&"2 A&!6* /# $ , (2 %#(2&!&#( ," $#,> !&#( #1&(&#( A6"!6", ," '#( @9"

?,#.(2'

@"9&"8"

?.&9!07 ' >"

$#,>"2 '! ?"

'1"(!

!6 ( !6,""

6 9$ %.'!#20* 1,#9#(?"2 &(% ,%", !&#(7 ?"(", 990 >&9&! !"'

? &('!

>#'!

1,"%&#.'

$.(2 >"(! 9 ,&?6!

?. , (!""2 ,!&%9"

#('!&!.!&#( '.%6

'&!. !&#(7 %#(2&!&#( 9 9&@",!0 >.'!

#8",,&2"

'! !.!#,0 ">@ ,?#

%," !"2 ;<;@<;&&< %!*G * 6","$#,"7 8&"A %#('&2",&(?

6&'

%9" ( $ %!

'&>&9 ,90 '&!. !"2 %# %%.'"2 "(9 ,?"2

##,2&( !"

"(%6 #.,!7 @ ,

A&99 119&% @9"

1,"'"(!

9&?6!

,!&%9"

#('!&!.!&#( (2& 9&?6!

+.2?>"(!'

(2& 2"'",8"'

%#(%"''&#( @ &9* * #('"C."(!907 1,"'"(!

1"!&!&#( 99#A"2 #,2","2 ,"9" '"2 $.,(&'6&(?

@#(2K'.,"!0 @#(2 ' !&'$ %!&#( #.,!K .!0 ?&'!, !"

%#(%",("27 &$ ,"C.&,"2 % '"* * #A"8",7 (0!6&(?

#@'",8"2 6","&( @#8"

'6 99 !," !"2 "D1,"''&#( #1&(&#( >",&!'

>" (!

1.,1#'"

2"%&'&#( 1,"'"(!

1"!&!&#(*

)**

;/ / < 6.>&5

* H6"!6", '1" 5&(?K," '#("2

"'K# * H6"!6", ,"1#,! @9"

"'K#