← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1874/2013dismissed

Joginder v. Sunita & ORS

2015-01-30Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri,Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta6 pages

 

       

 !"!#$ % &!#'( ))**  +(","

-.

-,#!

#' /("

 ")#'# "  

 

  

 ! 

-$ 0(0-1

/,(!

2'3

 #( "  

"  /!" */ "4#!*'45 6,'&.# '

') ""'45 /!3!*,'&7-#!(!3!"!#82 / (  9/(45  /  ) !#  !*'  45  /!.  (  ,"

'5    /  .!#( ,&/ (2# .*52 3! *!

"!##,29 "'!".!""' 

,  "/( *52  /  

"  # ""

(5  (  '6,'!

!#   

"# ((

' /(!#.

54# ! '/.

((!

&

9!

/(")#'# 9 ""*.#!:' ('!#& !#',(!

"

#'  (!

, *" 

 3!** &  ,.

5,#),(2 /"!*  #'  !"

 / (  / .

((!

&9 " #",..

' #', /"

!'9'* ;2 '

,&/ (2 .*52   3!  *!

"  !##,  9 "  4(# 

 3!** &  *    / .

((!

& ,*'# ),**#

(!.#!

*'!"), ""

'4 9#

#'  (")#'#     93(2  /  "

!'  .

((!

&  9 "

'!""*3'  45   ' (    '!3(   3!'  6,'&.# #'  ' (  '

  %-!#  /#2 #'(")#'# 9(*!3!#& ")

*5 ")#'# " ( "(")#'#  9/( "(")#'# !" /" #'/,"4 #'(")#'# 

")#'# " *#&9!

/"." !

**.# . /," #'( !4*5 ; 5 /.!#('

,&/ (/

4!#&

/( /.!#(9 /* 9,*&, # #'/ 3(5(!&/ (

!# /.!#(9 "/ 3!#&",! !#

!# .  (.  &(! ,* ,(    4(!#&  ,)  #'    ',

/  .!#( 9/( "(")#'# 9 "/ 3!#&#",( !# .0(3(2 (")#'# / ' #

'.

((!

&9!

/(")#'#  #'9 "

#  !# ' 4(!#&,) ',

/.!#(/

(<,"

'(")#'#  / #'3( /.!#(4,  #  ('!#&*52 !*' ) !#";!#& ,"

'5

/.!#(/"

!') !#9 "("!"

'45 "45!*!#&

9(!

#"

"!'"( !"!#&3 (!,")(*!.!# (546 !#"2!

"

)* ''

6,"

 ( /.

((!

&2(")#'# 9 "/ ""'

( ,('# '.

#''9(5 "/  (!.!# "

,#'(- !#"=>2?2%?( '9!

/- !#  /#'!

# '9 *"(&!"

(' #'/!" .!*5..4(" 93(2#*!#&"((545 2  .)(.!"9 "

/ (!.!# "9 "9!

/'( 9#45(")#'# /.

((!

9# #'(")#'# 9 "'!""*3'45 ' ( '!3( / /( 3(.# ".

'!# !#9('#!'

)( 5(('!".!""

* /"

.9 ".

' (. /)* '!#&" ) !"2 ( .' /**9!#&!"","$>  @/ /(  / #'!#&  3(  /  ,"

'5    .!#(

3!A!#,'B&!#'() !#(!"

 !# /9* (.!#(

 @/ /()("# ) !#!"# .

!#

!# 4*!#

/)("# (.C



*!

 #",))( /!" "2 (' @

#'('/!" !'

3!

D @B!#/!""

#'D .!#'-,.( -!#&/ @9/ *" #'('/!" !'

3!

D @B # / /( #'2(")#'# D .!#'/("* @ #'('/(

!'

3!

 D @B  #'  D .!#'  (")#'#    "  @  9/

#'('/!" !'

3!

D @B  / # ))( !

!#3!'# *'45 !"

' !''!"", /*'!#&

.!#( 3!A!##,!# // #'" "# 9* /.!#("",9 "' !''!# 3,(

/*'!#&

!#9 "# .

!#

!# 4* ('!#&*52

3!'  6,'&.#  '

'    '!".!""'  /  ) !#  # 2  )("# * % (#'  ,#"*  (   ",4.!

' 

4!#& /

/( /.!#(/ '3(5(!&/  * !. /.!#( #'/!" ))!# "&, #9 "6,"

!!'

") !

**59/# / '& (>.

((!' E (#' ,#"* ,( /(  ",4.!

' 

 9 "  / 3!#&  ",#'  !# # !

;&(,#' #'/ ,*')(3!'4

(, ,( /.!#( ?  (/ (!#&* (#' ,#"*( 29'#

!#' #5.(!

!# *  /)D,( !# #$%&'($)$)*(&+,-$..$  /(*(.01'!" ,""!#& /!"",(*

!#&  ,"

'5.!#( /!*'

  '/*' ",#'($> F

(.  43  !

 **9" 

#  ('(   '5.!#( /!*'(#!

/(,#'( /)(3!"!#"

 /  , #"  #'  @ ('"  2  =  (  !#', 0!#(!

5 #', #"/!) 2=%?!"(<,!(' 4 .

'45 /,(

!#& /!# #'9* (

/.!#( 4) .,# !.)(

#  !"#

((!&/ /!

/()

9,*'(<,!(

'6,'!

!#  9/!*  ' !'!#&  /!(  # *.#  '5  /  '"!(    /  /!*'  ,)*'  9!

/ 

!* 4!*!

5     #', !3  #'  ))()(!

#3!(#.# ()()(,)4(!#&!#& & /(9!

4!*!

5 #" / # (#')

;

/ /!*' (". /(*3 

("

3  4

;# !# 45 / ,( 9/!* ' !'!#& /!"", ,"

.!#(@/

.,"

4  .)/ "!:'  !" 

 9/!*  **   /(  

("  ,#',4 '*5 (*3 2  !

 !"  /  '"!(2  !# 9* /.!#(9/! /!" / (, !

#',* !.

#"!'(

!# 

 .,"

 &,!'  /  '

(.!#

!# (<,!(' 4.

'45 /,( G  /('( ,"

'5.!#(!"(<,!(' 4.

'45 ,(

!#& /!# #'9* /.!#( 4) .,#

!.)(

#   !"# /4

((!&/ /!

/()

9,*'

(<,!( '6,'!

!#9/!*' !'!#& /!(# *.#  ,"

'5 / '"!(  / /!*' ,)*' 9!

!* 4!*!

5   #', !3

))()(!

#3!(#.# ()()(,)4(!#&!#& & /(9!

4!*!

2

#" / # (#')

; / /!*' (".

/(*3 

("

/ 3 4

;#!# 45 / ,( 9/!* ' !'!#& /!"", ,"

.!#(@/

.,"

4.)/ "!:'!"

9/!* ** /(

(" (,#',4 '*5(*3 2!

!" /'"!(2 !# #'  9* (    /  .!#(  9/! /  !"  /  (, !

*  #'  ,* !.

#"!'(

!#

.,"

&,!' /'

(.!#

!#(<,!(' 4.

'45

/,(  = #  /  )("# "2  '.!

'*52  (")#'# 9(*!3!#&")

*5 /5/ 3& '!3( '/ .!#(9 "*!3!#&9!

//(. /("!# 4!( #'9 ""

,'5!#&!#= ""/(")#'# "/ ')* '#( ('  )5 !'

3!

'

 ?%4( !#9/! /!

" * (*5.# !#'

9,*'#  * !. /.!#((.(")#'#

 !**"/

!#" &5 ("  (.

6(!

52"/9,*'*!3 9!

9/9,*'4 ( ** /D)#""/ &

'!3( (.(")#'# !# /5 (% #'!*' !#!#

/5 (9!

/, #5( "# 4, /.!#(/ /.!#(9 *( '5"

*'3!' !'

3!

'

' ?% /.!#(4!#&.

*9 ""

!# // #'"/(. /(9/!" *"

) 4*()(3!'!#&&'',

!# #')(

!# /(/(!"# 6,"

!!

!# '!")* /(!&/ /. /(2

29/# /.!#( !"!#/( ,"

'52

;!#&',

!# /(!"#)( #5 (,*

/(45 /. /(# /

#' !( ,."

# "

"2 /*'

/.!#(!# // #'"

"# /9* /.!#(/* (#' ,#"*(

/ "# 4# 4* '!")* /!#'!#&"( (''45

9/! / (4 "'# ))( !

!#3!'# )(', '#

1 ( ('@'# !#' #5( "# '!(9!

/!#'!#&"( (''45

  #3!9 43 /!#'!#&"( (''45 ,( 2#&(,#'!".

', (/ #'!#&3( /.!#(

  ('!#&*52 *4!#&'3!' #5.(!

!"

/(45'!".!""' / 

0 3# $,4$'%" 2 / ! 0 &4"

3#