Sobh Nath v. The Central Administrative Tribunal And Others

 
    
 

 !"

#$% &%'()(*+,-(. /0

 12#$2 
 3


 
         
!+


 

 



 -%)%*$+ 2-(#4*()25,$#0&3'#$%0 -$2%,%$($(*%-
  

 

             

   

  

 

 

   -#."+ 2%,%$($(*%-#))#(.)$2%-&%-&#$%& 

6,#))%&17$2%
%*$-#.&8(*()$-#$(3%-(15*#.0
2#*&(9#-2 %*'20
2#*&(9#-2(*)2-$ $2%-(15*#."03(&%:2('22()-(9(*#.,,.('#$(*"0'2#..%*9(*9$2% )%.%'$(*#*&'*)%;5%*$(#. #,,(*$8%*$ -%),*&%*$)6#*&#) 5*(-*9(*%%-<17:#7 ,-8$(* -8$2%,)$ !($$%-#9#(*)$ !;5$#02#)1%%*&()8())%& 2%-(15*#.2#)&()8())%&$2%*$:'5*$)0*#8%.70 1%(*91#--%&17.(8($#$(*#*&$2#$$2%,%$($(*%-2#3(*9,#-$('(,#$%&(*$2% %=#8(*#$(*0'#**$1%,%-8($$%&$'2#..%*9%$2%)%.%'$(*#)#.)$2% '-($%-(#*$2%,.%#$2#$$2%;5%)$(*,#,%-(*$2%:-($$%*%=#8(*#$(*:#) 5$ )7..#15)-$2%#))%))8%*$2#)1%%*:-*9.78#&% %2#3%2%#-&>%#-*%&
5*)%. -$2%,%$($(*%-#*&9*% $2-592$2%-%'-&

$(),(*$%&5$$2#$%#-.(%-#.)$2%,%$($(*%-2#& (.%& 1%#-(*9  

?  

  '2#..%*9(*9  $2% )#8% )%.%'$(*  :2('2  2% :($2&-%::($2.(1%-$7$ (.%# -%)2:($21%$$%-,#-$('5.#-)2%)#(& :#),%-8($$%&$1%:($2&-#:*:($25$#*714%'$(* -8$2%)(&%

'5*)%. -$2%

('(#.-%),*&%*$)#*&.(1%-$7:#)9-#*$%&$$2%,%$($(*%- $ (.%# -%)2 2%-%# $%-0  #  -%)2   :#)  (.%&  :2('2  $2%  -(15*#.  2#) &()8())%&*$2%,.%# .(8($#$(*)-%9#-&)$2%8%-($)0($()'*$%*&%& $2#$  $2%  #**5#.  '* (&%*$(#.  -%,-$)  
)"  2#3%  *$  1%%*  '--%'$.7 %3#.5#$%&#*&&5%8#-@)2#3%*$1%%*#:#-&%& #3(*92%#-&.%#-*%&
5*)%. -$2%,%$($(*%-#*&# $%-9(*9 $2-592$2%-%'-&0:%#-%)#$() (%&$2#$$2%-(15*#.2#)-(92$.7**<)5($%& $2%,%$($(*%-*1$2$2%'5*$) $()#,,#-%*$ -8$2%,-%3(5)-&%-&#$%&6 

 ,#))%& 17$2%-(15*#.(*

? 

$2#$$2%,%$($(*%-&(&*$ (8,.%#&$2%)%.%'$%&'#*&(&#$%)#),#-$7-%),*&%*$)#*&#))5'20*() &%%8%&$2#3%1%%* (.%&#9#(*)$-%),*&%*$)6#*&(8(.#-.70$2%  :#)  &()8())%&  #)  :($2&-#:*  :($2  .(1%-$7  $  (.%  #  -%)2  *%  * 6 

 0  :2%-%#)  $2%  )%'*&   ()  )#(&  $  2#3%  1%%*  (.%&  17  $2% ,%$($(*%-*-# $%-)$5.70

 #,,.('#$(* -'*&*#$(* &%.#7 :#)#&8($$%&.7 (.%&172(82%,%$($(*%-2#) #(.%&$%=,.#(*#)$2:

)%'*&0 (.%&(*5.7

 0:#):($2(*.(8($#$(* (8(.#-.70$2%,%$($(*%-'#**$1%,%-8($$%&$'2#..%*9%$2% )%.%'$(*8%-%.7*$2%1#)() 
) 2%:-($$%*$%)$:#)2%.&#*& 3%-#..8%-($:#),-%,#-%&* $2%1#)() ,%- -8#*'%(*$2%:-($$%*

%=#8(*#$(*0)%-3('%-%'-&#*&,%- -8#*'%(*$2%(*$%-3(%: *'%$2% 8#-@) #..$2%-%.%3#*$ #'$-)#-%'.511%&$9%$2%-0-%),*&%*$)6#*& #-%#&8($$%&.72(92%-(*-#*@$2#*$2%,%$($(*%- *3(%: $2%#13%0*'#)%$(*$%- %-%:($2$2%(8,59*%& -&%-()8#&%5$

()8())%&