High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/97/2012allowed

Satyawan v. Rekha

2016-05-30Bench- 4,Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal7 pages

"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 #,

00#..3+$3$4353+61.#(30#$1$1-+'+(#%#7$1-+-6$"# 1+('3%%13)#7$899,##:1+)3(#7%##-6(1;-%7#/4(1,,-.'$1-+-6"1, *3%%13)#51$""1,516# #:"3-+$"#)%-'+(-67%'#.$4 "#,31(0#$1$1-+ 53,(1,*1,,#(/4.#3%+#(1,$%17$'()#1+( 00#..3+$3$4353+"3, 7"3..#+)#(/4534-60%#,#+$300#3.$"#(1,*1,,3.-6$"#0#$1$1-+61.#(/4 "1*'+(#%#7$1-+-6$"#1+('3%%13)#37$

#3%+#( 7-'+,#. 300#3%1+) 6-% $"# %#,0-+(#+$ %#0-%$#( +- 1+,$%'7$1-+,3+($"#%#6-%#$"#%#,0-+(#+$53,0%-7##(#(3)31+,$#<03%$#

"# *3%%13)# -6 $"# 300#..3+$ 51$" $"# %#,0-+(#+$ 53, ,-.#*+1=#(-+ 83$1,3%377-%(1+)$-1+('%1$#,3+(7#%#*-+1#,

-$"-6$"#*.1;#($-)#$"#%3,"',/3+(3+(516#3+(37"1.(53,/-%+-'$-6 $"#5#(.-7:-+

$ 53, 3..#)#( /4 $"# 300#..3+$ $"3$ -+ 8 $"#

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

#)3$1-+, -6 (#*3+( -6 (-5%4 3+( 7%'#.$4 + $"# )'1,# -6 7-*0%-*1,#$"#300#..3+$3+("1,63*1.4*#*/#%,5#%#73..#(/4$"# %#,0-+(#+$3+("#%63*1.4*#*/#%,$-1,3%5"#%#$"#45#%#1+,'.$#(3+( )1;#+/#3$1+), "#63$"#%-6$"#300#..3+$,'66#%#($"%##6%37$'%#,1+"1, .#) "#%#6-%#"#.-()#(37%1*1+3.73,#3,3)31+,$$"#63*1.4-6$"# %#,0-+(#+$ 5"17" 53, %#)1,$#%#( 3, - (3$#( '+(#% #7$1-+, 9 >?

..#)1+) $"3$ $"# %#,0-+(#+$,3+("#%63*1.4*#*/#%,7-**1$$#(7%'#.$43+($"#%#,0-+(#+$ .#6$$"#*3$%1*-+13.7-*03+4-6$"#300#..3+$0#%*3+#+$.451$"-'$3+4 %#3,-+3/.#73',#-%#<7',#$"#300#..3+$"3,,-')"$6-%(1;-%7#

"#%#,0-+(#+$7-+$#+(#(1+"#%5%1$$#+,$3$#*#+$$"3$$"# 300#..3+$3+("1,63*1.4*#*/#%,',#($-"3%3,,3+(3/',#"#%3,3%#,'.$-6 5"17","#61.#(37-*0.31+$'+(#%#7$1-+>8@ 5"17"1,0#+(1+)

3(&'(173$1-+3)31+,$"1* "#4(#*3+(#((-5%41+$"#6-%*-673,"

"#4 3.,- 1+,'.$#( "#% 3+( 73',#( 1+&'%1#, $- "#% 63*1.4 *#*/#%, -+ $"#1% 1+$#%;#+$1-+$"%-')"03+7"343$ +8 $"#63*1.4*#*/#%,-6$"# 300#..3+$)3;#,#;#%#/#3$1+),$-"#%6-%71+)"#% $-7-+$37$"#%03%#+$,

"#%#,0-+(#+$1,%#3(4$-&-1+$"#*3$%1*-+13.7-*03+4-6$"#300#..3+$

"#0%34#(6-%(1,*1,,3.-6$"#0#$1$1-+

"#$%13. -'%$"3;1+)3(;#%$#($-$"##+$1%##;1(#+7#-+%#7-%( 73*#$-$"#7-+7.',1-+$"3$-+377-'+$-6$"#63.,#3.3%*-6(#*3+(-6 (-5%4*3(#/4$"#%#,0-+(#+$$"#%#53,3+3$$37:.3'+7"#(/4$"#63*1.4 *#*/#%,-6$"#%#,0-+(#+$1+5"17"$"#300#..3+$A,63$"#%,',$31+#(1+&'%4 5"17"%#,'.$#(1+%#)1,$%3$1-+-637%1*1+3.73,#'+(#%#7$1-+9 >?>@>83+(9

"#$%13. -'%$3.,-6-'+($"3$$"#%#53,+- $%'$" 1+ $"# 3..#)3$1-+ %#)3%(1+) (#*3+( -6 (-5%4 .#;#..#( /4 $"# %#,0-+(#+$3)31+,$$"#300#..3+$3+("1,63*1.4*#*/#%,

"#$%13. -'%$"3;1+)6-'+($"3$('#$-,$%31+#(%#.3$1-+,"10-6 $"#03%$1#,$"#300#..3+$3+($"#%#,0-+(#+$7-'.(+-$.#3(*3$%1*-+13..16# "#.($"3$/-$"$"#03%$1#,"3(+-1+$#+$1-+$-#+($"#1%*3$%1*-+13.%#.3$1-+, 51$"#37"-$"#%0#%*3+#+$.4 "#*3%%13)#3.,-"3(+-$/%-:#+(-5+ 1$"

$"#3/-;#-/,#%;3$1-+,$"#$%13. -'%$7"-,#$-(1,*1,,$"#0#$1$1-+61.#(/4 $"#300#..3+$

#3%+#( 7-'+,#. 300#3%1+) 6-% $"# 300#..3+$ ;#"#*#+$.4 ,'/*1$$#($"3$363.,#73,#'+(#%#7$1-+>8@ 53,.-()#(/4$"# %#,0-+(#+$ 3)31+,$ $"# 300#..3+$ 3+( "1, 63*1.4 *#*/#%, 5"17" "3, 7'.*1+3$#(1+37B'1$$3.

"#;#%4637$$"3$363.,#73,#"3(/##+.-()#(

> 3)31+,$ $"# 300#..3+$ 3+( 63*1.4 *#*/#%, 5-'.( (#*-+,$%3$# $"3$ $"# %#,0-+(#+$ "3(/#"3;#(7%'#..4 #3.,-0.37#(-+%#7-%($"#%#0-%$ ,'/*1$$#(/4$"#$3$1-+-',# 6617#%-.17#$3$1-+1+(-+> 9 '+(#%#7$1-+ %

-+$"#/3,1,-6$"#7-*0.31+$.-()#(/4$"# 300#..3+$ "#$3$1-+-',# 6617#%1+"1,%#0-%$"3,7-+7.'(#($"3$$"# %#,0-+(#+$"3,7-+$%37$#(,#7-+(*3%%13)#51$"-+#',"1.C3.33+("3, ,$3%$#(.1;1+)"3001.451$""1* "#%#6-%#1$1,"1,,'/*1,,1-+$"3$$"# -/,#%;3$1-+*3(#/4$"#$%13. -'%$$"3$/-$"$"#03%$1#,3%#.-+)1+)$-&-1+ $-)#$"#%3,"',/3+(3+(516#3+($"#*3%%13)#"3(+-$/%-:#+(-5+3%# 7-*0.#$#.47-'+$#%/3.3+7#(/4$"#,'/,#B'#+$#;#+$,

"#%#1,+-(1,0'$#$-$"#637$$"3$63$"#%-6$"#300#..3+$"3, .-()#( - (3$#( 3$-.17#$3$1-+ 1$41,3%3)31+,$$"# 63*1.4*#*/#%,-6$"#%#,0-+(#+$'+(#%#7$1-+9>?>@>8 3+(9 "-')"$"#,31(73,#1,0#+(1+)(1,0-,3.$"#-77'%%#+7#53, '+3*/1)'-',.43(*1$$#(/4$"#63$"#%-6$"#%#,0-+(#+$('%1+)$"#7-'%,# -6#;1(#+7# "# D< E(#*-+,$%3$#,$"3$$"#63$"#%-6$"#300#..3+$ "3(,',$31+#(1+&'%1#,3+($"#%#6-%#"#"3($-$3:#$%#3$*#+$1+$"#"-,01$3.

"#$%13. -'%$"3,1+637$6-'+($"3$$"#%#53,+-(#*3+(-6 (-5%43,3..#)#(/4$"#%#,0-+(#+$3+("1,63*1.4*#*/#%, "#3/-;# -/,#%;3$1-+1,,$%#+)$"#+#(3+(6-%$161#(/4$"#37B'1$$3.-6$"#300#..3+$ 3+("1,63*1.4*#*/#%,1+$"#7%1*1+3.73,#.3'+7"#(/4$"#%#,0-+(#+$3, 3)31+,$$"#300#..3+$3+("1,63*1.4*#*/#%,'+(#%#7$1-+>8@> 83+(9 F>

"#7-04-6$"#&'()#*#+$0.37#(-+%#7-%(/4 $"#300#..3+$(#*-+,$%3$#,$"3$$"#300#..3+$3+("1,63*1.4*#*/#%,5#%#

9 37B'1$$#(-6$"#3/-;#7"3%)#, +637$$"#$%13. -'%$1+$"#3/-;#7%1*1+3.

73,#6-'+($"3$$"#%#53,+-*3$#%13.$-#,$3/.1,"$"#7"3%)#,6%3*#(3, 3)31+,$$"#300#..3+$3+("1,63*1.4*#*/#%,

$1,35#..,#$$.#(0%-0-,1$1-+-6.35$"3$.3'+7"1+)-663.,# 7%1*1+3.73,#/43,0-',#3)31+,$$"#-$"#%,0-',#5-'.((#61+1$#.43*-'+$ $-7%'#.$4 +

;, DE

1;1.E$"# -+A/.#'0%#*# -'%$"3,"#.(3,6-..-5,

# $

% !

& ( (

) !(" ( (

( ( "

%" !(" "

! &

,$$ - ./001

!(" "

3 $

! &

"" &

# $

(

! &

# $

3 $ (

2 "

! &

# $

( (

( 4 !(" "

3 $

& ! &

(

" & %

!(" "

" '

!!( "

(

! & "

! &

" & 2

& G

"#300#..3+$3.,-0.37#(-+%#7-%($"#%#0-%$,'/*1$$#(/4$"# $3$1-+-',# 6617#%1+(-+> 9'+(#%#7$1-+ %

/3,#( -+$"#7-*0.31+$.-()#(/4$"#300#..3+$$"3$$"#%#,0-+(#+$"3,*3%%1#( -+#',"1.C3.3,-+-63<*3+3,,3+("3,,$3%$#(.1;1+)"3001.451$" "1* +$"#3/,#+7#-63+4%#/'$$3.$-,'7"3*3$#%13.0%-('7#(/4$"# 300#..3+$$"# -'%$"3,+--$"#%-0$1-+#<7#0$%#.41+)'0-+,'7"3*3$#%13. 0%-('7#(/#6-%#1$ +$"#637#-6$"#%#0-%$,'/*1$$#(/4$"#$3$1-+-',#

6617#%1+(1$7-'.(/#,36#.47-+7.'(#($"3$$"#%#,0-+(#+$"3,*3%%1#( -+#',"1.3+(,$3%$#(.1;1+)"3001.451$""1* -+$%37$1+),#7-+(*3%%13)# ('%1+)$"#,'/,1,$#+7#-661%,$*3%%13)#5-'.(3.,-3*-'+$$-7%'#.$4

+$"#3/-;#637$,3+(71%7'*,$3+7#,5#3%#-6$"#7-+,1(#%#( ;1#5$"3$$"#300#..3+$"3,#,$3/.1,"#($"3$$"#%#,0-+(#+$1,)'1.$4-6 7%'#.$43+(3,3%#,'.$-65"17"$"#300#..3+$1,#+$1$.#($-)#$3(#7%##-6 (1;-%7# "#%#6-%#,#$$1+)3,1(#$"#1*0')+#(&'()#*#+$03,,#(/4$"# $%13. -'%$$"#*3%%13)#/#$5##+$"#300#..3+$3+($"#%#,0-+(#+$,$3+(, (1,,-.;#(/4)%3+$1+)3(#7%##-6(1;-%7# >

-+,#B'#+$.4$"#300#3.1,3..-5#( #7%##,"##$/#0%#03%#( 377-%(1+).4 ! " # 34

! "

'.3$1 #