High Court of Punjab and HaryanaEP/12/2014dismissed

Ramesh Khatri Lamberdar v. Kavita Jain

2017-06-01Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj26 pages

#$%&! $&!&! &$$%!'! () $*+

,'- . / ,'- ( 01 //

!" #

!" $ %%%%%%%

&'(!$ $ !"

)*+), $ $

- !" $ )*+)-."

$ "

" "

/ $0 /1 )+)'2')3$ 4)( " "/$ " "

)*)'2')3 2

'2)22')3

$ 3+/$ "

$ 6$

" $ "

$ 7"

" $

(

""/ " "

: )3,.$# 3( 0 #

6 1 (1 $

$" $ ( ) ! "

&2$ $ !"

)*+) / " ;

,). 5 # $ < ,2.

0 / 5 # ,4. 6$$ "

,3.

" 5 6$$ " =) 3

" "$ / "

$ !" 2 2$'& &$3$ &

4$''&2$5$&!&! $42 ' &6$$

!#$ 7!&2&2$5$&!&!

!&''5 4$%5!$' '4$8)!4$

69 )#$,2-*2 5&$4 ) :

!;2)4& )#$'

4 $4'*.#. 4 ## &2$ '5 4$ %5!$' &2$ 5$&!&! 2 <$ & 6$$

&&$'&$ 69&2$5$&!&! $4)

$42!'7 '!;

&)4$&6$ &4)$%59&2$5$&!&! ,/$%&! =,>-&2$ %&-

)4&2$4 $

!&!

#'5 4$%59&2$5$&!&! !'

$!&2$4 &&$'&$ 69 &2$ 5$&!&! $4 )

$4 2!' 7

'!;

&)4$&6$&4)$%59&2$5$&!&! * 4&2$4$!'

4'$3$ & &233!''! $4 &2$%59!&'

<!& 3 !$$ "

$ $

;

&4,).$ $ !"

)*+) $$

$ $

" " $

( -

>6 )+4!

? =4' @

0 /- 90 42!0 $$ "

+ <

" 24

A 2'

-1

- " $

8#0BA

$ $

B C 5 $ " $

;

/ )2,.$0 # D6 1 (1 E !# $

;

/ )2,.$0 # D6 1 1 & # $ "

" * ! & +

$ 2&'*2')3 "

" )' ! )* 22$

" / $"

$ / )* 6"

2')+ )) <

"/$

* )'

24 23 2C2E$ + & "

A 2'

2 )2 $!&2$4 43 4

9 %)3$ &"4!;!

$?)4$'

'3$ &! !

5 >&2$5$&!&! *2 '6$$

!#$ 69&2$5$&!&! $47!&2&2$5$&!&!

!&''5 4$ %5!$' )4&2$4 4)32 ' #' &6$$ !#$ 7!&2 &2$5$&!&!

!&''5 4$%5!$'B

- 7"

)+')2')+

$ F$ 2+'22')+ 62+'22')+

$ - 7"

2+'42')+ 6 2+'42')+

$ 2*'32')+ ?

2*'32')+

" / " 7"

2''+2')+ 3 !

$ $

2&'32')+ ($

)*'+2')+ !$ $ 7"

$ $

" )2'&2')+ +

< " "

6 C )E "

)+)#$#

" ,$

(##. C !" $)*+) "

!" "

$ "

&)$ !" $

( 8= 4$'$ & &! 5$&!&! 'G,.!

; / / $ "

,.$ "

)''"

)') 0 # // " " / " $ /($ /$

$ $

" $

$$ $ G< ("

H " H

" I%%%%%J @,-<$49$#$%&! 5$&!&! '2 ##6$ %%35

!$ 69 '

9 %5!$' &2$4$ ' &2$4$ 4$ 4$'5

3$ &! !

&2$5$&!&! @AAAB*

$<$49')%2%59 '2 ## 6$ &&$'&$ 69 &2$ 5$&!&! $4 )

$4 2!' 7

'!;

&)4$&6$ &4)$%59&2$5$&!&! B E <

"/$

/ /

" $"

&),4.$ !" $)*+) & "

&4$ $ !" " $

( 8=> &$ &'5$&!&! G,.!

G ,.

" ""

$" "

K , .

$ $

$/"

$ $

" ""

" "$ " $" " "K , .

#$#

" )*'& ,+$)*'&.$

4<!

&2 &72$4$&2$5$&!&! $4 ##$;$'

9%44)5& %&!%$*&2$5$&!&! '2 ## #'6$ %%35

!$ 69

<!& !

&2$ 54$'%4!6$ 43 !

')554& &2$

##$;

&! ')%2%44)5&54 %&!%$

&2$5 4&!%)# 4'

&2$4$ ,- 9'%2$ )#$4

$?)4$&&2$5$&!&! '2 ## #' 6$'!;

69&2$5$&!&! $4

<$4!!$ !

&2$'

$4 '&2$5$&!&! B

* 9 $"

" /

/$$ $

" $

/ " F

)) "

&C $ !" $)*+)

( 8I= 4!

#$#$%&! 5$&!&! 'G,.2$!;2)4& '2 ## !'3!''

$#$%&! 5$&!&! 72!%2 $' & %35#97!&2&2$54<!'! ''$%&! =4'$%&! = 4'$%&! + G! $ 0 #

,.$"

*& ,.!/ $

0 #

/ # $ "$

,.$"

&'! ,.?

0 # " $

/ "

/ /

,.!/"

/ 0 # $ /$ $"" $

7" / "

/$ " " / / 0 #

GA $ ("

$ "

"" $ F$

$ 0 # "

,.2$!;2)4&3 9*)5 ')%2&$43' '&%'&'

&2$47!'$ '!&3 9 $$3!&* ##7&2$5 4&!%)# 4'

9%44)5&54 %&!%$ ##$;$ !

&2$5$&!&! &6$

4 35#!!$ !

')%23

$4 '3 9!

!&'

! 6$ $%$''

494$ ')4!

; !4

$$%&!<$ &4!

# &2$ 5$&!&! * 6)& '2 ## & ##7

3$ &&2$5$&!&! 72!%27!##2 <$&2$$$%& !

&4 )%!

; 5 4&!%)# 4' %44)5& 54 %&!%$ & 54$<!)'#9 ##$;$ !

&2$5$&!&! ,.9

" / $7 "

" $

" $ / /

0 # $ 7 $

/ $

/ " /$

" ,.5 /

F $ "

0 # $

B )2 <

" " $"

&)$ !" $)*+)"

$ / $"

&C,).$ $ !" )4 "

&C,+.

F " $

$ "

" / "

< "

" "

&C,+.$ !" )3 !

/ " $ $

22)22')3 $"

2&'32')+

5 /

=4 + C E & * )), " =2 . / / )+ = $

; "

$ "

$ ""

&C,+.$ !" $)*+) A $ " " " $

( 8= ,-90 # / " " /$

$ /"

" / " /$

$$"

/ $

$$" $ "

$ "

" /

B )C < C 2'$

"$" " $ / "

"" $ F / /

$ " $ )C $

" /

;

/ $

"$ " " / )E "

&C,+.

/ "

/ " /$

$$"

/ $

$$" $ "

$ $"

" "

)& $

< " $

6 C )E "

)+) ## 9 ,!-,<-,<!-,?-&,??!!!- $

$/"

$/ 9 $/" $"

! //$ +,FF .

$ / "

K+,FF. $

K+,FF

.$ "

$A (@A (@@$

K+,FF

. $

K+ ,FF F. $ ! $

" /

$ "

&C,+.$ !" $)*+) )* = " "

&C,+.$ !" $)*+)

" $

)2'&2')+ $

9 # ;

)2'&2')+ " $

( 8! $ /

$ "

" B 2'

" $

2) $ $

$ $ $

$ $

/ $ 7"

$ /

6 " $

)2'&2')+

" 9 $ "

9 $ " $

$$" ""

22 = F ; "

$ " $

" $

!" $"

23 !

$ $

2+ A " 4$

( 84 9 5 # $< $ = 5F ( / : )* 2')3 "

$ 5

# "

$ $ 0 / "

" $

2E'*2')39

$ 6$$ "

$ "

/9 =+ $

$ $$@

/ / 2E'*2')3 " "" $

/B 2C 9

/ " 3

" 4,. 4,$.

/ $

" "

" $ <

=3+ $ "

$ $

6 $

" $

$3+/

&)$ !" $)*+)A F

)'$

=*)4 * )'$

( * 9

" $ $ $

+ " $ $" = '&)'2')3 !

@ "

$ " $ +

" $

/$ + <

" " " $ <= ,< = .2&'*2')3$ " $ )' 9

$$ $

" $ " "/

29 "F ? =4'$ " "/ " $ # / " $ 4)( # "/ " / /$ $ # "/ 5

4)( # "/ *)'$

(

8* 9

# "

1 " $ @ 0 / 7 @

/ '2)'2')3 "" 89

/!"

)*&*B " " "

/ / 9

" $$ " $ 9 "/ $

/ F!F >+ )' 9 $ 5 ! 7

$ #

'3)'2')3 0 /$ "

7 " $ <

/""

/ +' "

$ " "/95 ! $ /

7 $ 1 " $ @ 0 / 9 " $ "

" F / +' M ! F " / "

/$ / / "

$ " 9 / 'E 6"

2')3 @

" $

$ "

<= " )+ / /"

@ " 6 /@"$ " "

/ <=

6 7

# 0

$ 5F !

" B 2E )4$

/ " )4$

( 8)4 9 0 /1 7/

/'&)'2')3

$ # /

= " $ " <

" " <

/""

/ " ;

( $ $"

9 " $ "

" F / 'C , F.# M! F "

/ "

/$ / / "

$ "

$ "9F

" $

" 6$$ "

"(EE !"

)*+)

$ 9< !" 2''+>0 / " !"

)2')3 $

" 5 6$$ "

$ F

/ 9 / 'E 6"

2')3 @

" $

$ "

<= " )+ / /"

@ " 6 /@"$ " "

/ <=

6 7

# 0

$ 5F !

" B 2& !

/ "

" "

/ $ $"

&C,+.$ !" $)*+) " / F

$ "

" 2* " /

/ </ $"

$$"

"/$

" " /

$ " 4' !; $/ "

" 4) <$

/ $ $"

$ " <

/ "

&) &4&C$ !" $)*+) "

E ))##

/ "

!" 0

$$"

$ $!" $ )*+) " / $

$ "

" /" 42 = <

&) &4&C$ !" $)*+) 6 C 2 3 )C 6 E ))##$ 7"

> $

44 (

" 7"

> $

( , .

F "

/ " $"

$ $

&4$ !" $)*+) "

/ ,

!$$ "

A 2+ *3(!$ # " $5

)*C), $ $

- $)*C)-. , .

" / $ "

&) &2&4$ !" $)*+) 7"

/$ # "

$ " /$ "

$ 3+/6 / "

$3+ /<$ 7"

> $

> /

3+/

" $ "

)*)'2')3

$3+/F

'4)22')3 $

> 7"

/ /$ # /

$3+/ ,.

" / 9 "

$ $"

&C,+.$ !" $)*+) , .

$ $

" ;

&),4.$ !" $)*+) "

/ " 0 " "/$

$6 # 9

"" /$$ "

" ,

"" / " !F A (@ A (@@ $ $"

&4$ !" $)*+) )2, .,".,"".$ # 3 1 ,+.$ 7 0 /0 # 43 <

(

/ /$ #

4+ < " $

" (

" $

" (

$ $"

&) $ !" $)*+)

&C,).$ $ !" ! $"

&4$ !" $ )*+)

;

" ""

" $

$" "

$ $

$ "

"" /$$ "

$ $

< ;

/ "

" "

"$ $"

&4$ !" $)*+) "

&C,+.$ !" $)*+)

" 9" F

9 "

" "

"$ $"

&4,2.$ !" $)*+)"

$ $

&C,).$ $ !" <$

" $"

)''$ !" $)*+) "

$ "

# $

' () *!)+ ,-

. /

!+&0% 1 2 . ( $% !()+

!+ $3 2 .

4 -

! 4E

" $

/""

" / / $"

&) ,4.

&4 "

)''$ !" $)*+)0

/ ;

!" $)*+) 4& $ " $

$ $ "

&) &4 )''$ !" $)*+) 4* "

)''$ !" $)*+) "

" $ " " "

( 84)

'4 $%# 4!

;$#$%&! &6$<!

GI,.

7" $ ("

,. $ 0 # $ G ,. $ " ;

;

" $

!" $L 9

)*C4,2'$)*C4.K

, . /"

" " /

" //

" $ " K , . /

/ 7" K

,. $ $ ""

/$$" G , . / "" " /

, . //"

"" $ " I / J

, . / " $ 7"

$/ " $/ "

, . //G"

" $ #

$ !" $/

0 #

$ " I,.J <$ $ 0 #

/ / $/"

"I%%%J 0 # $ G ,. ""

"" / " " "

" " " / " $ " K I%%%%%J , . "

$ " $ "

I%%%J " K ,.

" $ $ / "

I%%%J " $ " / $ 0 # /"

" B

3' $

( 8C 9 +

$ " $

/ 9 =+ $

$ $$

5 " <

0 / E <

0 /

$ $

$ "$ 2 $ < " "

/ >" * 9

" $ $ $

+ " $ $" = '&)'2')3 !

@ "

$ " $ +

" $

/$ + <

" " " $ <= ,< = .2&'*2')3$ " $

)' 9

$$ $

" $ " "/

29 "F ? =4'

$ " "/ " $ # / " $ 4)( # "/ " / /$ $ # "/ 5

4)( # "/ )2 9 + / " +'' + $ "

" "

/ '2)'2')39

" $$ " $/ , " .B 3) <

"" $F$ 0

$" $

32 <

$ "

)'',). # , .

/ " "

" / " // " $ " 9

"" $F $ 7"

" " $ " / $ "

< $ $ /

" $"

34 <"$ #5$

' 0!6!F #

;

$ "

" $

" , D

$ !"

)*+E. / " $$" $("

"$ $ !" ""

2'$ 7 $

( 2' ? $ $

;

/"/$

$ " /

/ ;

;

*3$ !" 90 #

B 33

F /# @"$ #

$ . 0!

$ ("

"$ $"

&),4.$ !" $)*+) 0 #

&C,).$ $ !" 3+ 0 # "$ &0% 1 2 . 0!

)2)4$

( 8)2 !$

$( ( - "

/ #

$ $"

&) ,4. "

&C,). / " " #

" $ ("

" ;

&),4. <" ""

" $ $ $ )4 9 "

&),4.&C,). "

/ 9 "/ ("

&),4.8 7 $/

B, .

*..% ' *')* "!4

B 3C

F / #

0! /0 " 0 # "$$3 2 . 4 -

0! 3E

" $

"" $"

$!F# "$ ,

7 8 )" "! **9/" $ " $

$$$ $$ " $$ $

" "$

/ )&$ "

( 8)& ; ; $

" $ "$ # &1

2 .6 )! **//"9 " / " )9

; $ $

$$ $6 C )+,3.$ #$ #

" )*'& $

$$ " "

" ;

&4,).$ $ !"

)*+)< " $ !"

)*+) $

1 .. , 12

" " /"

F 4'</ "

" /

" $$

$ "

" / " 9 " " / " $ " " $$ / "

;

$ !" "

" $ 9 $

$ $$

/ !"

" "

/" $$

B 3& 9 $

/ !

" " F

"" " 9 $$ $$ $

;

" / $

$$$ $$ $

= "

" $

$ 0 # "$12:

': ) /!* * %!9( $

$" $

" $"

6 E ))##" +' 0 " $

$" $

$ "

" " $ "

$ 7 / 0 #

$" $

+) !; $/ "

" / $ "

&),4.$ !" $)*+)"

$ $"

&C,).$ $ !" "" / ,/

- ) $*+

;

< = ><- ;

0 %= ><-