Anand Goel v. State Bank Of India & ORS.
!"#$
% & '
(((
)"
*+ , - ."
(((/
!"#$%& '()*+% ,%(-*!.
$ !"#$%& '()*+%
*!.% /*!0-/*.-'
" "
%"1
/2 $%1 ".0
"
/2
.3
'$%1 ""
"
%4
$%1 ""
"
) *.1$%1 ""
//1 7.
0
. 8
'0"#
9 ":! .
9 "" ;
<%
=!"(0
8#8 / 1"#%00''7"
8!
'$'.
" . ">./%7>$?."
. 8 .'..0
"$?. ?
" !
90!". "!"
90"
8 "./%7.
"
9. 8 ".0" 0"#
- =!
/ <<@ "5$ $5 <5
' *+- )
B'B,.0 / $ <C' 4 !"
93 ?
.0"4
&!"0#'*
9' *
9'#'/ $. "
3' $B!.
?
8#) 2#3!4"" " . "D.8 "" ?"E? 0!
0!8'
!
<
7. .
9. 8 " @ % . , - !
"
F "
( " 5 " . " D!
0!". "E ? '"
0!". " " !4 '
7.8 "" ?" "
82
''9
9..!
.'
< 0!8'
!
"1 8
-? ''9 ..' .8 '." ??#0"
"8
"?
= .!
".
1?
..!
0!". G'
' 4 .1 8"8!#"$?. ? "# 0!". .' "'
7.4"?
"8#./ 1"#
"/7(--. 9". .8
. "0'#9 1 8#.+ ,$.!
0!". " "0 " . !"%!
"$
? '!..!
.8 ! 0"/!'
% "
9'#$ '' 82
"' .0" !" !
?"
G ?1"$.
!"9"
9
" ' 8#.8 "" ?"? ,0 0
) ;$ . 8 "" ?" ? 9 1 4 " . 8"
98"8!#" "' 0
.4 !
?
#
. ?.
8
-? '"'#4
. .
. '
0
.4 !
?
.
0"
$.
82
? !'8
.
'? !'
"4
1 !" .!
0!". 7.8 "" ?"
9
"
.
-
$.
' ."00'
@ 82
;
5 ;
"4 ". #" .!
$ "
9
. !
9 8"
98!#" ";'
%'
9?
..
00'
$
1 8# *.
14%99"?'?
'
9 0!". .' ";
'
4 " "A <'
<C .
"4 #?" '
?
..00'
7./ 1"#
" '!..
.
5 8 "" ?"? 8
-? .. 82
?""
8#. 8 "" ?"?
. !0
4 !
'
9?
.
" 0 '# ":!
" "/!' . *.!' .- 47=%$ % 9
.
'
" ' $
" "'
"4 !
;' 4 "'0
4 ". #" . ?
. !0
!''4 !
.
" 0!". 4 # % "
9'#$1 "" ;./ 1"#
"
. 82
7.0!8'
!
"
"#
"4 %9
.
"" . / 1"#
"$ . 8 "" ?"$ . 9!" " .
90!". " *.
14 %99"?'
' ? 0" 00'
!
" *
5 . / 1"# 8 ! + ,
'-
!
%$
5 " . "D
5%E 7.8 / 1"# 7"
8!
' " . "D."
8!
'E
". 82
.8 "" ?"
90!". "
.00'
1 ""5 5 ."9" . 82
.8 "" ?""9"
9.. 9 !
" 4 ;
< $ ? 8 "1.. 4.8 "
# "" " ."'
"
;
.00 8*!
# " 0"
4
0!8'
#? 9 1 "9"
9.. 98
=
.
7."8 "
?"0" . 4 !
. "" ""
4 # -? !"." 8 "1../ 1"#
"
.9 1 00 "!
# .8 "" ?" ,
9.
4 8"
98!#" "'
0".
"?
# . ?.
8
8!. ' 40'#?
..
4 7." "$ ;
5 ;$
4 ". #" ".!
$.4
" " ;' $?.
.? "
9.'#"28#./ 1"#
"
A % "
9'#$ ""9!'"
#? .0" 0"#.8 0! ' "
9
91'!
.8 0"
0"0"1' 4",
?
. . ""$ . 8 "" ?" .
0!". "*.
14%99"?'0" ""? 0"00'
8 "./%7$ '.
!"
9. !"
.."
98 "./%7 ;
A$ !
'
".8 "" ?"? ,
..8"8!#"?. !'
".0" 0"1' " !
' ".8 "" ?"":! " ?,> 4$?.
.?
9" . =$.8 "" ?" ." *.
14%99"?'?" 0" 7.8 "" ?" ... 8 8' "" 9 #8"8!#"
7. ." *.
*.
14%99"?'$. !9. ..? "#
"C 4 " 5 A$. !
' ".8 "" ?" ...8"
8!#"$?. ? "# 0#' !0 "
.
" 0
'
4 !
A' ?
0"
4 7./%7 0.
":! -
$ "
.8
.
98!#"$.? " 0
A' ?
#
7.
98!#"
" !.
9 ? .0
G0
4 !
A' ?
../9
"" . /%7 % 0
9 1 !
0!". " 4..8 $?.
..
7.8 "" ?". ..? !'0# !4 <'
7.
4 !
?
4.8#.!
0!". 7." "$.8 "" ?"
" 0
'4 !
<$@( 7.
4 !
? '
4.8# !
' "
.!
0!". 7.8 "" ?"=0"
!"." . . 4 !
?.
.. !
' ".!
0!". ""
82
. .00' '
4
8' .0
". 4 #0"( 0
"9"
9 . 4 " 4 # 0"#" " ,
9 ? 1" .
< ":!
"4 0"(0
7.
82
"
A < 7. !
'
".8 "" ?"0"# " 4 4 1 00" 0"
00'
G ?1"$ 4 ". ."."
1 4 . 82
8
9"
$ ''
!"." 4? !9. 4 1 !. 00'
5 <$?.
.?
'' ? !82 0#4 $ ? 8 "1.
. 8 "" ?" ' 4 1.00'
?
?,$.00'? !'8 ." 4"
7. !9.. ?"0 8! 00'
"9"
9? 1"
.0"(0
? .18 4 1 % "
9'#.B %00'' 7"
8!
'.'..00'? '
8' 8
4
8'
G ?1"$ . '
9 . 00' 8 4
8'$ . '"
/%7
".
! 4"
?''
-? .. 8 "" ?".8 9 1 !9. 00 "!
# 8"
98"8!#"8!. 8" !9.8!#" " !4$?.
.? 4!.'
. ?... 8 ". 7"
8!
-? .'..8 "" ?".8 8'
.00'
0"
4"
'#8#4
'
9.7"
8!
'8#
" !
9# ."0"
$?. ?
8 " #F "8' ?
7.8 "" ?" !' .1 #2!
" ! " 9" 8!#".00'' 9 /'
? 0'
G >8'.*!0"4 !"
12
34 /
%
"9" .0
"$ ? .'..8
9 ?'#
" !0"
.
"
9. 8 ".0" 0"# F!".".8!#".1
9"'
" 8 ". /%7... 8 8' "" 9.8"8!#"$ !' 80"4
" ! 0"
" ."
98!#"
- #0"
. #
" 8!#.0" 0"#. . . !'.10" 0
.!
%
0"
?. ?
" !
98!#" !' ' 4 #
"
. 0" 0"#$?.
.? '
=!
/ 1"#"
.!
$.
98!#" !' .1
' # 82
8 "./ 1"#
"
H1 00'
'8# !.
98!#"!
"*
5 .
5%
!8 :! 00'8 "./%7? 4
8' +!,
9 . ..!
0!". " "9"
9 0" 0
.
"( 8
9.=0"
.
?
''
0#. !4 <' $ ? ".. !' "
' " 4.
44 4 .?
"
9'# " 0
.8' 4 !
?
..+ , '
9?.
.$ .+ ,? !'8 ' " 1".4 !
" 4.
4
" ?
'?
B"
!
' ".0
". "9!..0
"?
" ! 8!#" 0". "
./%7 '
. . ?.
..0
A'
.4 . 148"$A ) ""
5 A./%791 0
.!
0!". " 4.. . ? 2 !"
"
A 8' !
' "!
0!". " ,
"!
A$ !
' ".!
0!". 91.
4..8 9 1 8#.0
5 <$. 0
"? "# 4,0#4 <' 8!.!
0!". " ' 4.. 4 A <$.0
"91
" < <'
-?
.
9..!
0!". ""
82
..00'
?" 4
8' !
0"(0
.1
9 8 4 -
"
9'# "9!. .0
"? '' ? 8 8#./%7 .!
0!". "
''# "
# 82
." $. . !'8, .1
? 1 .
"
9. 82 .
" .0
?$ " .1
''#0"4 .
4 8 $? ./%72!
. '
9..0
8
9 ?'#
" !0"
. "
9. 8 ".0" 0"#
B"
!
' ".!
0!". " . .". "9! ..0
". ' !
.'' 9. "" /%70
.00'
'8#8 "" ?"
G? '#
90!". "
" !8# .8 "" ?".00'' 98 "./%7 ? 1"0"# # 0"
."8 "./ 1"#
" "8 ". 7"
8!
' "1
8 "./%7 +#4"0" 0
.0"
4,
9
. 9 #1 "
9. G !".""9!..0" 0"#
:!
". ?
.
0 .!
0!". " ".' 4 ". ;#"
.
"4
.!
.
1 !" A ;
-. 8 4!
.
1 !"
."1 !" "
G
"9!'"'#0#
90" 0"#= ."
= . !
0' "0 "
. 4 40" 14 ."
8#
0
9
"8'4 !
7.0" 0"#.8 '
.#" $.
'.
# A ;$. 4
8
.4" ,
9 .
"0"
$?. ? 1 0"# .0"
G"9! ..B /%7. 0
''# 8 "1..8 "" ?". 4
'. 7"
8!
' !"9 . . . 8" 8!#" ?. . '
"( 8
/9"
9 .
0" 0
"( 8
9 "
9 # 82
"'
"$ '"
!
' ..!
0!". ".1
98 !9.. 0" 0"#
" 4 !
' .1
9
!""
"8' =0 !"
4,
9 40" 14 .1
9 8'
..
8!
."
?.".
!"" '#"!
9.
"# !' .1
" 0"?
..
;
.0" 0"#
:!
.!
. 0
8! 4.8
!84 8#.0
G . ""# .
"
. 0
"$.!
0!". ".4.''.
8 8 ""
9 82
. "
4 .00'
G'
"9!..?"
0
'8# .8 "" ?"9
. 40!9 "" ./%7.'"#8
8#.
!"1 2!94 <
'
>) 2#3!4")
*+ , - ."
> 7.0
"$?. ?
" !8#.8 "" ?".00'' 98 "./%7 !' ' #8""
9.. .8 "" ?" .
0
'
'
8' 8
'"'#
G"'"
!
' ".0" 0"!
." " "
.1 ?.."
4"
.0
>8'.*!0"4 !".
". "!4
?.
.
!
' 8
1"
- $G >8'*!0"4 !".'.
"4 '
8
4"'#8!
48 #
.
9."
4 !
!8 :! '# -? .'. '
"48#.!. "
#$ "
"
9. "!
1 !" .!
(0!". "$ . "
9.
8 =
9!
.=0
=0
' !. "! 7."'1 8 "1
.*!0"4 !"" !
"
!
! "
! ! # $! !%&! % &' %&'! ( # ) ! !
*
+ & , ! ,
-'
,! ! ) ! , $! ! ! ! . . .
-&
! -'
/
''- 0 " ""9!'"
#
.!
. 8 0
!8#.B !
'
".0
" ''.F "!4 8' ?.1 '!..!
!
" "
0" 4
7. 0
" . 8 ?'#
" !
98!#"8#.8 "" ?"8 "./%7 + ".$
.
"
00'
8 "./ 1"#
"$.8 "" ?" .
" 0" !8"8!#" "' $8! 4 # 00 "!
4, 9 .
G. 4 1 ."00'
4 ". #" ". !
8"
98!#"*.
14%99"?' ";' 8!0
'#<C
.
"4 !
?
..00'
7./ 1"#
" '!. .
?" 8
. 82
7. 7"
8!
.00'
.8 "" ?" *.
14%99"?'
+ "./%7 .8 "" ?"
''# '#4 ... 8 8' "" 9 8"8!#"
+!$'".
" !. ." *.
14%99"?'?.
" C4 ". ;' '''".0
"?.
8 <'
4.8#.!
0!". "
"( 8
%. 9.!
0!". " 82 .1"#4
8 '
# .00'?
. !4,
9. 4 "# 0"(0
7. !9. . /%7 .' . . 00' ? 4
8' "? .":!
0"(0
$#./%7
".
! 4"
1 . 40!9 ""
.00' .8 "" ?"
-? .'..8 "" ?" !'
" ! ?8!#".00''
9 ...
.00'0"
4"
'#8#4
'
9.7"
8!
" !
90"
?. ? 8 " # . "8' ?
/9"
9. 0
" ? .'.8
9 ?'#
" !
90!". "..
"
9. 8 ".0" 0"#
7.?"
0
'8#.8 "" ?". '"#8
8#
!"
) 2#3!4"> !0" 7.0
"
' 4 #8""
9.. .8 "" ?" .
0
.!
'
'
8' 8
". 4"
F!"."$? !''#9"?
..
.B !
' ". !
0!". ".4"'#8!
.0
"? 0"4 8 8#. /%7 ?.
..!
0!". " 44 '# 828!.
4.. 4$? !' ' ..
4?
. #'9'"
9. 7./%7. .'
..8 "" ?".
.00'0"
4"
'#8#4
'
9.7"
8!
" !
90"
?. ? 8 " # . "8' ?
- #1 $.!
'?
"4 A ;
""9!'"
#"9"
9. 4. 8 8'
. -
8 !9. .
' " 9"
9.
9."8 9.#"
." "
G $.
0
2/54 2//4 !'
6
1
.." 0,
9@"
I @ .."/0 "8' I @