Sonika Jaidka And ANR v. Hakam Singh And ORS
!!"" #$% &
'& !(
)$ $'%$*+,-.(*
$,!!"" $/"'$0.(*
$$!( 11111
! "# $%! & 2,!!" "(%($ 3 ,/4 $( ("- 5(- "0,!!" $,$4(,!!",("- 5 (- "0,!!"(( !!"((!(
'( $%! & "0,6$(((7 5
!(82 97
:-$(8"42$:%"./%(, $,$.,2$:%"2,!!"6 "(:-,!!""
$,4 4!6$((,4%
(, ($ %4$ (;,%:( !!"". ,$
!!"" ( !!""(74$*,%"$ (,;!"
9
9
. ($ %4$ (;((6 ($*0,$(<(*%$8$:$0$0$)+=8 = "06,, 4"-6$%$0 $44$$/%(, :%9 !46,,-$,($/(,6"8,6;.$"" :$0$0$):= ='=53,$ $$ $$(,
(0$"":0($*$,"-.0"0"-(,0,!( :-($*$&;4 0,=$!(%(("-%$(6$( $0,(6,%0*0-(>0"6,,,(( :0($*$ ,<(*%$$!!"(:$;(4($0$% 4!*,(:%,$$%;0,$$!$ ,$""%4! ,( ($ %4$%( 4%"!" 0$*% ?%$ & ,( 6 :("- $%,( ( , %%4:(,?%$,!2,,$44:$0 , $ " %( ?%$ ( 6$ ; 88 &!" /%(, $ $4$!$7(( 9 9
%($
9 .9.5. 7=. 7 9 )86$0$(!" /(6",4 )$4(8,($ (; ,$
,(( 2, ((= ($ %4$ (; %$**( :- , 6(6.4$(%0,$.4,$( ,$6, "("4! *;0,!$*
,$#,".
55 $,$@, 55@ $4!0($*$.
6$(%$$ ,
(0$""$!(2,! 6""6(:-"$(2$:%"(4!,%
9.3.
>="06,$A B!$%4 $4,(
"0 ,"4!""$".,4%6!( 6,64, $4,( 6$(,$6,$: !(A B!$%4.66$(( "0( (,"4 "(,!!"
%:4 4( :- $ '%$* +,-. (* $!$0,!!""($/"'$0.(*$!$0 $!(,*:,$(($$(!$%( 7
(!%( , ($ %4$ (; %
$( 4%"!"$%(0$*%?%$(%$0,*,%"$( (%%4:(,?%$,!2, (0 ,"$( 2$:%",,(%$$((%$,(0"0($*0 ,
(0$"":-$!(,:,""0(:- ,$!($0$(,C%%4 4!."$( %" $,"4$0%(,,((64!"-( 0$6,> (;24:$ $. ,*?0$./%(,( 6$0 .7 .9 >=6,,"%(("$- .77.
>=!$ %42,4D$%$ ,(( $,-$
=
.
5=
.
9=
5<D)E>.<D)E>+.<D)E>8 6$($(*(:-,"46,,,6,"$-
((6 .77.
>=!$%4 8($0,4D$%$ ((."$( 2$:%"(,%"4 ,(( .9.
>=
(!!"(,4%"!"$ 5,4,0 ,(( 6 7-$,4 (&6*$((, 464( $4!%0, %%$!$! ,(( (4% .
>=6$((6$(" $%4(
%$"D!*$-"6$($.4%6 6$((,4$(%0,$ $" "*.$(0%( F($"",*",(,4!$C%$(: ,( 3 2,(,(;!"
9
(!$, 4D$%$!$0,-$
9=
5<D8E>+ , ((. "$( 2$:%" ( , %" 4 , (( .9.
>=6,,!!$!$
)*+, -. /,*+ 0+
)12 2-3, -. /,*+ %! &'
45,&@:" %!$48%$,:$*(%($ G .,8%$ ,*@%!$ %""-(( ""6,!$!", "$( !$ "( $" #$4@ %!$(4;!!":"","
4!"-((!$ D(60."$ ( ,,$, ,0$%! B"6-H6""",*$ $,0
,$ 6$(. , "
4!"-( $ !$ D(60..,((*4 6:"67 -$.,$4%:((
B , %" 4 (( 6,"
4!%0 %%$!$!("-,, %"4,%"(:4 $!-0,D.
-((,%"(: B,(( 6,00$%! 7 3 -$I
,.,0 ,((6; -$:-"$(2$:%",4$%"$4- !!"" = ;6(6 ,((",%0,,((6 4D!-:%(%46$,46!$(%( !$*,( :$, 4!$,,!
;.6(6 ,((.4(,$603-$ (,0 ,$(4,$ ,((75(7 -$ $!*"-2,!"(0 ,"4$0$(,0$ !!$"-*0%
,6(6 ,((63-$"( (!!"!$%(4(,$4"$%4, 0 ,$,%:(((6 7-$2,0 ,!$ 4%:4%,4$,((,!E,,0 , 6(663-$6"":%4(,,0 , ((6", -$6,,((,( !!"-0,$
)*+, -. /,*+6 +*+78
B ,4 ,((:(((6$( %%$ !$!,$ ,((.4"-.)$4(8,($ (; "46$0(!("-(6(!( ,4 ,(( ,4$"-,6(6.4$ (%0,$ ( 4,$ $ , (!( , (( ( $(0"- ,"(
>$(
,4:((%(6$(!$"("*0D!
,((2,0 ,((:0 -$,!!$!$ 4%"!"$6"":3 9 %$,$.,4% 3.
>=6$((6$("
$%46(6,(
.
>=(, %$"
D!$",( 3.
>=%$,$4% .
.
>=% " "*.$(0%(6$(( ,4$(%0,$"4 (4% 3 .
>= 6$(( $" "*(
,4,$"47 $(0"-.,4!"%"(%($
$ &( 8"%" %"4 .9.
>=
B 4:(((%%$ !$! .9.
J355
K .9 .7
>= >$( ,4:((%( 6$(!$"("*0D! 9
=
K9
7 84! $ !!"-0 4%"!"$ 3 9
13K9
3 / $%4 .
.
>=
/ "*. $ ( 0%( 4$(%0,$ .
.
>= 9 / "*(
4,$ 3 .
>= 5 %$"8,$0 3.
>= 2,,(4% 7
>=
=9.3.
:(!(:-, %$84!-6,64, $4, ( $! ,$ (!- ,?%(04. "06,,.
,4,""$$-$A93B!$%4 $4,( "0 , !!" "" $"L 2, ,( 4% ,"" : (:%$(,!!""="4,4$((,
?%(046"",4!%0(6$( $(0"-.,6$(((7 5
( 4( (,:*D(,!$!!"!$"-""6( $, .
9
: