High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/20/2013disposed of

Naveen Kumar v. Mahender Pal And ANR

2018-11-05Mr. Justice K.Kannan11 pages

!"#"$%&''(

$*+, ..

-#+# $2

#.$2

% -' 34"

"//52)!

- '

-'6 $4

)*2 $52)!

- #.$2 7$#+- $!

$ *+, -5 "$4+- 2 )"!

", "# "$

/ #

9"$3

$1 $!

!,.

"$"$- #.

"$4+-"

##+ 2:;1","$

-) 1"!/

2&''2+ - #1 $2$ 3/"3 2-")"$3

--+!9:

-"$3- 3"#

"$$' (*<&'

-!!"2 / ",#-":+$ /56"-# )"2 -22

('>' 1 # 1 /2 !/ "

2 !,.

#'?5(>57'1

"$ #:

$!,.+

2:;

-":+$ / # //=#% 6-''

,+$ -2 2"!

/:"//#7

#'5<>5><@7

"$#+ -"$37,

/ 3$;

#'&57 A## "$!, -#"B,$ 1#

#'?57 ?

2"# ;

#'5@57

#'?5((5><@7

+$2 2 :;-":+$

#'?5(>57 +$# / - #!$

-2 -":+$ /"#3-##/;"$ C+

"$# !92-.

"$4+-"

##+ /# 2"# =1"!11 2:

$2+/;

.-) 2$- !-2' "#+-3

"$ -2 2+$2

2#$ "!

21 "$ :) =+/2$

#+:#

//; $1 $!

#"2

"$3 "

-2 2!,.

"$+$2 22"

2#'

+$# / - !$

"$3 "$#+- $!

!,.

$; 1 #

!$ -;#+..-

-2.

-":+$ /'

, ;:

-":+$ /1 2- !-2

!" "! "$2"$3

$./ 2+ - #1 $2$ 3/"3

2-")"$3 $2"$37"$#+- 2) 1"!/ $2=1"!11 21"

, -!;!/

"$32-") $:; $2$ =1"!1"$4+-"

#1 :

$#+#

"$ 2'$#+- $!

$;1 #$ !1 $3 2#+!1 "$2"$3#

-":+$ / ##+!15 1"# #.

"$ 2 "$ /"

;' +- -,- 5

"$ = #1 /2 4"$ $2#

##+!15"

"# - #.$2 "$#+- $!

$;=1"!1=+/2:

"$3.

;1 "$'

.-"$!"./ # -2

-,"$

"$ !,.

"$"$ !

/2"# :/

B1 +# ") /;/ "22=$:;

B+- "$

1 - .

3- .1# -,#+!14+23

+$2 -%

! !

# $

&'()*+)*+,- (./

)-) $

0 )

# 2 !

# "

# 5

! #

$ # !

! #

## $

$ # '

5 # ! #

4 # 4 $

:2 $ ;$ #

&'()*+)*+,- (./

)<) $ $

$ !

# $ # # ;

$ $ $ $ $

$ ! $ $ # $ $ # #

! $

2 $ (

! > &

'!,??@ 2 $ 'A! B $

* 2 $ '

! $ $

? $

$ $ !

! $9 $

$ <@C $!

<@C $ $ $$ $

$!$#

$ $ $ 5 +C $

&'()*+)*+,- (./

)@)

:+C $! $ $ ,<+C :+C

+C 5 $ #

$ !

$ $

,++C ,+9

! !

! $$ $ $

3 ! # <@C $!

<@C

,,9 3 $

$ $

! $3 !

9# !

! $

&'()*+)*+,- (./

)) $! $ !

A $ # .- !

-":+$ /1

="# ; " "!

22+!

$2.-) 2$- !-2 "'

'B' $2B' =1"!1-

2"#

-"31 /",:7/ 3 $2D2"# ;"$)"#"$- #.

") /; $21 -2

# #' / 91 $2 #'@57 $ .

2"# ;-

2"$ !

" "!

B' $2B' ';

9"$3

,$ 1/;

-$"$3# 7"$4+- #'?575

#'?571 #:

-2 -2#/## "$!, ) .

-"2 #"B ,$ 1# $ $2 !$# C+

1#."

/"E

"$7- !+.

"$'

/ #'&57 1 # :

-2 -":+$ / - .

"$ $2#+ -"$3 /# 3$; $2+- 2:;

$ !$#"2 2)"

= 1"#+-

=+/2- C+"- - )"#"

$2-

2"$ /"31 2"!

+,/ "22=$ :; .

B+- "$

#+.- '

-":+$ /"$"

-22

2('>' $2=1"/ !,.+ "$3

"$ #, !1 $"!

//; -2 #+, #'57 -

!1.

2"# ;"'

' #'/ 91"$/"

+ &D2"#

2"$B' #'@57 -2#D2"# ;-

2"$B'

"#:;$== //#

"$ -2"$3!,.

,+/ "./"

12"#/3"!

//;#+$2 $2/ //;= //

:/"#1 2' 1

-":+$ /+31

2"# ;$

-$"$3!

; "$4+- 27!/

##"$3 /##

-$"$3!

;"$

-,# .

"$!, 5"

+31

C+ " "

2"$

-,# ,$ --")

+ +- /##

-$"$3:;

../;"$3 #

$2 -2,+/ "./"

12 ,./;

-,"$ /## .

$2 $!;'6+!1 #.

$!,./

/;) -/9 $2"3$- 2:;

-":+$ /'

",.

"$1 2:

$ "/ 2#

9"$3

+$ #'&/ 91'/ 7"$4+- 21

= #;

5= :/ :2"

$2= #.+-#+"$31"# +2"

#' = # +- --

/#+# "$2+/3 "$ 3-"!+/ +- =-9 $2 = #

-$"$3 #'?57 .

- ,$ 1' / 1 2 "/ 2 1"#

"2 )"

B' @72 .#"$3 "$

",, 2"

#- ,) ")"/#."

/56"-# :+ $ # -"+# $2 3-"

)+#"$4+-"

##+ 251 2:

-- "$2 /#."

/5"# $2 =1 "$1 2:

2,"

2 - 1-

//#"'

' -,&''

''5'' '' $2>'@' &'<'' +-"$3 #+!1 .

-"2 1#."

/"E

"$ 1 1 2 +$2 -3$ - .

2 #+-3"!

.-!

2+- #'/ ,"$ 2-'

$*+, -5 2"!

/ "!

F $2 =1 2 .# 2

1 = # ,:

- -2 !

-#7 $2"!

. -2 $2 =1 1 2 ,"$ 2

$ *+, - $ '' $21 2"#

&D$

2 !-

2- $3 , "$ -"31 9$

$2-"31 1".2+

+- -"31 1"31 $2/ 3 $2, /+$"$ -"31 ":"

:$ ' 1

"# ; " "!

"$ #+!1 - -2 = # 2+/; .-) 2 # B' '

+- -,- 5!/ ,"$ 2-'

#11 +21 -;5;

6+-3

F $2=11 22 .#

= /# ,:

- $2"!

( -2 $21 ,"$ $'' 21"#)"#+ 2"#

D$ +#"$3 .-#

"! ;

-"31

;

'"# ; " "!

"$ 1"#- -2= #2+/;.-) #B' '1

5!/ ,"$ 26

;

!-2*

F $2=1 .-) 2, 2"!

/:"//#B' $2B' ?' +- )5,.+

- .

,"$ F? $2=1.-) 2, 2"!

/:"//#B' & B' &'

/ 2 +-

$2 2"$ )"2 $!

, 2"!

/:"//#

B' @ ><

$2, 2"!

/- ",:+-# -,# #B' &< B' @ /#!.; A -9' 1

/ #+!1, 2"!

/:"//#= #'5<>5><@7=1"!1

- C+"#"

-2

-":+$ /'

7!/ 21",# /

21"# ;

-# #$

$21 2!/ .+-#+"$31"## +2"

) 1+3151

-$"$3 #+, #'?57.

,$ 1 -, $3 3"$3 "$ 3-"!+/ +- / =-9 :+ $ )"2 $!

1 2 :

22+!

2 #+:#

#+!1 ./

' $2 - #+!1 !"-!+,#

# $2

!,.+

!,.

"$ -2# 1

2 /## + +-

-$"$3 $

2"# ;5 "

=+/2 :

",.

") ##

"$ /"$!, '+$# / - .

5 ,"$",+,= 2,"##":/ $+$#9"// 2=-9 #.

) ' " "!

"$ = #'??7 .

- ,$ 1' 1 $ "$ ,$ 1/;"$!, 5 ##+!15"# #'??7 ;

../;"$3 .

-# / "2 2=$ :; .

B +- "$ !

!" #

$ % & ' ( 1"#+- =+/2 -2?D 22"

"$"$"$!,

-2# + +- .-#.

#',+/ "./"

- (=+/2:

../"

."$3"$

> )"

= #$

-3+"2 /"$ +-$"#1 2 "$ % %

) * " "+(, &&'

"#$2"#.+

#- -2# )"$3#+

2"#

&D$ -"31 / 3"$ $

2- $3 , "$ -"31 9$

$2, /+$"$ -"31 ":"

:$ ' +- -,- 5 #/# 1"#-"31 ;

"$ $2"# +#"$3 .-#

"! ;

'"#)"#+ /2"# ;"$ 1"#- -21 #:

D' F1

-/; -3 #"#

1+315 = # ;

-# #$

:+ "$ + +- =+/2:

-- 2 -,

B./-"$3 #+!1 $+ # ,./;, =1"!1 =+/2 - C+"- !,./

.1;#"!

/ "

## /# 9

$)"#"$"$:

1 ;

#' # "

"# :# -)

=+/2:

$ - B./- )!

"$ -

-$"$31"#/") /"12-

-"$ ,./;, =1 "$ 4:=-9

"##

-;"$$

+- '

$ /"31 "$4+-"

##+ $2!+./ ="

1 .1;#"!

/2"# # "$3 ,"$ 2"$

/"31 .-"$!"./ # / "2 2=$ "$

#+.- 5"$ ,;

!$#"2 2)"

= $2# 4+# "!

=+/2:

# -) 25" 5!,.

"$ - /## + +-

-$"$3#"#

9"$3/##

-$"$3!

?D'$ 1"#, $$

"$.

;

+$2

2 .

!+$"

-;2 $2/## + +-

-$"$3#$

2"# ;=+/2:

!,.+

# //=#% 6-''

,+$

"$ /"$!, .

-,$

#'??7 ?D"$!-

-2# + +- .-#.

#'??G<@H@<@7 $$+ /"$!,

@<@BH #'<5>7 ? $!,

../;"$3,+/ "./"

- ( <5>B(H55?@7 & ?D

/"$!, -2#/## + +-

-$"$3#

#'&5?5>@@7

)"2 $!

$/ -2# 2"!

/:"//#71#."

#'5<>5><@7'-":+$ /1

2#+!1 $21 -2 # '6+!1 5 ##+!15 #$ - C+"- $;) -"

"$'

-":+$ /1 -2 #+, #'?57 -2#/## "$!, - #"B ,$ 1# $ 1#."

/"E

"$7- !+.

"$ :;

"$3 ,$ 1/;

-$"$3# #'?57' 6+!1

$$ #+#

"$'/

21",# / ;

$2= #.+-#+"$31"## +2"

#' ) 1+3151

-$"$3 #'?57:;2"$3 3-"!+/ +- /=-9:+ #+!1./

#$ #+:#

2:;/

2"$3 $; )"2 $!

'##+!15 !+/2

-$"$31 #$

1"#+- "$2#

-":+$ /1 -2 ) -;,

#'&57+$2

2 .

"$ $2#+ -"$37,

/ 3$;'

6+!1 =+/2#

$1 $!

#'5&579

."$3"$)"

+- "$4+-"

#5 .

-"2 1#."

/"E

"$ # /# #+-3"!

.-!

2+-

$2+- 2' $ #'57"#

-2 2 -2# # -)"!

# $

$2 $2 -

#'57 - B.

#$ $#.-

$)"

= :) 5

"$ "#-

$2!

/!+/

# //=#% 6-''

,+$

A## + +-

-$"$3# $ .

2"# ;

#'&5?5>@@7 2"!

/:"//#7

!1 -3

#'5<>5><@7

"$#+ -"$37,

/ 3$;

#'5&57 ?

$2 !1 -3

#'57 & - $#.-

"$!1 -3

#'57 @

#'>5(?5>?7

/!+/

2 $1 $!

2 !,.

"$ :

2"$ )+- /$3="

1"$

I@D.

$$+, -,

"/"$3 "$#

/ "// + /-

/"E

"$'

/"# //= 2"$ "2

-,#'

/+!9;

-#.

9"$37-

#$ 2% #7 F1

:/ % #7