High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2014/2013dismissed

Hdfc Ergo General Insurance Company Limited v. Akbar Khan And ANR

2015-04-06Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

!"!#$%$&'()

!&!*+&%,*&#! - " ..!++& /!*%,% 01*23&&"& 3!* !%.&"!& %

5 2 -5 *!%!& '6

*$ $& $ +7"8# !7*7

*5,13%3 9+7"8# !7* 3!..!++&

*5,*$&"!*:!*7"8# !7**!%.&"!& ;3! 3!* 3! !.* !*%+#+&!<%..!*=91!++<!" %!! 3!>,":=!& ?

1!*!!**!" 3! !.* !**& ;3! 3!* 3!>,":=!& %3,+"1!*!.* !"$& 3!"$:!% ? 66 66 -5 7

& 3$% ..!+7 3! ..!++& 6&%,*&#! =.&9 3% #3++!&:!" 3! *"!* " !" 7 .%%!" 19 3!

==$%%$&!* ,&"!* 3! =.+9!!4% =.!&% $& # 7 @7

!< 7$&%3* 4 3! ==$%%$&!*4 8$"!<3$#3 3! ==$%%$&!* <*"!"#=.!&% $& %A77@ 6 3!..+$#& 6$&>,*!"

$&#+,"$&:$& !*!% &"#%!!B.!&%!% 3!1*$!% *97<3$#3&!!"% 1!& $#!"*"$%.%+ 3!.*!%!& ..!+7$% 3 3!..+$#& 6$&>,*!"*!%.&"!& 3!*!$& <% <*0$&: % "*$8!* & 8!3$#+! 66 6A@ ,&"!* 3!<&!**,&23&*!%.&"!& 3!*!$& &=& 3+9 %+*9 %7) 6 &(@7 3!%$"8!3$#+!=! <$ 3&

66 ##$"!& ..+$#& 6$&>,*!"%,!*!"=,+ $.+!$&>,*$!%&3$%.!*%& &"*# ,*! 3!+!: !<%%3$ !" 8!*&=!& %.$ +7

,&$*1"&"<%+%: *! !" 8!*&=!& %.$ +7 &"$ 23!*&".*$8 !3%.$ +% ,*$&:!8$"!&#!73!+%.*",#!" "$%1$+$ 9#!* $$# !B %3<$&: 3 3!.!*=&!& "$%1$+$ 9$% %%!%%!" C3! ==$%%$&!*73<!8!*7 0 3!,&# $&+ "$%1$+$ 9 C&"##*"$&:+9<*"!" 3!#=.!&% $& 38! 3!*" 3! +!*&!" #,&%!+ * 3! ..!++& 6 &%,*&#! =.&97 +!*&!" #,&%!+ * *!%.&"!& ..+$#& 6$&>,*!"

&"38!+%#*!,++9:&! 3*,:3 3!$+! -!*&!"#,&%!+* 3!..!++& 6&%,*&#! =.&9 3% 8!3!=!& +9 *:,!" 3 3! ==$%%$&!* 3% !**!" $& %%!%%$&: 3!+%%!*&$&:#.#$ 9&",&# $&+"$%1$+$ 9 C 3%1!!&*:,!" 3 3!"$%1$+$ 9#!* $$# !B

%3<% 3 3!.!*=&!& "$%1$+$ 9<%&+9C8!& .*8! 3!"$%1$+$ 9C7&"# *<%!B=$&!"-!*&!"#,&%!+* 3!..!++& 3%*!+$!",.& 3!, 3*$ 9 3!&41+!5,.*!=!

,* $& 5,.*!=! ,* %!% <!8!*7 $ #=!% , 3 3!

==$%%$&!*%%!%%!" 3!+%%!*&$&:#.#$ 9 C7<3$+! =0$&: 3!++<$&:1%!*8 $&%'6 &8$!< 3!18!"$%#,%%$&%<!++%*!+9$&: ,.& 3!* $ 3!#%!%+<#$ !"19 3!#,&%!+* 3!..+$#& &".39%$#++9%!!& 3!..+$#& <3 ..!*!" $& 3! ,* 3 3! <% ,&1+! <+0 <$ 3, 3!3!+.% $#07= 3!.$&$& 3 3!

66 ..+$#& 3%+% 3$%C!*&$&:#.#$ 9%3!$% ,&1+! " 3!<*0"*$8!*7<3$#33!<%"$&:.*$* 3!##$"!& 3!+"%$& 3!#%!E :!% %3< 3 $& ""$ $& *!+9$&: ,.& 3! "$%1$+$ 9#!* $$# !B 7$%%,!"19 3!"# *7 3! ==$%%$&!* 3$=%!+.!*%&++9%< 3!..+$#& 6$&>,*!"$& 3! ,* &",&"

3 3!<%,&1+! <+0<$ 3, 3!3!+.% $#03!..+$#& 6 $&>,*!"<%<*0$&:%"*$8!* 3 <,+"=!& 3 <3!&3! #&& <+0.*.!*+973!#&& "*$8! 3!8!3$#+!+%3!*!*!7 3! %%!%%=!& 3! ==$%%$&!* 3 3! +%% !*&$&: #.#$ 9$%C#&& 1!"$%., !" 3! , 3*$ 9 3! &41+! 5,.*!=! ,* $& #%!%,.* $%"$% $&:,$%31+!*= 3!# %.*!%!& #%!& #%!%,.* 7 3!*!<%&1%!*8 $& 3!

, 3*$ 91!+< 3 3!3"3$=%!+%!!& 3!..+$#& %%!%% 3! +%%!*&$&:#.#$ 9 & 3!:$8!&#$*#,=% &#!%7= 3!8$!< 3 3!+%% !*&$&:#.#$ 9<%*$:3 +9%%!%%!" C&"#=.!&% $& <%##*"$&:+9%%!%%!"&":*& !" 3!*:*,&"3%1!!& .*!%%!" & 8$!< 3! = !*7 " & $&" &9 =!*$ $& 3! .*!%!& ..!+&" 3!%=!$%##*"$&:+9"$%=$%%!" 2 -5

() %>0%