Kamla Mehta v. Commissioner ITA & ORS.



  

   




!"#$%$% &' !( !"!)"* + "'#,%-% . / 





















00
 


12/
/2 /
 % 




0//  


00
 


12/
/2 /
 %








 

 # 3/ %0
04.00   3/ %0


0/  
  



   
 



   
 
 

   



 
 
!



  
"





  
#### 

0/2% $ %&

 ''


()*+,*+,$+

()*+$*+,$+






 


  

&



 ''


- 

 

 





 &



  '
()*+,*+,$+



+ )

 
 

 
  
+.,*


( '
)/

 
 
 


 
$.$++,$$ /
*0


&

( '
)/
 
) 

()

123 3+,$,





'
&
+,,2*,4 5 %  




&


  *



$2,2+,,2
   



'




 



'&

" 
6
  








"

' 



 
 
  
" 
%


'

7524+2+3*
&


  
)

  '


 
 
  
$5+7


( '
)/
 
$0.$


$0.$



 ' 

'


&


 

 " 
 '&
''

 
)

'


   


  

' 
)

  
  &
'  !'
 

' 
&
 




 
 "


'



&


 

)



'


&



 


" 
)

'








 



"

 




 
,5,4+,,2




'


&
 
 
 '&
''




 
)




  &
 
 
$1,++,,4
9 




'



/
  &

' 
&  

' 
!'
  7 )



 





'
&
+,,2* ,4

$4,++,,4
)

 
 
 

 




,

 
  
$15

$0.$
 
)



 

 '

22+1,,,3*
 
'
 

 

 




  
  &
)
 
 '



'


 


" 1 )



;


 

 
+4,7+,,0
'

'





'
&
+,,2*,4







)


'






 
 

/
  &


" 

/
  &





"
 

'

7525$5.3*




 
  
)

'




' &


 

 



 

 
 



;


9
"

''



( '
)/


 '

'





/
  &

 )
"

''



( '
)/
' 
 
 
 
+.,.+,,0 ' 



;



 

/
  &

 
)



;


 &

 

/
  &

 
 



;


  
 
  
+57%
'



 . )



'


  '



" 
 *

/


 
  
$7,

 
  
$5+%

$0.$


 


 

 
  
+57%




;


  
 
  
+57%

$0.$
 


 



"()

 '



  

 

'




"
 


/   &

 
/



2 )

   



)  
'



  



6 
%

 ' 
 
$.$++,$$
/
*0
'





 
)

/ 

 
 & ) 



  <



 

         

   

    

   

     "     $ %&'

 

( ( 

) *   

 *  $ + ,    

    

-       .#   

       

-    

    

            

 

 

   



  

   

          "     



-  (  

   

  

'      

-  ( 

    

  

/

 

      



 

    

      

5

  

    '0  "   '0          

   

     

   

    "    



-    

   

     

     '0     

    % &&2

   

      % &&2( '0



 "     

     

  % &&2

+

  

   

   

  " '0     $ %&'



   + ,

  

 + ,  "    -



 #

         #

  

-  ( 

    

          ) *  

 * 

   ) *  

 *     " 

   

      $ + ,      

- ( 

 $"      + ,

     ( '0                

  



6



-    

     '0     

                

  

-     '0 " 

          $ %&'



   

 

  

-    

     '0 '0   

 

   

   " 

  

     

-  ( '0(   (



 "        

  

    = 4
 



   
 '


  








 
   &
 

"
  &



'

&
&
 
 


" 
 
 

'

 
9 
 
 




'



&
)






'

 
/
  &

'

  
$5+%

$7,

 
  $15

 
 
  
+57%

$0.$

 
 
 )
 
 
$2,2+,,2


'




+4,7+,,0
)
 


 


 
 


 '

 
' 


&
+,,0
  

& +,,2

$

0 )




 
9




  


"

  <


 

 %



       34 !

5

      -

# '



    

'   1

'( &&2( '

0

   

        ' 

(    "      %&.'

     + &&6   

&&1    

 '        7+.'

-

# '   ! ++% -  +779

5

     ( -

# '



   " 

  1

'( &&2       + &&6    

           

    

    '      "  5

     ( -

# '



  '

0



        1

:( &&6

; 

       

-

   + ,<%5<5 '9= $, -



'


  


  



 

 


 $$ )

'

 
'




"  
 
 
'








/
  &
    
$7,

 
  
$15

$0.$
 
  
$5+%  


 


9   


(
 


 
  
$5+

9   
 
  
$5+




 


'
 


/ 

  
$5+%



  <  



!"   

 #

<5

     +     + '

  



( => <5   #

  '(

 .# '( 276 < 6 2765( ;#.# '( 216 <+7 2165( ?.# '( 271 <1 2715  -.# '( 26% <%7 26%5(          7+'

       

   (          @-
.,   (   <

       



5    

    (    

      !  . <5  %7!(    

=

7

####

####

#### #### < 5 A

 . <5             '

<+5 '     

     <5 . <5       

          

####

####

#### #### ;#

>/  ( 

  B#

C       

 D  @
-- = $ %& 
" '

$+ > '

 


  


 


&


 8 

/
  &
 
  ( '
)/
 
- 
)/
 
?/  
)/
 
@
)/
  ( 
)/
 A
  &
 ' 
 ' 

'
    
$15A
  &
 ' 
 ' 

'

 &



 
&





A

  &

 ' 


'



 



  &

 &
  $5 )



  


 
 

 

 




  
$5+%



9

/
  &
(

 

   
 '




" 
)





" 

  



 
' 
 



 
 


  
%





'
9




 
)


 ;


'

'

+,,0
)

'
 '  
 
'   





 

 
'


/
  &

 


 

'

' 
)

 

'


'






" 
 



  ' 
 

 " 
(


' 




/
  &




 " 
B

'
/
  &
 


" 

 


 


/
  &
8
 


/
  &

 
)
9

'

 
'  

 

'


'





" 



 








/
  &


" 


 
'





" 

9

'

 


)
 ' 

 

 

/   &

 
 

 



&
&'

/
)

 

'

'

  



   &


 
'









 






"


  
 




 
(



 

  




&
 
)
 

 &





"   


 

'


' 

 

 

 


/
  &

 $7   
$5+%
5
 




 




'
 

  

 








'





&





?/  
+
 
  
 
,$,.+,$5
 

/ 
  &



 
/
& 
> '
 *   
5

  
$5+%



 



'





&





  

'




/
  &


/  
/    &


 
/
 
   


 '


'






 
 


/
 &


'  
)
"





 




/  
+

  
 
,$,.+,$5 

'
&

9 

+,,2*+,,4 $1 )
 


 
 
  
+57%
  
 
  

& 
&
&'


/   
+57%
 
 



'
'
 
  $15





'

 

 




'


& 
'

 &


/

 


&


 




' 
)

/ 

  
+57%
 

  B( 

  "  )%   * +> <5 "    ( (   (         &1

  

(    

    &     

 #(         

  

       ' # 



   



   . <5  %+      (  

  (      (   (   

     

;# >- ( B #C       . <5  %+      (      

     (> <5       

  @
--    

" 

    

   



 E <5      2&      -E <5      2&'

      -  E <5  ( - .# (    2(      -E  <5          7:''

  7:F

;#

>

(    (         %6   7+'(             $. > '

 :


 

 
$7,
$5+%
 +57%


 


 '
/
  &

/
 


  





 
/
   '

   &
)



 
/

&

 &

,

'




  
$5+%

'


  '



"  
  
/
& 
& '
)

'



  &
&


 


  


"


 ' 

  &


   



9

'

 

   &

 
)&

 

&
 

'

  +57%

 

&
&'

 
/ $2 (







   



   

'


'



 "
 
 
 
 


 '

 

8


 
 

 


/   &
)


  &

 
'

 

'



'


 
 
  
+57%

&
&'


/ $4 

9



 


  
 


$0 % 

  '

+,  
' 
  


&








 04.00  

0/   5,,4+,+7 ' - 
3

 C

  8 G$A