High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/10067/2014allowed

Anil Kumar v. Mahender Singh Devra & ORS

2019-05-14Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

"# $ %!&

" ( !

')&

&*$ +&, - .

/ )0!%&+

1 2 0!%&+

*& 3&

"0!%&+

!*& 3&

" 0!%&+

".$ )0!%&+

*& 3&4& 16 &!

07 !& 8&

* *&* !

* *&* 9" ( !

')&08 + % &

++!

1 *6

!*+

& :+

!4&# +

&&*

+ + #

"# 9!% 0"

( !

')&9&8 !'

+ 2 7+ (&6;

! &* +/ 4 # # &3&'<2

&** !#% + 0+#+& &

&*' +

& - 4& =, 0 8!%# & &+6+ 4 # # &3&>' =!8 8

&*;?&

!&*%# /0

&** !#% + 4 #!% 46 3&9 !

"# ! ## & &+6+ 0 8

* !&8&

&!!** ! ) & &@

++!

!46

8&*

& 6 " 0 8 & 8 *&&8#

& &+6+ &*

& @ *

++!

& 8 &%

!+ &( ( 0>08 8 !+& #6 A !& @ *&7'3&-!

! 8 #

.&+ "

&18 *&

&** !

& 00 =7.(#

3&9 !

"# $ %&

4&*

&*" ++&!#

!6 &*'-+& 08 + #&#& !&

++!

8 #' 0: & 46!&#

!6*#!#+ 8&/ 3& +

&8#%

08 &

+ '

3&! * !)& 8

3&* !

* *&* 3&! 0

6 %

3&46!%#

&** !#% + !

## !+

++!

++&!#

8 # 0 3& 4

* 6%&% !++

+&& 8

&+ ) & #

+& & ! *

3&8 %#%!!%#+ !

+/ ?

&8 !8 3&9+ +&608 + &4 *&/!&*+& & 7

* *&* 3&9 + +&60 8 !

& 8 !

!&8 &*

% + ?

& !4 +

!+&! &&*

+ &+646&8# 3& &!%

% + 8 8& &!#%!!

** % !%#+ B 8 # !

! 4 6 6+& &

&4 *&*

9 !

6 !*&!&*

!#&*

*&&8# 8 * !, C

++!

&&/+ & - =,.

+ !

) &

& ! & ! ## !%#&*B # # &&'<246 3&D..

7* 3& &% !0 8

& ! *& +& &0*&0 &8 & !*&8 &D.. C

&& 4

*&D.'

& &&+ !&+ &*+ & &*

&D.' - C

!% &*

&** !#% + 8& &!#%!

!%#+ &

&*++!

D.' C

&4!*&)&!

!&)&!

&* 6 D.'

* 1&

+ $#

+& %!

#& +&!

.C 4 !

A# " " .C0 $<#! "

.C 0 $' .C0 " !

"# 0 '

+&!/

0 .27 "0 '& / .C 0 " $8 ( ! .C-0 " " .C! .C#.C=

! %!

+&6&*(&% &

EA' *

B4!

! 3& *%&&*

& !#

0 3& *%& &*

& !#

0 3&-*%&&* 3&!# 3&! 0 3&0 ! #

!*%&&*

& '

&8 6&8 !8 +& !+& &

- &*'-0==0=:&#8

FG *&

&* *#&*

&*+ H &88!

+ 0 64 46 3& ! )& 6 ! % 6 >&8 % 0 3&9+ +&68& !

4 66+& &*&

& 3&8& %# %!! ** % !%#+

&*++!

! 3& 9" ( !

')& ! * !8

!8!!

! !

6 % * !

4 *& (& 3& +

08 &

+ &# +& 7 % ! !+& *&

4 !

#&#

+&! 6+&# & * *&*

/# + &*+& & ;

!+& *&

* & &

!"#$# $ % &"

!' ( ( ) *+

! ,-"#$# $ % &"- !#.( ./(

"#$# $ % &"

B4 8!

! +& & &* '00 =:

&8! !+ /# &% 8

!+408 + 8

&% !& +&!>&8 % 064+&!& 4 A 4

!!8

) / !B & # & &8 *4+

!!&+ E% &

8 & &4 &/

+&!&* + ! % 6 6

&+ &* !+

+B/## ! +% 8

#% 8

&*)

+ 8&!4 ? &!

#&*

0 8&!4

& !!

&8!&*' 00:B *&

& &*'00 =: + &' 00: & 8!

&*'-0: *& + !

& % 6 &8 !

B + ! ' 0: "6

& &*'0:8!

! ** # & &8 !

B + ! ' -0: & & &+ # 0'-0:88!

!08 + 6 ! !

++ + ?

# !

+ &' -0: ++& &*&&*8&/0

B4 !

&&*+& &4 ' 0--:+&!

&*/ !4&

6 &4 ' :>&8 % 0 & ? &4 + !B + &' 0: B

+& &!

!+& & &'0:

0 A- B4 & 8!

!6& !

!&*

! + # B %#** ! # %&)

?# & H &!+&*# &4 ! % ? %+

! &&&/*

! &++&6

!&+ &*& *&&8

+&*' -0:8!

! "+

! & % ** !-G

!4 6! 8&!& % 4 &8/0!% / & 4 # &!& 0

! &4 +&

#!*&&&* &*' 0:8!

+ !

! B

+& &+& & &'0-0: B4 8!

!&*'-0==0=: 7

860

+ !& +& &'0 0 : 0-0-0==0= :+ 8&!4 &

&*-G *&

&**# + 6 C + &!*+ &0

0*1

2-1

! &8 !

6 *0*1-3,

-* *&*&8 9"

( !

')&0

B4 &4 % 3&8&

%# # !%!!%#+

6*&

3&! !4

!# A

&+ &*

B4 #!8* 6! & &'

3& !

)& 8

* !46

! +*+6

3& 8 %# # ! %! !%# + / 46 3&

3&8&

8 B B4 !* ! 3&-

#!+#

&& "+ 8

3&+ +&608 + ! # 3&8&

%#%!! ** % !%#+ 0&&*&%# *+

= &# & % 4

+ !&+ + +&6B &#

B4 & +* ! &&8 + &*

&8 + !4 &4%&6 8& 3&+ +&6 % 8 &*

& & A ! 4&% '

3& 9 +

+&68 A

& ! %!

&!+ # &&*&&*08 + * &!&7 & 4&# & +&! % & &* %!

!+ # & '

!! & ! 6 &

! !

!+&6&*+&% &

EA'0

+&#

+ 8* &

3&9 + +&6 & &8 3&8& %# # !%!!%#+ &!%

&** !#% + 08 +

! %& & &*

! +&! & &*

+ &+6 4&%# 3&9+ +&6&* 4 6 &6+& & ;

!+& *&

9&8 * & & 646 $%&1 + &* (& 4

&56 $+ + +

"$8778 8&4 % !!

# $

% & % '(

*!#&*

B4 #!8&# !

! 3&-!

3&9 + +&6'

4 6 &6

+& & 4 &*

)& 6! % 6!

3&9+ +&6 !

3& &*

& &*+& &64 46

8! B 00*1-3,

-* *&*

&8 9"

( !

')& !&8 !0++&!#6 - 1)

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#