High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18427/2024disposed of

Delhi Public School Ghaziabad Society v. Educational Tribunal, Gurugram And Another

2026-02-24Mr. Justice Tribhuvan Dahiya13 pages

!"#"$ % %

""( $ $ <$## :

: #'( # #

- .$(

$ 1 +/ $#( #

"#$#$%

"#'$( )

"#'+(( +/('$"%'$(0 "# 0++ "#'$( ) 3 $/&4&4&6 @,$$/&-&4&6

,#" @,$$/&-&4&6 '$( )($ @++ "0 /(0'$( )! (00++

(''+"),+ $(0 $# 2

:$! ' + $ 0($'""( $ %() :$ $/%$ $ + 8$( %"()( 0$ )"

:$=$

%() 0($$#'( (& %()

'""( #, 0"+#;

$"(0#"

#" '##,/"#$")3 >)!>)"( +$", +

$ $! &&&4&*

5$ >- - $,/ ''+ 0"+ ,/ #)( "

# "# $!"

0$(! #$%") # , '$+/ / ++( "$ )"

"#$"

?( % $)+"!0($ $ (0, 0" (06 7 / (!!"##"( #, )+"

& 0)# (0 )# "

,$"0 $ #)( # # ''("

# # $"

$ )$ 8 9 :!")# "

"% % $" ,+ +") )((+ %" +$ 4 47AA*

5$ >* (

)((+ ; (%$ ,/ '""( $>

()"/ ( 44-&46 # +#(

#$%")(0#)( #)( 0"$!!'+(/( $!# ""( # ($;"

"$# "+ )((+0$,(/$ +0 ()"/$!"

#)( 0$(!#$%")%"+$ *4&&47

5$ >B "

0($!"

"# #$%")# $ ( +( $$C"$"

)((+($$$## $2 ))($ ) ( +$ - (%!,$ AA7 (0 /($ 0"$!"( "## ,/ "$

"% $" )((+ "

)"( " $ (0 "

"## ,/

#'$"+&46 ")## $)( "

/($ !'+(/! "5"#"

$!# )( ""( # "#( 0($!/(/($#$%")#$ (+( $$C"$"

+!<"$ ( $ ,"

$!"

0$(! /($ #$%")# " "!!" 00)

"++ ( ($ $!# )( ""( # ") (%$ /($#$%")# & $!# (0 ""( * (0 +$ (0 )( 0"$!"( 464&44 "## ( #)( # "+ ( $ !( #D (") ($ #+$/ "

+" $(0 ( $!"

(0 #$%") !( # ( %$ ( '" ( "! ,/ ()"/ "! (0 $!"

#)( ;'( #;"

0($"0)# , $)($"

(#&64&&4B ")0($!#'$(0 $)($,0($$", +

5$>&?$+% 5$) $(0$##

$2  # #$%

>+! <"$ 0($ &- /$# * !( # &A/# "#+" ",+0($ $"//! 

)!,$*4&47$!"

+$ #"##( "! $"

""# # E/( $ ,"

$!"

""!!"00)F

 . % ( "% $ !( #D (") '$"( # $C"$"

"#''("

! +$#'$)+# (* (0"#''("

! +$E#)((+! ! % $" ($!"

/($#$%")#,/ "%"

/($ !( #D (")"

$""

($,/'/! (0$!( D# $(###+$/"

+"(0#) (")F  "# #+$/ 0($ !( (0 )!,$D7 # ' ( (+ && 0) (0 "# '$#"

!$ (0 $+#"

#G (") '$"(#+$/)$ " ()"/"#+#($)($"

(# B4-&4B ")+#(0($!#'$(0

5$>&?$+% 5$) $(0 $## $2  D#, (%$*!( ##"

)"#+# ($;"

"++ # , '" +/ 0(++( ' " ,( "# # % ( $"# / +"" "( #"$"

#! " "# $)(!! "# "$ # " * !( # $(## #+$/ $"/ , '" ( :$ =!$"

"#0"

+#+! $+"# #( ,(% "$! "$"#$C#("

#$) @"

)'$! ($+##(:$ =!$ ))($"

+/ &* 0$!)'$##"( ()"/'"!( #(0₹76&-1& ₹*A4%" ()C#4741&4B(#)( # 0++ 0"

+ '/! "! # #; ( #"

0($! E)+$"( ,/!'+(/FB41&4B ")$## $2 =!$#( (0 ="#($$,/)( 0"$! % ($;"

"#($ "H"( 0$(!4&47AA*( *4*&4B/$!"

!/#$%")#0$(!*4&&47 % $)"% '/! (0 #76&-1& I *A4 # (

4741&4B 0$(!($ "H"( $$ ( # ' "

( , $)"% 0$(! "# ($ "H"( !

"0/ (+ ($ "H"( "# (00")# "$)($# !'+(/# #$% # # ($ $'$# "%# 8 ''+"),+9$!+##0$(! "

# /($)+"! &- $0$ #)( 0"+ ''+ ,0($ $", +0($C#"

($$(0$!"

#;"

"$)"( ( '""( $$"

('/$!"

, 0"#(06 7/ (!!"##"( +( "$ ##++( )890$(!44&446(

$#''+

# '$+/ ++( ,/ $", + %" "!'

&&&4&*"

0(++( $!#2 -A ##C+(,(%! "( (,#$%"( #'$# ''+#$%#(,'$+/++( )#!"#$,/ '$+/ ++( "

# ''+ " $ $ ( '$/$ (0 ''++ 0($$"

#$%")"#$,/++( $#'( "# "$) ( $"

# ''++ ""

$ !( # 0$(! (0 "# ( %$ 0($ 0$! (0 , 0" (0 6 / (!!"##"( 7 /

(!!"##"( "

# ''+"#$,/"#!"##''+ # #'$+/++( ))($"

+/:!((0)(##,'$'$ ))($"

+/($" "

+#$%")$)($(0''++ '+) $)($,/$#'( ,$$ ($#'( # '$$+#0$$"

"#'(()('/0$)(!'+" ) ''+0"+,)( #"

($)($>$((! * "# 0)+ ,); $( +$ )( #+ 0($ '""( $ #0"$#)( 0$))'"

0++ 0"

+'/! (0$ !( #D (")'$"(#+$/ ($# "%"

)+$"( B41&4B(00)#)( ( "+(0"+

''+,0($$", +# "++"

+/ "%(00"#$" ((#( ,/ #"

)+$"( #''($ (0 )( "( # # '+) $+" ) '( '$! ($ 6&4& $ $ "

% &4&&8&9

*4 #)( #)( "# ( "+( )+"!! #0($$!"

(0"##$%")##"

)#! ##$")+/# '$$!# )( ""( #(0"#)( $)(0#$%") " ()"/+#( 0"+(#')"0")++/'+#(( ! # $!"##",+("! # )"$)!# )# "#, )( "

"$)"

(0 #)( "

#$%") $", + # ( "

# #+ + ( "## % "

)# (0 $( 0+ $!"

(0)( $)(0#$%") "'$"%! ! !'+(/"#

( "+($"

#)( $)(0#$%"))

(,#')"0")++/ 0($) "# $ $ # '+) $+" ) ( "%"#"( )

(0"# ($-&&4&&$ $"

(#*BA *A4 (0 &4B "+

! -

+$ )( #+ 0($ #)( %"(+"( (0 )( $) "

$!"

#)( $#'( D##$%")#, !",/'""( $> ()"/"

"# ( ## &64&&4B B4-&4B $ '/! (0 $ !( #D #+$/ $!"

# #!("!( +/0$!)'$##"( ""

0($(%$#"5!( #( B41&4B "#0)#+#(, $)($"

(##0($! "( "#%"(+"( (0$!#(0

$)))($"

+/ "+##)( ('/! (0! # # +#( , '("

( "! (0 $!"

#)( $#'( $ $ !($ / 0($ /$# (0 #$%") "

)((+? )( "

#$%") (+ % $"$ "

'!,$ &4&0$ )#+#(, !("#'/#+"'0($!( (0:$) &46 ( "

") #+$/ ,"

,/ "! ") #( # "# (+ !( +/$ ##₹116B6?'/#+"'0($!( (0'$"+&4-#( #"# !( +/ $ # # ₹-AA-4 #+/ " # , )( '""( $ %$)C"#)(0)$!"

(0"##$%") #"

$!#(0)( $)(0#$%") #!(#"

)+$"( "!(0$)"%"

)C# "!+#($0#( "%"

$""

$)"% 0++ 0"

+ '/! # )+$"( ($" "

++/! "( $0($$ (,$( "!(''$() $", +,/0"+"

''+"

C#"( 1

,!"##"( #!,/+$ )( #+0($'$"#%, #"$ 6 #''$ ( $)($#)( #''("

)((+# 8:!")#9%"+$447AA*0$!($ />0($ /$# "# #$%")# $ $!"

%" ($$ *4&&47 ""!!"00),"

(+( $$C"$ $!#(0"# $) (0 #$%") " ()"/ # "

)($'($ "

$!# (0 "# ''("

! )( 0"$!"( # "+ ( $ !( #D (") ($ #+$/"

+"$(0# #)( ),/ ()"/"!(0 $!"

#)( ('"$!( #D#+$/ ")

#! ($"+/$C"$ ($ # "% $!( #D% ) (") '$"($$("#!;#$!"

"++ +,"

%"(+"%(0$!# (0)( $)(0#$%")#+$/,/ /(0)C# #0"

++/ "% ("! +/( 4741&4B (##'$(),/ ()"/$)($ , 0(++( ' "! #($)'$! 0($)+$ ) (0"## "!(0!;"

'/! (0#G#+$/0$,( 0"%!( #(0$!"

#!(#"

)+$"( ( '$"

'$(0($! B41&4B "# ()! # , $+" '( ,/

()"/ ( )( $!"

# "

)(!'+" ) " $!# )( ""( # (0 )( $) (0 #$%") # $ ( ,/ #)( $#'( ,/00"5"

"##"

$#$'( %"(+"( (0$!#( '$(0 ()"/"# $"+$ "))

(,"

($($5'+"

"#!

$:$+/,)#"!(0 "

(%$)C#(0 $!"

# #)( # ! ( #"

'$"

)+$"( ))'"

!( "

"0/"

($ "#"( ()"/ ++ # "# !'+(/# "$)($# 0$(! / $! " )

( , # "

#"!"

#,#C +"" "( "

""0($##$"( (0"#$" # "#)+$"( ("

$( "( (0#)( D#$" ( )++ $!"

%"(+"% (0 )( $) (0 #$%") $ "

( " ()"/ ( #) #"'+"( # $ "

)+$"( "$""( ++/")

(,+(##" (0 ()"/ (!"

'(#""( %"#>J>%"# #)( "# $#( (('"( ,(#"

( (+"

#( #

,#"#)

(,#"(% "% '"#$" # "!"+$%"

; ,/"# ($"

.>A*>&4&-"+"! # #

! % $ % $ )$ #$!"

0$(!#$%"),/: ! 0($ ($#( $0# $ # +#(

#;"

0($ #! # # "% 0$# ''("

! $# $( # ("

#$%") )++ $!"

'+,/: ! #)(+ ()++ $!"

0$))'"

0$#''("

! #$ ),/ ($

"0(++( (,#$%"( #2 6 K:$+/,)##))'0$#''(" ! ( #(+" #+$/ $ ( "# $!# )( ""( # " )

( , #" # # "% ' $" ( )++ $ $!"

0$(!#$%")%"($$&*4A&4* +/ ( '""( $D# "!'$"(# '(#""( # 0($) ( ,( ( "# "## ))' ''("

! (

#(%$$!#" #,"

(00$ "

#'$)" )

(,"

$( "( (0$$" # #"#""#)( ) '(#""( $!"

($$ "# ( + ++/ ##"

,+ @$$))'"

$ ! (0+$ # "($)( #+ 0"$# $#'( )

( , ++( ( $ $( )++ ($$ (0 $!"

0$ ))'"

#,#C ''("

! "++ , (,+ !!/ 0($ $ > #00$"

"++ +$!"

(,"

++( ()++ "%

"))

(,)( ) 6 @$$ "

)#8&'9$+"'( ,/ +$ )( #+0($'""( $(# (% )"#)#"

$? $+" )#, '+)'( "#0(++( '$ $'2 *A 0($ '$()"

0$$ " "# "!'($ ( )+$"0/ "#"

)"( , L)C"#) )L L+/ +)#L

()$"

(0)C"#) )"# C",+()$"

")''+"#

'$/%"

$" # #,/ ## ($+"

$ "

#"# " $" "+ ) "# "

'$( $## 0$ %"(+"( "# )(!'+ ") )( ) $0+)#"### ($))($)

(0$ $#)(!'+"

+"$+ # # $! )C"#) ) ! # #"+ ## )" # )( )$$ ) ($ ))' ) ") (# )( ) "# %" ) (0 "

"( (0 '$/ ( , ( C",+$" +#(( ()( )0$(! ") ($ '$/ "++ , #"0" "

0$$"

#) "

"( )C"#) ) ) , "$ "$) " 0++ ;

+ 5'$##''$(,"( ($"

"$) $'$#( %"

$" (##")"( # #,/ ## ($+"

$ "

#"# " $" "

#'" (0 0$"

! ;# ( )"( !"$$($"

))' ) ( %$ )C"#) ) "++ (''+/"0+'#(0"!"#(0 ("!'($ ) ($)( #C ) ''$ +/ ($#+)C"#) )"#)( )$$ ) (,/ )!;#%" '$/D#"

"( (, ( C",+$" )( )#(,(0;"

0$(! ")($'$/"# #"0""

0$$"

#) "

"( 0)# (0 "

# )# ( ( "

/ !

")#)( %$ "

"( (, ( "#$" ()++ $!"

(0"##$%")# #( #;"

(0 ()"/(#"

'$"

)+$"( ")## "++/ );

+ ! (0!( (0#$)"% ("

!($ # (( /"

($; /# "

#"# ""#$" ( )++ $!"

7 ()"/ $ #)( # ($; # )$ "# "#'+/ '$"% )"( + "

#""( ( "

/ $ >"

>" 0$(! (%$ ! ))($"

+/ )( $) (0 #$%") $"

(, ()"/ #)( "#)( $)

")"# ("

$+!(0',+")+ +#("(# (#( $!# (0 )( $) $ $ + "

$!# (0 / #($/ $C"$! # ))($"

+/#)( )

(,+ "+($"

#$%"),"# "+()(!' #"( "

#"##, #(+,/ '$! ($"

(

%$ &4B8B9

&6)#$+($!"

(0 ( !'+(/# (0 '$"% " )"( + "

#""( ,/ ! ! ( ))( (0)( )#$",(!$!"

+ ( , "

%"(+"( (0 # ( > (%$ ! )"( + #""( # ) ABA 0($ (0 )( # (0 "$)($ #'" $!"

+ 0+ '""( $# $ ( + "+ ( $"

#$%")#"

)"$$+"( #"' "! ! $)+"

$ $(0! #G)(!' #"( #+(, ''$('$" $!/ +% '$ $' (0 "# 5$) $"

,+( 2 & .!/+#( ( $''++ #(0"+)"%"+ #" %" ) (+ % , $)($ !$ "

( $$"+"

0)+)( 5"#"#$+% 0$(! ,( #')# (0 #;"

$#($"( (0 #$%")# C "0")"( (0! ##"

"0") #')"#$ #(+ (,#')"0")'$0($! )(0!#$>#$% )( $) (0#$%") ! ##(+,''$('$"$!/

) #)( D# $!"

"# "

,$) (0 $)(0#$%")#"#)##$"

,0($"# "+()(!' #"( +" (0 $"

"## (0 '/! (0 )(!' #"( ( !'+(/ "

+" (0 $"

( ))( (0 $( 0+ $!"

(0 $)$0$ )) "

,!(( )#)+/# (

!((+( / ( )+)+ )(!' #"( "# ,# ( '$"

)"'+#(0 $( 0+$!"

(0 !'+(/ $!#$>#$% $+"( #"''+'$"

)"'+(0 $"

)(!' #"( "

0($!(0 ,); #;'"

$%"

!"" "

)"$)!# )# (,#$%"( #"

"#)( 5$# $2 *K#'$"

)"'+#(0 #$"+"#'#) A-7)

(,"'#(0)("!'($"

(0)+!$"5 (0 '$# $ 0($ # )( #C ) (0 "++ +"/ "

$!"

(0 #$%")# (0 ''++ # )(!' #"( # ( , $ !((+( / (0 )+)+"( (+ , ,# ( '$"

)"'+(0 $( 0+$!"

(0 !'+(/ $ !#$>#$% $+"( #"' "# "

$ (+ "!'($ "

( " $C"$! (0 ''++ # %($"

( !"" "$ +(### 0) "

"# 5 !/(,#$%)+"!0($,);> # #''$ +/, $"#0($0"$#"!( +/"

'$# '$()"

# $"#"

0$(! !

$ "

") " ($ + " !$ $ " $ #(!)(!' #"( *&'$"

)"'+(0 $"

C)(!' #"( "

0($!(0,);> #;'"

$%"

!"" "

)"$)!# )# (+ # % ( ,

(,#$%!( )

(,!#+/ ($) ", ,( H " ($ "

"# "#(! $ )(!' #"( (0 0"% 819 /$#D ,);> # ( +# '/ $

( ( +/ ""( + , 0" 0$$ ,/ '$(%""

0($ '$(%" 0 $"$+ #( , )+)+( '$!"# #"0 #$%")#

(+,)( "

"++''++ #"

(0 #'$

** . % ( $#( ( 0"

#) 0($#" '$"

)"'+) ,#"(,0++)"(#($ $( #(#( )++ 0($ ($ "

$0$ ) 5)' ( 5 "#)## $0$ *- . $ 0"$#+/ (0 %" " (+ ( , ''$('$"($!"

!( ( ,#"#(0 +#'/ ++( )#$

)+)+"( #(+, ,# ( )+ '/ ++( )# +",+ ( , $

0($/$#"

C#"( ' ( '$"( 0($ ")"#!( "#(,)+)+ "%"#"( )"

)#8&'9+#(0(++( + +"(

( )#0($ $"

)(!' #"( "

+"(0 $"

0($ $( 0+$!"

()$ A (C "0/! #'/,+('""( $""#''(#" ( ; "

( ))( 0) # , $!"

0$ !($ />0($/$#D#$%")"

)((+ (

)#8&'9 ( '""( $# $"

, "++ ++/ $!"

0$ ,( #"5 /$# (0 #$%") $ $ ! # "

0($! (0 #+$/ ++( )# '/,+ 0($ '$"( (0 " /$# ,/ " "$ '$(%" !( # ($ $"$+ # "# 0) ( $)($ "

:$)

&46 #)( # $ $(## #+$/ (0 ₹116B6 8,#") '/>&&*6- $ ## ++( )>&66* (# $ ++( )>674A9 "# #$%")# $ $!"

!($ /$ +0 +$ ( *4&&47 "# #+$/ (+ )$"

+/ % "

)$# 0$$ ,/ "!))($"

+/ "# !( +/ $(## #+$/ "! (0 $!" "# #### ( , ₹17444 #"$"

)"$)!# )# # "#)## $"

,0($ "# ($ !# " 0" ( $ )(!' #"( C"%+ ( 0"% /$#D '/ ++( )# ( #)( 0($ "++ + $!"

(0 "# #$%")# "

# (0 $"

" ,); # # ($$,/$", + 4 '""( $ "# ))($"

+/ "$) ( '/ !( (0 ₹*-&44448174445649(#)( ""

$#$(0 #"5'$) '$

!0$(!(0$!"

"++)+'/! !( "#(,'" ""

( ;#(0$)"%"

)$"0")('/(0

$0$ " "++ )$$/ "

$# $ (0 '$ ) '$

!"++)+'/! "!'

(0$", + &&&4&*"#!("0"(5 "

"),(% '""( # # "#'(#(0 "

''+")"( 8#9"0 /#+++#(# 8#9"#'(#(0

&'()*(+",#- $

* '

, * ')