← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2070/2013dismissed

Rashpal Chand And ANR v. Sumit Garg And ORS

2018-12-01Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages



    

  

 

  !

"##  





! "!#$ %

$%  &'()*+

,-./$+ .+/'+% -/'0& &/'-

'

(%)$ "$%

*+,

- ( '

(

"$%*+,

-

(.( /// .+/'+% -/'0& &/'- 

 1 0 + -$ $  $$%

,$$

1(2(342.- '(((*'$

#-5$,

,$#

$-$ !

"

$266- *2788-

 -,# (94:,,! - -  $ ;!# $# 5$, :, 28(3(3423*<

$#$  --, - ,

,$#

$<

-$  +

28(3(3423 <!

24024(.4 (' $;!#

=$,  >%5$ "!#$ %*');!# ! ;!#

%$%- #'% <5$$":, ( 4.?= #(> @@48( $% <A"!#$ %5!

$- 5$;!# =

(3<

'(((>( 5

5

,  +$% $%5$5$ $%

!,:

$

*"!#$ % ,

+

!

<$:$%-

#-,#$%+ !

5$,

!,:%$

<,:$

!,:

$

($# ,

"!#$ %5 $+$% $ #

 +

A$%

(

  $;!# 5$

$% -  $ $

 !--



$!$)!

$ (  5-$ :

 #B $ * $(  27(3(3423 $;!# 5

-

('(( $ *  C!$  <!

   !,,!#<     $  $)!

    3.(3(3423( 

 $;!# 5A.4A  $# - $ *5< <$  )A$%%  (-

,#

$- $ !$  )$ <:$% - $5$ : 5

 $ " ,$!$  --$,

(,# $#!

- (94:5,$# (  +$%<

$!

* ,$#

$5,

#-5



+$%<

-$ <A

(23<

$<!$( (

5

":  , (     5  

  $   5

  

 5    

-"!#$ %(  !

#

*, $5 $!

5$

(.!

#A(!

#A ,

,$#

$ :$%  $%$ $ +$ +$$- ( <

!

, 2.(2(3423  :

, 28(3(3423 5 +$%+$

$,

$-$,

!,

  $%- 

* -5$%$!

5

- # <A $<!&  

   

        

   

 





 !"#$%&'!((")

    

*+, -  

  .

!/

   *+, #    0 

     . 





.    

   *+,!#

  1     .  2   0 

 



  

 *+,!# 3          

2  0 4    .  0 *+ 5 , .6 <

 

$<+ *,$#

$5$#$ <A $<!+$ $#!%  ,$$

1(2(342.( ,! 

$%  %!

 $<!

:$% +$ 5 !

#A$

$< A,# $   5

(

$ !

!

#A,!+

<+ -$ $<$$ AA$-

<

A+$

#- !

$,A( !

,

$- ,# $$<$$ A,

-

! !

#A*



!% +

# $< (! -!

%!

"!#$  #$

  -, !#-,,$

$<!

B$ ,,!

!

! -$,:$%- 

#-,#$%+ !

$% $% !

!,*

-, !#-,,$  !A +

 ,

*  ,!  

$% 

!

#A!

$#!%  ,$$- $<! A $#$- ( +  ,! - 

+ 

!

- , <

D!$$ $  $

  $ $-5 $+$% - $ < + - #$ $$%

$!

"

$266- ( 

,  (23 

3.(3(3423<



-');!# (

2 # + 

$ !

-');!# B( $5$, 

$,

# ,,!

<A ,,  !

  <$:$%  -         ,,!  -  5$, 

0, $ $

!,:

$

( 

$$

B( 8 <A5 -! (');!# 5,,!

, 0+ $$ 



<

- $ ;!# =  >("!,

, *!,*< $, 0   B#$   

 ,,!  -   ,

# A! ;!# * E.5

$--$+$ B( E.0( 

+$ E.! ;!#  :

,  ,,! $+$%- -"!#$ %( 5

*! ;!# * E.

$$,  B#$ $ $



<A $, (  % #+ A  $, $    A !

 A   

%    $, $  -   $,

!

 ("!#$ %*

 -- $%+ 

 $ 5$ <B E2,

% $,A $ 5$

%



$-$ $+$%- -$$%

<A $<!5$

%  $+$%-

+$%

 + *$5  -! < !

,$ +$ !, 

 $ #$

$ $--, $

!

, 2.(2(3423  :

,  28(3(3423(

# A

$# :$% 5+$ 

$-.4AA  B$

 



!

A,# :  !, <A!

#A*!#-

(33*4440<

 $

!

A<A

  A23(.(3423$( (

!< D!

"

$.7-

!

      !



         

.                

    

           

   0         .  

.    

                

 

  

7   



  

       



.   /  

         8  6 $-

!,  $<$ $+$%-#

$A!<$,,  A

, 5$ !

$%

!

+$$- , (  $

 ,- $!

$



! " #!$% % &%

'

'

%( )( &*( )), A  $$ ! $5

$% 5$ !

+$

$  # :*    $<!  5!  <  )! $-$   $  B

$% 

!

#A- # $<$$ A(  B!

$  ' # % " + '

!

 &-.

/'

( ,"

0 &1*

#& ,$

, - "

$.7"

$1.-   -5& # 9 02  

  

1#2 

.         

   .

   

      

  :.

    

      2     

 .

  

 4

 

 &   

1#     

2 

   4  .

   . 

    

  



  0     

  

 .    0    

        



 0  

    

 

 .

 

 .

 0         

  

 . 

 1 :

2     

0  

 .   

;

2 0   4 

-""5       



---""5 0    0 0      



    

        0  .

 . -""52 0  

.    

4 2   2 .        .

   

 

   

#<  =      

 4

. 

     

   .     

:

  02 .

2 

   

          

 

..  

   

<- .  >   =    .    .     

.  

6

5$%   $, !#  $  5  $   )!%   -

 * $!

  -$A$-$ #$ A$ $#!%  ,$$-

$<!$% !

#A <  $<



<+ *

$#

$   $$#$

.+/'+% -/'0& &/'-

,0+  

!,:A E

 :$%0

 &  0 E



<  0