Nand Kishore v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!"#" $%&&'
(% )*( & +(, (
! "# $$$$ (, ( -&.
*/ % &
'
( ) *
++, * -
'.
*
'(
. / 0
+ & .
(
/ / .
*
'
" ( ((
'.
'-
1 /
%234+333 (
/ / !!
.
.!
(
!
#
5*6 ( *
'
. !/
3+37+333
1 / (
/ +4%++33% (
. / 0
( ( ! /
/
. / &
!/
// /
/. / *
'8
+%32+3%9 !
( ( :
1, ( '
!
* ! .
/. / *
' 0
(
( (( (!
%3%++3%2(
1 ! "#
$ % &&
$ & $ $## '
& $(# )' &&* &
. +73,+3%,
(
!
'
!
.
; / ( !
!
(
!
"((
'.
'
"0<0 = ! %234+333&
!!/
%+37+333
'. / /
!
/
>
? /
(/ (
0
! @:
@.
" % "0< = !
+33A+33%
:1.
#
/ &
) +A3A+33%
* %77A+ +3%2 /.
/ *
'( (( (! /
%3%++3%2- !
((
'.
'
(
!
:1.
( !
(
&
/
/ ( !) .
.
!
& :1.
3432%772;%34%772> :
1;<19?(
/ /
(. /
( !
(
(
.- !
( !
. %,
9
!/
((
'.
'-
(
!
.#
5*6 *
'
(
(
/ 0
& ( !
/
. / (
/ ' (
/
/
!
. #
5*6
/ .
!/
+%32+3%9> :
1,?
(
!
. !
2
!/
((
'.
'
'-
!/
!
!
/
'
.
)
/
/
3432%772;%34%772
. !
!
( ' (
(
. , -
/ A &
( !
!
/
) /
**+ 4 &
(
0
/ .
+33A+33% ) +A3A+33% ( !) (
/
!/
+%32+3%9
!
%;
( !
. +73,+3%,
( 373++3%A : !
. (
.
:
. *
!
/ .
7 & 6!
*
! "##$"
% "& (
.
(1 +
)
"
" , '
- # &
." "
$& # /"
#
12
3 # 4 $$$ "
- '
#
5%
.
0 $&
--" ' $
$$" - % "6#" & $
' ""#'"2 "# $6#" $$ $ 75 &
#' - 55 ' & "
$ # ' %
% (( )* +,* )-.$/#%/0$
"#2 " ." 6#"
,
-
9 ""% ( % * *
.2/& 3%"".
$-
: $$5
((1) (% )- .$0/ % .&3#
* % *
(4- (
)-.$0$ %5"$
9 ;
<& "
" #
7=#
,
"" " &# $""
#6# -5 '
,"# $
2
"#" '-
- =#5 &5
2 &
"#" -" #- $$ &5- '
$# $
# &# , $" '
'
& & 2
"2 $
'
' ' 9# 5
"2
-#' - & &# 6#2
# #$ '
"# '#- ,
#
'2 5
" '# #$ $"$ #,
=#, >& ""#'" & '$ " 2 -
#
" #- 5 '-
" $
"# ,"
6#" 6#" %- "# 2
' <
1 &# $$$ " "
$" & & /" :
# 1 $$ & - /" &# $$
2 /"
0 1 ,5 -6 7
) )-.$/#%&/#
" -5 $ & &#
, .$ $$" # /" :
1 #- /" :
1 -# -2
&
'
# '% # - $"$ -
$
1 6(()-.$2/ %"3.
-
."
"
"=#" -"
$
$
"
.$2
- '
" 5 -
."
& 6#" 1 # $' #',
"
-
$' , .
'
,"# %
"# " # $#,"
"5" ,- & 6#"2
& 6#" ." #, '
5
"
"-
$ "5" ,# 6#" $ 1 $ # & & 6#" 5%2 #.$
"#$ & "
$
- '' '$
" &- &
- "- & ." 6#" 5&
$ & " $$ ' ""- * %3 =
6!
* 7 (
%
8.1/+* 1 (
.
. .
.
)./
/ (
'
C !
!
!
!.
.
/
. .
!
(
. (
"
.
/
/ / !
( !
.
%9 * -
(
!
(
' ( (
(
. @ D !
/ . )
:
!
/ @
!
. (
++,
* - !
(
!
/
.)
/
!
.
(
:/
/
& .
(
! D
!
(
( .
(
/
/
!
(
. !
/
(
'
'
.
/ /!
(
!
.
/
)./
: !
( : 5 "
#, $ "# 5 "- "
$' " 6# '$ 5 '
"
.
6# '$ $' $
.
-# $' % $" #,'
"#
$
-5 $ 5 ' ,# '
1 - & -# " % $"2
""$ $
,"#
' 2 2
%"%
,#
: 1 "
"#
2
"
- & 6# '$ $' "
, +: %9 '
: (
8 "##2 .#%%..32 &(?#- 9" - & ""$
$ " #
"# ,# " $ "- 6" ".2 "# .$ #;(
75
$ @5'
'
$ ' A$ - ' 5 ,"' ,
'2 " 6" -# 2 &# .'- '
"' - $ # )$'2 $
'
'
' "" )$' '
$$$ )$' A$ & "'$ $"# '
$
%- 5 $"# $ $2 "
#
"#
" 55 "'*
B ..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
0 ..
..
..
..
6
1 :
'"
8"#..
&%%5/&2 (?#- 9"
,
#$' $"$ 9 1( 8 .$$/ 0%%352 $" ,5 $ $ $ 5 - $$" ,# 2
&# - ,
.+ 6 (8"##/ .#%% .5/2
,
#$' #2 - =#
"# ,"%
" $- -
5" , 2 # #;(
-
$ &# 5 $
' )
" 5
"
"#
& ' =# & "'
'
$$" 5 " )
C " $
-5' 5 '
$5 '
, -5 /" B
#
1 &# 2 #
#2 " & %& &
5#
& 5- ..
..
..
..
64'(
*(% (
8"##/ $%%"/22
,
#$' $ #- $
' $5
- & $ # /"
#
12
& $ #
& , ' " $
& $ 5
"#2 2 %
" 5
" $
- ." "
6#"* %% -
)./ ! " 0 * ;-< =8./+'1
(
) . /
.
C
. E
/
3+
! /
/.
:
. . * - )./ !
1 & & '$D2 $"#2 5"
$$ & -#D &
B /2 - $" "
$ " 2 "# 5 $'
&
5
2 - -
#$# ?#
#-
2 5 ', , 2 $'2 1$" >#2 $$ #
$
$$ $"#5 '$ #" "'
#$' #2 64'(
*(% (
>?8"##/$ %% "/22 ,5;
> $"
' " - A$
- -5"
- ' " 2 "'
$
& &%' $, $$#
'$ '5 $ 5 " '
1# >,# 1 " + '$ & & '$ & & "# "#(
5 - "
$ - '2 2 "# 5 5
'
# 1 "
6#" '
."
5#
& $$" - ' )
" 5
"
."
=#, 6#"
:
@ < - ? A"##& .%%5&/B8% 8 79(6
>94
A"##0 ."
%1+ 5&/B < 4 % *1
% >
'
<
** A"##0 &%%5""B*
' 9 1( > ? >?8.$$/ 0%%3522
#$' #;
> $2 $
2
$
"
# /"
:
# 1 "
"
$" ,
#
" $$ %$ $- 5 -
- " &% #$ &
'$#
'
# /6
- EE > 2 $ '$
$$ (
'
5# "C- #- ' 5" ""- B A# +
A#2 ', 6#" 5& , -E*
&%
$ %" # ,52 & # & '$#-
6#-'
- ?#- $$ ,- ,
' 2 ""- '* %+ & *
0 * ;6
C =8 2./+12 (
) . /
D .
D
1 :
1 " #$ ,
$
$$ 5 '$5C"=# - =# " &#
" ,& '$ &%- & #6, @5'2 - "$- $ '$ % $ & 5 &%
#6, 5
F- A"- /
" 1 '
"# $- $ "'
&# "5 '
"
:
,#"
& $ "#- %@6 2#25 .$2$ (- < 6 C
B
5- "#
$ -2
" 5& "'
$ &# =#
" ' & $ 5 ' -#
"
" " $$ /.# ( $"#
$ ,# /.# ( &# & $ 5# ,&
8#
:
$ 2
$ #$# '
,"% 0
> 6# " "'-
-
5- $$" # > .$ $#
$ &
"'
$ -
$ &
& 5" #
#,' 5"
"# '
# '$ $$" 5 -
# --
5%- .
& 6#" # /"
#
1 "
G,
#$' % 2 79(6
94
"##0 ..%%&0& "2 " '$ #
& , -
+
,# # $' "# 5"
-
#" '$ & 5" & & $ &
& $ & #'
& "- " #$ 6#-'2 '
'$ 2 &
#$#2
& $ %- ' , 75 $ & &
- '
&- 6#-' 6#-'
- "- /$.
& & - 6#-' -*'
7
) 8 .$2$ " %% 530D ;9 1( 8 .$$/ 0 %% 352 :
@ ( <- 8"##& .%%5&/2 $ $ & $$" , - $"- " #$ $ ' " 2 " "
-#
" 5 ,5 '
#$' " 2 0
6#-' ." #;(
$"$ # ""2
"# > 2 =# 5 - $$ 9#
=# -
$ & & 5- &% #$ "- ' ""$ ' ,#
& $ 6#-'
"# 4 < %
+
8 < 8 "##3 .5%%5##
'
H > 2 # =#
" & '$ & &% #$ "- ' ""$ '2 "" $( ' , 2 " $ -5
-
#,=# " 5
"#H
0
=#
" .'
"#
" "
" '$
" ."
"
# /"
# $ & 5-
- "=#" & #2 " & $ "#$
-# '
# - '
- $ '
# & 5- ,# - "- ' ' - -
+
" #$$ # $ # ,# & $ &
'$
-'
' & ' '& ,& :
0
:
>& & $ &
&
'
$
& - '
> $
& $
& '$ &
2
:2
2 &% #$
& $
'#" ' $ # - '
H ..
..
..
0
> 2 " , -
'
-5 $ & 5 $$" "# & #"
5,# -'
-'
& "'$
"$ & ,
$ ' $ '
&
G
" ,
$ "=# , > 2 & " -
$ & 5 $$" "# ' 8
$ & 5
& $ &
& 5" & 5 , '
'2 $ # & , * I7'$ #$$J +
#
&
( C 4 % *
8 "#.5 5 1- 5.& "
>'
3#$42 $ 5- %
'
& $($ : :
'
& $ - '
,
$ ""
#$ $
" "'$
:
5"
'
# $ $"
$ )#- 5" "2 - "'
"' K
'2 "'
'
+
6# ' $ #$# (#- $ ""#
"
&;( 6#-'2 "
& "
& 6#" 5, $
& 5
- " ' "# & , ' 6#-' " -5 "#
"
& $ , - %- '
#" $ " ' ""#
" /
" ,5 $ " &2 $ 6 5"
0
2 ,# # -- ,
$ ""
$ #$ $
" "'$
:
5"
'
# '
5
' - 6#-'
"#
$ "'- '
$
'
5" ::
"'
$- ,
$ ""
$ #$2 '
', $ #- 5" "2 #- '
5
'2 "'
' - 5 ' ""#
" $ "# -5" ,# $
" ', '
$
&
'
& , ' '
" $' '
' $ ' "#- "#
" :
- #"
&2 ,52 '
$2 $
$
$ 5 ' '
""#
"*
0
/ -2 "# $$-
$ &# '% '$ 5"' ,"
$"- " #$ K# 9" ?#-'
C< C 8.$$25 %
00& # &# -# $ "#'
&
6 #'G "3#$42 '
$
. 55 "#- "#
" #"2 & $
"'
" ' -#
" '2 '
" #$ :+ '
'
-
$ &
$
5 # ,"' ' ,
" $"
"# #$ 6#-'
6 #'G "2 &
'$" ,5 $"
6 #'G "2 & -
6#-'
#$'
-:* 7
) 8.$$3& -93#" FA @#$G "3#$42 "-"
- '$ 5"*
"#
" 5
' & -- '
,
&- ""# ' "
# 1
# "'
& ""
,
$$ $
. - #, #- #
5"*
) * 8
4 *
( 4
( )
E *
4 * *
(( *(
- "#'
& & '2 L ? -'G " 3#$42 *
( ( * *
( ( ( :
8 ""- * %; & " 0 * ;:
((7
) =81./+'
/
/
!
.
1
.
! /
37 &
/ )./
1 B $
""#
$"$
"
"5- $
$
"
A0
(
-
'
-
K
'2 '5 $
+
2 2 %$ '#'
,#
>#2 "'
$ -
, *
+ %9
( / !
( ( / ! /(
( !
.
( (( (! /
%3%++3%2
!
( .
/
.
!
( .
.
(.
%2 & F!
* 6 < !"#..5 %% : C
) D ! (
. )./
$"$
"#"5 6#"2 .$ .$ 1
"
5 "# 2 $$", & $*&
)./ : .
C
)
1 ..
..
..
..
..
B
$"$
A ?#"
#5 $$" , & - $"$2 ' M $#," #
#'G '
# - $"$ M' ,
5 2 " "# =# $ # ' "#G '- ,
#- 5. &" -
$$
' "# > "
A ?#" "'' "5D '
6#$#" . 6#-' $$
"'$ 6#" # -
""#5 '
=# - #
5 "5
> $"$
- , - $"$
$#,"
$"
,"
$"$ - $$ '- # # "# $"
& '#" &
- " '"# - & #""
5.- $$
$5 # " > '
"'$ &% $
=# - "
A ?#" 55 $5 " > &
$"5 $
A ?#" "" " ,#
#' $"$ # A#
!& #-
- > $"$ % $'
'
6#" $5 ,# '
""-
-- # 5 ,"'
,& $ ..
..
..
..
..
:
$' 2 " '$
$$ (- ' # & "
& 6" .$
$5# 6#-' / 1 F# "# 8- 3#$42 " "
,#
$"
$
'
" # ,
$"$
A ?#" #"5 A ?#" $"$ -# ..
..
..
..
..* ( + %, /
%234+333 &
/
!/ %+37+333
'.
/ / !
2 (/ /
(
/ 0
+33A+33%( ( ! /
) +A3A+33% !) / 8
/ 0
/ . .
/. .
& / / .
. ! & !) /
/ /
/
.
.
/
!
1
!
( .
. !(
. /
/ !
#
/ / .
" 0 * 1( !"##2& % &25 (
. /
1
G,
#$' "
7
<6 *( 8.$$&5 % ./&!.$$&5 -95.
$(
;
< =# " # -# & -5- $$' $#,"
5" "'$ -# 1 $$ -
, #" # / #2 $$' $#,"
5" # ' "
,
$ 5
$$" ' '
$$'
" $', @5' $#,"
# ,
&
$"# .
=# " &
#
$
&52 - #2
& "
5
"2 ' ."$ "5 #
6#" ' " "-" 8 ."$
5#
$
'$ - 5-
'
$#
&#
'
5 "2 #
$# #' " %- "
" # ' #"
5 $52
'
&# , '% , '2 $5 ' # $5 - # '$ '
$
" & '
-,
'$ ' & ,6"
-- "'$ '$ ' # ,
'
5 # " ,6" -5 '',
' $ '#" $
$
"
#2 '
'$
'
#"
5 @5' $#,"
#
"" .'
" "
'
"2
2 ,#
$5
'$ '2
'
& , ' " 6,
-, '',
' $ (1 1 & $ ( '# '# "- "
"
"'$ -#2 ,6" ,- 5
'
" # $ - 5 '-"
$5
'$ ' & $
'%- ."$ # 6# , 5 " "'
5#, ' -5 $
" '$ $ .# & ,6" #- "52 5D2
- # $ .$" =# -5
$#,"
#
$#$ 1 '# '', "" - #
'
" '
' =#
' # ."$ # '
5#
'
" '$ "
5"
'
-' .$"2 "- #
2
'
-
& '$ ' #
#$#< +
$ "2
'
5 )52
"
)"
+ $( '
!
'2 $
'
5 )5 ' B $$' "'$ -#
$ & $ +2 $
/#- $
+
$
'
5 )5 ,# # 5& 5- %2 $ -5 "'$ $$' '$"
5& %
$ -- '
$$' $
$ &#
$ % #$ $$' .# -
"'$ $$' 6- ,6" $#$
"'$ $$' 5- 52 $'
$ #
' ,(
' $ - & # #
(1 $ $
+
'
$$'* %A & /
)./ !
*
0 * C< C !"#.&..
-%-% ( .$" '(C
(( C !"#./.
% 30" %4 - ( !
/
/
!/ (
.(, ( &&'
'.C
C
!
C