Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. v. Mohindro Devi And ORS
!"#$%& ##
'
(#& ) )* #+&, -##
./! +&, #& 000
## -1 &1$- !"#$-
22 3 & && 4 + #& 1$ - & & !
" 1 + // 2 + - + -
& 6- 5 1 7 3 &2"# + + 8 9: (#& 3&3+3" &"- && /2-+3-&& " ,- &
5-5 1 ; -2 -&&8 $ + #-"2 &&&-"- $" - &&8+<9:&& 9- -" -&& 3"&1$-5 1 3 &-# =#5- +1$ ## $2"
# 67&1$3 &2 " %;- "& ;- ,&
-3" 1& 8+ 9: =#+ "# + + 8 9:33 &&
% & - ##
&& - &"& $-&&312#& $ +< 9:-"- $+ + " & 8+<9: 1$ ;2 - $3 2
$ 1 #
- "
+ 3 & 1 ; 1$ 3 & # # % &
- && - %;- #$1 "3 1 1 & & + 9: 3- " 3#$1 ,&
- " - % &
- && - 8+ 9: 3 && =#3 1 1 &&3 8+ 9: - # ## 1-
#& 9 "&# ,-$ 8 #& -3, # &&=# 3- &1 & #& 8 :
-2
&& -2+ & - ##
- 12 "& 2
#& 8+ - + - " 1 & &
" -
$
#& & & $ 8 -,- & 1" & -##
3
& #& & -, 2 , - & 3-- 1
&"& $+ - && 2 $ +< 9: - "- $+ + $ - " 3 ; 8+<9: >3, +-" 1 1;+< 9: -&"&#-"#33 &&
# # # # 2 #- , - & >71 - / # " ! !"#$ %& , ) $/-&- + <(!(!, 43- -&& =& $&32&138 $ & &-+ ? -1 -&" -&& ="#1 ; 3- "# 2- # #( ,= -&) $/-7 # # & & & : , - && 3
:"# $& =& $+&& ? -1 -&"- &1 -3
3- -&&31 3-2 $ && 8?3- -&&313-2 8 $ & ?3- -&&313 -2 8 $ - &1 2 &&- "-& "# 5- 1 -& " " - "" -="# /--&&3&"& $8 $ 2 & =& $+ - + - ##
- & & 3 & # # 1$ ;2 ? -1 -& " -&& ="# < - 2-+# 2 #- , -& - / # " ! ) $ /-7 # + + 9: #$1 "+$# -& - / # " ! 2" * ! %&,+ (" !- - ("+ !, ## 48 + &&& /#"1 + +-1- &-@ "@"#& "
3--"#A# "A+A# "A+&A "AB& + 9:-33 &&- - & - && " ( , = - & -/ # "! ) $/-7 # 3
2"* !%&7 # # & & & :
, (1 2 , -&+ " $+
+ "& =#- & 1 8+ 9:+ + 9: & 8+ 9: #, $ 5- &" - &1-&- ? , $- $ B
<! C- -! ) $/- # & 3--, -& & 3--"# 1 3 && &- - -& % ! " 2
+@ "@"#& " 3-- "# A# "A+ A# "A+ & A "A 5- 2- 3 & & - "#$+ + - #+ "
+ 2 &+ &
- &&+ 3-- -
" $ D- # # + 3 & & = 3- - && # /# " 2
& & 2- # 2 - -# - 1& 3 3--
3"#- ,,2#
@"#$+$+# +
+&& -- , $E 2 @) " &-- & #-# " &- # +
@# &+# +
+$+&# + 2 & & 2@ " - 2- - # "#- & &- - & & &2-&- - & 2 -; & 2$ - # & " $ - && 5- 2$ # - && 2-
" !- , & - ,+
+ "#-#&- - " $ ! " # # "
2-22 "1 - & 3 - -#& E &3
&, -, 2F& - - , - &A =&-", -"#3 && - -&- - & E & - # " # 1 3 && "# & "-&- - & 5-" 3 &&-# "# - ,+
+ &"#-# -&& - &5- '- 1 2 "& # ,&2 -," - " + 2 " 3- # - - "
- &+ "
& & 2- +-# & 1 3 && " & - -& ! ") ! "3 &&- 3-
- " ,- & & - 3>2-! -,3 &&"#- >3, +- 3 $3- #-# # 3-- "# & 1 3 && ! " 5- " "# 1 3 && " 3
1 2, & 1$ - # # 3 &2 "# & A% ! "A & &3 ) $ /- # - # + 3 &" ## # 3 &- - &- -&&+ " ( + - ! "
$+ 2 + + 9: 3 && # "++ + 9: + 9:-- &#$1 - 3&3 & 3 " - - && # 9# #, $ =# 3 && G 8+ 9: & &8+ 9:C& #&9 " - & & 8+ 9: >3, + " #$1 & --&2 ,&
- --&# -& -/ # "! ) $ /- # 4 - "+ #& 9 " - & &-
32"#
!
" # $%& ''!''!"()&*! +($%
# $%& ''!''!"()&*+' $ & " 8<9: < 9:
) # 8 9: ? < 8<9: < H I +
9:
5 " & # ## & 9- 8<9:I
9: 9- 8 & 3 & # =# -&&
I 8<9:
&#&$
3 2 $;
9:1$- 1 = =I8+8 + 9:
4 4= =I +4+4 9:
3 2 $3 8+ 8+ 8 9:3 & < =# 8+ 9: 8+ 9: 8.
% J 8+ 9: + + 9: + 9: 9.
% /# 10.
%
+ 9: + 9: - -" 11.
%,&
+ + 9:
12.
5 <+
+ 9: D 2 && + + 8 9:-3 & +44+4 9: $+2-"# <+
+ 9:3 && 1$-5 1 +3 2 $"& + + 8 9: #& 9 " - & & 3 & "# +44+4 9: 23- G ?# "3 -& 2 - " #
& #$"+ " $
&$#&
& "+- #&9 "3 &1 & -3 & "## # - - & "&1$- 1 1$ ";2( + 9:- #& 93&3 &3" && 9# #, $ 5- !"#$ -
"; #$" "#-##
";2&& -= 1 $ 3 & # #+ &3--& - / # "! ) $/-7 # $+##
3&&3 &&& 4 +#& 1$- &5 1 "& &-=&1, ,-..,/.-
E-;;- D-- #;29 & K9 D-- # 1 K9