High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8213/2016dismissed

Chander Pal Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-08-23Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages

!"#$%&'($!)'* $& +!,(

--.

'#+#+ !'* '*"/"

#$#' 0$*1$!$$!) #('*"

'"2 !)'!#"

3 4

5 3 3 4

5 3 *'"'!#

*'"'!#

6($!)$)7 8$#'0 *#('2'#+#+ !'* 9:9:9:

9:9:9:

('2'#+#+ !'*;( +""'*7+!,$"$ !"#$%&'/!)'*#(' $*1$!$ &+8';$"+!0&+8#')#('2/!+"(<'!# 0"# 22$,' 0#'! 0/#/*'$!!/$&+!8*'<'!#";+#(2'*<$!'!#'00'8#7+)' *)'*)$#') = >2$""')%1#(' /2'*+!#'!)'!# 0 &+8'+"$* ('

$22'$&2*'0'**')%1#('2'#+#+ !'*;$"2$*#&1$88'2#')$!)+! #'*<" 0 *)'*)$#')?

2$""')%1#('!"2'8# *'!'*$& 0 &+8'+"$*$!,'+"$*#('2/!+"(<'!#;$"< )+0+')# "# 22$,' 00+7'+!8*'<'!#";+#(2'*<$!'!#'00'8# '#+#+ !'* ($7+!,2*'0'**')$*'7+"+ !2'#+#+ !$! *)'*)$#')> ($"

%''!2$""')%1#('+*'8# *'!'*$& 0 &+8'$*1$!$$!)+! #'*<" 0 ;(+8( #(' 2/!+"(<'!# ($" %''! 0/*#('* *')/8') # "# 22$,' 00 /*+!8*'<'!#";+#(2'*<$!'!#'00'8#

(' +!"#$!# 2'#+#+ ! +" )+*'8#') $,$+!"# *)'* )$#') > 2$""')%1#('+*'8# *'!'*$& 0 &+8'$*1$!$$!) $22'!)')$"!!'@/*' ?

*+'0&1 ! #+8') )'2$*#<'!#$& 2* 8'')+!," ;'*' +!+#+$#')$,$+!"##('2'#+#+ !'*+!#('1'$*> !#('0 && ;+!, $*#+8&' 08($*,'

/ #(' 8 !"#$%&' ($!)'*2$&

--.+"$* ;(+&'

2 "#') +! &+8' "# /*1$ $,$* ! - > $!) %'+!,#('<'<%'* 0#(')+"8+2&+!'0 *8'8 !"/<') &+B/ *$!)<+"%'($7').$%/"')1 /*"'!+ * 00+8'* 3$($%+* +!,(

=>.+"$* $!) 8 <<+##') ,* ""

!',&+,'!8'$!)+!)+"8+2&+!'

(' '2/#1 /2'*+!#'!)'!# 0 &+8' +"$* ($7+!, %''!$22 +!#')$" 00+8'**'2 *#)$#') >;$"

0/*!+"(')( &)+!,#('2'#+#+ !'*# ($7'<+"%'($7')$%/"')$!) +!"/&#')(+""'!+ * 00+8'*+ #('8#+!,!48($*,' 0#(' &+8'

"# $"')/2 !"/8('!B/+*10+!)+!,"$"( ;8$/"'! #+8' )$#')> >;$""'*7')/2 !#('2'#+#+ !'*8 !#'<2&$#+!, #('+<2 "+#+ ! 0<$D * 2/!+"(<'!# 0)+"<+""$&0* < "'*7+8' 2 !8 !"+)'*$#+ ! 0#('*'"2 !"'0+&')%1#('2'#+#+ !'*# #(' "( ;8$/"'! #+8'$!)($7+!,%''!$00 *)')$! 22 *#/!+#1 0 2'*" !$& ('$*+!, #(' +"8+2&+!$*1 /#( *+#1 + #('

/2'*+!#'!)'!# 0 &+8' +"$* 2$""') $! *)'* )$#') = >!!'@/*' +<2 "+!,2/!+"(<'!# 0"# 22$,' 0 #'! 0/#/*' $!!/$& +!8*'<'!#" ;+#( 2'*<$!'!# '00'8# /8( 2/!+"(<'!#;$";(+##&')) ;!# "# 22$,' 00+7'+!8*'<'!#" ;+#(2'*<$!'!#'00'8#%1#('22'&&$#'/#( *+#1$!)"#+&&0/*#('*

# "# 22$,' 00 /*$!!/$&+!8*'<'!#";+#(2'*<$!'!#'00'8#%1 #(''7+"+ !$&/#( *+#1 > '$*!') 8 /!"'& $22'$*+!, 0 * #(' 2'#+#+ !'* ($" $*,/')#($##('2/!+"(<'!#($"%''!+<2 "');+#( /#2* 2'* $22*'8+$#+ !$!)8 !"+)'*$#+ ! 0'7+)'!8'&')%'0 *'#(' !B/+*1

00+8'* #+"8 !#'!)')#($##('2* "'8/#+ !;+#!'""'"($)! # "/22 *#') #(' $&&',$#+ ! $,$+!"# #(' 2'#+#+ !'* $" *',$*)" 8 !"/<2#+ ! $!) %'+!, /!)'* #(' +!0&/'!8' 0 &+B/ * !

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

2'*/"') - ! ($#/*7')+7 !+ ! 0!)+$==EF - ($#/*7')+7 !+ ! 0!)+$==EF - ($#/*7')+7 !+ ! 0!)+$==EF - ($#/*7')+7 !+ ! 0!)+$==EF - +# ;$" $/#( *+#$#+7'&1 &$+) ) ;! #($# D/)+8+$& *'7+'; +" ! # $! $22'$&0* <$)'8+"+ !%/#$*'7+'; 0#('<$!!'*+!;(+8(#(' )'8+"+ !

('2 ;'* 0D/)+8+$&*'7+';; /&)%''@'*8+"') # '!"/*'#($##(')'&+!B/'!#*'8'+7'"0$+*#*'$#<'!#%/#! ##

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

"#$#'<'!#"*'8 *)') 0#('2* "'8/#+ !;+#!'""'"%1#(' !B/+*1

00+8'* ($7' $&" %''! 2'*/"') * "'8/#+ ! ;+#!'""

!"#$%&' /%($"( $!) 2* "'8/#+ ! ;+#!'""

> !"#$%&'

$,)+"(($7'8'*#$+!&1)'2 "')$"*',$*)"$!$*,/<'!#($7+!, #$G'!2&$8'%'#;''!#(')'&+!B/'!#.2*'"'!#2'#+#+ !'*$!)'$) !"#$%&'3$($%+* +!,($!)#('*'%'+!,'@8($!,' 0( #; *)"

%'#;''!#('<+!& /)7 +8';+#(+!#(' &+8' "# <2&$+!$!# 3$($%+* +!,(($"$22'$*')$"2* "'8/#+ !;+#!'""

$!)*'4 +#'*$#') (+" 8 <2&$+!# $" *',$*)" !"#$%&' ($!)'* $&.2'#+#+ !'* ($7+!, <+"%'($7') $!) +!"/&#') (+< /!)'* #(' +!0&/'!8' 0&+B/ * * "'8/#+ !;+#!'""

($*$< +!,( ($" )'2 "') #($# $0#'* '$) !"#$%&' 3$($%+* +!,( ($) "/%<+##')$;*+##'!8 <2&$+!#('($)#$G'!#('2'#+#+ !'*# +7+& "2+#$& 0 * <')+8$& '@$<+!$#+ ! %/# 0* < #('*' (' ($) 0&')

> $;$1 !#('$%"'!8' 0<')+8$&'7+)'!8'#(' 00+8'* ($)! #('&)#('2'#+#+ !'*,/+&#1 0#('8($*,' 08 !"/<2#+ ! 0 $&8 ( & ('0+!)+!,*'8 *)')+" 0($7+!,$%/"')<+"%'($7') $!) 0($7+!,+!"/&#')(+""'!+ * #+"! #$8$"' ;('*'#(+"

/*#8$!8 !8&/)'#($#"/8(0+!)+!,+";+#( /#'7+)'!8' = ('*'+" ! $&&',$#+ ! 0 2* 8')/*$&+**',/&$*+#+'" * +&&',$&+#1 *7+ &$#+ ! 0"#$#/# *1*/&'"2*'"8*+%+!,#('< )' 0 '!B/+*1 #; /&)! #%' 2'!0 *#(+" /*## '!#'*#('$*'!$ 0 *'4$22*'8+$#+ ! $!) *'4$22*$+"$& 0 #(' '7+)'!8' $!) # "+# +! $22'$& 7'* #(' 0+!)+!," *'8 *)') %1 #(' !B/+*1 00+8'* $!) $""/<'#('* &' 0#('22'&&$#'/#( *+#1

7'!$"*',$*)"B/$!#/< 02/!+"(<'!##('2*+!8+2&'" , 7'*!+!,+!#'*0'*'!8'+!#('"$<'$*';'&&4"'##&') #($"%''!

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

!2/*"/$!8'# $*',/&$*)'2$*#<'!#$&'!B/+*18 !)/8#') $0#'*0 && ;+!,)/'2* 8')/*'$!)+!8 !" !$!8';+#(#('*/&'" 0 !$#/*$&D/"#+8'($"('&)(+<,/+&#1 0+!4"/% *)+!$#+ !+ ($7+!,

+!"/&#')$%/"')$!)($7+!,<+"%'($7');+#((+""'!+ * 00+8'* !)'* "/8( 8+*8/<"#$!8'" #('*' ; /&) %' ! "8 2' 0 * +!#'*0'*'!8' $!) # #$G' $ )+00'*'!# 7+'; $" *',$*)" #(' 2/!+"(<'!##($#($)%''!+<2 "')/2 !#('2'#+#+ !'*%1#(' +*'8# *'!'*$& 0 &+8'$*1$!$7+)'+<2/,!') *)'*)$#') > !!'@/*' ?

*#('*'$" !"*'8 *)')$% 7'#(';*+#2'#+#+ !+" )+"<+""') E F E F E F E F

('#('*"2'$G+!,.*'$" !')H ('#('*"2'$G+!,.*'$" !')H ('#('*"2'$G+!,.*'$" !')H ('#('*"2'$G+!,.*'$" !')H

'".

('#('**'0'**')# '2 *#'*H ('#('**'0'**')# '2 *#'*H ('#('**'0'**')# '2 *#'*H ('#('**'0'**')# '2 *#'*H

'".