← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/10201/2014allowed

Harish Goyal v. Citigroup Wealth Advisers India Pvt Ltd And ORS

2015-12-09Mr. Justice Arun Monga6 pages

          

 ! " 

#$ % &' ( ) * ++++,, --.!/ 0))   1* 0))  0+ *+  ) ++++ 2, !

!/2  " 3* + )   1* % !/"

 

 

          

  

 

 

       1*'  *  

 ! "                # $%&$ ' (  )     



  *

   &+$+&$$,    

"   

  )    (        

   $ $,&$$%      

   "     ) )  

 -!

.    (/     

   

   

  1  )

      2                 

   )      

3&4##!) ##!5.     -!

 



         ! !!""

! #   !  !!  $ " !   %    $ "% %   "%"!

# "#%" #         "  & "  "%   #      '"!# ! !!$ "" #"!&"() "  !  # )

$   # *" *" "% #  * +,- + '  - '  .  / "'

.%'  -

%  / "'

/0#'  1

  2  3"

'

* $' 0" ,3  4"  $' 

'  15 '

 ""'"" '%/ "'

7 '

6 '



'

6$ '  $ '   '

* "$ *-    / "'  35'

3'  

 '      2  %#'

,5" &'

/ % 6.6  6"'80'8'+ '

'  +   2  $  - '

6  / " #   

""9%   &  #   "  5 %  "  #  "%  %  "    #     #  

:%$! 



  

 #    " "%% $ ;

< *   

,*  

 

    "& ""%  #   '

  %    !  "%   !  "  !  #   !    %  ""!&"() / "   " /%  !  !

$    % ! #  /%! $  6=  >9"

  !     $ !!

%"!# $

#"! &    $  &"

%   ""

   !""

% #

  %  *      %   ! #   "  #  #

  %)  $ 6 #  *    $  "  #   *&    %)  $ 6 #  "  !

    % ! #     

" )  $ 6 #  "      $      % * #  !     $ !!

%"

!

#  $ 6 #"

!  &    $  &"  %     "

  ""  %  #

!!  *      %   ! #   "  #       * % $" & % 

" )  $ 6 #?"

 $ !!

% ""

 

/ "   " /%  !  !

$    % ! #  /%! $ 6>9*= 2*>9" 6    %   ! #   "  #  #  %  *% $ " & % *"    "

"    $  "  #    *&  %"!

    %   ! #     

"  "      $   % * =; 6;" "!  $ #; *;" "! *" ;

6     



  

 4+.##)   (

  

 



         )       !

 7 17

   7 7

3

              )     )    ( "  ) )   



/  (      

 ( 

 

  

 

        

       "  

6 )     (  )     

 

   

 ) /

 )

##!5

(   

 

5     

         

( 

   



(  

 

   )

##45. 2

    

  "  68

 )  

*""3 " 

  % % %"%@AB** 2     



 

 /     

 

 

 

                   

( / )

## 4).4 . (       

       

 (

  (

/

 7

3

    *

 

  

   "  / 

    (

        " )   2       

 7 '     "

 

  

  ( 



      )   /

  

 2        



  " 5 )   

)  9  /

2    *       

 -!

:  

 7)47



) . 

  

 



  

   



7);

0  "  ( 68

  ) 

4 . 68

 )       



        



     

  &$  )) 

  2 

( 

   



   (    7 7

 



 

( /

 5 2      "   

   

 (5 )    

)   (   )            

   

    )   

)    )   



          

)

)  

  

 2    

               

 !< "  

 ( 

   ) =

)       (  ( 



#$ % &' (   1* "