High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9060/2015dismissed

Shivji Singla And Sons v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2015-05-26Mr. Justice Satpal,Mr. Justice S.S. Saron6 pages

#$%&#'()#

* +*, # ,&-)$*

* 0* #1$(2#*/%23$ 0*1#04*2/%2*$.* 0*+/#$*/3&2//(2 ,&- 0*41$5.2/%2**./627)" 0*##*,(2/%2**./"" $ .* $ ,'$ 3* 4/4, * /*' $ *./ . $ -/ $ .* *. 3*8

!"#$%

&$'( )

&*'(+ %+, -.

"/ 0 -.

#1$2

#1 (+ -.

& ) 3

&* '45 "

%, /,

&'"

+ -

&#' + 6 -

"# 2+

$& )+ -

'&"#* -

%+, -

&#*(+

$&6, ) 7,

6 + + -

$!45'

8 ,

!$ 6

!4 !

""" $'"* 4 %/ %//*9,* :

2 :;2 :<) :!*.%(5 .(// -5 $ .* $ $ ( -/ $ .* *. 3*8 =('>(' 3/2 &(2 -2 *8/(3(*

:"6;

?4,' ;;;; (%/%/9,* :!3./-5$*./$,'$$ * 3 <@ ( $ $ 4/ 4, .(// $ $ ( **.'$(3-/$.*3$$.* $,/*84(*,*3*8./,$4(*3*8 $% - // 53$* / $ ,$ (, $ /* '%(-*5.(53$$-/$.*. $3*4(/-$($#2./ ,$$.*8((43*8(/-535/* //; < "!$,'$$.*:('-(*4$('-(5 * *./* *:A,(B*3*54C/$ $.*$.

*./$*:/*.*2-,8* $ - .*%, /* $ .* ,'$ $% ,,((5 4.(/4(*3*8/,*'$(D5*/'(/$4$ .*%, $ 3$$ ..( * %/ $ 9.* *,*$/-5$.*3*$,*4(*3*8 $-/$((3' $ $ 9.* *2 3$$ 3* .*%// -5 $ .

;

%' /* BC 3$$ $ .* .*./2 (( .**>(/3*/*2$-8/$-43$* =8$?/-*8(/52$*4*-*83*8 $/*-4$/*3$$**/-5(5/''' ,*$$*(4*4/*(('(33* $/*/$3*8(*'3/2&(2-,2*8/ B$3*8*3$$$/*(/C-/=3$* ?-$/**$,*A,*/-(*/3//. $//-4-'''53$(*$2/44% 3$ 3* (3' $*,'$ $4 $ * 3$$ $ /* .*'$/**,/(3*(''/23$'*,/ 3*(%(-'/.

$-,*.( ; $$9.**3$$$.*8- /*/4(*3*8*($/*-,*3$$* 4/4*/-*8(/$/3(($ -4 / (( /*-,* $% 4$4 ..

,*$* $ 9.* * ,'$ - *(/ ,. -5 $ .*.*(5-*8('/4*3*8$ /*-,* 3$$ ,/* 5 *,4 - A,/ 3$ ('/*3$$*4.((58$/*4-($ *8 4 / 4$*5 -' 4-/// 3 (>*$ $ 9.* * ,-4/ -5 $ .* * -' $/ $*3$9,* :"**/5**%3$-%2 $.*3/(*(5('-(*$3*8 3$$3* (/%/$/*A,/$$$-(,(5(( /8((43*8-535.*3*.F .**4$-%2./,$$.*$ .*./$*$/**$*3*83$$$-/3((/ $*:/*.,-($/; < "!2$$(-/3*./ ! !

"!/$(-/3*./ D ! "! ,*,$ *$23*8$%-((/$-//*23$$%-,/ ('-($-9.*/$*-/3(3*$$-/*(* */ -5 $ .* ( .(// $ $ .* $

< 4.(// $ ,,( /**2 3$ 3* ,,( :( /* //; < "!./,$$3*89.*$.* 33$$*A,*49.*$4(*3*8 /(/$%'/*$/(,3**%/ *(($*3*83$$$.*3$(3-//*/3 A,(5 *44// $ $ /* $,(/ - ((/ / *$ /*$,(/-%/*$3*8.*%/A,(..*,5(( $3$3/-/*$3*8$*&,$/ $44',*#,.*/''*// 7 < "! $ - ..

// 3$ $ 3* 4 9,* :< $ %*44/$3*4*-/,.,$4, G*/,(*$.*$%$4(5*',/$$ 9.*=,,((54.(/4(*3*8?%',/.-( -'4:,/H$4(*,*3*8/./,.$3$4 /$%(,44$**2$-/*/-5$ .*,(/$%-*&/*$*$$.*$ **/,4(*3*8 * /(' 3$ $ *',4 */ -$( $ .*2$*(%/*4$/*/-9*/ $4,/* E; *>G)#> *43$$%9.*$%' ,,((5 4.

(/ 4(* 3*8 /,*' ( % 5* /' ( /5 4$ .*%, $ 3$$ ..(*%/$,(/-$*$((3' 4(* 4.

* - 34(*4.(/3*8'($$ 4,A,(! @$3*8$/* * $*4(*4.(/3*8'($$ 4,A,(< @$3*8$/* /,4*5 .* ,/ -5 $ * -(3 $ *8 9,% '* $ */ /.*4$,(/-$/F $4(*3*84/$%'/** 4(*$3*8*.3$$-/$%-%/9.(/ -5 $ 44 ' #,.*/' '* / ( $ 3*42$.*$9.*/*-,*23$$* 4/4*/-*8(/$/3(($-4 / (( /*-,* $% 4$4 ..

' (3 3* * 5 3*8-'**/,3$*'*/$/*-,*23$*$3*8 ,**(('/*23$$*4.((5 + /3$, 54*-*83*8$/*-4$/*23$$**/ -5(5/''',*$$*(4*4/*(('(3 3*$/*/$3*8(*'3/2&(2-,2*8/ -/=3$*?-#44$*23$$/* .*'$/**,/2(3*(''/3$'*,/3* (%( -' /.$ -, 2 * 3$$ $ .* $ 9.* H/$$9.*=4(*3*8?

-//*4(*,***A,*/-94/-5$9.*

,*#,.*/''*$*4'$(/ $2

// ;*/ .*(2 "!$%94/$$3*8*3$$-/3*%/3$ $%4$(,$$.*$9.*$/' 4(* 3*8 $**2 $ .* $ - *'$(5 /A,(/ $ 4%(,$(-/ ((5 $ 44-* $ 44 3* 4.(// $ .*5:*./$.*(%((/3.'(('2-,-* 5 . ((' 4(/ $ .* $ '% ,. ,$ 04-*$$(%(,44#,$9.*$(%( #,.*/''*$%/*/$,*3*8**/,-5 $ .* /$ 3*8 * 3$$-/ 3* %/ $ ,* 3$( 9*'$.3*&,/(*%394$/48'.

* $ $( %(, 44 $ %(,/ $ /* $ .*/,/$$3*8**/,-5$.**4(* 3$$$-/$%-%/ $,2 $ *' **// -5 $ $( %(, 44 - / - ,*2 ,*-( / ,&,/2 3$$ 453****$3*&,*/$,* A,(52$.*3*.

"! BG#GGC +4(