Ashok Kumar v. Gurwinder Singh And Others


    


  




  






  !




  



 




! 
"""
 #


"

 #$ 
 
 
 $

"


%
&
 '(
#)

*
 "

++++
 


% 

"
,- & 
."

#

*
   (
 #
 #
 
/

0 &  

(
.123(
4 '
 #  

#%

.2
#%
  '
*
 "

5"

) 6

*


&
*
   (
#%

.2 #%
  '
*


 # #"

3"

!*
  
# #
"

'() '*+

."

!*



7#'& 
 #
#
##
3."83"5853( 

#
9%
 #
##   
  
:#'(
 '(
 & '
*
7#'& ##
.3".."58.;(


#
9%
 #
##   
< ) 
:#'
,   ) -(
 '"

"" 5"

=
 %
 (
 

*


* 
*
9
# 

* 

9
*
 #
 
<"


3"

> 


*
 


*(
*


 # 
 ) 
 

& 
* 9 %
7  


# (
# *
*
 

*
 
 #
*



 #( 
&  '
.51
 
 #
8/
(

# #

*
*#

 (


* 
* "

 

*
? )



 %

 *
#
&
*
 "
!*
#
* 
9
   # 9%
&
 #
9
 #
 

7 
*#


*
 @"















#
*
#  #

* '
*


*
   #
6* *

&
)9(
9%


'
'


    4* A
 

*
#

*
9 


  
*

  
  A4* 
&9


*
7 
#
# )
*


  
  A4* 
&9

&
* #


'%  #
 9%(
6 *
' '
*
&
   #
9%
&
 #
9 "
!*
*
##
*
#
*)
* #

 

 #
*)
 #

#

*
# B

*
 (
 #
#


&
* 
) 
#

(
*9%(



 '
*


 
 
 ) 
 "

/"
  
9 '
)#(

#

9*

#

9
*
 #
 
<"
# '%(
#
6
## '


 "

2"

!
9  
* 
 (
  
"5
4*

* 

#

*
6 

9?

$

 #
 #
*
)

*


" "  #
 #
*

  

*
%
58.3 .@
,
?"$ .-
 #
%

 ##
##
5."85"588C
,4
-
"
!*(

 #
*
) # "

C"


*


& 

*
) # (
 #
 
< &

#
*
 

*
 (
 # '
*
#



6 *

 #"
!*
 

*



 *


& 9"

=  

 #
9%
*

6
 
# &

#
9% *
0 #
=  

<(
 & '
*


*
 #
!  <"

;"



  #
6 *
*


*

96(
*  A  
*
#
*
 
"

1"

*)
*#
*
 #




*
  
 *)
' 
*'*
*


*

96
 #
*
 94
 #
#
6 *
*
)9




*
 #



 #



' #



*


*

96

* 6 '


, - !*

*)
 4#

6
#
   
 & 
* 9 %
7  

  D
#
9
  #
&
   '
     A 
&9
&
*
7 
*# "
 #( #
9
  #
&


'


E * '
 

55
4 
.C
&

*
  '

4*6
".552A../;
4*
".15@
E
.138 & #

* 
 "1CAA.5A.A3 .2(
1CAA.5A5A.A8 ;( 1CAA.5A3A.A.

3(
1CAA.5A3A5A.

;(
1CAA.3A5A5A8 .2(
1CAA.3A.A3

"!" 8(
1CAA.;AC .8(
1CAA.1A.A5 5(
1CAA53A5 .@(
& '

 
 #
&  '
.51
 
8/
&


:&9 
*
%
58.3
.@
#

 '
>*6 '*( !* 
>*6 '*(
  
 '"

!

*
9) & 


 

(
*
 %
& 

*  
,$

.-
 #
:&9 #

*
%
58.3 58.@ ?"$ .
#  '
*


7 
*#

*  
 #
*
 .8"













 

& 

  
"5 4*

,$

.-


   

' 
*
 

%#
D
  %(
*
& 


  


*
%A 



(
#
*)
'#% * #

 
 #
7#  '
*
 '*





"

=*(

#
 #
  & 
 

  
"5 4* 
,$

.-
 


*
)

'#%
&& #
9%
* # (



'


"

!*

 #

' ) # 

&


 '
*

 #
 #

#
*)
9

*
*
& #

*
 


&
*
7 
 #

 #
  
 %
9



*

 %
&

"
!*


96
*)
* (
 '*%
4
*
  #
 &  
*
 

* (
  '

&4


7   9
 

 

&   '

.."









=*&(

96
 '*%
 ##
*



*
*
 '*

 
)%


*
 #


7 
*# '
 #
*
 '* 

* *

*
7 
*# "

& &9

*   (

*

9
*#
*

 *
*)
B
 '*

)%
*

7 
 #"


","


&
  
*


  
4* 
&9
9%
 %

*


6 *
' '
*
7 
 #
   #
6#
& 



*

*
 %"

* 
 &  (
%

6

'%(
*


 #

&  

 
&
'

"


*
9

%
9 )#
9%
 #
 
<
*

  
&#%

' '
*  #
  
) 9

  "

.5"


*
 
'#"

.3"


* 

4
'*(
&4 
' #

&
 #  


9 '
*


*

96
6 *
* &

) %"
.@"









=
*


& #(

#

 %
' %
 ) %(

*
  
 (
6* *

9 #
  #
  



 #
#& % ) # "

' #

 

&#
 &*


))& 

 %
9  
B

6"
./"

  %(
*

& 

*

 #
(
*9%( &

#"
.2"







 
*
&
 
*
9
# ##(
 '
&  

   , -(

 %(

 
# #

# '%"

 


  !

  '-.'/ 0.01 Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No