High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1084/2012allowed

Ambala College Of Engineering & Applie;D Research & ORS v. Ramesh Kumar And ORS

2015-01-09Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri,Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain4 pages

!""#$%$&'09.01.2015 () * **"+"&+$&"",$&+ &-..*$"% "%" ,#/ &- &!/", .."** &!% 0",%1%

("%/21( , &-!/",% "%.&-"&!%

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.J.VAZIFDAR, ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE. HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH.

3/"!/", ".,!",%*# *. .",%( 4)" **5"-!%""!/"61-+("&!7

3/"!/",!)","",,"-!!/" ".,!",%,&!7 83/"!/",!/"61-+("&!%/1*-)",".,!"-$&!/"$+"%!7 ,"%"&!' ,$&"%/21( ,9-:# !"9,!/" .."** &!%

, 2 *$;9<"&$,-:# !"5$!/

,"6. */1**9-:# !"9,.,$: !","%.&-"&!%!=

,( ,0$:";9--*-:# !""&", *9 ,4 & 9 ,,"%.&-"&!% &-

,<0$,;9-:# !"9,,"%.&-"&! >>>> S.J.VAZIFDAR A.C.J. , * /$% .." * 5 % -$%.%"- )4 !/" ,-", &- 61-+("&! &!/",$:$%$&"&#/- !"-? 8/","%.&-"&!%9/5":",9$*"-

":$"5 ..*$# !$& @A89 5/$#/ 5 % **5"- )4 & ,-", - !"- B8 /"$:$%$&"&#/.$&"-!/ !!/"-#1("&!%,"",,"-!)4 !/". ,!$"%1+/!!)"! ;"&$&!#&%$-", !$& &-9!/",","9,"# **"-!/" % $- ,-", &- 61-+("&! - !"- ? 8 &- *$%!"- !/" ( !!", % .", ,%!",/$%$%/5!/$% .." *#("%)","1%

/",$+$& *,-", &-61-+("&!- !"-? 8-$%.%"- !/$% .." * )4 %"!!$&+C %$-" !/" $(.1+&"- ,-", !/" *" ,&"- <$&+*" 1-+" &- !/" ,-", !/" -1# !$& * ,$)1& * $(.1+&"- $& !/" 5,$! ."!$!$& &-,"( &-"-!/"( !!",!!/"-1# !$& *,$)1& *, -"#$%$& &!/","%.&-"&!%D#* $(&C(",$!%

3" %"" & ," %& 5/ !%":", ! ! ;" -$","&! :$"5 3" / :"#("!!/"% ("#&#*1%$& %!/"&" ,,$:"- !$&!/",-", &- 61-+("&! - !"- ? 8 ! $% %1$#$"&!9 !/",","9 ! -" * 5$!/ !/" ( !!",&*4),$"*4 8 /" 5,$! ."!$!$& 5 % $*"- )4 !/" ,"%.&-"&!%9 5/ ," !/" &&C!" #/$&+ %! !/" .."** &!C#**"+" 5/$#/ $% ,1& )4 !/" %"#&- .."** &!,$)1& *9& ("*49</,$ (<5 ,1. "(,$ *,$)1& *

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

"!$!$&@88= <1&$! 1.! :<! !" ,4 & &-!/",%

/"*-!/ ! **!/""(.*4""%$&%",:$#"!/"#**"+"% $*$ !"-1&-",!/"

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

!/" -1# !$& * ,$)1& * ! -"#$-" !/" ,"%.&-"&!%D #* $( &C(",$!% & )"/ * !/" ,"%.&-"&!%9 $! 5 % #&!"&-"- !/ ! !/" ,"%.&-"&!% 5"," ..$&!"- & ,"+1* , ) %$% )4 !/" %1)%"F1"&! ..$&!("&! *"!!",% /" : *$-$!4 !/"%" *"!!",% / % )""& -$%.1!"- )4 !/" .."** &!% 5/$#/ $!%"* #&%!$!1!"% %",$1%*4-$%.1!"-F1"%!$& #! 1,!/",9 %&!"-$&!

$(.1+&"-61-+("&!$!%"*9!/" .."** &!%#&!"&-"-!/ !!/" ..$&!("&!% 5","$,,"+1* , &-$**"+ * $,%!*49!/"& !1," !/" **"+"-$,,"+1* ,$!4, $**"+ *$!4(1%!)"-"!",($&"-!51*-)"&"#"%% ,4!-"!",($&"5/"!/", !/" ..$&!("&!% 5"," $& #! $**"+ * , $,,"+1* , <"#&-*49 $! 51*- )" &"#"%% ,4!-"!",($&"5/"!/",!/" .."** &!% ,""%!.."-,(, ," -$%"&!$!*"- ! , $%" !/" $**"+ *$!49 $ &49 % -""&#" /$% $& !1,& 51*- , $%" 1,!/", -$%.1!"- F1"%!$&%9 %1#/ % 5/"!/", !/" .."** &!% / - 5 $:"- !/" $**"+ *$!4 &- $ % 5/"!/", !/"4 5"," "&!$!*"- ! 5 $:" !/" $**"+ *$!4

, ** !/"%" ," %&%9 5" ," !/" % (" :$"5 % !/" &" ! ;"&$&!/",$+$& *,-", &-61-+("&!- !"-? 8-$%.%$&+!/" .." *3"9!/",","9-$%.%"!/" .." *$&!/"% ("!",(%9& ("*49 $ !/ ! !/" $(.1+&"- ,-", !/" *" ,&"- <$&+*" 1-+" $% %"!C %$-" $$ !/" ,-", !/" -1# !$& * ,$)1& * $(.1+&"- $& !/" 5,$! ."!$!$&$% *%%"!C %$-" $$$ !/" ( !!", $% ,"($!!"- ! !/" -1# !$& * ,$)1& * 5/ %/ ** -"#$-"!/","%.&-"&!%D#* $(&C(",$!% /","%/ **9/5":",9)"&,-", %!#%!% <0G < < < 09.01.2015 H, :$&-",D Whether to be referred to the Reporters or not? Yes No √