High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2350/2013allowed

Kanishka Narang And ORS. v. Harbhajan Singh And ORS.

2022-01-27Mrs. Justice Archana Puri20 pages

#(' '&)$,#$-#./01 , 23 4 4

# # $

% $

% '

( # ! % $

() ****

1 +(

& &, -'./ ( + 0 & 1

.2.334.3 1

( %1 1

% $

32.4344/%1 &( ..5%..2 ..6 & % + $)% 1 % ( ../%

) %( $

)1 #$% $& )

( ( &

% $''$% & !+ & &

( &

% $''$%

) %( $

** 1$ % )!"#$%!" $& )

()% )%

7 %$1

% &

( % ( &

+ $ & (% 4..33446% 11&

%() +% 1

( &

( 9

++ '4:!'4;6<% &

(

=) +

% !

..; (%

'/4/3%

$ ) .' % ( % (&

%1 % % +%

8 356 4..33446 32/%::6%:4<' <32 !% !

% 1

% $ ( % > ?1:6) 1

( ) &0 ,$

# ( @ % ) ; ( 1% 1 :.) %

( )

*!* 0 ,$ # ( @ 1

% ) : (.1

(

% +1<) %(

)

% ( &;4%444A'1 ( 1/) %( &

)

% (

1 -# %

% ) % %

) % 8 %# ( &3; 1

(

$1 & %

)

( 0 &54%;4%:4 :4 % $)% (

)% .%1 1

$ &

'/4/3%

3 :'

() ) .1 $ && $

1 (

% 1$ % 1

$ & &&

% 1 $%(

( %1 0 $

( & $ % 1 & (

#+ ..5 &344/%& 1 1 & ( "'

" " # $ %

% ! &

! & " "# &

&#&'( )

" " '($ ) * $

#+ ..2 &344/%& 1 1 & ( "'

" "#+

% !

! & " "# &

&#&'( )

" " '($ ) * $

#+ ..6 &344/%& 1 1 & ( "'

" "#,

% !

! & " "# &

&#&'( )

" " '($ )

*5* * $

#+ ../ &344/%& 1 1 & ( "'

" " # -

! & " "# &

&#&'( )

" " '($ ) * $

% # '

( 3%(& 1 0!='. 0( !='3%

( ) $ 1$ % ) $ ) $ )

( )$ + %&

$ %

% (

$ &

'/4/3%

.' % 1 &% & % +

6)&$&7-)$1#))-&61)$(%)8-('%9/'(6'. (6'8#.(') $(6'.')8'&( '#88'#7)$%& &

:6) % :3) %+ ;)

/) % $(%

1$ %& $&

*0* 0 &

) + (

$%$

1 % 1 %

() %

7 & % $ 1

% (

) &%

& & %

%1 $ 7'#.$'%&-$)'7 .

(6'$)-.#$&':8#$/#$%(6'&7#:#$()#.'(6#($&:'(#; .'(-.$) (6'%'&'#)'% #<$'')6#.#$=#$%4$##.#$= .(6'

#))')):'$(/'#.)0*"1"*+#$%+* 1#.'';(.':'7/ .'7' #$(#$%$'&'))#./1 .<-)(#%<-%&#($ (6':#(('.+ %

(1 ( $ %

& () 3442'3446%3446'344/ 344/'34.4 +( 1 $ +

$ & $ ( 7 % + 0( ='.A

% %

( +0 - (% 1

& & ()

3442'34460=.A.%3446'344/0=.A3 344/'34.40=.A: 1$ % $ 1 )

() 1 10(

$ 0=.A.% 0=.A3

0=.A:& & $() 7

( 0

% $ 1 )

()

)#$%!" .'7#($=(

5 + $ )

& (

*"*

) ( + 1

)1 &

5.%5/%:54A'%1 1 ( + 1

)

(0&

( & 0 &.%::%632A'%1 %0)%$ % 0 ;5%4;6A' ) (

1 ) 7

@ (% (

( ) 8$B

C @ & C (

" " # $%% (

&& 0% 1 (

$%1 7 $

( , % ( )

() + &

%11

1 ( &5.%5/%:54A' ( 1

)

0;%1 ) 1

( &

( 0

&344/'34.4%1 1& & ( %&

(

& ( 1

$ $ &

( + %

) & %

%$ 0=.A.% 1 ) 3442'3446% 1 .%/6%.<4A' 0

(1/6%.<4A' 0

0=.A3& () 3446'344/%

( & 13%2:%434A'%1 0;

& () 344/'34.4%1 1& (

*+* & %

(& <%//%6<3A'+ %0

(

1 % &0; + % &0;%

(

<%//%6<3A' $

&;4D 3%</%/3.A' ( ( %1

(

2%</%25:A' (

(0% 0 .%::%6:2A' &

(15%.;%/:5A'

(

( %

&.A:

)1 5%.;%/:5E3%4;%:.3F<%.4%53<A'+ (

%( &C C1 )11

5.%;/%:54A' @ (% 0 0 & .4%444A' 1 $ + %

11 5.%5/%:54A' G% ( %

)1 8 )%

( +

() (

( +& () 3442'34460=A. 3446'344/0=.A3

( ( 1 +& () 344/'34.40=.A:% 0

1 +& & & 1$ % (

( 0=.A.% & 1 .%/6%.<4A' 7 ) 3446'344/% 1 3%2:%434A' 1 1

+ & %) 344/'

34.4% 1 <%//%6<3A' = ) 1 $ & + $ %

) &%

() )$ 1

* *

'0( 1

1 +

% ( & % 1 1 ) $ %(

)% %1

%$ &

(

&1 ) + %

( % &

() 344/'34.4 <%//%6<3A'

.%::%632A'0 1$ % ( 01 +0=.A:;5%4;6A' + & %(

(( 0%1

+ % <%//%6<3A'

';5%4;6A'F<%<:%26<A' + 1&'( ) + %

( % !

" % <4D

&;4D )+

% & (

( ) C (

&' (

)

) * + # , , $ + %<4D <%<:%26<A'

( .%22%;.:5 + % ) (

&<4D <%<:%26<%

( 5%3.%3/25 0 %

&.A:

0%1 0 &3%42%4//3&

(

%0 &

( <%.<%./6< & %C C( %1 1

) %) ( % ) 53%.3%/25A'

* @ & %(

$ ()% &%

( & 0 !

# (9

> ?%

(0 & 1"'

. / 0 /

!+ 1 2

& #

( 3/ & " 4 &5 &

& #

& 6 &7"6 &7"

&7, &#

& !"

"" &"

& ! " #

8 # + & !

# #

# &

4 & !"

!" "

! % 5 & &

" " "

5 )9 &

& !

, !

&/ " "

& !

/ &

# : %

; 7

& 8 &

& #

& # &

& , & # & " "

) , : <

& & "

& # &

" & " #

9 / & / & # #

#= / #

& =#"# !#

& #

9 / &5

* * + %

(% & ( .'

() % ( $

% & %

( !

(%1

% <4%444A'% & & .;%444A' 1 & & 0.;%444A' 1&

$' & (

H.4D%& $ ) ) %

( :..434.2% (

&.4D &

$ %1

( <<%444A'

(%.5%;44A' & .5%;44A' 0

& &

& 1"'

. /""

/ 0 .

) 53%.3%/25A'

3 !

( <<%444A'

& .5%;44A'

< 8 0 .5%;44A'

(#7

)51"+1+05>*

)#$%!" .'7#($=(

0 + & %

7 &

% + % & 1

( 0A5%

3%<.%<;;A' (

&;4D% 0 &.%34%236A'&

( & :%53%.6:A', & (

(0 0 &3;%.24A'1

( 11 :%:2%4.:A' (

&.A:

1( )1 :%:2%4.:E.%.3%::6%

* * 1

( 3%3<%52;A'% 1 %( &C 5C1

)1 :;%/<%644A'@ (%

(

& .4%444A' 1 $ 0

+ %

11 :5%4<%644A' 1$ % ( &

( &

% $ &

(

() ( (

$ 1$ %

$ & % (

$ %

)

& & ( ) 3442'3446%1 0=.A.%3446'344/%1 0=.A3

344/'34.4%1 0=.A: 1 0=.A.1.%43%;::A' +%& ()

3446'344/0=.A3% 1 3%25%..4A' 1$ % 0=.A: & ( ) 344/'34.4% 1 3%<.%<54A' + %

(

( & & 1 ) % %

(3%<.%<54A'%1 @ (% $ %

% )

()

'0( &='.A

% %

(+0- (%1

, % + )

( 3%<.%<54A' ( 1$ %

( 1 ( 00=.A: & 05%.2<A'

(

1 7

% &3;%.24%

* !* ) + + %&

0 (

& 5%.2<A'% 1 3%:;%365A'<4D &(

( /<%..<<%

+ %

(

( 3%:;%365I/<%..<<F :%3/%<44< .A:

((

0 %

(

( 3%./%544: + ( !

C 5C@)) ( % 1 :;%.:%54<A'

(%<<%444A'

(% .5%;44A' & .5%;44A'& 0% % $ &

(

& &

& 1"'

. /""

/ 0 .

) :;%.:%54<A'

3 !

( <<%444A'

& .5%;44A'

< 8 0 .5%;44A'

(#7

)1+15!>*>*

.'7#($=(

" + + > ? 1 ; ) % (

&+%1

:%6;%444A'% 1 )

( ) C (

)1& 2 "

" # $ ))

$$% & (

( ) C-

3 4 " # 05 %6$ 5 1 "

" # 05 %1 % (

&:%2;%444A'1

* *

% 2) :) (%11

:%2;%444A'%

(

&.4%444A'%1

%& + %

)+ :%6;%444A'

& (

) (

1 & + (%

& (

( ) C (

1 ! )!

" # $

% )1& 2 "

" # 1 " ( "

" #

0 6 #

0 * 0

"! 1 " & " # 6 , %

() & ( & ( ( (

& &

( C (

1 " ( -

% .4 ) %

( & :4%444A'

( &C C

( <;;4%444A'1

$ 1

$ && %& 0 +

) .//3 1$ %

( & C (

1 0 -

% 1 %

&2) %( $

% 1

) 344< ( $ %

* 5*

$"'

&# &

+ >)

: <

??"

&&",

& + @

& , , # & !

& $A"B

& ! !

& 6A7" # & $ " A"B

C>D

& & % & !

/& ! #

& && % & "= /

& ! /& !"

! "# &

& #

! $ " A"B " #

&$A"B # 8

! & $ "*"B #

C>D

& ! !

/& !

& &$

# & !

% &

&& E(" / / F & # # # &

#+ >)

1)2 :<

??" # &"

# / F & & &

& +

% & "

& & "

# # & !

& $""B

1$ !2# &

A1 2!

& $"A"B 1$ !

& A1 2! ) $-: E

" /

& 8

+ >)

" ?? $A"B

8 # ! &

* - F E

)# # !

" / 8

& $)"B

& * "

# > *

"+ ! &

& $A"B

&& %

A #% &

&& E("

* 0* $-: E

- F E

"# #

# &"% &

$ %

E(* !

/& !#

& !

$1 & & $ %

( & )1A' (

&C C%

& ( .5: & # %./66 1 (

:2;% 1

)@ (%<4%444A' 1

$ (%1 1 1 ( % 1

( .;%444A' 1 $ 1

& 0 +

11 <%24%444A'

1% $ %

() 1

4..33446 $ & % 1 %

344<%

1 0 -

1 " ( -

% $ &

(

) @ & % +1

)

% %1

&&&

& ) %

(% & (&%1 $) +

( &) ::%444A'%

% & (

30+ #

7 "

* "* ( 8 '"

" # %%%1 %

(

& %1

34.3%1 ;4%444A' $% & (

( )

)9 1 "

" # )) %%,%1 %

( &.3) %7

3445%1<4%444A' + %

& 1%

' $"'

&@$))"B

2/& & GAG@))"8AH$*"

A"B

2/ 1

8 2@$>"AB

I D !

J + (

( ;%36%444A' +

) 1

) + :%6;%444A'+ & % & (

% %1 ;%36%444E:%6;%444F ) 1!1>*

!+ .'7#($=(

+ +

7 % % 1 1

&'& % &&

$ (% &&

)!='.# % 1

& & %

$ ( %1 0. 0..3%0..< 0..5 0.3.% 1 3%4<%4;;A'%1 (

( & $ )+ %$ ) @ (

&%+

(

& 34%444A'%

& && %

* +* ;%444A'

& ;%444A' 1

+ %

%1 1

) 3%:<%4;;A'+(

) ( 1

( &

(

10 (&

%-# %

%) % %8 %#

$ +

) $ ) ( && ( &

+ % $

( $

(%(

)%1$

(& &

7 &$ ( $( ) &()( $ ( 1)

(

%1 &&

+ %

& %

(

.%3;%444A' )

% ( &3%4<%4;;A' + %

( 3%4<%4;; I .%3;%444 F

)1+1>*

%8, 3:;4 &34.:

1 %1 8, <36: &34.: ( 8,

3:;3 &34.: ( %1 8, <363 &34.: ) 1 % 1 $' (

& % (

1$ %(

((

( 3'# % + 8,

3:;. <;3/ &34.: 1 $' (

** + (

8, 3:;4 3:;. 34.:%) ( &24D :4D # % 1 %

)+ 1$ % (

<;3/ &34.:%) ( % 1 %

#$-#./01

') = ')