Mohinder Singh v. Presiding Officer And ANR.
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&, - - &.*,(%/ 0*,1.
------ %$*$*&,%/ 2%/+3+ /%+*(*,1
''*)%/4 #,&$.%/
------
%+7&,(%,$+
/%+%,$ /-
#8* #9.#/4 (8&)#$% 7%$*$*&,%/-
+- 3/7/%%$ :#3/4 (8&)#$% - - %$*$*&,%/
&.*,(%/ 0*,1. '*5%( *,+$#,$ ;/*$ 7%$*$*&, /$*)5%+
&,+$*$3$*&, ,(*# +%%9*,1 ;/*$ ,#$3/% )%/$*&/#/* <3#+.*,1 #;#/(
4 7#++%(
.%/%*, ;.%/%6> /%'%/%,)% #,+;%/%( '#8&3/ 7%$*$*&,%/ ;.*5% 1/#,$*,1
4 5*%3 /%*,+$#$%?%,$ '355 6#)9 ;#1%+ )&,$*,3*$> #5&,1;*$.
&$.%/ )&,+%<3%,$*#5 6%,%'*$+-
3/$.%/ 7/#>%/ ?#(% (*/%)$*,1 /%*,+$#$% 7%$*$*&,%/ '355 6#)9 ;#1%+4 )&,$*,3*$> +%/8*)% 1/#,$*,1 #55 #(?*++*65% 6%,%'*$+ (3/*,1 +%/8*)% $%,3/%- - /*%'5>4 7%$*$*&,%/ /#*+%( #, *,(3+$/*#5 (*+73$% +%/8*,1 (%?#,( ,&$*)% 37&, '#*53/% )&,)*5*#$*&, 7/&)%%(*,1+4 (*+73$%
/%'%//%( 0%)$*&, 0%)$*&,
) !*+73$%+ )$4 @
.%/%*,#'$%/ /%'%//%( A @
)$A #(B3(*)#$*&,-
- 7%$*$*&,%/ )5#*?%( .% B&*,%( + &&7%/ 3$&?#$*8% C$(-
#,#1%?%,$ .%/%*, &, - - 0%)3/*$> 037%/8*+&/ (/#;*,1 +#5#/>
4 7%/ ?&,$.
#$ $*?% *55%1#5 $%/?*,#$*&, &, @-- - $ )#$%1&/*)#55>
)5#*?%( 7%$*$*&,%/ .#( ;&/9%( ?&/% $.#, @ (#>+ #,#1%?%,$ %#).
>%#/ ;%55 5#+$ )#5%,(#/ >%#/-
$ '3/$.%/ )5#*?%( 7%$*$*&,%/ )&,$*,3&3+5> ;&/9%( #,#1%?%,$ 7%/*&( '/&?
- - @-- -
$ #55%1%( ,%;
#77&*,$?%,$ ?#(% #,#1%?%,$ #'$%/ $%/?*,#$*&, 7%$*$*&,%/ %8%, B3,*&/+ 7%$*$*&,%/ ;%/% /%$#*,%( #,#1%?%,$-
$ ;#+4 $.%/%'&/%4 +$#$%( $%/?*,#$*&, 7%$*$*&,%/ 8*&5#$*&, 7/&8*+*&,+ 0%)$*&,+ @
)$-
))&/(*,15>4 *$ 7/#>%( 7%$*$*&,%/ %,$*$5%( )&,$*,3*$> +%/8*)% '355 6#)9 ;#1%+ '/&?
(#$% *55%1#5 $%/?*,#$*&,-
@- #'&/%+#*( )5#*?
+$#$%?%,$ )&,$%+$%( '*5*,1 *$+ ;/*$$%, +$#$%?%,$- '*5%( /%75*)#$*&, ;/*$$%, +$#$%?%,$ '*5%( #,#1%?%,$- &;%8%/4 *$ #77%#/+ ;.%, )#+% #$ +$#1% %8*(%,)% 7%$*$*&,%/;&/9?#,4 #,#1%?%,$ 7/&)%%(%( #1#*,+$ %=7#/$%-
- #$*#5#4 8*(% *$+ ;#/(
4 *,$%/ #5*#4 .%5(
* ;&/9%( /%+7&,(%,$ @ (#>+ >%#/ *??%(*#$%5> 7/%)%(*,1 (#$% $%/?*,#$*&,
** 7#*( #,> )&?7%,+#$*&,4 ,&$*)%4 ,&$*)% 7#> 5*%3 ,&$*)%
*** .#8% $%/?*,#$%( 8*&5#$*&, 7/&8*+*&,+ 0%)$*&,
@
)$- - &,+*(%/*,1 ?#$%/*#5%8*(%,)% &, /%)&/(4 5%#/,%( /%+*(*,1
''*)%/4 1/#,$%( '&55&;*,1 /%5*%'
!" #$%&' ()***+!, -
%*' **) *&*. *%%
/
(%.***+!0(
-1
- (
%*
- -
@
(%.***+!0(
-1 & -
2)3
4
5
- 1#*,+$ #'&/%+#*( ;#/(
4 #77/&#).%( $.*+ &3/$ '*5*,1 *,+$#,$ ;/*$ 7%$*$*&,-
- &,)%(%(5>4 #'&/%+#*( ;#/( *?731,%( #,#1%?%,$- - .#8% .%#/( 5%#/,%( )&3,+%5+ 7#/$*%+ .#8% #5+& 7%/3+%( 7#7%/ 6&&9 ;%55 *?731,%( ;#/(
4 7#++%( 5%#/,%( #$*#5#- - '$%/ #/13*,1 +&?% $*?%4 5%#/,%( )&3,+%5 7%$*$*&,%/ ;&/9?#, )&,'*,%+ 7/#>%/ &,5> /%1#/( %,.#,)%?%,$ #;#/(%( #$*#5#4 +36?*$$*,1 #;#/(%( /*63,#5 *+ $&& ?%#1/%- -
, &$.%/ .#,(4 5%#/,%( )&3,+%5 &77&+%( 7/#>%/ %,.#,)%?%,$ +36?*$$*,1 #;#/(%( *+ B3+$*'*%( #))&/(*,15>4 7/#>%/
(*+?*++#5 *,+$#,$ ;/*$ 7%$*$*&, ?#(%-
- &,A65% 037/%?% &3/$ )#+% 6 78 9 6 @
0 @ 4 .%5( : / -
-
;
-
+
-+ + - - 4
<
-
-
" # $ =
-
/ (
&( -
!
-
-
- >
" # $
-
- - -
-
? @A# 0 **)1& == %1
-
-
- = -
-
-
-
B5
- , )#+% $ C
(/# = 9 D
4
037/%?% &3/$ #+%+ 4 #6&8%+$#$( 8*%;
#''*/?%(- $ .%5( /%*,+$#$%?%,$ *+ /35%4 *$ (%7%,(+ 37&, 8#/*&3+ )*/)3?+$#,)%+4 5*9% ,#$3/% ;&/94 ?#,,%/ ?%$.&( #77&*,$?%,$4 5%,1$.
+%/8*)% %$)- , 8*%;
/#$*& B3(1?%,$+4 /%'%//%( #6&8%4 1/#,$ *,+$%#( /%*,+$#$%?%,$ 7/&7%/ /%?%(>-
@- &,A65% 7%= &3/$ 75%$.&/# )#+%+ (*/%)$%( 5*%3 /%*,+$#$%?%,$-
%'%/%,)% )#, 6% ?#(%
7 ,-D/ ?0 **.1% == '
(
7 " ?0 **.1 ==' D#$ $ @?0 **.1& == )% -
#9*,1 ,&$% '#)$ #77&*,$%( 0%)3/*$> 037%/8*+&/ .% ;&/9%( '/&?
- - @-- #,#1%?%,$ )&,$*,3&3+5> 5#+$ (/#;, +#5#/> #$ $*?% $%/?*,#$*&,
4 7%/ ?&,$.
.#( $%/?*,#$*&, 8*&5#$*&, 7/&8*+*&,+ 0%))$*&,
@
)$4 )&375%( '#)$ 5#*( #,> ).#55%,1% #'&/%+#*( ;#/(
#5+& )&,+*(%/*,1
5*$*1#$*,1 #,#1%?%,$ +*,)% >%#/ D $.%/%'&/%4 #?
&7*,*&, #;#/(%( *+ &, 5&;%/ +*(%-
- ))&/(*,15>4 )&,+*(%/*,1 $&$#5*$> )*/)3?+$#,)%+4 ?> )&,+*(%/%( 8*%;4 *,$%/%+$ B3+$*)% ;&35( 6% ?%$ *'
#;#/(%( 7%$*$*&,%/
*+ %,.#,)%( '/&?
4
44-
%+7&,(%,$ #,#1%?%,$ *+ (*/%)$%( 7#>
%,.#,)%( #?&3,$ ;*$.*, 7%/*&( $./%% ?&,$.+ '/&?
(#$% /%)%*7$ )%/$*'*%( )&7> $.*+ &/(%/- , )#+%4 ,&,7#>?%,$ #?&3,$
;*$.*, +$*735#$%( 7%/*&(4 +.#55 6% %,$*$5%( )5#*?
+*?75% *,$%/%+$ #$ /#$% E 7%/ #,,3?
$*55 +3).
$*?% 7#>?%,$ *+ ?#(%-
- *,+$#,$ ;/*$ 7%$*$*&, *+ (*+7&+%( #'&/%+$#$%( $%/?+- - 7%,(*,1 #775*)#$*&, +4 *'
#,>4 +.#55 +$#,( )5&+%(- - -
+B9+ .%$.%/ +7%#9*,1/%#+&,%(
"%+
& .%$.%/ /%7&/$#65% "%+
&