← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20465/2022disposed of

Himmat Singh v. The Oriental Insurance Company Limited And Others

2024-09-26Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj13 pages



    

     

 



 !

"# !$%&%"'( )

 * 

 



 

+

* 



+



 *





(  ,+  * -  *       



 

   !" #



$ % &'

( )  -  *  .



+

%  (         

     *   +,-,%.) " / 0 1.

2 )

3 24 (      

 $ %

 ,%- * .)   " / 0   1.

 2 ) 

3 * .)   

5 '

 ( ) 

 .      ) %6 0 .  *  

)

  "

 76 0   

 *





%6 0* *

 .   ) 8

( )  )"" : 

     

     *

 0.

   

$ 9,5(5 -;%  4 

   0 *

 .) < # /)   8

/ "  * 



",;,,% ,7,,%+

 '

 !   

 %6,,,&5 4  " "

    '!

 *    .)   

 *  

5'

( )  !

 

)

 

 

)   * 

 ,,6,%+ 

 *  

  

"      8' * 

    

   *      4 

 

   "       

 *  .)  

,,,%6 + 4  

 "

    

 *  

5 '

 ( )

  

 .  

 

)  *   " *  )   .) 

5'

) 6   

    

   

 5(

  / 



  %-;*



.) 

.

 " / 0 1.

2 )

324(    4

* 

5'

)*   

  

 .#

*    "  . )

/

 "

 

'*  ".)

5'

)     

 



  

)

  %,6,%6 

*

 *

  "

 

   

.  

 "   *



*  

  " ) '*   ."  

   "* "=  .)*)

  

 

5(

/ 

 

    %-;    

 

 .)   

  *

)



 ' *    "

 

 

 "

   *   

  

.     

   



)



5'

) 7 >



"

.   

 "  

5(1+3 1;3

/ 



  %-; .  0 .) " / 0 1.

2 )

3  * " 

" 

# 

 

( 13

/ 



  %-;* 0  ; 2

  

  

 

 .

 

       ." 

 

    

 

5(

/ 



  %-; " / 0   1.

 2 ) 

3 24 (      

5'

) "0)"

'!

 "

%6,,,&5  

 "

 "

%6 0



*  .   ) 8

( )  "

 "

76,,,&5*  .   

* 

 ? -@   

"

"  

       :

 4

  

* 5 A  

            

  

                            

        

              

   

  !

     

       

           

  

 

        " #

     $ 

   

         

         

   % &        

             

    

   % "  #

%

'





       $        

     

 (% )* +, ---!. (    /  0$  1 2    3 4

5   345 %

/   (%)* +, ---!. (  /  0$12  

(*, -- ---!. (  2 0$ 

     

% %

 

0  2 0%

  

$     

    

  (%7 +, ---!. (  8 0$  1     )* ,- ---!.9(*, -- ---!.



        

    : ;< %%  (%7 +, ---!.

( 80$1   

     

 = %        (, ---!. (     

                             

  %

             (%, ---!. (  2    /         

  %       

    

         > 2

                   

     

 

 

  

      %& %   

 

   *)<       (% )* +, ---!. (    /  0$ 12     

      % %   8       %& %   

 :;< 

      % %  8     %     



    8       

       

     

%2  

   



%?



 4

5'

 ( ) 

  *    

  )    "*  



  (   

 *  -  ) *  

. 

)

 .  



 

 

'

 )    ) .     .    '     

  





 *  0

    "  / 0   1.

 2 ) 

3 * # 

  )" 

5'

( ) 

 %6 0' ."  

 

) B  . "





   %, /



 

 

 

 " 

)    =          "

   

*    '!

.

.) " / 0  1.

2 )

324(    * .

   .  ) .  



  "

 %6 0 <

     B

  .  



" 

) 

%- 0 ) ,%  

  

  

5 "5 " *  

  "

 %6 0   " *  "

.) 

' 



*    "

0

.)   

  . )

 

) *

    "

 '!

 

 )   " "

  "    # ) . 

.)*   "

  ) " / 0  1.

2 )

324(         

 "

   

"

%6 0    .)   

 *  

)    

   "

   .  

   

 4 .     "    

#"

<

C.   "( "





        





 ! "  # $ %# $&' 4   

 =   5 @)%      

   

 

           &4(% 3   **      

  

 

 &4(

 

A @**%2        3

 

     (%* ,) BC C;D!.

 

                   

   % 

 

  

 



 A

 

!/"

 (%* ,) BC C;D!. (%* *B -- ---!.E(%D+ BC C;D!.  

 %

  /"

 :;<   

       (%* ,) BC C;D!.% %%8  

 

   



        (%* *B -- ---!.  

 %

1

  /"

 :;<   

       (%D+ BC C;D!.% %%       (%* *B -- ---!. 

                       %

     

   



   $      

$         

 % 



$     $   

 %3  

 

          

  

  

    $                   

  

  

 %

             

        

 %? D%'   



   .        

     

    :;<     

!

        (%* ,) BC C;D!.% %%8 

 

 

  

 

             (%* *B -- ---!.       

!

 %  

     .3       

   :;<%%  

!

 

         (%D+ BC C;D!. % %%         (%* *B -- ---!. 

               % B%F   

         &4(

               G 6  %  > / % % & 

)

3'    %0%> / % )--* ) ;   

  5 $    %/   3   0%>' % )--;

+,-C%? %% D   ) 

  .

  * ."  .)   

  *     

 "

 " )" * .  . 0

"  "

 . 

"

* . .   % 

   "

 "

(       

)      ** *#   + %,&,*% *, 4    =  5 +%3 

           % % D%**%)-*)     

       

                            %(            

 



 %     0 $'    

   

     

     

    

 % 888 888 888 *-%3  

                

%    3

       

       

           C<         (%* -- ---!.

  

           



  % % 

 *%)%)-*D 

            % 

    

         

      

       )%B%)-*B            

         

 %              

  

   % 

   

 %    

           



 :*-<%%

      % %D        %0 



      %H %  

*    

#" "

 ( -    ./0 "        $  ' *    *  #  4   =

" 5 @+% I  (    ;  3   (      

  '  "

   "



  3  (    )--) 8 8 

   

 

   3

    

%3              3         )<       $        % 0  



  *,%-D%)-*C% 8   8   *,%;%)-*C%   

  3     

   % /(41(



3    

 

 

 (%,----!.        

  (%D,+*)+,C!.

  ;< 

*,%-;%)-*C

        

     % F $       

   

%?  %+ /



 

 

5'

 ( ) 

  ." 



 *  " 

  



 

* 

) 

  ".



 "

 

 " 

) *  

 %6 $  " .   %7 <

  



 



    





"   . 

'"



      

  . 

 

5 '

) 

"    ) 



   "  B       '!

 *   

 )  .

 ) " .) 

* 

. 0 

 

 '!

<



5'

( ) 

    0 ="

 . )



&  " 

 

5 " " * 8

( )8

)  



 )  '!

*     " ". 4  . 

" '

( ) 



*   . ) 

*  

. .  

 . )

  .

*   =   '!

 4 . )

  '

( )     

)  

) 



"

).   4

*   .  



).  %; '



)  .) 

 

    

.)<

C.  "( "





  1  2% % '"

*.

'!

 

. "   " 

.) 

 

5'

) 

  . )*

'!

 *       4

5'

 ( ) 

  .   

    "

)*

 )0 . 

 

*

   ")

   "

)     

   .   ")   



  "

  * *

 )*  &  .)" %- 4   

  )

 .  ) *   *   +,-,%  .)   "  / 0   1.

2 )

324(     

$ %

,%- 

 ."

 4

5'

) 

  )   .    )  ? -@   

"

     '!

  %6,,,&54"

%6 0). 

)

/

*   .     

"       "

    

  "

  B  . . 

 

 , / 

5'

)

)  

 

*  

,"



 



)

 

"  . .   

.    

*  

,+*0  '



  . 

 .    

5'

)   . .  )  

  ?7@

"

"



     *   

        . "

  "

 

 % 4*  

   ) *

  ) *!2 !34!5 .



1-  *  

56 5"5



  F   $!

   AJ !& F     AJ !&