High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/248/2013dismissed

Reliance Gen Ins Co Ltd v. Neelam & ORS

2019-03-14Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!" ##"

%&" '&"(

!" ##"

%&" '&"(

)"*) + , "+

%(&-." *"(##"

% , ((-." * ' "/0"(##

23"( - ( # *"4

*0(**##"5

!" -4(((. "*"( & "

2*3 ""- *"

* "( "(" / 6

%( 7 # %8( %( &( 8 4"( %( %&0 * %( % 9(04 &8*& '8""(.82(#

":"("4("(3( *"3"(*.8 (-" 9"088 ""' ;< < (*" *" "(**8.(08.03 #"' $,%(& (88"&"(8( #& (8 ""( "-

""30"("( *"( " &3 %( 7 # %8( %( %&0

** = : "(" %( #%8(

&0""(= -4( %( %&0= 4

(*"" .;

#"-2( 8(0 ""("

**03(&"(":"(""(&""4"(8" "( " 4 #" " "( # * , %"" %- 2( 8(030 *).%8(' /" < 6 4 "(:"(""(# "&"&>&""( 0 *0"("( 4 " ?( 8 # "". * %( 7 # %8( &3%&" '&54*- "& "("5& - 2037"& 8("-%( &(5*"(%&" %("&"( (0 8("&#""08'

6* %" <<* "( "$( "8 ""( $,%(&5 .-%&054

&#3!" - 2( 8

*"(**8.(-&8&# "* 84"( " " 8 " "(&"

- %( 7 #%8(4 80 " 3 ""("&*" 4 8" (#"

"@ ""-2( 8(

8 -A#&"("(&"

4#"

#( 8

?( 8 # "". * %( %&0 &3 %&" '&54*- ")# ( "7#5& - %( % 9(05*"(%&" 7&&"(( 0 8("& #""08'

* %" <<*"( "$(

"8 ""(0. -&8&# "* 84"(" " 8""(&"

- %( %&0 4 80 "3 ""("&*"4 8 " (# "

" @ ""- 2( 8( 8 -A # &"( "( &"

4 #" # (

%0"("("4&#"" "*"( & "-"( 4""8"(03 ""

& ?0 - B(== "-*"

' (*="4""

""&""98.

80=" 38"(*"

&*"

C " ""8"(" #"' (0483.."( & 03"(#

4"("(#"" :"("

#"' 4 (.8.**"..8""( "&*" "(4"" ""&"*0(** #"'

&#3" "9 #.

80=" -&"

38..&"*"(" 9"C ""(" ""8 "("48( 08"8 "4"("(#..8"(

" 9 " C " 4"( .4 " >"" ( 8 & " * &# "*&"( #"'

"("( .* &

*"(& #""

% C "3 ' "## # ""8 ##0*"(?0 -

("(34#8 "> #" "( #8 * "( #" - *48

4 *&+ D("( "( " C " "9 # " ( 88" .8 * .( ' ;< < 03 ' E,, D("("(#"" """8"&# "& "* "("(*7 #%&0*&"( #"-* "4("

& "*&4(&E,,

D("( #"' (.**"..8 ""("&*8"E,

D("( #"' "."("& " * "(

#3E,

/ * 2"("(#" .

##"*"( #". &

?#."( "(#""' &#"" '

6* &3%&" '&(8"( ""&"

,D #"" ' & #"" ' * &3

/ %&" '&(8"( ""&" ,D ?(#"" (. * "(>&%( 0%8( ,D-%( 2=%8( ,D %( ,& ,9 (- (& ,D/ 0 "8 & &"

"("((- "3.

##"*"(& *"(88 &"

-"(?0

' *.

*#"" -

' *.

*"(#"" 8 "

"( -

8 ""( '

*"(#""

""3-"(&#"" 4403

" "

& ?0 - B(== &# " * 6- /-A4 4(#""""(#"" A&"

4"(" " "

" *4"("(4#

03"(?0 - #"'

&#3( * #"## 0* "(

'" * "( ## 4

" "(

' "/0"("(## (.# "##"( 8( (.( *"(#" 0 88 "( 8("( ?(* "*& """* *"(

&#34 "(""(..&"*"(" 9""( "4 " "0 (& (

"(*""(""("-4(( %( 7 #%8(%( %&0(

**= -"4(("(3(

&0("9# " (88".8*"( .3 " 9"03 #"' 5$,%(& ! * "(##"5

&#3( * "(""(""(?0 ( 4838..""(4 "(" "(*""("

"( 8 34"

,D 0 %8( ( "" (

>&""("(4 ""(34"

*"("(( 8""( #"*""(8" ;(* "( """("( "8."(8 "" &0*"(" 9"(("

"(" 9""( #"

*"(##"* "(""("

."(4 "(&# "40"("(#"" "( (8( ?(*-"(40 " D( ##8 * "(&"

(

.(&"3" "

(

#8"(""(."8.03 "( ?0 " " * 3 "* ?( &# " "(8( *"(8"(."" 88"( 8("( -*"(""("" * *"(##"

"(.3* "( "09#"&"(" ""&"*4"

0 ""3*4 *&"( ""&"*4"

#9 #"#" "*">" ?(?0 ( 8.8"

.8 *&8""(

"(" #"'

$,%(&4 "(*"("03 (88".8 *"(**8" 9%( 7 #%8(%( %&0(

** = "( & (#"4(("(3(

&0 3 *"(."# 4"(8"

6 +

#$% # #

" &

'() *& #+ ,'** -

. "

! '

/ "

#$' . "

0 " &

4 2 "

671#,8

- / +

9 "

&/ "

. "

"#$ ( :

0 / 0 /

/ &"

1 / "

/ &"

/ /

%& '

( )* +, !% , -&. )*

( (' +" !

% $

/ 0 # !

"++) /

1! % # !

"#)- 2 , #$' . "

( +#+671#'

8 "

( ' +"

!%,4 5 ) "

1 0

;" 0

+ # 9" 0

3' &

6 &

+ % "

44 2< - "

+ -

/ "

;" 0

'* -

(

,% # 0

;" 0

+ # 9"

0 " 5.

/ - "

" 1

' / "

0 "

?( 88.03"(?0 .3.8 **".40"9"(&"" ?(?0 4 =

"* 8

' *.

*"(&"

8 ""(

?(&# "4 =

"C ". ( 08.*.8""(

&4 ?(*8 03"(?0 4 "0 "00"3

"3""(.

.0 ?(*-"( 8 " " "(4 8&""(## -"( & " &

83 2=

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#