← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9394/2015allowed

A.K.Tangri v. Oriental Bank Of Commerce & ANR.

2017-05-11Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan8 pages

  

         

 ! "#$%$&'(')*  + ,")-.'

$#'#')$. (!

/$.(0(

.'$)#"1")2 33$.&$")%")#4$.

 $(5)%$)# (!

 *  67  8 , 78  .$($)#*9 ..":$$) 05#";%:&"#$;.#4$5$#'#')$. ."-"#.."")% . 74");%:&"#$(;

..$(5)%$)#(  4$#4$.#4$ $5.#$.(1&"1)$<(5"5$.3"=>$"11<$%# ($$#4$?0%-3$)#@  >$.$$..$%##4$ $5.#$..)#  4$#4$.#4$?0%-3$)#(401%>$.$5.#$%')#4$%'-$(#@ 99 99 , 78 

7!

4$5$#'#')$.<"(<.2')-"(" $)$."1 ")"-$.<'#4#4$

33$.&$  ')  (4.#  6  6!  ")%  (05$."))0"#$%  )   ;:'%$.%$.%"#$% + ))$A0.$99!#$.)$=$". #4$.$#'.$3$)#;#4$ 5$#'#')$. <"( ($.:$% <'#4 "&4".-$(4$$#%"#$% +   ))$A0.$99!4$5$#'#')$.&4"11$)-$%#4$("'%&4".-$(4$$# %"#$%+  >=<"='1')-#4$<.'#5$#'#')'$  B  ;#'#1$%"(,")-.'/$.(0( .'$)#"1")2 33$.&$")%#4$.(;

>$.$#4'( 0.# 4$("'%<.'#5$#'#')<"(%'(3'(($%)5.$1'3')".= 4$".')->=#4'( 0.#;:'%$.%$.%"#$%  ))$A0.$99 !")%#4'(

0.#.$0($%#')#$.$.$')#4$("'%&4".-$(4$$#%"#$%+  )#4$ -.0)%#4"##4$')C0'.='("1.$"%=5$)%')-4$.$"#$.;#4$')C0'.='&$. <"("55')#$%")%#4$')C0'.=<"(')'#'"#$%)#4$')C0'.=;&4".-$ <"(5".#1=5.:$%")%&4".-$<"(5.:$%4$&35$#$)#"0#4.'#= '$#4$%'(&'51')".="0#4.'#=; 4"'.3")")% ")"-')-'.$&#.;:'%$.%$.

99 %"#$%+  ))$A0.$99D!;'35($"&0# E) #4$3)#41= 5$)(')#4$5$#'#')$.."5$.'%#<=$".(4$5$#'#')$.5.$$..$% ")"55$"1"-"')(##4$("'%.%$.%"#$%+  ))$A0.$99D! 4$ "55$11"#$"0#4.'#=;:'%$.%$.%"#$%D  ))$A0.$99 !;%'(3'(($% #4$  ("'%  "55$"1   0.#4$.;  .$:'$<  >$.$  #4$   .$:'$<')-  "0#4.'#=  <"( %'(3'(($%;:'%$.%$.%"#$%+ ))$A0.$99!4$5$#'#')$.4"( '350-)$%"11#4$($.%$.(')#4$5.$($)#<.'#5$#'#');(#"#')-#4"##4$.%$.( ".$'11$-"1")%)#')"&&.%")&$<'#4 $-01"#')#4$ .'$)#"1")2

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

&..$( $(5)%$)#(?0(#''$%#4$')C0'.=;')%')-(")%#4$.%$.(5"(($%>= :".'0("0#4.'#'$( 4":$4$".%#4$1$".)$%&0)($1(.>#4#4$5".#'$(")%4":$ "1(&".$011=-)$#4.0-4#4$.$&.% 4$50)'(43$)#4"(>$$)"<".%$%0)%$. $-01"#')#4$

$-01"#')(  $-01"#') $-01"#')( ;0)%$.<4'&4 "&#')4"(>$$)#"2$)"-"')(##4$5$#'#')$.'(.$5.%0&$%"(0)%$.*9

99 G '#441%')-.<'#4%."<"15$)(') 4$&35$#$)#"0#4.'#=3"=;>=.%$..')<.'#')-; <'#441%.<'#4%."<"5$)(')."5".##4$.$;<4$#4$. 5$.3")$)#1=.."(5$&''&5$.'%;'#4$5$)(')$.'( &):'&#$%"($.'0(&.'3$.&.'3')"1>.$"&4#.0(#. .-$.=."&#')-."0%01$)#1=.'(0)%-0'1#=-.":$ 3'(&)%0&#HI

$-01"#') #4$ $-01"#')( '("1(.$5.%0&$%"( 0)%$.*9 G  $)(')$.-0'1#=-.":$3'(&)%0&# )  "  &"($  )#  "11')-  0)%$.  $-01"#')    '  #4$

35$#$)#  0#4.'#=  &)('%$.(  #4"#  #4$  5$)(')$.  '( 5.'3""&'$-0'1#=-.":$3'(&)%0&#;'(4"11;>$.$ 5"((')-  ")  .%$.;  11<  #4$  5.&$%0.$  (5$&''$%  ')

33$.&$  '&$.   351=$$(6

'(&'51')$  ")%  55$"1!  $-01"#')(;  D   .  ') 8$##1$3$)#;"(#4$&"($3"=>$I 4$<.%6-.":$3'(&)%0&#6'(%$')$%"(0)%$.*9 >!

#4$  $A5.$((')  G-.":$  3'(&)%0&#I  ')&10%$(  #4$ &330)'&"#').%'(&1(0.$")=($&.$#'&'"1&%$ .5"((<.%.")=(2$#&4;51");3%$1;".#'&1$;)#$; %&03$)#.').3"#');(0&4"(3$)#')$%')8$&#')

#4$ '&'"18$&.$#(&#; !<4'&4<"( >#"')$%  <4'1$  41%')-  '&$  ')  #4$  ")2  (  "(  # 5.$?0%'&'"11="$&##4$')#$.$(#(#4$-$)$."150>1'&. #4$($&0.'#=#4$8#"#$I 4$5$.0("1#4$%$')'#')<.%6-.":$3'(&)%0&#6(4<( #4"#'#<"()#$A4"0(#':$4$.$.$;'#<'11%$5$)%05)"&#($"&4&"($ <4$#4$.#4$3'(&)%0&#;"("11$-$%"-"')(#".$#'.$%$351=$$;'("-.":$ 3'(&)%0&##<'11"1(>$)$&$((".=#12')##4$&4".-$(#')%0##4"# <4$#4$."11$-$%"&#("11(')#4$%$')'#')6-.":$3'(&)%0&#6 4$

5$#'#')$.<"(&4".-$%<'#4#4$11<')-#<&4".-$(*9 4".-$ 84.',")-.'%0.')-4'(:'('##43$%">"%".%""(5".# 4'-41$:$1#$"3;"'1$%#&.'#'&"11=$A"3')$#4$"&##4"# >.")&44"%%'(>0.($% (D B&..$')"(')-1$#.")&4$>"($% )J3$(("-$(.$&$':$%)+

.3 8'#.

)%0(#.'$(7#%;".%";"('#'($:'%$)##4"##4$%'(>0.($3$)# <"(  3"%$  ')  "  40..=;  <'#40#  &351$#')-  #4$  1"'%  %<) .3"1'#'$(40-4#4$%$:'"#')(.3#$.3((")&#')<$.$

99 (033".'F$%  >=  4'3  ')  :'('#  .$5.#  %"#$%   

  51"&$% >$.$  #4$  &35$#$)#  "0#4.'#=;  =$#  4$  5.$$..$% .$&33$)%"#')(##4$ 35$#$)#0#4.'#=.5(#"&# "3$)%3$)#')#$.3((")&#') =4'(">:$"&#(84.',")-.'"11$-$%1="'1$%#%'(&4".-$ 4'(%0#'$(<'#40#3(#%$:#')")%%'1'-$)&$")%#40(:'1"#$%

$-01"#')   !    33$.&$  '&$.

351=$$( 

)%0&#!  $-01"#')(;  D  <4'&4  .$"%  <'#4

$-01"#')GI#4$("'% $-01"#')(&)(#'#0#$3'(&)%0&# 50)'(4">1$  0)%$.  33$.&$  '&$.

351=$$( '(&'51')$")%55$"1! $-01"#')(;D

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

&.'#'&"11=$A"3')$#4$"&##4"##4$>.")&44"%%'(>0.($% (D B&..$(') "(')-1$#.")&4$6;<"(0)%#>$)#5.:$%4$)1=($&)%5".#<"( 5.:$%  <4$.$>=  '#  <"(  "11$-$%  #4"#  #4$  5$#'#')$.  4"%  5.$$..$% .$&33$)%"#')##4$&35$#$)#"0#4.'#=.5(#"&#"3$)%3$)#') #$.3((")&#') $-".%')-#4$($&)%&4".-$;'#<"(0)%#4"#4'-41$:$1 #$"3  4$"%$%  >=  #4$  5$#'#')$.  4"%  :'('#$%  :'11"-$(  ".%;  8".("  ")%

"-4":50.")B

")%+

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

 ")%5.$$..$%.$&33$)%"#')##4$&35$#$)#"0#4.'#='$ 4"'.3")")% ")"-')-'.$&#..5(#"&#"3$)%3$)#')#4$#$.3((")&#') "3#4$:'$<#4"##4$("'%.$&33$)%"#')(".$5".##4$ ).3"1%0#'$(")%3"="11<'#4')#4$%$')'#')6&)%0&#6")%$:$)&"))# >$&"11$%63'(&)%0&#6#<"(#4$:'$<#4$5$#'#')$.#4"##4$#$.3( (")&#')(401%>$"3$)%$%5(#"&#4$("'%.$&33$)%"#')(<$.$)# >')%')-)#4$ 4"'.3")")% ")"-')-'.$&#.#4$>")24$.$.$; #4$5$#'#')$.<"(5$..3')-4'().3"1%0#'$( )4'(<)<'(%3;4$ #40-4#'#5.5$.#4"#5(#"&#"3$)%3$)#')#$.3((")&#')'(.$C0'.$%

9B9 #>$-.")#$%")%4$"&&.%')-1=3"%$.$&33$)%"#')( 4$.$.$;#4$ ("'%&)%0&#%$()#"11<'#4')#4$%$')'#')63'(&)%0&#6;<4"##&"11 6-.":$3'(&)%0&#6

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

))$A0.$99D!;'#'(0)%#4"#')#4$.%$.; #4$ &35$#$)# "0#4.'#=; <4'1$&)&10%')-;5"(($%#4$11<')-.%$.*9 )('%$.')-"11#4$"&#(#4$&"($;$:'%$)&$).$&.% ')C0'.=")%(0>3'((')(#4$

"(%'(&0(($%4$.$')">:$ ")%  &33$)(0."#$  <'#4  #4$  -.":'#=    5.:$%  3'(&)%0&# "-"')(##4$

').$(5$&#".#'&1$(&4".-$("(".$("'%; 4":$%$&'%$%#'35($05)#4$

#4$11<')-5$)"1#= 0)%$.  $-01"#')      33$.&$

351=$$(!$)(') $-01"#')(;  G'#4%."<"1 E3)#41=5$)(')."5$.'%#< =$".( 4$.%$.(4"11&3$')#.&$<'#4'33$%'"#$$$&#I 4$.%$.(4<(#4"##4$&35$#$)#"0#4.'#=&)('%$.')-#4$

9+9 -.":'#=    5.:$%  63'(&)%0&#6   6)#  3'(&)%0&#6;  5"(($%  #4$  .%$.   <'#4%."<"1 E#4$3)#41=5$)(')."5$.'%#<=$".( # (4<(#4"##4$%'(&'51')".="0#4.'#=0)%'##>$"63'(&)%0&#6")%)# $:$)6-.":$3'(&)%0&#6;"(.$C0'.$%0)%$. $-01"#')#4$ $-01"#')(    4$.$.$;#4$ %'(&'51')".="0#4.'#="'1$%#"55.$&'"#$#4$ .$C0'.$3$)#( $-01"#')#4$ $-01"#')( ")%"1("'1$%# ($$#4"##4$.$C0'.$3$)#( $-01"#')#4$ $-01"#')( ".$ )#3$#<'#4>$.$5"((')-#4$'350-)$%.%$.8'3'1".1=;#4$"55$11"#$ "0#4.'#="(<$11"(#4$.$:'$<')-"0#4.'#="'1$%#"55.$&'"#$<4$#4$.#4$ 5.:$%&4".-$("30)##-.":$3'(&)%0&#.)#@ <;  #4'(  0.#  '(  #  ($$  #4"#  #4$  %'(&'51')".=  "0#4.'#=; 50)'(4')-"0#4.'

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

$:'$<')- "0#4.'#=; #4$ "55$11"#$  "0#4.'#=  ")%  #4$  50)'(4')-   %"#$%  + ;  D   ")% +   ))$A0.$(99;  9  ")%  9D  .$(5$&#':$1=!;   ".$  4$.$>= C0"(4$%4$5.$($)#<.'#5$#'#')'("11<$% $(5)%$)#(".$%'.

9D9 .$1$"($ E5$)(');"1.$"%=%$%0&#$%.3#4$3)#41=5$)(')#4$ 5$#'#')$.;"1)-<'#4')#$.$(#"##4$."#$E5$."))03 4$"..$".( "1)-<'#4')#$.$(#(4"11>$ .$1$"($%<'#4')#<3)#4(.3#4$%"#$ .$&$'5#&$.#''$%&5=#4'(.%$.

, 78 !

     + (?2( 4$#4$.(5$"2')-.$"()$% * $( 4$#4$. $5.#">1$ * $(