Davinder Singh v. Director, Rural Development And Panchayats, Punjab & Others




 



 




 

  

 !

"#











 

$ 
% & '

( (%

 
# ) %! *
!

" %#  ! +
 !!

 &

, ! -#  &!
%  &# ( %# ! 

  



 

 
 





 
  
 
 

 



       

   

   


!"

 








#   $       % &      '( '

)'*+   "    ,  
 - .,./
 0   &"$    + & /,,0 23& 4 *(5*2 "
!"4 2  6 74 "  ,
   & 

 #

$    &

&  ,  , &*5 
 $  *8+9*8(  ):+  +;   (5 + " & &    2
4  " $        );

'8 )'*8 " $  " "

,  "

3, 

!"2< &$ /,,  4 =" "   $  " ,
9   )* *) )'** $  $     + 2)4 &   +;2'*4 "<& $    >   &   ?  &         * 99*5<    +; (, +  

= $       "             = &      $  );

'+ )'*;" ,
,   $
- = &  '* '8 )'*)1
- $$
-1 &      

    @$    ,      $& "  , "  <&       "$       



#       +  

&  , %  &    ,  " &   "  ,   2$  4  #      

   " 

&  $  , $   & %        , 

,&   '( '

)'*+ $$ "/

             
 2

 
 


 =$ 


  !

   <& $       , #    "    &   ,&  

 '( '

)'*+$

,  "/,,  

,&    );

'8 )'*8 &&   &   

,&     "/ /,,     " $  &        %    <&          " " ,
  <&  @            ,$"   <& %  3:
!" &/,,0 23& 43*(5;2 6374,"&  
  &      /  ./!0. 1./ ! 2341./A

!

5# 676 =   ",          "   <&", "     <&" " , -             ",  
!

<&           ,  =   &  ", 3:3 = ",   
                         @7" , /     8095!0.1./ ! 2341./A

!


6

B       $  "  #          $  

  " " ,
   "$<&"   " <& 
" $    ,C =  $   "      %  " ,      "    3;3$ , " 

        "          
", 


,$   "  "   3 ;   3            .


%/: /;0<09
 
!

"! #$
 $%
&
"$
' 




(

 

 
 )
  

 )
 
"


*
( 

 
 


 + *

 )
)
,










()

$
 





 
-
- 







(
  
()






 
()


.
-






 (


)

  
 
)*


(
- 


 

(


-



  
-
)

)
(
  
()

 ).


($
  







 
 

(
  
()






 
()






 - 




#$
(/ 

( 
"$*

 
 
  
  

 


*

(
  
()

 )0
@$        <&     $ 3: 

3 , : $   *:24 $    ,  " 
  "



 " 
"  "

 &  ,  "       

 &    "  

"

"$<&3:

 . =<.0 51>=1= ?+
 )*




  





)





(  


 ( 
 -
)*
,



-


-  


 )
 



()
  
,

 


1- 
-
  ) 2 4       D="

    &E ,   $        $ 

  

  &

,""   ,,$ 

  &   ) 2&4     $     "   D
E     ) 2 4      D ,E $ , ,
!" 3:3& 


 ,      $  "   "    "

   &   ,       
 " $  <&$  % "$ 9//99/;5  ,

#$ D9//99/;5E& &    < $


 &    
      "    

 D  "  "

 &E   ,   ,
  $<&  ,
9
$ ""  "

 & ,
  !  "

&,  &"& & , 

"$<& #   ,  
1
  <&"   , "  
$   $ <& & ,   $ ",    &$    

 $ " ,$ " " @7",/ 8095!0.1./24 2 


 

-*

 )
 1 

, 



-  
(




  

, 


 ( 
 







(  


 ( 


-
 
 


 )


 


 )
 




3   *


-  


 




 
 )*
,
  




-
4



-

  


 
 )


)


 


(
 *

 

(
( 


 
 - 
 


  

  )



 
()
,)


 
2
 *

 ( 


-


 *




-
(

 


    
 
, 

 



*
 

-*


 
 
 

( 
 







 )


- 
  
, 



 )



  

 
, 

  
()

 
 )
,


-


-  

# ,$    +    $   &       
   , %  &    %      ,  , /

$  %  ",   ,  **   %  

           +    ,  

&  1    $   %  &      ",     ,     **    $     ,  " /,%  & 

    
     ,,"

=       $  

&     2 <
.84$   %   &   

   / / $, 

&   + %  

", , **

  ,    

$ , , ,

& ,  

 $ & <& $   $" & "
 # ",

$ %  $  ,              <& $   "
$   ,$ 

   $ ,3:3 $ " & "      % $   &   2, 4 " $  &  

  % & ,&    $  

,  &$  














 


!







































  "#"$%"&
'
('































  
 
 !







F   

Whether speaking / reasoned :

Yes / No Whether Reportable :

Yes / No